User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > How to improve Pass Blocking Assignments and still allow realistic levels of Pass Rush Pressure
Page:
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
This timing thing seems to be the key here to an easy answer...

If the HB/FB assignments are working correctly then test holding them steady them for a second or two and see how that looks.

Then add a short pause for the OGs as well and see how strong the Pass Protection is then.

 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
It'd be nice if they looked at least to the right side of the line.

If when the defence lines up in a WSS the O-Line naturally shifts their blocking assignment over by 1, it could perhaps help (particularly if the FB/TE then takes over spot blocking to the outside).

It'd increase the value of blocking talent at HB, FB and TE too.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
I'll try playing around with the delay thing.

I think maybe the pocket "radius" could be a little smaller, too, now that I look at it. Smaller gaps = less ground to cover for the blockers when a defenders makes a move towards one of them.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by chief31
Originally posted by Mike Rogers

Originally posted by chief31



But, I also wanted to add another problem. The offense never seems to learn during the game. I mean, once a guy has four sacks in the game, the offense (in reality) would adjust to find double-teams against that player, or start going with very short, quick-release passes.

I don't think that this is as easy a change to make to the sim, but it is something that is amplifying the problem.


the ends are way too fast for that at the moment, they need to have a speed to weight ratio in place to offbalance this

Maybe not the quick pass stuff, but possibly the HB/FB actions???

How about an option in tactics screen as follows...

* If x amount of sacks/hurries then HB/FB stays in and blocks more on passing plays???


Something like that. That would definitely be a helpful step. Screen passes would be great too. I know that alot of NFL teams will use screens to slow-down a pesky pass-rushing DE.


de's are way to fast for this too be effective, I think a speed to weight ratio would help with this
Last edited Oct 19, 2008 06:12:45
 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
Originally posted by jdros13


Ken, you own a team that has given up 32 sacks on the season or 2 per game on average and is right in the middle of the league. There are many other teams in the same league that have given up less than 10 the entire year. The Orlando team you GM has given up 8 the entire year and there is a team in that league that has never been sacked on 384 attempts. There are at least some OLine builds that seem to be neutralizing most of the top pass rushers. Even the Alpine Golfers, with their poster child for the Speed DE build has been held to 2 or fewer sacks in 2 of their last 4 games.


As a GM on the Golfers - I have to say that a lot of the time there are infinitely more "hurries" than are recorded in the stats.

There's also the factor that a QB who releases quickly, often beats the pass rush. In the last game the QB had an exceedingly quick/agile WR's that meant they could get open, and make completions before the pressure got to them. In addition their QB has (I suspect) exceedingly high vision.

Not all sacks are down to purely the mistakes of the tackles in forming the pocket it does have to be said


Not sure where you were going there with the hurries thing, but one of the teams I GM has 6 fewer sacks than yours does (we have 2 players who combine for 84 sacks on our team, rather than one and 9 different players have recorded sacks) and has twice the recorded hurries that the Golfers do (and many, many more unrecorded ones). There are still games where we get held down to only a couple of sacks though, when we play well built O-Lines. When they try and throw deep 50% of the time with run blocking OTs we get 10 sacks. It's really very simple.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
What I was trying to say that the speed DE problem isn't always about the statistical sack, or even the statistical hurry. It's an issue as it stands, the fact it doesn't result in a sack or hurry doesn't meant it wasn't exploited and/or that someone has a better O-Line, build or that it's down to settings.

Sometimes it's simply a matter of:

A - Open receiver = pass.
B - No open receiver = sack.

The length of time between A and B is less than the blink of an eye. There's no C option of "Hang in the pocket and wait for an opportunity" because there is no pocket, and chances are there wont be an opportunity as there's no real logic on the WR's to "come back" to help out the QB under pressure.

With teams able to set their defence in a particular fashion, or exploit mismatches with their WR - that influences sack counts often more than the O-Line.

Watch the Golfers game and you'll see that if not for the WR wriggling free, or the QB pump faking or using his vision that he'd have had a dozen sacks in the game.
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Why do the offensive linemen (as well as supporting blockers such as FB or TE) each make their decisions as individuals in a vacuum? Blocking is a team function in the team sport that is football.

Is there any way you could implement communication between blockers on their assignments, or the fact that a FB should be able to recognize or predict which assignment the C and LG are going to be picking up so he attacks a 3rd rusher? Such "communication" could even vary in quality depending on each player's Vision and the C's Line General SA. Assignments could then be determined from inside-out. For even better simulation, high-Vision QBs could make presnap reads and alter their check-down order when they see more rushers than blockers.
 
Anarcho
offline
Link
 
I posted this in another thread. Perhaps it would be better here.

"Personally, I think strength should play more of a part in a DE's burst or ability to explode off the line. We are basically putting CBs in at DE right now. The reason CBs wouldn't work at DE is because they don't have the strength or explosion to get off the tackle.

I don't think more pancakes is the solution. I think strength should play more of a part in some of the pass rushing SAs and the DEs ability to engage a lineman and then utilize the speed/agility to get around him.

Other ways to help the problem would be to have an option in either QB tactics or play calling to favor quick passes. You could have in QB tactics the option to favor quick passes (meaning the QB would throw the ball early even if the receiver isn't clearly open), the current way of throwing, or favor letting the play develop (meaning the QB would hold on to the ball longer, even under pressure, to ensure hitting an open receiver).

The pros/cons to quick passes is that you are less likely to get sacked but more likely to throw an INT because you aren't letting the play fully develop. The pros/cons to letting the play develop is that you are less likely to throw a pick under pressure, but more likely to get sacked because you don't throw the ball away.

For game planning, you could implement an option in passing plays for either a 3 step drop, 5 step drop, or 7 step drop. The difference being that the more steps you take, the more vulnerable you are to the pass rush, but the better chance you have of letting a receiver get open.

Another possible way to address the issue is to have OTs take more sweeping angles on outside rushes. In real life (I know this is a GLB no-no) speed DEs and OTs usually battle several yards past the QB. In GLB, the DE has a straight shot to the QB normally. On outside rushes, just make the OTs make a more sweeping angle that would direct DEs back behind the QB. I know a huge problem has been inside rushes, so just have it so OTs don't engage in the sweeping angle until after the DE has made an outside move. It would mean that OTs would need good vision or they'd get faked on double moves by DEs, but it would also allow OTs a better chance to stay with DEs on outside rushes without being more vulnerable on inside stuff."
 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
What I was trying to say that the speed DE problem isn't always about the statistical sack, or even the statistical hurry. It's an issue as it stands, the fact it doesn't result in a sack or hurry doesn't meant it wasn't exploited and/or that someone has a better O-Line, build or that it's down to settings.

Sometimes it's simply a matter of:

A - Open receiver = pass.
B - No open receiver = sack.

The length of time between A and B is less than the blink of an eye. There's no C option of "Hang in the pocket and wait for an opportunity" because there is no pocket, and chances are there wont be an opportunity as there's no real logic on the WR's to "come back" to help out the QB under pressure.

With teams able to set their defence in a particular fashion, or exploit mismatches with their WR - that influences sack counts often more than the O-Line.

Watch the Golfers game and you'll see that if not for the WR wriggling free, or the QB pump faking or using his vision that he'd have had a dozen sacks in the game.


Isn't that somewhat realistic though? If the receiver is open they get the ball. If they aren't, the QB holds on to the ball and you possibly get a "coverage" sack.

I'm not going to argue that the OLine blocking assignments aren't screwed up. Why in the world a RG would be responsible for picking up the ROLB or the NT gets triple or quadruple teamed against 3 man rushes is beyond me. But I know that I actually blitz the LOLB and ROLB sometimes to make the RG stay home and free up the ROLB to the QB since a lot of guys have built fast agile RGs to help with the pitch play in the past couple of years (before the pitch play was basically rendered useless of course).

If I send 5 or 6 guys at your 5 or 6 (including HB/FB staying in to block) the defense should have a very good chance at winning a good number of those one-on-one battles, especially if I'm bringing a Pass Rush specialist and the OLine is bringing a Run Blocker.

What would probably be a huge addition to the game from a O-Line tactical standpoint would be the ability to designate certain double-teams. I'm guessing that it would open up another can of worms though on the defensive side as even more holes would be created to run 90+ speed LBs through.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
It is realistic, if you consider offensive tackles being rendered all but useless on pass rushing downs...

The fact the QB is getting rid of the ball is helping to mask the fact that the DE's in many cases are in the backfield on 8/10 pass attempts. Just because the Golfers only got 2 sacks, doesn't mean the O-Line wasn't being shredded.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Painmaker
Why do the offensive linemen (as well as supporting blockers such as FB or TE) each make their decisions as individuals in a vacuum? Blocking is a team function in the team sport that is football.

Is there any way you could implement communication between blockers on their assignments, or the fact that a FB should be able to recognize or predict which assignment the C and LG are going to be picking up so he attacks a 3rd rusher? Such "communication" could even vary in quality depending on each player's Vision and the C's Line General SA. Assignments could then be determined from inside-out. For even better simulation, high-Vision QBs could make presnap reads and alter their check-down order when they see more rushers than blockers.


They actually all do "know" who everyone is blocking and who is heading where even if they block's not engaged. It makes checks based on that to see who need help or which players are unblocked, etc. If they had no clue, they'd all calculate one guy as the highest risk and 5-on-1 him every play.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

They actually all do "know" who everyone is blocking and who is heading where even if they block's not engaged. It makes checks based on that to see who need help or which players are unblocked, etc. If they had no clue, they'd all calculate one guy as the highest risk and 5-on-1 him every play.


Ever watch the NT in a 3-4?

2 guards, center, and the FB/HB if they stay to block, while the OT/DE are 1-on-1.
Last edited Oct 19, 2008 12:14:58
 
Ehlers
offline
Link
 
Please do something about the lame sacks per player.

We just played a team where the DE had 13 sacks in the game and he now has 91 on the year.

Oh yeah. Nice sim.
 
Grantdawg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ehlers
Please do something about the lame sacks per player.

We just played a team where the DE had 13 sacks in the game and he now has 91 on the year.

Oh yeah. Nice sim.


How in the heck did you keep that game close? They just killed you with sacks.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Bort Posts added to front page
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.