User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
Originally posted by islander1

Originally posted by Robbnva


Originally posted by islander1



Originally posted by Bort




I was thinking about how to implement this just the other day, actually. Math required.

I wonder if I put it in, how many people would complain about how it ruined their gameplans? Might be something best left for an off-season add.


Could you make a couple minor tweaks in addition:

add stat : punts fielded inside own 20
fix/modify stat: yards per punt (make it either gross yardage and fix the touchbacks, or make it net yards and fix every other punt.



I could give bort a ton of stats that need to be tracked for a ton of positions.


Well it's just kinda sad when someone in greasemonkey can write a replay rewrite that actually tracks these stats yet the game doesn't officially

and we're talking about punters here. Remember?


I must have missed that one, where is this punter script?


It's not a script specific. It keeps track of this in real time during the viewing of a game. It's the replay rewrite, I use version 8.8.22
 
randomguymike
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by randomguymike

In what way would punting actually working realistically screw with people's gameplans?


I honestly dunno, but people will surprise you sometimes.


This is true, and sometimes the complaints are legit, but I think you'd make a lot of owners and punters happy with this one. I fail to see the parties (outside of PR/KR) that would be harmed by this.
Also, agree the logic around direction, returns, etc would likely be a bitch to code, but that's irrelevant to me. Because it is hard is never a valid reason not to do anything (I don't think you said this, but I'm sure somebody will).
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TreMetal
Knowing the sim your coffin corner kick will go to your endzone and all the monkeys will tell you that you need more vision.


well I wouldnt expect 48 vision to cut it for consistently accurate coffin corners.
 
randomguymike
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
well I wouldnt expect 48 vision to cut it for consistently accurate coffin corners.


I'd hope it is much higher than that. The skill is one of the hardest to master IRL. Also, I have a lvl 34 punter with over that right now in only his 4th full season. I'd expect it to take at least another 2 before he does it consistantly. I'd settle for a 50/50 chance right now between corner & shank/touch back.

Shans would also be nice to have in the code. That I could see pissing a lot of people off, but just watch any college game. At least one shank a game.
 
TreMetal
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by TreMetal

Knowing the sim your coffin corner kick will go to your endzone and all the monkeys will tell you that you need more vision.


well I wouldnt expect 48 vision to cut it for consistently accurate coffin corners.

 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I was thinking about how to implement this just the other day, actually. Math required.

I wonder if I put it in, how many people would complain about how it ruined their gameplans? Might be something best left for an off-season add.


Simple solution: Punter tactics. I was actually just getting ready to suggest that before I saw this thread. Give punters a setting to try coffin corners whenever applicable, or sometimes, or never. Also give them a 2nd setting to favor kicking for distance vs kicking high vs in-between. You could also give them a 3rd setting to kick away from the returner.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
Originally posted by Bort

I was thinking about how to implement this just the other day, actually. Math required.

I wonder if I put it in, how many people would complain about how it ruined their gameplans? Might be something best left for an off-season add.


Simple solution: Punter tactics. I was actually just getting ready to suggest that before I saw this thread. Give punters a setting to try coffin corners whenever applicable, or sometimes, or never. Also give them a 2nd setting to favor kicking for distance vs kicking high vs in-between. You could also give them a 3rd setting to kick away from the returner.


Seems like most of that (kick for distance/height) is situational, though. Of course, I guess it's kinda like the QB tactics - choose an option for when there isn't a clear choice.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I was thinking about how to implement this just the other day, actually. Math required.

I wonder if I put it in, how many people would complain about how it ruined their gameplans? Might be something best left for an off-season add.


I actually agree -- there would have to be an increased risk of a short shank when trying to coffin corner, and people would be complaining about 10-30 yard punts going out of bounds.
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by Bort

I was thinking about how to implement this just the other day, actually. Math required.

I wonder if I put it in, how many people would complain about how it ruined their gameplans? Might be something best left for an off-season add.


I actually agree -- there would have to be an increased risk of a short shank when trying to coffin corner, and people would be complaining about 10-30 yard punts going out of bounds.


I a fine with the risk
 
blitzy
offline
Link
 
bump from a level 23 P
 
kbbl
offline
Link
 
Let's do this AND make the stats be net yards punted. Please.

B.
 
smarchit
offline
Link
 
Directional kicking is a part of the real life game....it should certainly be included here. And while on the topic of special teams in general, why don't we have depth charts specific for punt coverage and punt return teams? They exist for the kickoff/return teams, but not for the punting side. Then backups could be set for individual positions for all of the kick/punt teams, instead of just the random positional substitution we currently get when energy levels slip too low.
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
any update?
 
Roctronic
offline
Link
 
I agree,

My punter is getting touchbacks like no tomorrow and his average is going down so much!
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
bort said he was going to wait until the off season and we all disagree
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.