If you can afford to be a crappy player for a long time, the best way to go is all the way on one, then the next. If you can't, then doing them one at a time does not cost you much at all, especially at CB.
Forum > FAQ's, Player Guides and Newbie Help > My slow build strategy good?
sew3663
offline
offline
So, I can go speed only for him until the 3rd soft cap (or 4th, depending on what the future importance of speed will be). Cool.
About a training plan, once I hit the first softcap, then training speed is no longer as beneficial than something else. If I have been doing speed/agi, I'll have to find something else to mix with agi.
Damn, this gets tough to plan relatively quickly. I wonder if Bort has thought about just giving us the option of any two skills to train on intense. That would be very convenient.
About a training plan, once I hit the first softcap, then training speed is no longer as beneficial than something else. If I have been doing speed/agi, I'll have to find something else to mix with agi.
Damn, this gets tough to plan relatively quickly. I wonder if Bort has thought about just giving us the option of any two skills to train on intense. That would be very convenient.
TheGreatPuma
offline
offline
Originally posted by sew3663
So, I can go speed only for him until the 3rd soft cap (or 4th, depending on what the future importance of speed will be). Cool.
About a training plan, once I hit the first softcap, then training speed is no longer as beneficial than something else. If I have been doing speed/agi, I'll have to find something else to mix with agi.
Damn, this gets tough to plan relatively quickly. I wonder if Bort has thought about just giving us the option of any two skills to train on intense. That would be very convenient.
Would be nice, I don't see it happening though. I'd recommend stamina or vision with agility depending on position. Tackling/blocking as well for certain positions. http://www.glbwiki.com/index.php?title=Intense_Training_Combination_Chart
So, I can go speed only for him until the 3rd soft cap (or 4th, depending on what the future importance of speed will be). Cool.
About a training plan, once I hit the first softcap, then training speed is no longer as beneficial than something else. If I have been doing speed/agi, I'll have to find something else to mix with agi.
Damn, this gets tough to plan relatively quickly. I wonder if Bort has thought about just giving us the option of any two skills to train on intense. That would be very convenient.
Would be nice, I don't see it happening though. I'd recommend stamina or vision with agility depending on position. Tackling/blocking as well for certain positions. http://www.glbwiki.com/index.php?title=Intense_Training_Combination_Chart
Last edited Nov 13, 2008 17:35:27
TJ Spikes
offline
offline
Originally posted by sew3663
So, I can go speed only for him until the 3rd soft cap (or 4th, depending on what the future importance of speed will be). Cool.
just something to keep in mind... the acceleration mechanic is tied to agility, it probably won't do you much good to max out speed before touching agility.
Remember the purpose of slow building is to get the most free points from leveling as possible. So, from an overall progression stand point, there is no advantage to be gained from maxing out 1 attribute at the expense of another equally important attribute. Speed and Agility are both Major attributes for a CB (get equal Automatic Skill Improvement By Leveling). The free points start to taper off at L22, so you really have to prioritize your attributes so that the ones you need the most get the most free points. That's why I'm fairly convinced that focussed training (normal) on one attribute at a time is the smart thing to do for some slow builds (but probably not everyone).
IMHO, players should get every attribute they need to the first soft cap ASAP. Then go back and increase them as time allows.
So, I can go speed only for him until the 3rd soft cap (or 4th, depending on what the future importance of speed will be). Cool.
just something to keep in mind... the acceleration mechanic is tied to agility, it probably won't do you much good to max out speed before touching agility.
Remember the purpose of slow building is to get the most free points from leveling as possible. So, from an overall progression stand point, there is no advantage to be gained from maxing out 1 attribute at the expense of another equally important attribute. Speed and Agility are both Major attributes for a CB (get equal Automatic Skill Improvement By Leveling). The free points start to taper off at L22, so you really have to prioritize your attributes so that the ones you need the most get the most free points. That's why I'm fairly convinced that focussed training (normal) on one attribute at a time is the smart thing to do for some slow builds (but probably not everyone).
IMHO, players should get every attribute they need to the first soft cap ASAP. Then go back and increase them as time allows.
TheGreatPuma
offline
offline
As long as the attributes are equally important (i.e. your goal is to have speed = agility throughout your career) then you're right. Most CBs I've seen though have more speed than agility and if that's your goal, speed should come first, then agility.
Also, we'll have to agree to disagree on the normal vs intense training. IMO there are few instances where normal training makes sense if you're not shopping for Advanced Eq. The numbers I've run result in more overall SPs resulting from Intense training, which really is the goal of slow building.
Also, we'll have to agree to disagree on the normal vs intense training. IMO there are few instances where normal training makes sense if you're not shopping for Advanced Eq. The numbers I've run result in more overall SPs resulting from Intense training, which really is the goal of slow building.
TJ Spikes
offline
offline
OT - Str 18.4, 19% complete, Actual gain 53% => Str 18.4, 72% complete ***
---- 24 plays, 496 XP -- L2
OG - Str 19.67, 9% complete, Actual gain 41% => Str 19.67, 50% complete
---- 78 plays, 569 XP -- L2
OC - Str 23, 24% complete, Actual gain 35% => Str 23, 59% complete
===
I got my first training "Break Through" doing Normal training, but it was only for an extra 9% which is like +21% of the listed traing. Also, I've decided Stamina is much less important than blind stupid luck. A new player joined the team and stole my starting slot, so I only got 24 plays. One drawback to slow builds that I never even thought of is: if a new player joins your team -- even if he happens to be your level (maybe lower) -- if he isn't slow building, he'll have a higher overall rating a take your starting spot.
---- 24 plays, 496 XP -- L2
OG - Str 19.67, 9% complete, Actual gain 41% => Str 19.67, 50% complete
---- 78 plays, 569 XP -- L2
OC - Str 23, 24% complete, Actual gain 35% => Str 23, 59% complete
===
I got my first training "Break Through" doing Normal training, but it was only for an extra 9% which is like +21% of the listed traing. Also, I've decided Stamina is much less important than blind stupid luck. A new player joined the team and stole my starting slot, so I only got 24 plays. One drawback to slow builds that I never even thought of is: if a new player joins your team -- even if he happens to be your level (maybe lower) -- if he isn't slow building, he'll have a higher overall rating a take your starting spot.
Last edited Nov 14, 2008 19:20:33
TJ Spikes
offline
offline
Originally posted by TheGreatPuma
Also, we'll have to agree to disagree on the normal vs intense training. The numbers I've run result in more overall SPs resulting from Intense training, which really is the goal of slow building.
well I know for a fact that for P, K and OC it most likely makes more sense to train on normal.
Normal train will probably result in hitting the cap a couple of levels sooner. Like My OC is set to hit it at L3 where as yours did it at 5. So that means for those 2 levels I'll be getting an extra point each. If I choose (haven't really decided yet) to go for the 60 cap, I could do it at L7 compared to yours doing it at L8. So by doing it one level sooner that's 2 points gained over yours--for a total of 4. That makes up for the 4 SP gained in a season with bonus tokens.
Another thing I haven't quite wrapped my head around yet is the difference that XP makes. It seems like a flaw to assume max XP, when the player only has a Stam of 10 to start with. That flaw makes for the assumption that a player is going to make L11 before boosting, which might not happen. From a pure SP stand point that doesn't make any difference, but from a maximized player stand point, it could mean a big difference. What if over the course of the 16 week season you miss 125 XP each game? That's 2 levels missed.
That's another reason why I'm doing this tracking. It isn't just a projection of what will probably happen, but will serve as a record of what did happen.
Also, we'll have to agree to disagree on the normal vs intense training. The numbers I've run result in more overall SPs resulting from Intense training, which really is the goal of slow building.
well I know for a fact that for P, K and OC it most likely makes more sense to train on normal.
Normal train will probably result in hitting the cap a couple of levels sooner. Like My OC is set to hit it at L3 where as yours did it at 5. So that means for those 2 levels I'll be getting an extra point each. If I choose (haven't really decided yet) to go for the 60 cap, I could do it at L7 compared to yours doing it at L8. So by doing it one level sooner that's 2 points gained over yours--for a total of 4. That makes up for the 4 SP gained in a season with bonus tokens.
Another thing I haven't quite wrapped my head around yet is the difference that XP makes. It seems like a flaw to assume max XP, when the player only has a Stam of 10 to start with. That flaw makes for the assumption that a player is going to make L11 before boosting, which might not happen. From a pure SP stand point that doesn't make any difference, but from a maximized player stand point, it could mean a big difference. What if over the course of the 16 week season you miss 125 XP each game? That's 2 levels missed.
That's another reason why I'm doing this tracking. It isn't just a projection of what will probably happen, but will serve as a record of what did happen.
TJ Spikes
offline
offline
OT - Str 18.4, 72% complete, Actual gain 42% => Str 19.4, 14% complete
OG - Str 19.67, 50% complete, Actual gain 40% => Str 19.67, 90% complete
OC - Str 24, 59% complete, Actual gain 34% => Str 24, 93% complete
---- 97 Plays, 554 XP -- L2
===
Ok so I started doing projections (now that I know about what to expect from my players) so I know when to switch attributes for training.
The way I do projections is: make a basic hand written spread sheet type thing
Levels on the rows, Attributes in the columns
Like
L3 18.8
L4 19.2
L5 19.6
L6 20
then to that I add in my skill points in the next column
L3 18.8 + 25 = 43
L4 19.2 + 30 = 49*
L5 19.6
L6 20
once I see where the caps are, that gives me an idea of when I can stop. In this example I would have been 1 SP over if I didn't train anymore. So, in this case today, I decided to train STR again to go from 18.8 to 19.8, that way I'll be carrying 2 SPs over.
Now I'll run that same kind of chart for my block. When I did that I saw that if I idin't train block at all I would hit the cap at L9, if I can train block 7 points worth (over about 21ish days,) the I could cap my block at L8. That seems like kind of a tall order and it should be interesting to see if I can make that goal. Of course that all depends on if my XP stays on the same pace it is now (including the slowed XP gain from leveling).
I ran that same kind of a chart for my OC and I've projected that a can have both Strength and Block at the 60 cap by L12 if a train block a measely 2 points by the time I hit L7. So once I get those 2 points, I'll probably switch to training Agility and train it for a very long time (or I might keep training Block so I get a few extra SPs to put towards Strength).
GLB wiki has a nice chart of XP gains that I use for comparison purposes.
http://www.glbwiki.com/index.php?title=Experience
about a third of the way down there's a simple list of days and XP gains. That's what I based my training days versus level projections on. That chart says L8 on Day 23. I'm gaining a little slower than that chart though so I'm projecting Day 25 or so.
Also, My OC is all set to cap at L3 on Day 6 there's no way I can speed up that process any more. So I just brought my STR training up to 93% so that when I hit my 68 cap with it, I'l be able to train it at 7% and that 1 point that will in effect be 3 SPs worth of Strength.
OG - Str 19.67, 50% complete, Actual gain 40% => Str 19.67, 90% complete
OC - Str 24, 59% complete, Actual gain 34% => Str 24, 93% complete
---- 97 Plays, 554 XP -- L2
===
Ok so I started doing projections (now that I know about what to expect from my players) so I know when to switch attributes for training.
The way I do projections is: make a basic hand written spread sheet type thing
Levels on the rows, Attributes in the columns
Like
L3 18.8
L4 19.2
L5 19.6
L6 20
then to that I add in my skill points in the next column
L3 18.8 + 25 = 43
L4 19.2 + 30 = 49*
L5 19.6
L6 20
once I see where the caps are, that gives me an idea of when I can stop. In this example I would have been 1 SP over if I didn't train anymore. So, in this case today, I decided to train STR again to go from 18.8 to 19.8, that way I'll be carrying 2 SPs over.
Now I'll run that same kind of chart for my block. When I did that I saw that if I idin't train block at all I would hit the cap at L9, if I can train block 7 points worth (over about 21ish days,) the I could cap my block at L8. That seems like kind of a tall order and it should be interesting to see if I can make that goal. Of course that all depends on if my XP stays on the same pace it is now (including the slowed XP gain from leveling).
I ran that same kind of a chart for my OC and I've projected that a can have both Strength and Block at the 60 cap by L12 if a train block a measely 2 points by the time I hit L7. So once I get those 2 points, I'll probably switch to training Agility and train it for a very long time (or I might keep training Block so I get a few extra SPs to put towards Strength).
GLB wiki has a nice chart of XP gains that I use for comparison purposes.
http://www.glbwiki.com/index.php?title=Experience
about a third of the way down there's a simple list of days and XP gains. That's what I based my training days versus level projections on. That chart says L8 on Day 23. I'm gaining a little slower than that chart though so I'm projecting Day 25 or so.
Also, My OC is all set to cap at L3 on Day 6 there's no way I can speed up that process any more. So I just brought my STR training up to 93% so that when I hit my 68 cap with it, I'l be able to train it at 7% and that 1 point that will in effect be 3 SPs worth of Strength.
Last edited Nov 14, 2008 19:20:45
TJ Spikes
offline
offline
OT - Block 17.8, 0% complete, Actual gain 42% => Block 17.8, 42% complete
---- 40 Plays, 517 XP -- L3
OG - Str 20.34, 90% complete, Actual gain 39% => Str 21.34, 29% complete
---- 72 plays, 540 XP -- L3
OC - Block 19, 42% complete, Actual gain 42% => Block 19, 84% complete
==
Ran into a bit of a situation with my OG. The way the math will work out, I will be able to cap STR at L4. Unfortunately, I'll need the .67 points gained from hitting L4 to do it. So, in effect, I'll be carrying over 5 SPs to start on my Block with.
In case anyone is actually following this, I've decided that pushing 1 attribute up to the 68 cap really isn't a good idea. It might work for a P or K, but everyone else has 2 or more attributes they need to be as good as possible. It doesn't make any sense to have 1 attribute so much better than the other, and also the stunted growth of the other attributes will probably hurt the player overall later on. I'm recomending that players cap every important attribute before pushing an attribute to the next cap (60, 68, whatever). My OC will have Str and Block. Same with my OG. But with my OT, I'm going to include Agility as a major stat--hopefully I'll be able to handle those pesky DEs a bit better.
---- 40 Plays, 517 XP -- L3
OG - Str 20.34, 90% complete, Actual gain 39% => Str 21.34, 29% complete
---- 72 plays, 540 XP -- L3
OC - Block 19, 42% complete, Actual gain 42% => Block 19, 84% complete
==
Ran into a bit of a situation with my OG. The way the math will work out, I will be able to cap STR at L4. Unfortunately, I'll need the .67 points gained from hitting L4 to do it. So, in effect, I'll be carrying over 5 SPs to start on my Block with.
In case anyone is actually following this, I've decided that pushing 1 attribute up to the 68 cap really isn't a good idea. It might work for a P or K, but everyone else has 2 or more attributes they need to be as good as possible. It doesn't make any sense to have 1 attribute so much better than the other, and also the stunted growth of the other attributes will probably hurt the player overall later on. I'm recomending that players cap every important attribute before pushing an attribute to the next cap (60, 68, whatever). My OC will have Str and Block. Same with my OG. But with my OT, I'm going to include Agility as a major stat--hopefully I'll be able to handle those pesky DEs a bit better.
FatNasty
offline
offline
I've been following it. I was also aware of TheGreatPuma's theory in the area you are exploring even before I started this thread so it has been interesting to get verification. Thanks! 

TJ Spikes
offline
offline
OT - Block 17.8, 42% complete, Actual gain 43% => Block 17.8, 85% complete
OG - Str 21.34, 29% complete, Actual gain 38% => Str 21.34, 67% complete
OC - Block 20, 84% complete, Actual gain 38% => Block 21, 22% complete
---- 95 Plays, 545 XP -- L3
==
Big day for the OC
http://img185.imageshack.us/my.php?image=95092659cx8.jpg
got a little surprise tho... the cap isn't exactly 48. It's 48.07 according to GLBwiki http://www.glbwiki.com/index.php?title=Ability_Softcaps . Because the OC doesn't get any fractional points in his strength early on, and (with the training changes last season) his cap is basically 49. So that means the same thing will be happening with my OG. .34 + .67 = 1.01 so his cap will be at 49 also. I think because of that I'm going to finish his current Str training point, and then switch over to block.
OG - Str 21.34, 29% complete, Actual gain 38% => Str 21.34, 67% complete
OC - Block 20, 84% complete, Actual gain 38% => Block 21, 22% complete
---- 95 Plays, 545 XP -- L3
==
Big day for the OC
http://img185.imageshack.us/my.php?image=95092659cx8.jpg
got a little surprise tho... the cap isn't exactly 48. It's 48.07 according to GLBwiki http://www.glbwiki.com/index.php?title=Ability_Softcaps . Because the OC doesn't get any fractional points in his strength early on, and (with the training changes last season) his cap is basically 49. So that means the same thing will be happening with my OG. .34 + .67 = 1.01 so his cap will be at 49 also. I think because of that I'm going to finish his current Str training point, and then switch over to block.
TheGreatPuma
offline
offline
Originally posted by TJ Spikes
well I know for a fact that for P, K and OC it most likely makes more sense to train on normal.
Normal train will probably result in hitting the cap a couple of levels sooner. Like My OC is set to hit it at L3 where as yours did it at 5.
Where did you get this information? The spreadsheets I provided earlier had a center with a starting str of 19 capping at lvl 4 (with 5 SP left over). The punter example in my Intense vs. Normal comparison had him capping punting at 3 (with 0 sp left over). With a slightly different roll, this center could easily be capping str at 3; maybe 2.
So your center got a 1 SP advantage over the spreadsheet while losing out on training a second attribute intense roughly 4 times. And he's got 0 bonus tokens.
You simply don't gain as many SPs from training as you do from leveling early on, unless you're super slow building. Further, with intense not only are you gaining to your next cap attribute you're also gaining in your second cap attr as well.
well I know for a fact that for P, K and OC it most likely makes more sense to train on normal.
Normal train will probably result in hitting the cap a couple of levels sooner. Like My OC is set to hit it at L3 where as yours did it at 5.
Where did you get this information? The spreadsheets I provided earlier had a center with a starting str of 19 capping at lvl 4 (with 5 SP left over). The punter example in my Intense vs. Normal comparison had him capping punting at 3 (with 0 sp left over). With a slightly different roll, this center could easily be capping str at 3; maybe 2.
So your center got a 1 SP advantage over the spreadsheet while losing out on training a second attribute intense roughly 4 times. And he's got 0 bonus tokens.
You simply don't gain as many SPs from training as you do from leveling early on, unless you're super slow building. Further, with intense not only are you gaining to your next cap attribute you're also gaining in your second cap attr as well.
TJ Spikes
offline
offline
Originally posted by TheGreatPuma
You simply don't gain as many SPs from training as you do from leveling early on, unless you're super slow building. Further, with intense not only are you gaining to your next cap attribute you're also gaining in your second cap attr as well.
We'll see what the final numbers look like. I don't care what your hypothetical spread sheet says, I'm going to finish this out.
I can already tell that there are "magic numbers" with starting rolls. Like if you roll an X or above your player can cap Y levels sooner if you train normal. If you roll a Z you can cap C levels later by training Intense.
Hopefully someone will be able to use this to figure out the difference bewteen when it's better to train normal and when it's not going to make enough of a difference.
It's very obvious to me that players should switch between normal an intense early on. Given the way the bonus token system works, I'd say it's probably around Day 10 depending on the build. That way a player could stil get 3 bonus SPs by training intense, and they's get the extra points from capping those attributes a level or 2 sooner by training normal.
You simply don't gain as many SPs from training as you do from leveling early on, unless you're super slow building. Further, with intense not only are you gaining to your next cap attribute you're also gaining in your second cap attr as well.
We'll see what the final numbers look like. I don't care what your hypothetical spread sheet says, I'm going to finish this out.
I can already tell that there are "magic numbers" with starting rolls. Like if you roll an X or above your player can cap Y levels sooner if you train normal. If you roll a Z you can cap C levels later by training Intense.
Hopefully someone will be able to use this to figure out the difference bewteen when it's better to train normal and when it's not going to make enough of a difference.
It's very obvious to me that players should switch between normal an intense early on. Given the way the bonus token system works, I'd say it's probably around Day 10 depending on the build. That way a player could stil get 3 bonus SPs by training intense, and they's get the extra points from capping those attributes a level or 2 sooner by training normal.
TheGreatPuma
offline
offline
Originally posted by TJ Spikes
We'll see what the final numbers look like. I don't care what your hypothetical spread sheet says, I'm going to finish this out.
I'm not trying to discourage your test. I'm trying to help you out by pointing out things that your test doesn't appear to be considering. If you'd like me to stop, I will do so - just say the word.
Originally posted by TJ Spikes
I can already tell that there are "magic numbers" with starting rolls. Like if you roll an X or above your player can cap Y levels sooner if you train normal. If you roll a Z you can cap C levels later by training Intense.
Hopefully someone will be able to use this to figure out the difference bewteen when it's better to train normal and when it's not going to make enough of a difference.
It's very obvious to me that players should switch between normal an intense early on. Given the way the bonus token system works, I'd say it's probably around Day 10 depending on the build. That way a player could stil get 3 bonus SPs by training intense, and they's get the extra points from capping those attributes a level or 2 sooner by training normal.
Do you have actual examples of a specific roll at a specific position where training on Normal results in being able to hit the first cap 1-2 levels sooner? I could possibly see this happening 1 level sooner, at most, and only in specific instances where 1 or 2 SP make the difference in being able to level up at level 3 or level 4 (this is a rare occurrence). It is unlikely that you'd be able to train up any attribute 5 SP in less time than you'll level up when you're under level 6; which is what you'd need to do to be able to softcap 2 levels earlier.
The part in an earlier post you made about assuming max XP is something I've thought about before but never spent much time on. When I was comparing build strategies I had to keep XP fixed across the strategies, otherwise the comparison would be bogus. For my own interest I ran the Intense vs Normal Comparison for a punter at 75% max XP, which results in a level 9 punter with 779 XP toward level 10. This run actually resulted in 2 additional SP for the Intense training player vs. the Normal training player. If you care you can view here:
http://spreadsheets.google.com/ccc?key=pbmck92KTeeUf1hD8Zve-dQ
Both finished with 80+% in their punting training bar, which will provide an additional 4 SP bonus when trained up during season 2.
We'll see what the final numbers look like. I don't care what your hypothetical spread sheet says, I'm going to finish this out.
I'm not trying to discourage your test. I'm trying to help you out by pointing out things that your test doesn't appear to be considering. If you'd like me to stop, I will do so - just say the word.
Originally posted by TJ Spikes
I can already tell that there are "magic numbers" with starting rolls. Like if you roll an X or above your player can cap Y levels sooner if you train normal. If you roll a Z you can cap C levels later by training Intense.
Hopefully someone will be able to use this to figure out the difference bewteen when it's better to train normal and when it's not going to make enough of a difference.
It's very obvious to me that players should switch between normal an intense early on. Given the way the bonus token system works, I'd say it's probably around Day 10 depending on the build. That way a player could stil get 3 bonus SPs by training intense, and they's get the extra points from capping those attributes a level or 2 sooner by training normal.
Do you have actual examples of a specific roll at a specific position where training on Normal results in being able to hit the first cap 1-2 levels sooner? I could possibly see this happening 1 level sooner, at most, and only in specific instances where 1 or 2 SP make the difference in being able to level up at level 3 or level 4 (this is a rare occurrence). It is unlikely that you'd be able to train up any attribute 5 SP in less time than you'll level up when you're under level 6; which is what you'd need to do to be able to softcap 2 levels earlier.
The part in an earlier post you made about assuming max XP is something I've thought about before but never spent much time on. When I was comparing build strategies I had to keep XP fixed across the strategies, otherwise the comparison would be bogus. For my own interest I ran the Intense vs Normal Comparison for a punter at 75% max XP, which results in a level 9 punter with 779 XP toward level 10. This run actually resulted in 2 additional SP for the Intense training player vs. the Normal training player. If you care you can view here:
http://spreadsheets.google.com/ccc?key=pbmck92KTeeUf1hD8Zve-dQ
Both finished with 80+% in their punting training bar, which will provide an additional 4 SP bonus when trained up during season 2.
Last edited Nov 16, 2008 23:35:42
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























