User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
anthon9283
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Takary240
people just have better builds now adays and since they keep em hidden you cant do an accurate assesment. just cause ur fumbling more now doesnt mean somethings wrong with the game


If it was just me then yes..but there are quite a few people with the same issue.

I might not have the best build but it is definitely not bad enough to fumble this much. Even if that was the case, if I had a crappy build then last season I would have fumbled at a somewhat similar rate.

Really what attributes would a RB have to have to not fumble as much?
Last edited Oct 3, 2008 01:56:23
 
NFLVols
offline
Link
 
I have a running back who has 57 strength 50 carrying and he has 7 fumbles through 5 games....and he has 2 SA's in Cover up.

This is the same RB that had 6 fumbles altogther in the first 3 seasons. There is some sort of fumbling issue. May be 'changes' were made to make something else like jumping or confidence effect it more....but another HB who has 35 carrying and 53 strength...only has 1 fumble this year....

Also like to add that CB's have caused 5 of the 7 fumbles....after about a 10 yard gain or more.
Last edited Oct 3, 2008 02:16:02
 
bruser23
offline
Link
 
maybe it's your stamina or vision? you run harder and thru more tackles now that your getting tired faster and aren't seeing the right holes and making sloppy cuts not protecting the ball enough
 
NFLVols
offline
Link
 
Vision is 49.....stamina is 35
 
NFLVols
offline
Link
 
He didn't fumble today....first time in 7 or 8 games dating back to last years scrimmage games. Before that he hadn't fumbled in 10 games......SOMETHING changed.
 
bruser23
offline
Link
 
wow just really unlucky
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Takary240
people just have better builds now adays and since they keep em hidden you cant do an accurate assesment. just cause ur fumbling more now doesnt mean somethings wrong with the game


But if most, or even a lot of backs are fumbling a lot more than they did just half a season ago, it probably means something is wrong with the game.
 
anthon9283
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by McGruffHawk
Originally posted by Takary240

people just have better builds now adays and since they keep em hidden you cant do an accurate assesment. just cause ur fumbling more now doesnt mean somethings wrong with the game


But if most, or even a lot of backs are fumbling a lot more than they did just half a season ago, it probably means something is wrong with the game.


Exactly.
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
120 carries without a fumble over the last 6 games but he isn't playing against 30+ players who I'd imagine have mad SA's and more and more stats at the soft cap.
Last edited Oct 3, 2008 05:52:37
 
Booster4324
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
120 carries without a fumble over the last 6 games but he isn't playing against 30+ players who I'd imagine have mad SA's and more and more stats at the soft cap.


Congrats on popping into a thread, not reading any of the particulars and still feeling the need to comment
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Booster4324
Originally posted by Mightyhalo

120 carries without a fumble over the last 6 games but he isn't playing against 30+ players who I'd imagine have mad SA's and more and more stats at the soft cap.


Congrats on popping into a thread, not reading any of the particulars and still feeling the need to comment


I read it all. And it confirms my theory that people always hang on to last years stats without ever considering that defensive players are improving in stats they may have ignored or kept too low for most of their career.

Like the QB threads, "But my QB had a 100+ QB rating last 2 seasons, now he has a 75 QB Rating. What was nerfed?"

I could have left my comment at "My RB has no fumbles last 120 carries" but I wanted to factor in higher level RB's that may be getting abused by improving defensive players.
Last edited Oct 3, 2008 06:26:20
 
bdnannac
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Takary240
people just have better builds now adays and since they keep em hidden you cant do an accurate assesment. just cause ur fumbling more now doesnt mean somethings wrong with the game


I love how it's always better builds or someone has a BAD build. Something is going on here imo.
 
GwennA
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Takary240
what is everyones confidence look like. It has been said that there are some psycological attribute that go along in this game. Running Backs and returners not going through opening holes or getting scared of players with high strength so they take too long to make a sure cut, Wide Recievers not thinking the can make catches rusulting in drops, DB backs not thinking they can catch a ball so so they dont go for the Int, etc etc. just something to look into.


This is why confidence was one of the attributes I posted concerning the RB I was using as an example earlier. Over 30. Going along with the power focused high strength and carrying, not total agility/speed focus. Vision is also in the same area.

If a level 26 back needs 60 strength, carrying, confidence, vision and agility to not fumble 1-2 times a game against similar competition, then something needs to change, because that's just not possible.

Last year might not be a perfect example, but its something to go on. Having equal or greater fumbles through 5 games to all of last season for a power back with ranks in cover up suggests to me that either something has changed, or the mechanics need a second look.

And to re-post for those asking - well, what's your strength, what's your vision, etc. -
Strength 60.82, Carry 35.39, Confidence 32.49, Agility 49.13, Vision 40.63, Cover Up 2

312 rushes, 5 receptions last season, 5 total fumbles
This season, 91 rushes, 1 reception, 6 fumbles so far.

So what is it? 60 strength needs to be 80? Str+Carry needs to be 130? Needs 60 strength and agility to avoid tackles? Confidence needed to be at least 50? 40 Vision isn't nearly enough to notice the right holes to rush through?

What kind of stats would have to be expected to not go from 5 fumbles in a very good season to being on pace for a fumble per game average?
Last edited Oct 3, 2008 06:56:11
 
Booster4324
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
Originally posted by Booster4324

Originally posted by Mightyhalo


120 carries without a fumble over the last 6 games but he isn't playing against 30+ players who I'd imagine have mad SA's and more and more stats at the soft cap.


Congrats on popping into a thread, not reading any of the particulars and still feeling the need to comment


I read it all. And it confirms my theory that people always hang on to last years stats without ever considering that defensive players are improving in stats they may have ignored or kept too low for most of their career.

Like the QB threads, "But my QB had a 100+ QB rating last 2 seasons, now he has a 75 QB Rating. What was nerfed?"

I could have left my comment at "My RB has no fumbles last 120 carries" but I wanted to factor in higher level RB's that may be getting abused by improving defensive players.


Not all, my example is an anomaly at least. I even opened my stats.
 
sunder B
offline
Link
 
Is it me, but from what I am reading most of these fumbling problems are with power backs (Both HB's having trouble on my team, as well as my own are power backs)? Maybe there was an unintentional change (Bort admits to constantly making what he believes are small changes) that effected "power running". Last season, there were tons of complaints about missed tackles from the defensive people that neglected tackling. Maybe in an effort to please these people this was an unfortunate side effect.

One thing cannot be denied IMO, the ridiculous fumbling numbers are nowhere near realistic at any level of football.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.