User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
essteeay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OSU_Ed
Originally posted by essteeay

Originally posted by OSU_Ed


Originally posted by essteeay



I don't think you've understood the discussion.


Go play w/ that shinny object over there. The adults are talking.


Is there a reason you've decided to come in here and be such an ass?


You started the whole OCD conversation and circled back around on yourself. Not I.


Ok, you obviously weren't paying attention to what was being said. Reread it and get back to me. And maybe rein the needless insults in a bit.

Anyway, at the risk of sounding like a broken record, I'm still unclear as to why we have the new training bar in the first place.
 
OSU_Ed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Synovia
Originally posted by Tito716

All I am saying is...

Why should my players be made slower, weaker, and less skilled because some of the other agents don't want to look at decimals?


EVERY PLAYER WOULD BE MADE SLOWER AND WEAKER. Its just changing the scale, not the competitive balance.


Wrong.
 
essteeay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OSU_Ed
Originally posted by Sleepy Mule

Wow… this got out of control rather quickly.


I don’t have time to read all the posts from the various boards, so perhaps someone can help me understand something… do fractional points impact the simulation? For example, someone who has 72.4 speed is faster than someone who has 77.1 speed.


He meant "72.4 is faster than someone who has 72.1 speed?"


Yes, he did. And yes, they do.
 
Synovia
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sleepy Mule
omeone who has 72.4 speed is faster than someone who has 72.1 speed.


Yes.


The problem is, someone with 72.4 speed, and 0% speed training is faster than someone with 72.3 speed, and 90% training. Why is 90% of the way between 72.3 and 73.3 slower than 72.4? It doesn't make sense on any sort of level.


I like the even numbers, personally, it lends to the idea that you can't go out and practice 1 day, and see an improvement. You need to put in time. If you and I are the same speed, me doing wind sprints tonight isn't going to make me any faster than you. Me doing windsprints for 2 weeks? maybe.



Theres no reason to have 2 sets of fractions. It just adds inefficiency.
 
Synovia
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OSU_Ed
Originally posted by Synovia

Originally posted by Tito716


All I am saying is...

Why should my players be made slower, weaker, and less skilled because some of the other agents don't want to look at decimals?


EVERY PLAYER WOULD BE MADE SLOWER AND WEAKER. Its just changing the scale, not the competitive balance.


Wrong.


Hold on, you're arguing that not counting fractions wouldn't make every player weaker? Really? Explain?


Yeah, you with your .9 speed training would get shafted today, as opposed to the guy with .1, but in 4 days, when you're at 1.1, and hes at 1.5, he's the one getting shafted. It all evens out.
Last edited Sep 25, 2008 13:57:13
 
essteeay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Synovia
Originally posted by OSU_Ed

Originally posted by Synovia


Originally posted by Tito716



All I am saying is...

Why should my players be made slower, weaker, and less skilled because some of the other agents don't want to look at decimals?


EVERY PLAYER WOULD BE MADE SLOWER AND WEAKER. Its just changing the scale, not the competitive balance.


Wrong.


Hold on, you're arguing that not counting fractions wouldn't make every player weaker? Really? Explain?


Well, someone who had, say, exactly 30 speed wouldn't be made any weaker.
 
Synovia
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by essteeay
Originally posted by Synovia

Originally posted by OSU_Ed


Originally posted by Synovia



Originally posted by Tito716




All I am saying is...

Why should my players be made slower, weaker, and less skilled because some of the other agents don't want to look at decimals?


EVERY PLAYER WOULD BE MADE SLOWER AND WEAKER. Its just changing the scale, not the competitive balance.


Wrong.


Hold on, you're arguing that not counting fractions wouldn't make every player weaker? Really? Explain?


Well, someone who had, say, exactly 30 speed wouldn't be made any weaker.


For the time being, no, but as soon as he starts training, he will. And, if hes got 30 speed, hes been training something else, and is going to get hit more in that than you will.
 
essteeay
offline
Link
 
Huh?
 
Tito716
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Synovia
Originally posted by OSU_Ed

Originally posted by Synovia


Originally posted by Tito716



All I am saying is...

Why should my players be made slower, weaker, and less skilled because some of the other agents don't want to look at decimals?


EVERY PLAYER WOULD BE MADE SLOWER AND WEAKER. Its just changing the scale, not the competitive balance.


Wrong.


Hold on, you're arguing that not counting fractions wouldn't make every player weaker? Really? Explain?


Yeah, you with your .9 speed training would get shafted today, as opposed to the guy with .1, but in 4 days, when you're at 1.1, and hes at 1.5, he's the one getting shafted. It all evens out.


Unless he is at 17.1 speed and I am at 48.7.

Then 5 days from now he is at 19.2 and I am at 48.95. Of course, I will also have the opportunity cost of training another attribute that was at 20 instead of training full time to get my attributes at 48+ up to round numbers because you don't like decimals.
 
essteeay
offline
Link
 
Why are we rounding the numbers down? What problem is that meant to solve? What problem was the training bar meant to solve in the first place? Lunacy.
 
Synovia
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tito716


Unless he is at 17.1 speed and I am at 48.7.

Then 5 days from now he is at 19.2 and I am at 48.95. Of course, I will also have the opportunity cost of training another attribute that was at 20 instead of training full time to get my attributes at 48+ up to round numbers because you don't like decimals.


Why do you feel like you're getting screwed here? It would hit everyone just the same, just at different times.


The next day, when hes at 19.5, and you're at 49, hes getting screwed just as bad as you were. And the day after, when hes at 19.9, same.

Its not that I don't like decimals, its that there's no reason for TWO SETS of decimals. Just mash them together. Make the fractional points and training the same thing.


Whether or not fractional points actually get counted doesn't make a difference to me. The playing field is even either way.
Last edited Sep 25, 2008 14:07:15
 
OSU_Ed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Synovia
Originally posted by OSU_Ed

Originally posted by Synovia


Originally posted by Tito716



All I am saying is...

Why should my players be made slower, weaker, and less skilled because some of the other agents don't want to look at decimals?


EVERY PLAYER WOULD BE MADE SLOWER AND WEAKER. Its just changing the scale, not the competitive balance.


Wrong.


Hold on, you're arguing that not counting fractions wouldn't make every player weaker? Really? Explain?


Yeah, you with your .9 speed training would get shafted today, as opposed to the guy with .1, but in 4 days, when you're at 1.1, and hes at 1.5, he's the one getting shafted. It all evens out.


It doesn't even out if you don't train on it.
 
Synovia
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OSU_Ed


It doesn't even out if you don't train on it.


If you're not training on one attribute, you are on another, plus you're getting fractional level ups. THeres no way to not get hit by it.
 
OSU_Ed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Synovia
Originally posted by OSU_Ed



It doesn't even out if you don't train on it.


If you're not training on one attribute, you are on another, plus you're getting fractional level ups. THeres no way to not get hit by it.


It's not about whether everyone get's hit by it. It's that some get hit more than others.
 
Synovia
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OSU_Ed


It's not about whether everyone get's hit by it. It's that some get hit more than others.


No, they don't. Not over the long run. Everyone gets hit the same over the long run. Higher level players will feel it more than lower level guys, (stats move slower), but they'll get it the same as other high level guys.
Last edited Sep 25, 2008 14:12:54
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.