User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > World Championship Playoff vs. Champions' League
Page:
 
Mob-6
offline
Link
 
Good idea DMFA. I'd actually suggest the implementation would go as follows:

First season:
Top two playoff finishers from each Pro league (there are 8) are promoted to the Champions league. It would feature 16 teams. 1st season they only play 15 games rather than the standard 16 with one team from outside the division.

Second and future seasons: Each Bowl winner from the Pro Leagues are promoted (8) and each team in the Champions league that finished behind the other Pro team from their division in the Championship League is relegated back to Pro (8). The 16 game is added that features Bort's All-Star team from the previous season (Bort Pick's his favorite players from the previous seasons Champions League and comprises a team of them just to fill the 16th game, they don't compete for the league. Bort would GM this team).
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
That league idea's been suggested before. The problem is that if two teams from the same region are 1-2 and two teams from the same region are 15-16, then #15 stays up while #2 is sent back down.
 
slntkilla
offline
Link
 
Yay another idea of mine revived +1
 
Mob-6
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dmfa41
That league idea's been suggested before. The problem is that if two teams from the same region are 1-2 and two teams from the same region are 15-16, then #15 stays up while #2 is sent back down.


That's not a problem, happens in the NFL all the time. Division winners with mediocre records make the play-offs while teams with better records in tough divisions can't even get wild cards spots.
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
Yeah, but at the very least, they have wild cards for that.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dmfa41
I'd like to bring this back to the forefront since this appears to have fallen by the wayside.

I would prefer a 3-round playoff of the champions of the Pro Leagues from each of the 8 regions to crown a world champion. This would take place on days 42-46 after the playoffs or in the preseason using the previous year's standings.

Pros:
- We know who the best in the world is, and just in case a trophy isn't enough, it makes winning the regional championship even more worthwhile.
- It makes winning promotion up the pyramid from AAA to the Pro Leagues more worthwhile.
- Makes competition between regions sanctioned and official.

Cons:
- Takes away from the offseason time so world champions wouldn't begin their signings until day 46.
- Also would not work for contracts which end on Day 40, but would increase incentive to retain players.

Changes which would be needed:
- consideration for end-on-day 40 contracts for teams who make the tournament, e.g. 5-day short term or freeze them until championship is over
- consideration for players to be signed after day 40 during World Championship push (disallow new signings from competition?)
- 1 more day of offseason (1 less day of preseason?)

Reasons against a top World League
- Promotion/relegation from Regions: worse teams will stay while better teams will make the drop if regions are to be kept.


The only part I would be against is not being able to sign players...that seems stupid, if you can still lose day 40 contracts then you should be able to sign players even if you are in the playoffs...it's the off-season after all.
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
That's why you'd have to keep your end-on-day 40 players andnot be able to add new ones, or neither. Those two would have to go hand in hand. If you could lose players, then you'd have to be able to gain players as well.

Personally, I think it's all the more incentive to re-sign your players. I'd rather keep it open. I'm not sure that I'd discourage teams who won their Pro Leagues from trying to stack themselves for that competition: they won their league; let them sign good players. If they won their Pro League, how many more blockbuster players could they really need?
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dmfa41
That's why you'd have to keep your end-on-day 40 players andnot be able to add new ones, or neither. Those two would have to go hand in hand. If you could lose players, then you'd have to be able to gain players as well.

Personally, I think it's all the more incentive to re-sign your players. I'd rather keep it open. I'm not sure that I'd discourage teams who won their Pro Leagues from trying to stack themselves for that competition: they won their league; let them sign good players. If they won their Pro League, how many more blockbuster players could they really need?


I don't see why they shouldn't sign players...all the top teams can...so why stop them...if they can recruit 10 elite players(example) between the end of the season and the final game of the tourny...more power to them.
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
Yeah, I said that.
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
More real suggestions at the top of the suggestions forum.
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
I chose the wrong time for the last bump...the middle of a complaining session about moderators
 
amerker
offline
Link
 
i like it sounds good
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Forum Rules
(http://goallineblitz/com/game/forum_rules.pl)

* Please wait a reasonable amount of time before "bumping" a thread, such as waiting until it reaches the second page.

Check.
Last edited Dec 19, 2008 09:37:08
 
slashxtreme
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
I'd be glad to help rank the teams if each of the 16 conference winners would be willing to join I will run it.. or help run it..
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
I'd imagine you could group them by geography: e.g. USA plays Canada, South America plays, um, Africa, I guess. E. Europe plays W. Europe, Oceania plays SE Asia. That would create local rivalries.

Or you could seed them by overall rating, 1 vs. 8, 2 vs. 7, and so forth.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.