User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
CoachBradley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
And what happens if he is going to face a 90 strength DE. What is that DE going to do to him? Have you ever seen an OT get pancaked by a DE on the way to a quick sack? I've seen alot of games and I've never seen one. A 50 strength OT can handle a 80 strength DE just fine in pass blocking.


IRL, or in this game? IRL, pancaked would be a strong word, but DE's bull-rush a tackle back into the QB's face fairly often. In this game, I admit I haven't watched enough PBP to really know how often it happens.

Originally posted by SteelersInsider
If you want to complain about something, complain about that. Complain that high strength DE's are good for nothing. I'll back you on that. They should pummel low strength OT's and drive them back on running plays and back into the QB on passing plays. But it doesn't happen.

Don't punish the speed DE's because the strength DE build isn't working. If the speed DE's can't get sacks using their speed, then how the hell are they going to get a sack.

In RL, teams often have to keep a RB or TE in all game to help double a fast DE. Bort just implemented that now, so that should help also.


When I think of a speed rusher, I think of a guy like Dwight Freeney. He is the epitome of a speed rusher in that, at the combine, I think he ran something like a 4.38 40, and also put up phenomenal numbers in the short shuttle, which is a measure of agility. Even against guys not named Johnathan Ogden, he can't do what the original PBP showed. The cartoonish builds of the DE need to be slowed down, and I agree with you that the strength DE needs a little bump. But this sack in less than a second BS is exactly that, BS.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Cruzi
The entire concept of "speed" needs a serious reevaluation if an offensive linemen needs DE-like speed just to get set in pass protection. They're not running. They're not chasing. They're taking a couple steps back and engaging. Foot speed should have very little at all to do with it.

Or did we decide that achieving some semblance of realism was no longer a goal here?



we decided that you don't understand that speed can be over something as short as 3 yards in each direction. It doesn't have to be 40 yards. People hear speed and they think 40 yard dash. Linemen at the combine to 10 yard speed drills and some teams even time shorter. That quick burst is what is important. Not the 40 time.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by CoachBradley
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

And what happens if he is going to face a 90 strength DE. What is that DE going to do to him? Have you ever seen an OT get pancaked by a DE on the way to a quick sack? I've seen alot of games and I've never seen one. A 50 strength OT can handle a 80 strength DE just fine in pass blocking.


IRL, or in this game? IRL, pancaked would be a strong word, but DE's bull-rush a tackle back into the QB's face fairly often. In this game, I admit I haven't watched enough PBP to really know how often it happens.


watch the sims. They give you all the info you need to improve your player.


 
CoachBradley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
agility in GLB = not agility in RL


Here's my biggest issue then. I thought this was a football SIM. I thought that as a football SIM, it would do it's best to simulate the game of football. It's clearly obvious that this is not the case.

As long as it's possible for DE's to do this, it can't really be considered SIM IMO.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by CoachBradley


When I think of a speed rusher, I think of a guy like Dwight Freeney. He is the epitome of a speed rusher in that, at the combine, I think he ran something like a 4.38 40, and also put up phenomenal numbers in the short shuttle, which is a measure of agility. Even against guys not named Johnathan Ogden, he can't do what the original PBP showed. The cartoonish builds of the DE need to be slowed down, and I agree with you that the strength DE needs a little bump. But this sack in less than a second BS is exactly that, BS.


In real life Dwight Freeney (in his prime...he isn't as quick any more) could have had 10 sacks in 1 game against Max Starks if the Steelers didn't decide to help Starks with a RB or TE on every single pass play for the rest of the game. It was that bad.

Read your announcements. Bort just gave us a way to have the TE or RB help with any DE now. Try it out.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CoachBradley
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

agility in GLB = not agility in RL


Here's my biggest issue then. I thought this was a football SIM. I thought that as a football SIM, it would do it's best to simulate the game of football. It's clearly obvious that this is not the case.

As long as it's possible for DE's to do this, it can't really be considered SIM IMO.


Its possible to stop them from doing that, with the proper builds and gameplanning. going up against a speed DE? Don't have an OT capable of handling it? Pass block TE to that side, or hold your HB/FB in (preferably FB in the HB slot) to help hold him up...or to cover for the TE not being on the right.

IRL, if there is a monster freak DE that can cause havoc in the backfield, you can bet teams plan for them specifically.
 
CoachBradley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
In real life Dwight Freeney (in his prime...he isn't as quick any more) could have had 10 sacks in 1 game against Max Starks if the Steelers didn't decide to help Starks with a RB or TE on every single pass play for the rest of the game. It was that bad.

Read your announcements. Bort just gave us a way to have the TE or RB help with any DE now. Try it out.


Fair enough...but how many of those sacks would Max Starks not have gotten at least a hand on him? And how many of the sacks would have been within one second of the snap?

That's my issue...I don't have a problem with a stud DE. I have a problem with a DE that can do what the OP's links showed.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by CoachBradley
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

agility in GLB = not agility in RL


Here's my biggest issue then. I thought this was a football SIM. I thought that as a football SIM, it would do it's best to simulate the game of football. It's clearly obvious that this is not the case.

As long as it's possible for DE's to do this, it can't really be considered SIM IMO.


The problem is that there is only 1 man programming the entire game and he can't simulate NFL action perfectly in a few months for hundreds of different plays. He's doing the best he can. I'd like to see anyone else do better. If you could do better, you would make your own site and be making $50K a month also.

 
CoachBradley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Its possible to stop them from doing that, with the proper builds and gameplanning. going up against a speed DE? Don't have an OT capable of handling it? Pass block TE to that side, or hold your HB/FB in (preferably FB in the HB slot) to help hold him up...or to cover for the TE not being on the right.

IRL, if there is a monster freak DE that can cause havoc in the backfield, you can bet teams plan for them specifically.


I'll stick with my below answer as a response to this post.

Originally posted by CoachBradley
That's my issue...I don't have a problem with a stud DE. I have a problem with a DE that can do what the OP's links showed.


Last edited Nov 11, 2008 09:57:31
 
Link
 
Originally posted by CoachBradley
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

In real life Dwight Freeney (in his prime...he isn't as quick any more) could have had 10 sacks in 1 game against Max Starks if the Steelers didn't decide to help Starks with a RB or TE on every single pass play for the rest of the game. It was that bad.

Read your announcements. Bort just gave us a way to have the TE or RB help with any DE now. Try it out.


Fair enough...but how many of those sacks would Max Starks not have gotten at least a hand on him? And how many of the sacks would have been within one second of the snap?

That's my issue...I don't have a problem with a stud DE. I have a problem with a DE that can do what the OP's links showed.




In real life, if a OT was that bad, he would be cut and out of the NFL forever.

Last edited Nov 11, 2008 09:59:53
 
CoachBradley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
The problem is that there is only 1 man programming the entire game and he can't simulate NFL action perfectly in a few months for hundreds of different plays. He's doing the best he can. I'd like to see anyone else do better. If you could do better, you would make your own site and be making $50K a month also.


Of course I would. But I couldn't do better...I don't know syntax from income tax (well, actually I do, I am a senior accountant, but you get my point )

But this isn't exactly a new issue; by the same token, I don't know how he prioritizes which bugs get fixed first.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by CoachBradley
Originally posted by SCACE

Its possible to stop them from doing that, with the proper builds and gameplanning. going up against a speed DE? Don't have an OT capable of handling it? Pass block TE to that side, or hold your HB/FB in (preferably FB in the HB slot) to help hold him up...or to cover for the TE not being on the right.

IRL, if there is a monster freak DE that can cause havoc in the backfield, you can bet teams plan for them specifically.


I'll stick with my below answer as a response to this post.

Originally posted by CoachBradley

That's my issue...I don't have a problem with a stud DE. I have a problem with a DE that can do what the OP's links showed.





we don't have the ability to yank a poorly performing player out of the game.


And if you don't think sacks can happen that quickly, I think you should watch the Colts-Steelers playoff game from 2005. Porter had a couple sacks where he just ran straight at Manning and was untouched (the OG picked up the wrong guy). Immediate sack. Polamalu had one also if I recall and there were about 5 as a result of an overload on the left side and countless other hurries.
 
MadCow420
offline
Link
 
yea but in the plays above, there wasnt an overload to distract the lineman, It was 1-1.. which is bullshit paco
 
CoachBradley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
In real life, if a OT was that bad, he would be cut and out of the NFL forever.


Then it should come back to what the ratings mean. Does an OT with 80 blocking, 50 agility, and 30-something speed mean that he is in the 80th, 50th, and 30th percentile of those attributes? Or are we using a zero based system to measure attributes, in that the numbers are what they are?

If that's the case, how much faster is a 70 speed guy than a 30-something speed guy? What is the difference between a 75 agility guy and a 50 agility guy?

I think this is one of the problems with the game...guys are now building OT's to respond to the epidemic of speed DE's, while those who have the OT's built to realistic specifications are now getting torched. If/as soon as Bort installs a fix, all those new OT's who have been created now have to scamper to get points into Strength and blocking (blocking probably not so much) to counter the DE's that now become the dominant force (the guys who dumped points into strength). It's a slippery slope, and it's tough because everyone is paying their own money and trying to get the same enjoyment, and you can't always please everyone.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by CoachBradley
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

The problem is that there is only 1 man programming the entire game and he can't simulate NFL action perfectly in a few months for hundreds of different plays. He's doing the best he can. I'd like to see anyone else do better. If you could do better, you would make your own site and be making $50K a month also.


Of course I would. But I couldn't do better...I don't know syntax from income tax (well, actually I do, I am a senior accountant, but you get my point )

But this isn't exactly a new issue; by the same token, I don't know how he prioritizes which bugs get fixed first.



I'm telling you the bug is in that the high strength OT isn't pummeling the low strength DE in the running game. I'm sure he is working on it. But he is probably dealing with changing 1 variable from 0.0125 to 0.0123 and then making sure that adjustment doesn't cause other problems, etc etc. It has to be alot of fine tuning. Plus he has to make sure it doesn't cause problems for all players from level 1 to level 44. It can't be easy.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.