User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Thoughts on Borts new post about XP changes in the announcements forum.
Page:
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Epic thread - gotta get a post in before it hits page 50.


If you're going to draw a line that says a type of behavior is competitive up to a point, and then becomes unfair beyond that point, obviously you can never share the formula. Hopefully the formula will be so complex - and possibly dynamic - so that no one ever knows where the line is. Personally I'm concerned that the presentation seems to have discouraged some players because they understood they would be punished for 'normal' competitive behavior... it's important to emphasize that it's still OK to try to be the best team in your league and that this policy only affects the ridiculously overpowered. I know that's been addressed a few times, but when people get excited sometimes they have trouble listening so there's a need to keep the emphasis up.

I'll wait to assess the move until we've seen the impact of the actual hit to XP that some players experience as well as the impact on the community of the announcement itself - whether we see fewer mobs of level 24 players going down to BBB to demolish their leagues (which apparently must have been happening or else there wouldn't be so many complaints) and more importantly, which players choose to leave the game because they see it as too "anticompetitive" (which might even be 'addition by subtraction' if they're players who aren't fun to play against anyway).




Originally posted by Bort
I love the complaints, guys. Keep them coming. You have no idea how big or small the effect will be, how the math will work, and yet you are worried it will allow other people to catch up and compete (including the other players on your own team!), or that it will somehow decimate your team. That helps prove to me that we're targeting the right area of the game: the part that people actually care enough about that they will think about fair play.


Don't forget to do those stretching exercises!

Idea is 10%, implementation 90%... once the latter has been proven the back-patting can commence. There's no doubt that people are sensitive to XP, but if you really wanted to get people's attention you could simply take skill points away - it's not a question of whether you have heavy-handed leverage available as the game creator but rather how elegantly you can influence behavior without that influence becoming a dominant factor in the game.

Now people are certainly going to be conscious of what level their players are in relation to the league - but that comes at some cost to game immersion. There are lots of ways to skin a cat but this one has the potential to become messier than others. As I said above, I think the biggest risk is how people perceive the new XP penalty and the philosophy behind it, rather than the mechanics of how players are affected in-game. That perception must be managed if this idea is to be effective... communication is key. Perhaps we could get an official "Standards of Fair Play" context which the community can refer to, discuss, and even modify as it becomes appropriate?
 
Schaff
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Finnious Cretin
Originally posted by palindrome

Originally posted by Maksim



You know exactly what I mean, you been trolling me all thread. Do the math you see the problem.


This will only affect one of your players - the WR on the Fiji team. Who will just gain XP at a slower rate compared to a lvl 14 WR in another, higher levelled, league.

This is a great idea and will hopefully prevent people moving loads of high level players into lower leagues just to dominate them. It makes the game fairer and a lot more newbie-friendly. Exactly what the game needs.


i doubt it will affect any of his players, with max sportsmanship score and only about 4 levels over what looks like the median all his player will gain full XP

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=355508

everyone please go read this... please!


Already read this crap. Says the same thing each time I read it. Lower league are now officially FARM teams.
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 04:38:16
 
WVUFAN1971
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Finnious Cretin

you are missing alot. http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=355508
read the second post.. not only are you going to start with maximum sporstmanship score, you also get +'s for boosting.
please don't just half read and assume you think it means you are getting fucked. you aren't.. bort is not going to screw up his cash cow.


First off, thanks for pointing that out. I had not read the second post (I think he posted it after I read the initial announcement. I hope you understand what I meant by my post -- but some of my points still stand. What's happening now is you're gonna punish TEAMS and OWNERS for being good at recruiting.

I think Bort is assuming the worst out of people who sign with "lower" leagues with higher level players. He assumes people do that as to boost stats, when for a good number of us it's nothing like that. I know that when I make a decision of what team to sign with, I'm not at all looking at the league or the relegation of that league. I'm looking at the owner and whether he seems to be a good person to deal with. I'm looking at the other players. I'm looking at the forum to see the environment. None of which has anything at all to do with the league designation.

Instead of balancing leagues by mandating money used by those leagues, then going after teams who violate the rules and the spirit of the games, I believe he's assuming the worst out of his paying customers and punishing EVERYONE without knowing the reason why players go to lower leagues. That sort of attitude is functionally doing the exact opposite of the intent. You're still going to have cheaters, and those who bypass the rules, and those are the exact same people who are currently abusing the system.

The only ones this ruling is going to hurt is those who are playing the game right, they're just cool people to deal with. Players will gravitate to those owners who are easy to deal with.

 
Link
 
WVUfan while i understand your premise, i think you are giving the effects of this change too much credit.
If a good owner is now running a team in a league with a median level of 12, then why is he looking for players above 20 to play on his team?
There are plenty of players in the 18's, that would have just as much an impact on his roster, and have no threat of an XP loss.
I don't think he's assuming the worse at all, i think the median levels and +/-'s will be large enough that 90% of anyone playing this game will have see no effect. keep your sportsmanship high, and don't be an asshole and you should never lose 1 point of gained XP.

Now how does this turn any team into a farm team. if you are level 10 in a level 10 league, everyone in that league levels up pretty close to evenly, you never have to worry about outpacing the median. plus sticking with a team, not getting traded, not dropping to FA and looking for a team where you are outside of the median, you will never have to worry about these things.
This actually stops heavy farming, since teams won't want to trade down to bring up players.

i editted this after i reread bort's post and saw it will probably be the median plus 8.
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 04:47:04
 
Link
 
Unfortunately whenever anything in any game is implemented with the express interest to stop cheating and abuse it will invariably roll over and cause some problems for the good guys.

That is why the saying goes "the few that spoil it for the many". Live and learn and adjust.
 
Bigmo6967
offline
Link
 
Good owners who run good teams get shafted when another team does this Collusion in their league. Did you see how hard some owners tried to get teams in Africa just so they could beat the noobs? I seen attempts at switching to Gm's buying a team and their former owners gutting theirs and selling it. I even seen a team sign 6 kickers to meet the roster requirments before selling it back. All that driven by someone wanting to beat some noobs. whatever rule will work better than what we have now.
 
WVUFAN1971
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Finnious Cretin
WVUfan while i understand your premise, i think you are giving the effects of this change too much credit.
If a good owner is now running a team in a league with a median level of 14, then why is he looking for players above 20 to play on his team?


Because good owners look for the best players to help their team win. What's the harm in try to recruit the best players willing to come to your team?

Isn't this the same thing as saying why a Division III team in college would go after a 4-Star high school recruit -- if they can get him to sign, even if his talent level is remarkably higher than the rest of the team and the division -- wouldn't you still go after him? Would you be wrong if you do so? After all, that would be unfair that you have such highly regarded player(s) than other teams in your division. That would create an "unfair" advantage, right?

Or perhaps the other teams in the conference should realize they have the same opportunity to sign the same exact players.

Originally posted by

There are plenty of players in the 18's, that would have just as much an impact on his roster, and have no threat of an XP loss.
I don't think he's assuming the worse at all, i think the median levels and +/-'s will be large enough that 90% of anyone playing this game will have see no effect. keep your sportsmanship high, and don't be an asshole and you should never lose 1 point of gained XP.


Problem is (again, if I'm reading this right), since the rules regarding sportsmanship and XP loss is not revealed, you reallly won't know if you're losing XP.

Again, this is punishing the whole for the infractions of the few.



Last edited Jun 10, 2008 04:52:13
 
Maksim
offline
Link
 
When ppl wake up and read this thread they will riot i think like the africa league cheat scandal.
 
Bigmo6967
offline
Link
 
I have trouble signing good players to decent contracts because they can go dominate in lower leagues and get ridicuously high contracts to do so. well now they can also take that penalty or maybe just not consider those kinda ridiculous offers.
 
Schaff
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Finnious Cretin
WVUfan while i understand your premise, i think you are giving the effects of this change too much credit.
If a good owner is now running a team in a league with a median level of 14, then why is he looking for players above 20 to play on his team?
There are plenty of players in the 18's, that would have just as much an impact on his roster, and have no threat of an XP loss.
I don't think he's assuming the worse at all, i think the median levels and +/-'s will be large enough that 90% of anyone playing this game will have see no effect. keep your sportsmanship high, and don't be an asshole and you should never lose 1 point of gained XP.

Now how does this turn any team into a farm team. if you are level 10 in a level 10 league, everyone in that league levels up pretty close to evenly, you never have to worry about outpacing the median. plus sticking with a team, not getting traded, not dropping to FA and looking for a team where you are outside of the median, you will never have to worry about these things.
This actually stops heavy farming, since teams won't want to trade down to bring up players.


Not Hard to figure out. If I'm in a level 10 league, I want a level 20 player because he will help me win my league so I can move up to a higher level. If I have players on my team who develop to level 20 over time, they won't want to stay because they will get penalized, so they will leave for higher level leagues. I will end up developing these players for higher level leagues making me a FARM team. Even if I develop great strategies that no one else has thought of and win my devision, I'll move to a higher level where the other teams have more highly developed players and won't be able to compete. So next year I.m back down to a lower leaague where my higher level players will be penalized and leave. The vicious cycle strats all over again and my team remains a Farm team. IT FUCKING SUCKS.
 
WVUFAN1971
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jerome Lamberth
Unfortunately whenever anything in any game is implemented with the express interest to stop cheating and abuse it will invariably roll over and cause some problems for the good guys.

That is why the saying goes "the few that spoil it for the many". Live and learn and adjust.


No, I disagree. BAD rules that are not thought through roll over and cause problems for the good guys.

If you go after JUST the rulebreakers, spend time and effort in seeking out those rulebreakers instead of taking the easy route of implementing general rules that harm just as many good guys as those the rules were designed against, you inevitably will be those same good guys moving on to other games where they're not punished for nothing.
 
Maksim
offline
Link
 
THERE ISNT THAT MANY CHEATS!

Just go after them and punish them, leave the rest of us fair player alone.
 
Bigmo6967
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaff
Originally posted by Finnious Cretin

WVUfan while i understand your premise, i think you are giving the effects of this change too much credit.
If a good owner is now running a team in a league with a median level of 14, then why is he looking for players above 20 to play on his team?
There are plenty of players in the 18's, that would have just as much an impact on his roster, and have no threat of an XP loss.
I don't think he's assuming the worse at all, i think the median levels and +/-'s will be large enough that 90% of anyone playing this game will have see no effect. keep your sportsmanship high, and don't be an asshole and you should never lose 1 point of gained XP.

Now how does this turn any team into a farm team. if you are level 10 in a level 10 league, everyone in that league levels up pretty close to evenly, you never have to worry about outpacing the median. plus sticking with a team, not getting traded, not dropping to FA and looking for a team where you are outside of the median, you will never have to worry about these things.
This actually stops heavy farming, since teams won't want to trade down to bring up players.


Not Hard to figure out. If I'm in a level 10 league, I want a level 20 player because he will help me win my league so I can move up to a higher level. If I have players on my team who develop to level 20 over time, they won't want to stay because they will get penalized, so they will leave for higher level leagues. I will end up developing these players for higher level leagues making me a FARM team. Even if I develop great strategies that no one else has thought of and win my devision, I'll move to a higher level where the other teams have more highly developed players and won't be able to compete. So next year I.m back down to a lower leaague where my higher level players will be penalized and leave. The vicious cycle strats all over again and my team remains a Farm team. IT FUCKING SUCKS.


Please read Borts post. Staying with a team and resigning is actually a plus. They will be rewarded for staying with you. No XP hit. Nada. Nothing wrong. Good deal. They will develop as normal.
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 04:59:17
 
Schaff
offline
Link
 
THE REAL PROBLEM HERE IS, THERE SHOULD BE NO LOWER LEAGUES, don't refer to my team as if it where less or not equal to other teams. I should be able to compete for players just like any other league.
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 05:01:56
 
Link
 
actually WVU, what bort is trying to stop here, is for a Division III team in college recruiting from a Superbowl championship league... it's the same reason colleges have a rule of eligibility, and age restrictions, and other rules. To make sure that yes while some teams are better, much better, than others, there is still some sort of competition.
No college team on any given saturday is going to to beat another team 105-0, and their OLine rack up 150 pancakes. That doesn't happen in college because they aren't allowed to play powderpuff teams.
You can still put together the best team possible, you have Median +8 levels, so a level 14 median league could still have level 22's without so much as batting an eye. This is pretty lenient i think.

And yes we won't know if we lose XP, but we will know our Sportsmanship score, and if it's 100 i'm guessing it means i'll get 100% of my XP.

And again this isn't punishment, it's a coding change to stop future people from trying to pull the same shit that happened this offseason.

Bort said this..
Originally posted by bort
Now I'm pretty much giving everybody a clean slate at this point with a max sportsmanship score EXCEPT for some of the teams that have recently done some obvious stack/gut jobs.
i'm pretty sure that means we'll all be getting max XP
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.