User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Demotion Ideas for the WPL
Page:
 
walker1
offline
Link
 
Random demotion just makes a ton more sense to me IMO. Poll?
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
people are agreein' an' shit on this page

edit: fail
Edited by Gart888 on Jul 27, 2009 22:32:57
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnit643
Originally posted by lukin83

Originally posted by turnit643

Originally posted by lukin83

Originally posted by turnit643

Originally posted by lukin83



I am not 100% for divisions. I am 100% for all 8 regions being represented equally. If that is possible without divisions, I am all for it. Show me the way and I will follow.


Done.

4 teams from each get a shot in the first season.

2 more each season after that.

Make the playoffs or go home.

Always at least two from a region.

Always opportunity for more.

All 8 regions repped equally.


: middlefinger :

How does this ultimately make OPL = USAPL?


The same way any of these suggestions do ... players look at the ladder, they see wow OPL is easy, let's join a team there, win, and get to the WL quick.


I can see from where this thread is going that USAPL will always remain the elite pro league in the game. I don't like it, but that ultimately does not matter in the grad scheme of things. The inferior regions will never close the gap on USAPL because the perception of USAPL is not going to change. USA will own the WL and up-and-coming teams will want to be a part of that and not the underdog OPL, SEAPL, etc. I honestly did not know why I thought it could be any different.


Luke, do you think I'm pushing a USAPL-first bias? I'm not, no reason to and really don't get why the system I support would lead you to think that. You want four teams from each region each season, period. I want the best to stay regardless of home region with two from each getting a chance to join each season. Yeah, it may for a while be USAPL heavy, but it may also be OPL heavy at some point in the future, or EEPL, or whatever. I just don't want to sacrifice competition - potentially the best this game has seen - just to make each region feel loved.


I don't think it supports USAPL bias, but it doesn't change the perception of USAPL either. I will try to explain what I am thinking...

If I have a player that the top OPL team and top USAPL teams both want and I see that the WL is composed of 15+ USA teams, which region do you think I am going to choose for my player? USA teams do better in the WL, so I will assume I have a better chance at winning in the WL with the USA team. See how this leads to USA remaining the preferred region?

Maybe we will be surprised and WEPL will rise up and dominate the WL, but the odds are that USA will rule supreme, have four playoff teams, and 6 teams in the WL for Season 12 (and very likely 8 teams for Season 13). As long as agents see USAPL as the easiest avenue for their players getting to the WL and staying there, they will choose USAPL over any other region that wants their players. I hope I am wrong, but it is what it is.
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gart888
people are agreein' an' shit on this page

edit: fail


People are getting tired and going to bed. It just looks like agreein'
 
Ubasstards
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnit643
Originally posted by Gart888

people are agreein' an' shit on this page

edit: fail


People are getting tired and going to bed. It just looks like agreein'


everyone go to sleep, I will figure this out
 
Link
 
Originally posted by turnit643
Originally posted by Gart888

people are agreein' an' shit on this page

edit: fail


People are getting tired and going to bed. It just looks like agreein'


4:30am wake up time is rough....if anyone finds anymore Bort quotes that are good in this thread PM me and I'll update the OP so bort has some organization to his thoughts, likes/dislikes.
 
Outlawz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by boomer82
Divisions are a poor idea.

Keep the setup the same, don't try to overthink it.


^
Yes please.
It's really not that hard.
 
Galkuris
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gabrosin
Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla

Originally posted by Gabrosin


Originally posted by ICRockets



OMFG the division idea doesn't work. You just freakin admitted that it's possible for a 14-2 team to get demoted based on your system.


BULLSHIT. It's only a mathematical possibility for a 14-2 team to be flagged for demotion... in reality it won't happen.

In the current GLB system, a 4-12 can make the playoffs as an eighth seed. Does that mean it should be scrapped??
it's a highly possible reality that a 10-6 or 9-7 tema that should be in the playoffs won't because in one of your shitty divisions they lost to a ton of WPL so a 7-9 team gets in. Divisions fail because they give automatic bids based on an arbitrary subgrouping rather than on round-robin performance like the regional Pro leagues.


What? That makes no sense. A 10-6 would make the playoffs ahead of a 7-9 team every time. I never said that division champions should be guaranteed a playoff spot (that would be a different debate).

And if you're talking about promotion or demotion, it's pretty obvious that the promotion would be based on your "arbitrary subgroupings" (i.e. the freakin' Pro leagues) regardless of what else is decided here. No one is suggesting anything other than promoting all the league/conference champs each season. It's merely a question of how to decide which teams go back down. Why the hell does it not make sense for an OPL team to take the place of another OPL team?

The idea is to promote parity, right? If over the first few seasons of the WPL, we wind up having 8-10 USAPL teams and other regions can't produce a team that sticks, doesn't that just mean that the best players who can't find spots in the WPL would just continue signing with USAPL teams, because they're the ones that are filling up the WPL and sticking? How is that parity? I agree with the sentiment posted elsewhere. If the best players believe their best chance into the WPL is to sign on with a "soft" Pro league rather than try to gut through a "hard" one like USAPL, then those players will sign on with other leagues instead of USAPL. Bam, parity.


If players think signing into the toughest sub-region is the easiest way to get into the WL under ANY structure then they need to quit playing the game because they honestly do not understand how it works. They need to go back to grade school. The easiest way "up" in any format suggested so far is through the "weaker" conferences wherever they may be. Two teams move up every season. You have 2 choices as a player that has been around for 9 seasons:

1. Go to the best OPL team
2. Go to the third best USAPL team

Any agent with a brain would pick option 1 since they could go to the WL right away. If you pick option 2 and it takes the team 3 years to promote...guess what...decline/retirement and your last 3 seasons were useless.
 
JeffSteele
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gabrosin
Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla

Originally posted by Gabrosin


Originally posted by ICRockets



OMFG the division idea doesn't work. You just freakin admitted that it's possible for a 14-2 team to get demoted based on your system.


BULLSHIT. It's only a mathematical possibility for a 14-2 team to be flagged for demotion... in reality it won't happen.

In the current GLB system, a 4-12 can make the playoffs as an eighth seed. Does that mean it should be scrapped??
it's a highly possible reality that a 10-6 or 9-7 tema that should be in the playoffs won't because in one of your shitty divisions they lost to a ton of WPL so a 7-9 team gets in. Divisions fail because they give automatic bids based on an arbitrary subgrouping rather than on round-robin performance like the regional Pro leagues.


What? That makes no sense. A 10-6 would make the playoffs ahead of a 7-9 team every time. I never said that division champions should be guaranteed a playoff spot (that would be a different debate).

And if you're talking about promotion or demotion, it's pretty obvious that the promotion would be based on your "arbitrary subgroupings" (i.e. the freakin' Pro leagues) regardless of what else is decided here. No one is suggesting anything other than promoting all the league/conference champs each season. It's merely a question of how to decide which teams go back down. Why the hell does it not make sense for an OPL team to take the place of another OPL team?

The idea is to promote parity, right? If over the first few seasons of the WPL, we wind up having 8-10 USAPL teams and other regions can't produce a team that sticks, doesn't that just mean that the best players who can't find spots in the WPL would just continue signing with USAPL teams, because they're the ones that are filling up the WPL and sticking? How is that parity? I agree with the sentiment posted elsewhere. If the best players believe their best chance into the WPL is to sign on with a "soft" Pro league rather than try to gut through a "hard" one like USAPL, then those players will sign on with other leagues instead of USAPL. Bam, parity.
First, that "different debate" is very important. Second, isnt your idea that the bottom 2 in each division gets demoted? Third, having arbitrary groupings in Pro is wrong because we've filtered tthrough hundreds of teams to get aa Pro champion and runner up. Fourth, arbitrary divisions also introduce a completely retarded and unnecessary scheduling bias, one well beyond the one that is, sadly, a necessary evil in the conference setup in GLB.
 
Galkuris
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lukin83
Originally posted by turnit643

Originally posted by lukin83


Originally posted by turnit643


Originally posted by lukin83


Originally posted by turnit643


Originally posted by lukin83




I am not 100% for divisions. I am 100% for all 8 regions being represented equally. If that is possible without divisions, I am all for it. Show me the way and I will follow.


Done.

4 teams from each get a shot in the first season.

2 more each season after that.

Make the playoffs or go home.

Always at least two from a region.

Always opportunity for more.

All 8 regions repped equally.


: middlefinger :

How does this ultimately make OPL = USAPL?


The same way any of these suggestions do ... players look at the ladder, they see wow OPL is easy, let's join a team there, win, and get to the WL quick.


I can see from where this thread is going that USAPL will always remain the elite pro league in the game. I don't like it, but that ultimately does not matter in the grad scheme of things. The inferior regions will never close the gap on USAPL because the perception of USAPL is not going to change. USA will own the WL and up-and-coming teams will want to be a part of that and not the underdog OPL, SEAPL, etc. I honestly did not know why I thought it could be any different.


Luke, do you think I'm pushing a USAPL-first bias? I'm not, no reason to and really don't get why the system I support would lead you to think that. You want four teams from each region each season, period. I want the best to stay regardless of home region with two from each getting a chance to join each season. Yeah, it may for a while be USAPL heavy, but it may also be OPL heavy at some point in the future, or EEPL, or whatever. I just don't want to sacrifice competition - potentially the best this game has seen - just to make each region feel loved.


I don't think it supports USAPL bias, but it doesn't change the perception of USAPL either. I will try to explain what I am thinking...

If I have a player that the top OPL team and top USAPL teams both want and I see that the WL is composed of 15+ USA teams, which region do you think I am going to choose for my player? USA teams do better in the WL, so I will assume I have a better chance at winning in the WL with the USA team. See how this leads to USA remaining the preferred region?

Maybe we will be surprised and WEPL will rise up and dominate the WL, but the odds are that USA will rule supreme, have four playoff teams, and 6 teams in the WL for Season 12 (and very likely 8 teams for Season 13). As long as agents see USAPL as the easiest avenue for their players getting to the WL and staying there, they will choose USAPL over any other region that wants their players. I hope I am wrong, but it is what it is.


Why assume USAPL teams will win every season? I think Drygerian, Marblehead, Santiago, Krazy, and Bonn (just to name a few) would take offense to that as they all have as good of a chance to win next season as the 4 from USA Pro.
 
walker1
offline
Link
 
Alright here is why random is better then back down to the original league:

Look, if you were a AAA team, and finished 5-11 and 12th in your conference and got demoted because 5 teams came down wouldn't you be pissed? It makes no sense to demote back to the own region. It is unfair and makes it harder to get into the world league for some teams. Plus it basicly makes region jumping possible. Wouldn't it be cool to see Drygerion demoted to USA Pro?
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lukin83
Originally posted by turnit643
Originally posted by lukin83
Originally posted by turnit643
Originally posted by lukin83
Originally posted by turnit643
Originally posted by lukin83


I am not 100% for divisions. I am 100% for all 8 regions being represented equally. If that is possible without divisions, I am all for it. Show me the way and I will follow.


Done.

4 teams from each get a shot in the first season.

2 more each season after that.

Make the playoffs or go home.

Always at least two from a region.

Always opportunity for more.

All 8 regions repped equally.


: middlefinger :

How does this ultimately make OPL = USAPL?


The same way any of these suggestions do ... players look at the ladder, they see wow OPL is easy, let's join a team there, win, and get to the WL quick.


I can see from where this thread is going that USAPL will always remain the elite pro league in the game. I don't like it, but that ultimately does not matter in the grad scheme of things. The inferior regions will never close the gap on USAPL because the perception of USAPL is not going to change. USA will own the WL and up-and-coming teams will want to be a part of that and not the underdog OPL, SEAPL, etc. I honestly did not know why I thought it could be any different.


Luke, do you think I'm pushing a USAPL-first bias? I'm not, no reason to and really don't get why the system I support would lead you to think that. You want four teams from each region each season, period. I want the best to stay regardless of home region with two from each getting a chance to join each season. Yeah, it may for a while be USAPL heavy, but it may also be OPL heavy at some point in the future, or EEPL, or whatever. I just don't want to sacrifice competition - potentially the best this game has seen - just to make each region feel loved.


I don't think it supports USAPL bias, but it doesn't change the perception of USAPL either. I will try to explain what I am thinking...

If I have a player that the top OPL team and top USAPL teams both want and I see that the WL is composed of 15+ USA teams, which region do you think I am going to choose for my player? USA teams do better in the WL, so I will assume I have a better chance at winning in the WL with the USA team. See how this leads to USA remaining the preferred region?

Maybe we will be surprised and WEPL will rise up and dominate the WL, but the odds are that USA will rule supreme, have four playoff teams, and 6 teams in the WL for Season 12 (and very likely 8 teams for Season 13). As long as agents see USAPL as the easiest avenue for their players getting to the WL and staying there, they will choose USAPL over any other region that wants their players. I hope I am wrong, but it is what it is.


FA's will have the choice, merging teams will have the choice, teams emerging from the cloud will have the choice. The path to the WL is going to be easier - for a while - through non-USAPL leagues. That will attract many (not all, you are right, some will still want to go to USAPL) of the best up and coming players and agents. I think things will even out more than you think. And, I really don't think most will opt for the USAPL just because many of the older USAPL teams have succeeded in the WL. Maybe I'm wrong, dunno. Hope many (most) would choose to blaze their own path.
Edited by turnit643 on Jul 27, 2009 22:40:50
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by walker1
Alright here is why random is better then back down to the original league:

Look, if you were a AAA team, and finished 5-11 and 12th in your conference and got demoted because 5 teams came down wouldn't you be pissed? It makes no sense to demote back to the own region. It is unfair and makes it harder to get into the world league for some teams. Plus it basicly makes region jumping possible. Wouldn't it be cool to see Drygerion demoted to USA Pro?


And what if Drygeria got demoted to EEPro or something?

Plus, Drygeria is the merger of 4 teams, 3 of which are canadian cities. Clearly a Canadian team.

Edit: also, that 5-11th, 12th in your conference and getting demoted is impossible under this format, sorry.
Edited by Gart888 on Jul 27, 2009 22:41:58
 
JeffSteele
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by walker1
Alright here is why random is better then back down to the original league:

Look, if you were a AAA team, and finished 5-11 and 12th in your conference and got demoted because 5 teams came down wouldn't you be pissed? It makes no sense to demote back to the own region. It is unfair and makes it harder to get into the world league for some teams. Plus it basicly makes region jumping possible. Wouldn't it be cool to see Drygerion demoted to USA Pro?
12th would only happen if 9 teams came down, not 5. 9 teams won't come down ever, so that situation doesn't apply. it's more likely that the team is 3-13 or 2-14 is forced down, and they deserve to go down b/c they went 3-13 or 2-14.
 
Anarcho
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by walker1
Alright here is why random is better then back down to the original league:

Look, if you were a AAA team, and finished 5-11 and 12th in your conference and got demoted because 5 teams came down wouldn't you be pissed? It makes no sense to demote back to the own region. It is unfair and makes it harder to get into the world league for some teams. Plus it basicly makes region jumping possible. Wouldn't it be cool to see Drygerion demoted to USA Pro?


Does it matter if they are pissed? That scenario is extremely unlikely statistically, whereas the chances of owners getting randomly put into regions they don't want to be is pretty high.

Personally, if you are finishing at less than .500 in any league, I think you should probably move down a level either way.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.