Originally posted by rmead
Originally posted by smallbugger
Why is everyone pissed off at Buddy for how he built his team? We'll see if it pays off this season or not, but hey he did things how he wanted to do them
rmead... honestly I've been just reading the forums and assumed you had sold/gutted the team. Glad you didn't! but no one on the forums knew what you're plans are... so lay off the people trying to do the best with what they know. If you were doing the ranking on a team similar looking you probably would have said the exact same thing.
See there is the problem right there... you as well as a lot of people seem to be putting selling and gutting into the same category... people can sell a team for a lot of reasons, most of which are benign if not justified, but the term gutting in GLB has a very negative connotation attached to it, to be fair the term gutting or the act of gutting in of itself is a derogatory term.
I wasn't even referring to the insult towards me as an owner for accusing me of gutting my team, even though in no shape or form is my team outside the stipulated rules or the "unspoken rules" concerning the act of gutting. The criteria is pretty simple for a team to be considered gutted... and none of those criteria include leaving it with one of the largest stadiums, one of the biggest bank accounts or some of the highest fan support levels in the league... so even had I sold it, it would have been a new owners dream, not a "A tragic tale of GLB gutting". I ask you, as a new owner could you ask for a better start then a team with a 43,000 seat stadium, 100/90/100 fan support and 20 million in cash... if anything that would be unfair not to the new owner but the other 15 or so owners in his conference who had to start out at default or worse....
I'm also not sure how it is somehow my responsibility to inform anyone that I haven't sold the team before they go and start throwing the single worst accusation that can be made against an owner in this game out in public posts. To be honest not only is that not an excuse for making a statement against my integrity as an owner and a player of this game, the evidence to the contrary is quite easy to glean considering that everything that defines a gutted team is publicly available to anyone playing this game. I don't disagree with the ranking, if this team wins a single game then i will probably quit playing GLB all together because it would be so outlandish, but to throw the snipe in was uncalled for.
As far as being pissed off about how buddy built his team, quite the contrary, I have been a supporter of the cartoon robots since day one. The point was it is a bit narrowed sighted and to be quite honest baselessly arrogant to slander and dissect another team in the league for their strategy or team building when your own strategies are at best unproven and at worst complete failures. It's really that simple.
All that being said I took exception to the fact that my name was connected with this despicable act, opinion or not, it's a baseless and unjustified slander upon my reputation as an owner, and ignorance of the facts is no excuse for that sort of thing. So if you are asking me to "lay off" people who attack my character as an owner publicly, then I will have to respectfully decline. Granted I haven't looked at these forums in a while and probably wont again for a while, but if people have the right to post opinions about me as an owner or the manner in which my team is managed then I have the right to respond.
Hey brother, I was not even slightly trying to insult you. I am glad you did whatever you did to your team in the off season instead of the playoffs. Yes your franchise is in good financial state. Kudos. I don't know if I used the term gutting correctly or not. I just know that one day the team was a top two team in the conference and when I did my write up it was full of CPU. TO me if one day you are a competitive team and the next it is full of cpu it is gutted.
I don't have a problem with your actions in the least, but it is sad that the team won't be able to compete this year. And yes if whoever is running the show makes it compete it will be a miracle.