User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Defense AI occasionally not followed
Page:
 
Link
 
hazy-

I'm assuming that you run a 3-4 base defense and have that checked off, right?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by tautology

Not denying your reality, but I also watch every single play of every game for the team I own, and for one of the teams I GM as well (though only on offense for them).

I have many times seen a defense that didn't look right...and every time I eventually tracked down the error...which was mine.

I am fairly fastidious, and have a background writing code, so I am no prone to these mistakes...yet they do seem to happen to me at least.

A few questions, meant to be helpful...

Do these unexpected formations always occur in the same quarter? Do they ever occur at the beginning of a game, or only towards the end? If you see the wrong coverage called, will it ever return tp the correct coverage later in the game?



I agree with everything you said and how to start de-bugging it.

I pull plays that didn't seem right and every time I go back, *I* was the one who made the error. Even though I spent tons of time fixing it.

If the OP had a couple people (or at least 1 other person) take a look we could easily get this thing solved or pass it along for Bort to see.

It seems at this point that the OP is the only owner (out of all 2,000 teams or however many there are) that is experiencing this problem.

Maybe the OP should try the exact same defense on another team you play/GM for and see if it does the same thing (maybe in a game vs weak opponent).

If it is happening to many teams, then it is a bug. If it is only your team, then 99.99% chance it is user error.


I also saw the same problem once in a while. It doesn't happen often and it's not always the same play. I didn't bother to find my case since I think OP already showed a legit case here.

It doesn't look like it is an user error because Defense AI tester showed something which was different to what was used in the game. It may be a human mistake when what OP thought was different to what was called, but when defense AI tester wasn't consistent to the play in the game, it is a legit bug.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw


I also saw the same problem once in a while. It doesn't happen often and it's not always the same play. I didn't bother to find my case since I think OP already showed a legit case here.

It doesn't look like it is an user error because Defense AI tester showed something which was different to what was used in the game. It may be a human mistake when what OP thought was different to what was called, but when defense AI tester wasn't consistent to the play in the game, it is a legit bug.


I don't know how this OP showed to be any more legit that the others. Several of the others let me in their AI and then I fixed it for them. I'm sure it is possible, but I've yet to see a legit one.

Actually there are several reasons why the tester may not show what was in the game. We went over a couple and there are a couple more. If could be as simple as the guy said and it wasn't inputted for the game. It could be a mix-up between the my 30 yard line vs OPP 30 yard line.

There is no way to verify that he entered everything correctly in the tester.

Maybe he has 2 different inputs named the same thing and he was looking at the wrong one. Maybe he was doing something not allowed in that defense like blitzing too many players or shifting a certain way.

If the basic settings are involved, then that opens up a new can of things that could flawed.

I think the OP is the one that has to prove that something is flawed before wasting Bort's time. This is what mods *should* be for: to look over stuff like this so that it doesn't bog Bort down and prevent him from developing the game.

If you want to back the OP's case up and show on a similar formation or similar play call, the same thing happened, then maybe we have something here for Bort to look into.
 
Link
 
The same input name theory doesn't apply since defense AI tester also shows defense shell (cover 0, 1, ...) and it is obvious is is inconsistent to the play OP provided. Basic setting also doesn't overwrite defense AI when defense AI covers certain situations, thus, it doesn't explain why defense AI tester shows something different.

The only possible human error is when OP didn't input defense AI tester correctly, however, I double it's the case. There is actually a way to verify he inputs everything right, for example, maybe OP can take a snapshot of defense AI tester screen, then he can show he didn't type anything wrong in defense AI tester.

 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by tautology

Not denying your reality, but I also watch every single play of every game for the team I own, and for one of the teams I GM as well (though only on offense for them).

I have many times seen a defense that didn't look right...and every time I eventually tracked down the error...which was mine.

I am fairly fastidious, and have a background writing code, so I am no prone to these mistakes...yet they do seem to happen to me at least.

A few questions, meant to be helpful...

Do these unexpected formations always occur in the same quarter? Do they ever occur at the beginning of a game, or only towards the end? If you see the wrong coverage called, will it ever return tp the correct coverage later in the game?



I agree with everything you said and how to start de-bugging it.

I pull plays that didn't seem right and every time I go back, *I* was the one who made the error. Even though I spent tons of time fixing it.

If the OP had a couple people (or at least 1 other person) take a look we could easily get this thing solved or pass it along for Bort to see.

It seems at this point that the OP is the only owner (out of all 2,000 teams or however many there are) that is experiencing this problem.

Maybe the OP should try the exact same defense on another team you play/GM for and see if it does the same thing (maybe in a game vs weak opponent).

If it is happening to many teams, then it is a bug. If it is only your team, then 99.99% chance it is user error.


Been there, done that. It's happened on other teams I GM for. It didn't happen last game, did happen game before that. Like I said it happens very infrequently, but enough for me to be convinced it's a bug.

And sorry, I'm not letting anyone but Bort have access to my defensive playbooks. I've worked really hard to develop what I think is a pretty special playbook and I'd like to keep it that way.
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Not denying your reality, but I also watch every single play of every game for the team I own, and for one of the teams I GM as well (though only on offense for them).

I have many times seen a defense that didn't look right...and every time I eventually tracked down the error...which was mine.

I am fairly fastidious, and have a background writing code, so I am no prone to these mistakes...yet they do seem to happen to me at least.

A few questions, meant to be helpful...

Do these unexpected formations always occur in the same quarter? Do they ever occur at the beginning of a game, or only towards the end? If you see the wrong coverage called, will it ever return tp the correct coverage later in the game?



I was a programmer as well (I went through the torture known as COBOL and have also done some ColdFusion and SQL programming), so I also have a background in this as well.

It happens randomly. It's happened in every quarter. It has called the wrong play in the 2nd quarter (or 3rd) and then returned to the correct play.

Seriously, I wouldn't have posted it here if it wasn't legit. I've always been one of those people who harp on people for wasting Bort's time since he has so little of it, and I didn't post this one until I had enough evidence to do so.
Last edited Oct 13, 2008 09:56:29
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Actually there are several reasons why the tester may not show what was in the game. We went over a couple and there are a couple more. If could be as simple as the guy said and it wasn't inputted for the game. It could be a mix-up between the my 30 yard line vs OPP 30 yard line.


Not possible here. It's a 100% formation specific regardless of field position.

Originally posted by SteelersInsider
There is no way to verify that he entered everything correctly in the tester.


You can't verify it, but I have enough common sense to enter the exact data required. It's not that difficult. Ummm, let's see. It's the 2nd quarter. OK, I'll select 2nd quarter. There is 4:23 left in the quarter. OK, I'll input 263 seconds remaining. The ball is at my opponent's 35 yard line. OK, I'll select OPPONENT and 35 yard line. It was 2nd down and 8. OK, I'll select 2nd down and 8 yards to go. I am ahead by 21. OK, I will select I'm leading by and 21. The opponent was in the Pro Set formation. OK, I'll select Pro Set formation. There were 2 WR's in the formation. OK, I'll select 2 WR's. Now I hit Test.

Yep, I think I can handle that.

Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Maybe he has 2 different inputs named the same thing and he was looking at the wrong one. Maybe he was doing something not allowed in that defense like blitzing too many players or shifting a certain way.


Again, makes no sense since the CORRECT play was called on 5 different occasions in the game. Or did you even bother to read that far?

Originally posted by SteelersInsider
If the basic settings are involved, then that opens up a new can of things that could flawed.


No basic settings. I have something inputted for every available setting.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

I don't know how this OP showed to be any more legit that the others. Several of the others let me in their AI and then I fixed it for them. I'm sure it is possible, but I've yet to see a legit one.


How past cases are really has nothing to do with OP's case. Besides, I know there was at least one legit case that defense AI tester showed something different to in-game play. It was the 'and G' bug. Support acknowledged it was a bug and Bort looked into it. I didn't keep track what happened in the end since I worked around the problem in my defense AI.

Here is one of the treads talking about this bug: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=882417

Now you see a legit case. Many AI problems are human errors but there are indeed legit cases.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw
Originally posted by SteelersInsider


I don't know how this OP showed to be any more legit that the others. Several of the others let me in their AI and then I fixed it for them. I'm sure it is possible, but I've yet to see a legit one.


How past cases are really has nothing to do with OP's case. Besides, I know there was at least one legit case that defense AI tester showed something different to in-game play. It was the 'and G' bug. Support acknowledged it was a bug and Bort looked into it. I didn't keep track what happened in the end since I worked around the problem in my defense AI.

Here is one of the treads talking about this bug: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=882417

Now you see a legit case. Many AI problems are human errors but there are indeed legit cases.



That is a longtime known problem. Every team that pays attention had that one nailed a long time ago. 2,000 teams of out of 2,000 have that problem.

Not even really an bug imo. The AI settings are "til a 1st down" and you don't get a 1st down at the goal line. The settings should be switched to "1st down or TD", but that is another story.

The case we are talking about has only happened to 1 user out of 2,000.

No one has reported something similar happening to them. Instead of having another person look at for $0/hr, they want to bother Bort who obviously makes about $100/hr or more. That's all I suggested.

Have another student look over your code before you call up java and tell them that their program is broken.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw

How past cases are really has nothing to do with OP's case. Besides, I know there was at least one legit case that defense AI tester showed something different to in-game play. It was the 'and G' bug. Support acknowledged it was a bug and Bort looked into it. I didn't keep track what happened in the end since I worked around the problem in my defense AI.

Here is one of the treads talking about this bug: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=882417

Now you see a legit case. Many AI problems are human errors but there are indeed legit cases.



That is a longtime known problem. Every team that pays attention had that one nailed a long time ago. 2,000 teams of out of 2,000 have that problem.

Not even really an bug imo. The AI settings are "til a 1st down" and you don't get a 1st down at the goal line. The settings should be switched to "1st down or TD", but that is another story.

The case we are talking about has only happened to 1 user out of 2,000.

No one has reported something similar happening to them. Instead of having another person look at for $0/hr, they want to bother Bort who obviously makes about $100/hr or more. That's all I suggested.

Have another student look over your code before you call up java and tell them that their program is broken.


I don't think we are talking about the same bug, please read that link again. Do you even read Bort's post in that thread, he had hard time reproducing the problem. It is certainly not a "every team sees it" bug.

Go back to the topic, the only possible human mistake in OP's case is he typed something wrong in defense AI tester. He already showed what he input, do you see any problem there? If not, it is a legit bug when defense AI tester showed something different to in-game plays.
Last edited Oct 13, 2008 18:06:12
 
tautology
offline
Link
 

thehazyone is legit, I am inclined to believe there is a problem.

You may have covered this before, but I don't recall and couldn't tell for certain in the OP...

Does this only occur against the Pro Set (to the best of your knowledge?)

Is the Pro Set defense package the very first formation in your list?
(if so, you could try switching formations up and down on the list order to see if it begins to occur with another formation...could be limited to "first on the list" formations, which might make a certain sense, depending on how the sim is coded in defensive play calling...)

 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Originally posted by buffalobills_tw


How past cases are really has nothing to do with OP's case. Besides, I know there was at least one legit case that defense AI tester showed something different to in-game play. It was the 'and G' bug. Support acknowledged it was a bug and Bort looked into it. I didn't keep track what happened in the end since I worked around the problem in my defense AI.

Here is one of the treads talking about this bug: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=882417

Now you see a legit case. Many AI problems are human errors but there are indeed legit cases.



That is a longtime known problem. Every team that pays attention had that one nailed a long time ago. 2,000 teams of out of 2,000 have that problem.

Not even really an bug imo. The AI settings are "til a 1st down" and you don't get a 1st down at the goal line. The settings should be switched to "1st down or TD", but that is another story.

The case we are talking about has only happened to 1 user out of 2,000.

No one has reported something similar happening to them. Instead of having another person look at for $0/hr, they want to bother Bort who obviously makes about $100/hr or more. That's all I suggested.

Have another student look over your code before you call up java and tell them that their program is broken.


I don't think we are talking about the same bug, please read that link again. Do you even read Bort's post in that thread, he had hard time reproducing the problem. It is certainly not a "every team sees it" bug.

Go back to the topic, the only possible human mistake in OP's case is he typed something wrong in defense AI tester. He already showed what he input, do you see any problem there? If not, it is a legit bug when defense AI tester showed something different to in-game plays.


The "and goal" bug is ubiquitous, as SteelersInsider has said. If you have situational calls based on down and distance near the goal line, you encounter this problem eventually.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
This kind of thing happened to me as well today. The very top input in my defensive AI is to use a goalline defense whenever the offense uses a goalline formation (with no qualifications on yardage, score, or anything else), but today for the first time ever I had one play where it used a different defense. On the next play it went back to the proper input.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
This kind of thing happened to me as well today. The very top input in my defensive AI is to use a goalline defense whenever the offense uses a goalline formation (with no qualifications on yardage, score, or anything else), but today for the first time ever I had one play where it used a different defense. On the next play it went back to the proper input.


Interesting that this is the very top of your list...and I bet it is for a lot of people. Hmmm.

Very interested to hear thehazyone's response to my question above ^^^
 
Link
 
In my case, it is not the first input. It is 5th or 6th input. Thus, I don't think it is limited to the very top input having this problem.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.