User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Bort, This Looks Like HorseCrap To Me
Page:
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jiddy78
Originally posted by cdcollins

Originally posted by Mightyhalo


Your CB got owned by a better player. Deal with it and take your loss like a man instead of whining like a baby.


Correct answer.
/thread.


Gotcha does not approve of closing discussions.

/Go Staleys.


/Go Staleys is right! Good ol' Gotcha.

 
Kutzy
Child Support
offline
Link
 
TJ, I love your avatar. Just pointing that out again.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kutzy
Confidence at 50 will mean you lack in other aspects of your build.

While "low confidence" is an easy cop out, why did it never happen before this game?


Could just be on the wrong end of some bad luck. We have discussed the whole "snowballing" effect that happens sometimes with confidence. Maybe he was just lucky it didn't happen before (or unlucky as it might have exposed the flaw).
 
Kutzy
Child Support
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
Originally posted by Kutzy

Confidence at 50 will mean you lack in other aspects of your build.

While "low confidence" is an easy cop out, why did it never happen before this game?


Could just be on the wrong end of some bad luck. We have discussed the whole "snowballing" effect that happens sometimes with confidence. Maybe he was just lucky it didn't happen before (or unlucky as it might have exposed the flaw).


Very possible. But when everyone asks: "How much is your Vision?" "How much is your confidence?" "How much is your Super Vision?", all this does is looks for a cop out. There were several WR's who did that to the CB. So the same flaw would not be exploited by all of them becuase more than likely their builds arent the exact same. People are looking for an easy fix to a problem than actually finding out the entire fix.

Maybe there was a big advantage to one of the WR's based on situational attributes, but its doubtfull for all.
 
HSKRCHMPS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kutzy
Originally posted by wombat killer

Originally posted by Kutzy


Confidence at 50 will mean you lack in other aspects of your build.

While "low confidence" is an easy cop out, why did it never happen before this game?


Could just be on the wrong end of some bad luck. We have discussed the whole "snowballing" effect that happens sometimes with confidence. Maybe he was just lucky it didn't happen before (or unlucky as it might have exposed the flaw).


Very possible. But when everyone asks: "How much is your Vision?" "How much is your confidence?" "How much is your Super Vision?", all this does is looks for a cop out. There were several WR's who did that to the CB. So the same flaw would not be exploited by all of them becuase more than likely their builds arent the exact same. People are looking for an easy fix to a problem than actually finding out the entire fix.

Maybe there was a big advantage to one of the WR's based on situational attributes, but its doubtfull for all.

I agree to an extent, but I'm sure a lot of teams, like mine, post guides in their forums for their players to follow. It could also be that maybe a particular weakness of theirs was exploited, and they decided to mimick a build. We did that in Omaha from a game last season, and found it very beneficial, especially with how the importance of some attributes has declined from season to season, making others more important. Just a thought. What other fix are you thinking of? Honestly, asking those questions and getting those answers help to rule out potential problems. More often than not, issues from a game are due to build, not to an actual bug.
Last edited Oct 27, 2008 13:03:56
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
Onyxgem,

First, let me say that judging by the regular season game against Wasaga Beach Crash, I can see why this comes as a shock. In your regular season game, you shut them down 29-0. And held their WR's to 83 yards total.

So why 10 games later did they throw for 445 yards and 4 TD's?

Frankly I would say that it is a good and valid question.

I have been looking over the game tape for Clyde in this game in particular, but other games as well. I think I have come up with some factors that went into it.

In the first game, Wasaga Beach only threw to the right side(Clyde Armstrong's) a handfull of times, one of which was a 23 yard gain that looked quite similar to the playoff game plays you have posted.

The Wasaga Beach QB had the best game of his entire season in your playoff game, I think it is a safe bet that he boosted for the game.

In the playoff game it looks like Clyde had virtualy no safety support. The SS was either covering the TE or running under the coverage. Clyde was in single coverage even when he was supposed to have over the top coverage support.

In the plays you posted there were 2 where it looks like the reciever was covered and he just made a play on the ball. The other 3(and a few from other games I watched) Clyde was way off of the reciever just after the reciever made a cut. Is it possible that the recievers had an Agility advantage and could maintain their speed through the cut when Clyde couldn't? Or possibly as others had mentioned before Clyde got fooled by a very good head/pump fake combo?

Having said all that, I still share your puzzlement. In going from a regular season shutout to a blowout loss in the Playoffs, In going from Clyde being a virtual shutdown CB in the regular season to being a 4th string D-League CB in the playoffs... something has got to give.

Sure everyone can have an off game, but players who are historicaly among the best players on your team, and even in your league should not have swings this great in performace. Just my opinion.
 
Kutzy
Child Support
offline
Link
 
Im not necessarily saying its a bug, but looking for an exact cause to the exploit. Noone can actually fully explain that outside of the Devs. This is why certain things need to be looked at and explained. It looks really weird to have your dude running in circles until the WR catches the ball. Anytype of REAL explination would be better than 10 different guys giving 10 different opinions.
 
huskerfantic
offline
Link
 
i think qjam is obsessed with fat pple look at his players
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
Originally posted by Kutzy

Confidence at 50 will mean you lack in other aspects of your build.

While "low confidence" is an easy cop out, why did it never happen before this game?


Could just be on the wrong end of some bad luck. We have discussed the whole "snowballing" effect that happens sometimes with confidence. Maybe he was just lucky it didn't happen before (or unlucky as it might have exposed the flaw).


I am sure that the snowball effect had a bit to do with it, but if Clyde had a flaw in his build, shouldn't it have shown up on one of the 16 regular season games?

 
soapbox
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Onyxgem
Originally posted by soapbox

http://www.eliboat.com/wp-content/uploads/2007/03/0326071326.jpg

This looks like horse crap to me.

Your post looks like med/med to me.

My CB (Pacman Asomugha) led the league in INTs and PDs in S3 when I had him at med/med. When I switched him to close, he rarely gave up catches. If the CB is an INT machine, I doubt he's on close (personal experience). It looks like he's playing medium as far as the distances go, and either way, CBs do lose some battles. If you showed me his build, I could show you the reason for him getting beat (but I'd need 100% honesty in terms of the tactics).



I was 100% honestly Close/Medium I had him set like that all year long except for a game or 2 that were blowouts, and one where we wanted to try something else...other than that it was close/medium


The TD looked like close but you just missed the tackle.

All of those plays have 2 things in common and it actually just shows a build flaw. I think you need to raise two or three stats higher. However, in the interest of self-preservation, I won't tell you which. You should easily be able to figure out from those plays (it's a pretty glaring issue... just think real life).

Edit: Eh, actually why not. Vision and Agility seem to be your main problem, and tackling would help erase that one TD.
Last edited Oct 27, 2008 13:16:48
 
HSKRCHMPS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kutzy
Im not necessarily saying its a bug, but looking for an exact cause to the exploit. Noone can actually fully explain that outside of the Devs. This is why certain things need to be looked at and explained. It looks really weird to have your dude running in circles until the WR catches the ball. Anytype of REAL explination would be better than 10 different guys giving 10 different opinions.


Listing potential causes of the problem is not giving different opinions, rather than exluding them as possible problems. It is known that low vision, confidence, etc. could be a cause of the problem. The player stating what those particular attributes are just helps to figure out where the problem lies. I'm sure that there have been more similar problems, so I do agree that an explanation from a Dev. would be very helpful.
Last edited Oct 27, 2008 13:13:43
 
UnsaidPlayer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AirMcMVP
All those replays appear to be the same offensive play. If it was the same WR in each case, I'd probably say it was a build issue. At this point, I'd guess it was a build/tactics issue.

Perhaps their WRs have high head fake SAs or the QB has high pump fake (or both). A CB playing close/aggressive would be very susceptible to that combination.

Perhaps the team you faced figured that one out and did all they could to ensure the play would be called frequently?




I have noticed a play as of abt a week ago that will cause 4-3 man coverage to suck all the players out of the box to the strong side on 2WR passing play...But still have never seen a CB float like that till that game..When the QB releases the ball time seems to stand still for the that CB..





 
HSKRCHMPS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by UnsaidPlayer
Originally posted by AirMcMVP

All those replays appear to be the same offensive play. If it was the same WR in each case, I'd probably say it was a build issue. At this point, I'd guess it was a build/tactics issue.

Perhaps their WRs have high head fake SAs or the QB has high pump fake (or both). A CB playing close/aggressive would be very susceptible to that combination.

Perhaps the team you faced figured that one out and did all they could to ensure the play would be called frequently?




I have noticed a play as of abt a week ago that will cause 4-3 man coverage to suck all the players out of the box to the strong side on 2WR passing play...But still have never seen a CB float like that till that game..When the QB releases the ball time seems to stand still for the that CB..







As it's been explained to me in a similar type of thread involving my WR, that's a fake, either by the QB or the WR. I would think that high vision, super vision, and confidence would help to alleviate that problem as well
 
whoshotjr
offline
Link
 
One other thing it could be that your opponent benefited from the the extra "tick" to get rid of phantom incompletions. I didn't look through your whole regular season game, but noticed this in the first series:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=154117&pbp_id=5037247 - Could have been a TD early on which may have changed the complexion of the game.

 
UnsaidPlayer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by soapbox
Originally posted by Onyxgem

Originally posted by soapbox


http://www.eliboat.com/wp-content/uploads/2007/03/0326071326.jpg

This looks like horse crap to me.

Your post looks like med/med to me.

My CB (Pacman Asomugha) led the league in INTs and PDs in S3 when I had him at med/med. When I switched him to close, he rarely gave up catches. If the CB is an INT machine, I doubt he's on close (personal experience). It looks like he's playing medium as far as the distances go, and either way, CBs do lose some battles. If you showed me his build, I could show you the reason for him getting beat (but I'd need 100% honesty in terms of the tactics).



I was 100% honestly Close/Medium I had him set like that all year long except for a game or 2 that were blowouts, and one where we wanted to try something else...other than that it was close/medium


The TD looked like close but you just missed the tackle.

All of those plays have 2 things in common and it actually just shows a build flaw. I think you need to raise two or three stats higher. However, in the interest of self-preservation, I won't tell you which. You should easily be able to figure out from those plays (it's a pretty glaring issue... just think real life).

Edit: Eh, actually why not. Vision and Agility seem to be your main problem, and tackling would help erase that one TD.


Look at the TD play again..Try to watch the CB and the QB at the same time..lol..I use puase...Cb gets a small burst of aimless running..In turn he has a bad angle on the WR when making the tackle.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.