User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > A WPL WITHOUT MM-OFGand WW IS BS
Page:
 
nthomas
offline
Link
 
USAPL teams have had a HUGE recruiting edge since season 3. Anyone who denies that is either ignorant or just in denial. The WPL will even out the players across all the leagues, and erase the HUGE USAPL bias that has existed since the start. If teams (and players) want to make the WPL, then they can reach it through any league.

The biggest whiners are those who have teams that will not make the WPL because they could not win two playoff games, and have players that will start to decline in season 12.

The way the WPL is envisioned, it will have the best teams in 2-3 seasons, and will continue to have the best teams for seasons to come. Setting it up any other way, including taking more USAPL teams right now (and I agree that there will be some of the top 32 teams left out in the first season) only plays to the long-standing USAPL bias.

Do the right thing...take the top 4 teams from each of the pro leagues, and give everyone an equal shot to earn their WPL status by winning. I think you will be surprised how many teams will be able to recruit better because they are in the WPL, and how many USAPL teams will suddenly know what it is like for others outside USAPL when they try to land top recruits.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Originally posted by Tony Dungy


because all non-USA teams know that USA has enjoyed a huge recruiting advantage since the beginning

go check out the FA ads from the last 10 seasons and see how many said USA ONLY

not only would the balanced system make the other leagues even with USA Pro in recruiting, this would even turn the table and even make people favor non-USA leagues because it would be easier to make the WPL. in EE or SEA for instance


Actually, folks have wanted a World League for a long time. Since it was on the NGTH list, folks made USAPL the defacto World League and the best talent flocked there.

Now you are telling the best talent and the best teams that the effort they put into the game doesn't matter because we are going to reward weaker leagues and ignore the fact the community tried to build a World League on it's own.

Is that what this is about? The destruction of USAPL because folks looked to it as the World League for quite some time? If so, come out and say. Put your agenda on the table.


destruction?

the agenda is to make all 8 leagues equal as Bort intended from day 1

maybe you should ask Bort if he intended to have 1 league which was far and away most popular?


The question in my mind is......should Bort allow USPL teams to move to other leagues to achieve the balance that is needed? I think the answer is yes, he should allow the movement.

I would push off the WPL for 1 more season and allow teams to switch leagues if they want knowing that the WPL spots are at stake. If they want to battle with the best teams in USPL, fine. If they want to play weaker competition in EE, then fine, they have a better shot at getting in.

What is wrong with that?
Edited by Tony Dungy on Jul 28, 2009 07:32:41
 
taurran
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Originally posted by taurran

It will have the best of the best from each region, barring those making excuses for losing early in the playoffs. It will mean jack, because the top 4 teams from each region is a large enough sample size to get the "best" in the game involved.


And yet everyone is saying that it's time to break USAPL's stranglehold on the best teams and best talent. If that's the case, taking 4 teams from USAPL and 4 teams from APL and 4 teams from OPL...pretty much means you aren't taking the best teams. Or are you telling me the 5th team in USAPL isn't better than the 4th teams from OPL or APL or SEAPL or pretty much any other league?

The best teams from each region is not the best teams because we all know the regions aren't equally balanced.


Look at the other thread.

I agree that the system you posted sounds good. I still think that the first season should have a balanced sample as well - 4 teams from each league.

From there it will balance out.
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tony Dungy
I think some are saying that balancing the leagues is just as important as having the top teams together

taking all USAPL teams means that no one currently in APL, EE, or SEA will EVER be able to recruit the best players and be the #1 team in the game.

It will take 4-5 seasons of relegations for there to be even 2-3 top teams relegated there and odds are that the recruiting of those teams would go way down and they might have to gut unless it is a Evil Monkeys or Benitos that somehow gets relegated there. Even then, we all saw how recruiting for a elite team like WSI withered in 1 season.


wat?

Talent will spread out if making the World League is the new goal, teams will flock to weaker leagues to make the World League.

It won't take 4-5 seasons of relegation if you do it right. It would take one. This isn't about how demotion/promotion works. Pretty much everyone agrees, non-playoff teams go down, league finalists go up. 16 down, 16 up. There will be plenty of churn to get new blood in the World League.

This is about how you want the World League to start. Do you want it to be the best of the best, or just some of the best?
 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tony Dungy

I think some are saying that balancing the leagues is just as important as having the top teams together

taking all USAPL teams means that no one currently in APL, EE, or SEA will EVER be able to recruit the best players and be the #1 team in the game.

It will take 4-5 seasons of relegations for there to be even 2-3 top teams relegated there and odds are that the recruiting of those teams would go way down and they might have to gut unless it is a Evil Monkeys or Benitos that somehow gets relegated there. Even then, we all saw how recruiting for a elite team like WSI withered in 1 season.



Like I said - people can't have it both ways. They either want the best teams in there or they don't - and if that means 10 teams from 1 league EARN their way there so be it. The world won't stop revolving if USA AAA has to send 10 teams to cover the vacancies in USA Pro - any more than what is happening with teams getting promoted 3 levels in the Minors.
Edited by greengoose on Jul 28, 2009 07:34:03
 
Link
 
Originally posted by nthomas
USAPL teams have had a HUGE recruiting edge since season 3. Anyone who denies that is either ignorant or just in denial. The WPL will even out the players across all the leagues, and erase the HUGE USAPL bias that has existed since the start. If teams (and players) want to make the WPL, then they can reach it through any league.

The biggest whiners are those who have teams that will not make the WPL because they could not win two playoff games, and have players that will start to decline in season 12.

The way the WPL is envisioned, it will have the best teams in 2-3 seasons, and will continue to have the best teams for seasons to come. Setting it up any other way, including taking more USAPL teams right now (and I agree that there will be some of the top 32 teams left out in the first season) only plays to the long-standing USAPL bias.

Do the right thing...take the top 4 teams from each of the pro leagues, and give everyone an equal shot to earn their WPL status by winning. I think you will be surprised how many teams will be able to recruit better because they are in the WPL, and how many USAPL teams will suddenly know what it is like for others outside USAPL when they try to land top recruits.


This is true.

The only thing that wasn't fair to the USPL teams was that they didn't know about this WPL thing going into effect back when they joined USPL and some might have opted to play in another region. Bort needs to let them choose a league with the knowledge that it will affect their WPL chances
 
taurran
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Originally posted by Tony Dungy

I think some are saying that balancing the leagues is just as important as having the top teams together

taking all USAPL teams means that no one currently in APL, EE, or SEA will EVER be able to recruit the best players and be the #1 team in the game.

It will take 4-5 seasons of relegations for there to be even 2-3 top teams relegated there and odds are that the recruiting of those teams would go way down and they might have to gut unless it is a Evil Monkeys or Benitos that somehow gets relegated there. Even then, we all saw how recruiting for a elite team like WSI withered in 1 season.


wat?

Talent will spread out if making the World League is the new goal, teams will flock to weaker leagues to make the World League.

It won't take 4-5 seasons of relegation if you do it right. It would take one. This isn't about how demotion/promotion works. Pretty much everyone agrees, non-playoff teams go down, league finalists go up. 16 down, 16 up. There will be plenty of churn to get new blood in the World League.

This is about how you want the World League to start. Do you want it to be the best of the best, or just some of the best?


We'd rather have a balanced sample rather than a biased selection laced with human opinion.

I understand you're angry that you lost out of the playoffs early. The penalty is that you don't go to the WPL. Deal with it.
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tony Dungy
What is wrong with that?


Nothing, other than it is unnecessary. Simply put the best teams in the World League now and let promotion/demotion sort it out.

The problem is that there are in the weaker leagues 1-3 deserving teams and there are 8-12 in USAPL. Do you see the problem?
 
taurran
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Originally posted by Tony Dungy

What is wrong with that?


Nothing, other than it is unnecessary. Simply put the best teams in the World League now and let promotion/demotion sort it out.

The problem is that there are in the weaker leagues 1-3 deserving teams and there are 8-12 in USAPL. Do you see the problem?


The problem is all in your head.

When it comes to hard facts, not human opinion, the teams that won playoff games are the most deserving.
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by taurran
We'd rather have a balanced sample rather than a biased selection laced with human opinion.

I understand you're angry that you lost out of the playoffs early. The penalty is that you don't go to the WPL. Deal with it.


Actually, your balanced sample is a human opinion. You want equal representation regardless of league strength.

I actually have two Pro teams I'm a part of, one of which I actually coordinate, recruit and help run....of course they lost in the first round of the playoffs quite badly. I am upset about that.
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by taurran
Originally posted by PackMan97

Originally posted by Tony Dungy


What is wrong with that?


Nothing, other than it is unnecessary. Simply put the best teams in the World League now and let promotion/demotion sort it out.

The problem is that there are in the weaker leagues 1-3 deserving teams and there are 8-12 in USAPL. Do you see the problem?


The problem is all in your head.

When it comes to hard facts, not human opinion, the teams that won playoff games are the most deserving.


This.
 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
Deserving means nothing if they don't have to play their way into the WL through a tournament - all deserving means in the absence of a tournament is subjective opinion. We all know the story about opinions though.......
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by taurran
When it comes to hard facts, not human opinion, the teams that won playoff games are the most deserving.


That's your opinion.
 
taurran
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Originally posted by taurran

We'd rather have a balanced sample rather than a biased selection laced with human opinion.

I understand you're angry that you lost out of the playoffs early. The penalty is that you don't go to the WPL. Deal with it.


Actually, your balanced sample is a human opinion. You want equal representation regardless of league strength.

I actually have two Pro teams I'm a part of, one of which I actually coordinate, recruit and help run....of course they lost in the first round of the playoffs quite badly. I am upset about that.


How is winning playoff games human opinion?

I'm curious how you came up with that. If you're comparing a panel of users voting on a teams to teams actually winning structured league playoffs then you're insane.
Edited by taurran on Jul 28, 2009 07:38:52
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Originally posted by taurran

When it comes to hard facts, not human opinion, the teams that won playoff games are the most deserving.


That's your opinion.


And yours is yours, nothing more.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.