User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > IS STRONGBASE BROKEN? (by WiSeIVIaN, the guy who posts threads that never really go anywhere)
Page:
 
Havoc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pestface


You seem to be arguing that agility/speed are the only way to produce pressure, which would imply strong base is useless.


Not at all. I am saying that even if Strong Base is quickly pushing the OL out of the way, the player doesnt have the agility and speed to capitalize on the open path to the QB.
 
Madd_Maxx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by j10er


http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=356507

45+ Vision, 30+ Confidence.

3 Hurries, 1 Sack and 7 TFL in 5 games this year. We've only played one weak team, although they weren't gutted, just not up to the level of the league.

He's had highs and lows, for sure. Last year was not a very productive year. I think his build is finally getting to the point of solid, steady production. In fact, I predict him to be a true force by the end of the season.

Of course, it's pretty tough to get a hurry or sack when the DEs he plays with are in the backfield on every play...


No offense, but that is hardly production.
 
silencie
offline
Link
 
In regards to the OP I cannot but agree...

My DT has 85 STR and Speed softcapped and agility to the 2nd softcap, both confidence and vision are over 35.

shed block is at 9 and strong base is at 5.

Last year I had 12 hurries and 2 sacks. That's almost a hurry or a sack every game. Now of course everyone wants to see more stats but I think with a DT you can't really expect those. We're just not fit for pass rushing like a DE is... so whether you boost Strong Base to max or shed block to max, your production will always be behind a DE's.

Just be glad when you get one ;p the life of a DT is just boring.
 
whoshotjr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Madd_Maxx
Originally posted by notrippedyet


Your DT is a level 25 in a second season league. You can't base anything off of him.


Sure I can...he is going up against good, similar level Guards, against some very good teams and dominating all of them.


I know that level 22 to 26 or so seemed to be the sweet spot for my DTs (against equal or better competion anyway), so I don't have a hard time believing your success is legit. Maybe at the higher levels guys with marginal builds are forced to make their guys better just by the fact that upgrading Pancake gets too expensive.

Plus it does help to be a DT rather than NT, I know I got moved from NT to DT in the second half of the season and my production pretty much doubled.

 
Madd_Maxx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by silencie
In regards to the OP I cannot but agree...

My DT has 85 STR and Speed softcapped and agility to the 2nd softcap, both confidence and vision are over 35.

shed block is at 9 and strong base is at 5.

Last year I had 12 hurries and 2 sacks. That's almost a hurry or a sack every game. Now of course everyone wants to see more stats but I think with a DT you can't really expect those. We're just not fit for pass rushing like a DE is... so whether you boost Strong Base to max or shed block to max, your production will always be behind a DE's.

Just be glad when you get one ;p the life of a DT is just boring.


My DT is second in my league in sacks and again...has zero shed block and strong base.
 
missnlife
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Havoc
Originally posted by pestface



You seem to be arguing that agility/speed are the only way to produce pressure, which would imply strong base is useless.


Not at all. I am saying that even if Strong Base is quickly pushing the OL out of the way, the player doesn't have the agility and speed to capitalize on the open path to the QB.


This. This. This.


Oh, and yes, an arc is a curved line. But the fact that you put curved before line should notate to someone that said line is not straight, as it SHOULD automatically be thought to be.
 
missnlife
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Madd_Maxx
Originally posted by silencie

In regards to the OP I cannot but agree...

My DT has 85 STR and Speed softcapped and agility to the 2nd softcap, both confidence and vision are over 35.

shed block is at 9 and strong base is at 5.

Last year I had 12 hurries and 2 sacks. That's almost a hurry or a sack every game. Now of course everyone wants to see more stats but I think with a DT you can't really expect those. We're just not fit for pass rushing like a DE is... so whether you boost Strong Base to max or shed block to max, your production will always be behind a DE's.

Just be glad when you get one ;p the life of a DT is just boring.


My DT is second in my league in sacks and again...has zero shed block and strong base.


And in the only game of your season where you were regularly going against like-leveled OGs and C(including backups, where you're pulling HUGE advantages in some of your teams' blowouts) - your team's only loss - you were held to a single Hurry.

The REAL issue here is that the OP's DT was built as a run-stopper...he just doesn't realize it, and has been pumping wasted SPs into the wrong tree of SAs. Unfortunately for him, your lvl25 is much better-built pass rusher than his lvl29 will be without serious changes.
Last edited Oct 1, 2008 14:44:16
 
gravenimages
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by WiSeIVIaN
Originally posted by gravenimages

Something I've not seen asked regards your pass rushing tactic... Set to power I'd imagine?


Yes set to power. Though come to think of it perhaps evasive will lead me to avoiding getting reblocked after I "throw the blocker out of the way". I'll set it to evasive for my next few games, though I have doubts that it'll make a difference. Only so many paths a DT can take to a QB imo, and a straight line is of course the quickest...


From my experience a straight-line rush actually requires shed block to fire (seems to go off of agility) rather than strong base.

My DT has less strength, more agility, 6/5 shed block/strong base, 40 speed, and plays in BBB instead of AA in the US. When I see what I think it strong base firing, it looks more like my DT is pushing himself away from the blocker (breaking the LG's 'hold block' chance) and taking a different angle to rush.

I can't say that I've ever seen him get a sack or hurry after it's fired, usually my guy ends up running into the LT/RE scrum or trying to loop outside of that and stunt, but the pass is away by then.

He does get off of a few blocks to make short-yardage HB tackles and even has a few PDs from hitting guys who are trying to catch short passes.

I agree that what I've seen of strong base is fairly useless as it stands for a strength-based DT pass rusher.
 
Madd_Maxx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by missnlife

And in the only game of your season where you were regularly going against like-leveled OGs and C(including backups, where you're pulling HUGE advantages in some of your teams' blowouts) - your team's only loss - you were held to a single Hurry.

The REAL issue here is that the OP's DT was built as a run-stopper...he just doesn't realize it, and has been pumping wasted SPs into the wrong tree of SAs. Unfortunately for him, your lvl25 is much better-built pass rusher than his lvl29 will be without serious changes.


Your on crack. Only two of my sacks came on level 20 or lower Guards including tournaments and scrimmages, our opponents combined are 25-10. The 0-5 Budapest has been only really bad team and I didnt even have a sack in that game.

7 of my 10 sacks are against level 23 or higher Guards which is only two levels below me.

Sacks Against Leveled Guards....

Level 25 - 1 sack
Level 24 - 1 Sack
Level 23 - 5 sacks
Level 21 - 1 sacks
Level 20 or lower - 2 sacks

18 hurries in those eight games
Last edited Oct 1, 2008 15:15:46
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Madd_Maxx
Originally posted by j10er



http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=356507

45+ Vision, 30+ Confidence.

3 Hurries, 1 Sack and 7 TFL in 5 games this year. We've only played one weak team, although they weren't gutted, just not up to the level of the league.

He's had highs and lows, for sure. Last year was not a very productive year. I think his build is finally getting to the point of solid, steady production. In fact, I predict him to be a true force by the end of the season.

Of course, it's pretty tough to get a hurry or sack when the DEs he plays with are in the backfield on every play...


No offense, but that is hardly production.


You have to look at the leagues - production is relative.

SA AAA #2 Zeta Conference is extremely competitive. My guys stats are quite productive for that league.

If I was playing in a single A league, my stats would be through the roof. If you're 24+ and have a solid build, stats are easy to come by in A leagues. Heck, in AA my guy had 29 Hurries and 23 TFLs - he just had no speed for sacks two seasons ago

But back to the OP - Strong Base is tough to utilize for all the aforementioned reasons. It's easier to fight against an LG's agility than it is their strength, so any strength-based builds are not as effective. Maybe higher vision/confidence will help, maybe not.

I would think with that build, though, you should be getting more production, honestly. Maybe you will in a few levels, once you're rounded out more? Tough to say...
 
Motiak
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by j10er
Originally posted by Madd_Maxx

Originally posted by j10er




http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=356507

45+ Vision, 30+ Confidence.

3 Hurries, 1 Sack and 7 TFL in 5 games this year. We've only played one weak team, although they weren't gutted, just not up to the level of the league.

He's had highs and lows, for sure. Last year was not a very productive year. I think his build is finally getting to the point of solid, steady production. In fact, I predict him to be a true force by the end of the season.

Of course, it's pretty tough to get a hurry or sack when the DEs he plays with are in the backfield on every play...


No offense, but that is hardly production.


You have to look at the leagues - production is relative.

SA AAA #2 Zeta Conference is extremely competitive. My guys stats are quite productive for that league.

If I was playing in a single A league, my stats would be through the roof. If you're 24+ and have a solid build, stats are easy to come by in A leagues. Heck, in AA my guy had 29 Hurries and 23 TFLs - he just had no speed for sacks two seasons ago

But back to the OP - Strong Base is tough to utilize for all the aforementioned reasons. It's easier to fight against an LG's agility than it is their strength, so any strength-based builds are not as effective. Maybe higher vision/confidence will help, maybe not.

I would think with that build, though, you should be getting more production, honestly. Maybe you will in a few levels, once you're rounded out more? Tough to say...


DTs were nerfed after game 3 of last season, the change in league was not the chief difference. For an example of how the DT nerf affected some people, look at Edonidd's DT http://goallineblitz.com/game/full_player_stats.pl?player_id=64017&playoffs=0 who has a solid Strong Base DT but the nerf killed those builds.
 
Madd_Maxx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by j10er


You have to look at the leagues - production is relative.

SA AAA #2 Zeta Conference is extremely competitive. My guys stats are quite productive for that league.

If I was playing in a single A league, my stats would be through the roof. If you're 24+ and have a solid build, stats are easy to come by in A leagues. Heck, in AA my guy had 29 Hurries and 23 TFLs - he just had no speed for sacks two seasons ago

But back to the OP - Strong Base is tough to utilize for all the aforementioned reasons. It's easier to fight against an LG's agility than it is their strength, so any strength-based builds are not as effective. Maybe higher vision/confidence will help, maybe not.

I would think with that build, though, you should be getting more production, honestly. Maybe you will in a few levels, once you're rounded out more? Tough to say...


Your delusional if you consider 14 tackles and a sack as productive. My DT is facing similar level builds on tough teams, again our opponents were 25-10.

How do you consider 10 sacks, 18 hurries and 47 tackles in 8 games against competitive teams with similar levels as not being productive enough? My DT is second in sacks in the league.

I doubt you will find a great number of DT's with that kind of production at any level unless they play gutted teams.
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Madd_Maxx
Originally posted by j10er



You have to look at the leagues - production is relative.

SA AAA #2 Zeta Conference is extremely competitive. My guys stats are quite productive for that league.

If I was playing in a single A league, my stats would be through the roof. If you're 24+ and have a solid build, stats are easy to come by in A leagues. Heck, in AA my guy had 29 Hurries and 23 TFLs - he just had no speed for sacks two seasons ago

But back to the OP - Strong Base is tough to utilize for all the aforementioned reasons. It's easier to fight against an LG's agility than it is their strength, so any strength-based builds are not as effective. Maybe higher vision/confidence will help, maybe not.

I would think with that build, though, you should be getting more production, honestly. Maybe you will in a few levels, once you're rounded out more? Tough to say...


Your delusional if you consider 14 tackles and a sack as productive. My DT is facing similar level builds on tough teams, again our opponents were 25-10.

How do you consider 10 sacks, 18 hurries and 47 tackles in 8 games against competitive teams with similar levels as not being productive enough? My DT is second in sacks in the league.

I doubt you will find a great number of DT's with that kind of production at any level unless they play gutted teams.


And you're nuts if you think EE A is anything close to SA AAA.

Do I think you have a solid build? Yes, definitely. Is your league even close to SA AAA or even most AA leagues? Not a freakin' chance.

The linemen you abuse have sub-par builds, to say the least. Your guy is built well, so he takes full advantage of that. That level 23 guard you got 4 sacks and 3 hurries against is terrible, for instance. And that was their starter...

Here's your build: above the second cap in strength and agility, soft cap in speed, 40+ in tackling. Most, if not all, of your equipment in agility and/or strength.

You play against equal or lesser competition. Move up to AA or AAA and then see how well you do.
 
Madd_Maxx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by j10er


And you're nuts if you think EE A is anything close to SA AAA.

Do I think you have a solid build? Yes, definitely. Is your league even close to SA AAA or even most AA leagues? Not a freakin' chance.

linemen you abuse have sub-par builds, to say the least. Your guy is built well, so he takes full advantage of that. That level 23 guard you got 4 sacks and 3 hurries against is terrible, for instance. And that was their starter...

Here's your build: above the second cap in strength and agility, soft cap in speed, 40+ in tackling. Most, if not all, of your equipment in agility and/or strength.

You play against equal or lesser competition. Move up to AA or AAA and then see how well you do.


I never said A is like AAA, all I said was my DT performed well against similar level Guards. Since most AAA teams consist of level 34 or higher players, I doubt my DT would do well against players who are 8 or 9 levels higher than he is. Lets not lose sight that he is only a level 25 DT.

Most of the lineman I have gone up against are good linemen, they are on good teams and rarely give up a sack. However I expect most are strength builds and since mine has good agility and speed, I become a bad matchup for them. I dont spend SP's for useless SA's, so my physical numbers are good.

If you want to take your level 29 to AAA when you are outleveled by quite abit, so be it. But 14 tackles and 1 sack in 5 games sucks at any level.
Last edited Oct 1, 2008 18:19:28
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Madd_Maxx
But 14 tackles and 1 sack in 5 games sucks at any level.


You obviously are stat-blind.

No one runs against us. The DEs on my team are in the backfield on every play, making it kind of difficult to register stats on passing plays.

Most DTs struggle mightily to get any kind of pressure at the higher levels. The OP wanted a DT that had good vision/confidence and was still able to get in the backfield, and I provided him one.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.