User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Provide a Refund to the Nashville Team in USA AA#1
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by Gator93


Because your running game carried him all season. When the running game was working his pass game worked. Almost everytime you threw more than 30 passes because the run game wasn't working your passer rating was below 50.


OH SNAP again...when will you accept the logic Larry, probably never, but we can hope or you could take your ball and go home to cry some more.



I'm not sure whether you realize what your advocating--are you honestly telling us all that you find it "logical" that a QB in a playoff game threw NINE picks, and that his backup came on to throw a tenth? And against a defense that has acknowledged it game-planned to shut down the RUN?
 
superman8456
offline
Link
 
Everybody is just making up excuses for the sim. It doesnt matter if your running game carried him the whole season, look at the stats. If he is going to have 1 game like this wouldnt it show in previous sims? Atleast a 4-5 INT game would show this, but it didnt, thus leading you to the conclusion the formula is flawed.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by atm490

Originally posted by atm490


Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader





Again though, not the point. A valid sim doesn't include coding that allows for 10 picks by one team in a playoff game, period.


You keep saying this, and I don't quite understand what you're suggesting:

A) Are you suggesting that the sim should put a hardcap on interceptions? And after a QB has thrown, say, 6, he then becomes invincible?

or

B) Are you suggesting that there be a lower end to the in-game morale downward spiral that your QB suffered in this game?

If A, then wow...

If B, then that issue has already been addressed, by Bort, and will be taken into consideration soon. That, in my opinion, is the only useful thing that has happened in this thread.


Quoted because Larry ignored it the first time.

Comments?



Certainly not "A".

"B" is more central to my argument.

Pretend for a moment that you had never heard of this site before and that a buddy of yours who you knew to be a big football fan said "Hey, I've found this great site where you create a football player and get to have him compete in simulated games!" You'd be curious, and click around the site a bit to get an idea of what's going on. IF a PLAYOFF game where ONE team is picked TEN TIMES were one of the first things you accidently clicked on, would you choose to spend money here?


Larry,

If you choose B, then why are you still surprised and throwing around "10 picks" in a "playoff game" rehtoric. If you know or understand there is no way of pulling players yet due to morale, performance issues, then throwing ten picks is EASILY understandable.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
I'd look into WHY the team was picked ten times, and after reading through the good portions of this thread, I'd have my answer and if I chose to build a QB myself, I'd do it right.

I'd also be curious to see what the INT records were in the NFL and NCAA games, and after looking through them and seeing there isn't much if any difference, I'd be satisfied as long as this was an outlier, which it appears to be among closely matched clubs.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by superman8456
Everybody is just making up excuses for the sim. It doesnt matter if your running game carried him the whole season, look at the stats. If he is going to have 1 game like this wouldnt it show in previous sims? Atleast a 4-5 INT game would show this, but it didnt, thus leading you to the conclusion the formula is flawed.


You've added zip to the conversation, why bother coming back this morning?
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by superman8456
Everybody is just making up excuses for the sim. It doesnt matter if your running game carried him the whole season, look at the stats. If he is going to have 1 game like this wouldnt it show in previous sims? Atleast a 4-5 INT game would show this, but it didnt, thus leading you to the conclusion the formula is flawed.


Why would a 4-5 INT game show up before this? What logical reason do you reach for that? Especially given the fact that his team RUSHED the ball almost the entire season.
 
Ubasstards
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

Certainly not "A".

"B" is more central to my argument.

Pretend for a moment that you had never heard of this site before and that a buddy of yours who you knew to be a big football fan said "Hey, I've found this great site where you create a football player and get to have him compete in simulated games!" You'd be curious, and click around the site a bit to get an idea of what's going on. IF a PLAYOFF game where ONE team is picked TEN TIMES were one of the first things you accidently clicked on, would you choose to spend money here?


I would think "Hey, I can make a better QB then that guy! Sign me up."
 
Gator93
offline
Link
 
His passer rating when he threw 30 passes or more was 62.92, but take out the 51-0, 40-3, and 58-3 blowouts he had a 49.6 rating in games he threw more than 30 times
 
atm490
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader


Pretend for a moment that you had never heard of this site before and that a buddy of yours who you knew to be a big football fan said "Hey, I've found this great site where you create a football player and get to have him compete in simulated games!" You'd be curious, and click around the site a bit to get an idea of what's going on. IF a PLAYOFF game where ONE team is picked TEN TIMES were one of the first things you accidently clicked on, would you choose to spend money here?


First off, my point was in either selection that both issues have been covered. Bort addressed B, which is why I don't think there's anything left for you, or anyone else to add to this thread.

Second, to answer your question, if I had never heard of the site, and I clicked around, and I saw a game in which one team has ten interceptions... and then I kept clicking around and saw lots of really close scores, lots of overtime games, lots of exciting games, a ton of blowouts, and even some times... I would think a few things:

A) Man, that quarterback that threw 9 interceptions is really bad
B) Man, this game really simulates every type of game from nail-biters to squashes
C) Man, dots? Really... dots?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by superman8456
Everybody is just making up excuses for the sim. It doesnt matter if your running game carried him the whole season, look at the stats. If he is going to have 1 game like this wouldnt it show in previous sims? Atleast a 4-5 INT game would show this, but it didnt, thus leading you to the conclusion the formula is flawed.



Well said.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by SCACE

Originally posted by Gator93



Because your running game carried him all season. When the running game was working his pass game worked. Almost everytime you threw more than 30 passes because the run game wasn't working your passer rating was below 50.


OH SNAP again...when will you accept the logic Larry, probably never, but we can hope or you could take your ball and go home to cry some more.



I'm not sure whether you realize what your advocating--are you honestly telling us all that you find it "logical" that a QB in a playoff game threw NINE picks, and that his backup came on to throw a tenth? And against a defense that has acknowledged it game-planned to shut down the RUN?


Not according to Bort, who can see what settings were used. If you go back through the thread, you'll see that Miami game planned against the pass and very aggressively so with their players going for INT's even without help.

I'm not advocating that every game have 10 picks against one club. But if it happens once in a blue moon in a competitive game, I have no issue with it -- I'd be pissed if it was my club too, but I'd look at solving the issue, not come crying for my money back.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by superman8456

Everybody is just making up excuses for the sim. It doesnt matter if your running game carried him the whole season, look at the stats. If he is going to have 1 game like this wouldnt it show in previous sims? Atleast a 4-5 INT game would show this, but it didnt, thus leading you to the conclusion the formula is flawed.


Why would a 4-5 INT game show up before this? What logical reason do you reach for that? Especially given the fact that his team RUSHED the ball almost the entire season.



511 passes on the season--only 15 picks.

But you've demonstrated that you abhore facts.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by atm490
C) Man, dots? Really... dots?


LOL - thread winner

 
hambone77us
offline
Link
 
no one is making excuses for the sim seriouslly this guy quarterback sucks look at his build , if he had a decent quarterback there would be no arguement here
 
superman8456
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by superman8456

Everybody is just making up excuses for the sim. It doesnt matter if your running game carried him the whole season, look at the stats. If he is going to have 1 game like this wouldnt it show in previous sims? Atleast a 4-5 INT game would show this, but it didnt, thus leading you to the conclusion the formula is flawed.


Why would a 4-5 INT game show up before this? What logical reason do you reach for that? Especially given the fact that his team RUSHED the ball almost the entire season.


You're saying that his build is so horrible. You cant have both sides to the argument. Bad build would show atleast a game with 4-5 INT's for the team to know. It didnt happen that way, this was an out of the blue thing and you guys are making up excuses for it.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.