Epic thread - gotta get a post in before it hits page 50. 
If you're going to draw a line that says a type of behavior is competitive up to a point, and then becomes unfair beyond that point, obviously you can never share the formula. Hopefully the formula will be so complex - and possibly dynamic - so that no one ever knows where the line is. Personally I'm concerned that the presentation seems to have discouraged some players because they understood they would be punished for 'normal' competitive behavior... it's important to emphasize that it's still OK to try to be the best team in your league and that this policy only affects the ridiculously overpowered. I know that's been addressed a few times, but when people get excited sometimes they have trouble listening so there's a need to keep the emphasis up.
I'll wait to assess the move until we've seen the impact of the actual hit to XP that some players experience as well as the impact on the community of the announcement itself - whether we see fewer mobs of level 24 players going down to BBB to demolish their leagues (which apparently must have been happening or else there wouldn't be so many complaints) and more importantly, which players choose to leave the game because they see it as too "anticompetitive" (which might even be 'addition by subtraction' if they're players who aren't fun to play against anyway).
Originally posted by Bort
I love the complaints, guys. Keep them coming. You have no idea how big or small the effect will be, how the math will work, and yet you are worried it will allow other people to catch up and compete (including the other players on your own team!), or that it will somehow decimate your team. That helps prove to me that we're targeting the right area of the game: the part that people actually care enough about that they will think about fair play.
Don't forget to do those stretching exercises!
Idea is 10%, implementation 90%... once the latter has been proven the back-patting can commence. There's no doubt that people are sensitive to XP, but if you really wanted to get people's attention you could simply take skill points away - it's not a question of whether you have heavy-handed leverage available as the game creator but rather how elegantly you can influence behavior without that influence becoming a dominant factor in the game.
Now people are certainly going to be conscious of what level their players are in relation to the league - but that comes at some cost to game immersion. There are lots of ways to skin a cat but this one has the potential to become messier than others. As I said above, I think the biggest risk is how people perceive the new XP penalty and the philosophy behind it, rather than the mechanics of how players are affected in-game. That perception must be managed if this idea is to be effective... communication is key. Perhaps we could get an official "Standards of Fair Play" context which the community can refer to, discuss, and even modify as it becomes appropriate?

If you're going to draw a line that says a type of behavior is competitive up to a point, and then becomes unfair beyond that point, obviously you can never share the formula. Hopefully the formula will be so complex - and possibly dynamic - so that no one ever knows where the line is. Personally I'm concerned that the presentation seems to have discouraged some players because they understood they would be punished for 'normal' competitive behavior... it's important to emphasize that it's still OK to try to be the best team in your league and that this policy only affects the ridiculously overpowered. I know that's been addressed a few times, but when people get excited sometimes they have trouble listening so there's a need to keep the emphasis up.
I'll wait to assess the move until we've seen the impact of the actual hit to XP that some players experience as well as the impact on the community of the announcement itself - whether we see fewer mobs of level 24 players going down to BBB to demolish their leagues (which apparently must have been happening or else there wouldn't be so many complaints) and more importantly, which players choose to leave the game because they see it as too "anticompetitive" (which might even be 'addition by subtraction' if they're players who aren't fun to play against anyway).
Originally posted by Bort
I love the complaints, guys. Keep them coming. You have no idea how big or small the effect will be, how the math will work, and yet you are worried it will allow other people to catch up and compete (including the other players on your own team!), or that it will somehow decimate your team. That helps prove to me that we're targeting the right area of the game: the part that people actually care enough about that they will think about fair play.
Don't forget to do those stretching exercises!

Idea is 10%, implementation 90%... once the latter has been proven the back-patting can commence. There's no doubt that people are sensitive to XP, but if you really wanted to get people's attention you could simply take skill points away - it's not a question of whether you have heavy-handed leverage available as the game creator but rather how elegantly you can influence behavior without that influence becoming a dominant factor in the game.
Now people are certainly going to be conscious of what level their players are in relation to the league - but that comes at some cost to game immersion. There are lots of ways to skin a cat but this one has the potential to become messier than others. As I said above, I think the biggest risk is how people perceive the new XP penalty and the philosophy behind it, rather than the mechanics of how players are affected in-game. That perception must be managed if this idea is to be effective... communication is key. Perhaps we could get an official "Standards of Fair Play" context which the community can refer to, discuss, and even modify as it becomes appropriate?




























