User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > NERF THE FUMBLES NOW!!!
Page:
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lolMurp
Originally posted by jrry32

Originally posted by CapnEnnui


Originally posted by jrry32



Originally posted by CapnEnnui





Originally posted by Luzod






I think we are getting close to realism. However, Bort must stop falling for whinners.

If you look at this topic, many people are defending the actual sim. Still there are 4~5 whinners (yes, because the arguments you are using are really weak. The guy who's HB fumbled 15 times after his 180 plays still here for example) and they seems to be getting to Bort. Really, listen to reason and stop listening to guys that chose (yes, because in RPG you make choices on how you want your players to be) to have a very fast/agile HB that can't hold the ball.

It was their choice not to invest on carrying, so let them suffer.

The only guy with a point actually is GeneralM, but still, it's only 1 player in 1 game and we don't even know opponents builds, so...


They chose not to invest in a stat that wasn't useful until now. How is that their fault?

And how is this many fumbles "close to realism"? I said it already, Adrian Peterson is "fumble prone" because he fumbled 6 times in 16 games. That's not the rate we're going right now.


Oh so there should be realism on fumbles but yet a RB should still be able to average 300 yards a game.


SHUT UP you're just evading one problem by pointing at another!

RBs in pro leagues DON'T tend to average 300 yards a game. RBs who play gutted teams better damn well get tons of yards. This is about how the PRO LEAGUES are working, and I'm not even in them, I'm just sick of having almost no control over how good or bad my builds are!

Now that people know how good picking Sure Tackler/Power Tackler is, it's going to be the new I Slam unless something is done, so quit whining about RB yards and think about how stupid THIS problem is.


Well no, actually I was pointing out that it's bad logic that something that is detrimental to the offense should have to be made to have realistic stats while something in favor of offense shouldn't have realistic numbers.



I think no matter what we do, the game is going to be a game.

There's always going to be a 100-0 game, I think.

Striving for realism is fine and all, but sooner or later, we've all got to realize that internet text footballs ran by some guy in his basement =/= a real, honest-to-god american football sim.


I completely agree. That's my point, we should just focus on getting the sim working right instead of aiming for realistic numbers that break the sim even worse. Stop aiming for, well, NFL RBs only get 4-6 fumbles a year so my HB shouldn't fumble more than that. Bort should get fumbles a bit under control(but NOT make them non existant) and Bort should then focus on fixing broken elements in the sim instead of aiming to please whoever comes out screaming next about the lack of realism whether it be OL owners about DEs or LB owner about Power HBs or etc.

 
ShakeNBake
offline
Link
 
y can u ladies not show me a decent HB who fumbles? I don't get it
 
CapnEnnui
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by CapnEnnui

Originally posted by jrry32


Originally posted by CapnEnnui



Originally posted by jrry32




Originally posted by CapnEnnui






Originally posted by Luzod







I think we are getting close to realism. However, Bort must stop falling for whinners.

If you look at this topic, many people are defending the actual sim. Still there are 4~5 whinners (yes, because the arguments you are using are really weak. The guy who's HB fumbled 15 times after his 180 plays still here for example) and they seems to be getting to Bort. Really, listen to reason and stop listening to guys that chose (yes, because in RPG you make choices on how you want your players to be) to have a very fast/agile HB that can't hold the ball.

It was their choice not to invest on carrying, so let them suffer.

The only guy with a point actually is GeneralM, but still, it's only 1 player in 1 game and we don't even know opponents builds, so...


They chose not to invest in a stat that wasn't useful until now. How is that their fault?

And how is this many fumbles "close to realism"? I said it already, Adrian Peterson is "fumble prone" because he fumbled 6 times in 16 games. That's not the rate we're going right now.


Oh so there should be realism on fumbles but yet a RB should still be able to average 300 yards a game.


SHUT UP you're just evading one problem by pointing at another!

RBs in pro leagues DON'T tend to average 300 yards a game. RBs who play gutted teams better damn well get tons of yards. This is about how the PRO LEAGUES are working, and I'm not even in them, I'm just sick of having almost no control over how good or bad my builds are!

Now that people know how good picking Sure Tackler/Power Tackler is, it's going to be the new I Slam unless something is done, so quit whining about RB yards and think about how stupid THIS problem is.


Well no, actually I was pointing out that it's bad logic that something that is detrimental to the offense should have to be made to have realistic stats while something in favor of offense shouldn't have realistic numbers.



You're naming AA stats against gutted teams as a good reason to leave how bad the fumble situation is in Pro Leagues. So your argument is bad logic, not mine. I Slam is fixed. This isn't


Actually, no I'm more basing it off the people who still think that DEs are working properly because they aren't getting a lot of stats even against bad teams or the same people who scream for fumbles to be fixed when their HB has 40 carrying. Fumbles are out of whack, especially on kickoffs but part of this problem is people not getting their carrying up while Defensive players got strength and tackling up.


This would be true if it happened gradually, but it didn't. At the end of last season fumbling wasn't happening all the time. Did those defensive players really just get all the str/tkl they need to force a fumble plus per game, or did the dynamic of the game change?
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CapnEnnui
People keep building a good build one way, then it gets changed on them, and hordes of people shout YOURE BUILDING IT WRONG when that wasn't the case a week ago.


How about instead of building to the current popular flavor, you build a balanced build so you don't get screwed when the sim changes?
 
headsigh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ShakeNBake
Originally posted by CapnEnnui

People keep building a good build one way, then it gets changed on them, and hordes of people shout YOURE BUILDING IT WRONG when that wasn't the case a week ago.


Again, u no show a decent HB that fumbles


Adrian Peterson, Ahman Green.

GLB?
Why have you not actually tried to look for them yourself? I'm not a search engine.
 
ShakeNBake
offline
Link
 
Example of a decent HB that fumbles? No? Ok


/end thread
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CapnEnnui
Originally posted by jrry32



Actually, no I'm more basing it off the people who still think that DEs are working properly because they aren't getting a lot of stats even against bad teams or the same people who scream for fumbles to be fixed when their HB has 40 carrying. Fumbles are out of whack, especially on kickoffs but part of this problem is people not getting their carrying up while Defensive players got strength and tackling up.


This would be true if it happened gradually, but it didn't. At the end of last season fumbling wasn't happening all the time. Did those defensive players really just get all the str/tkl they need to force a fumble plus per game, or did the dynamic of the game change?


You're 100% INCORRECT. Fumbles were just like this at the end of last season, it just so happened that not many people had the balls to play on power tackling with Power HBs and the Strong I Slam. Do you want proof?
 
CapnEnnui
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by lolMurp

Originally posted by jrry32


Originally posted by CapnEnnui



Originally posted by jrry32




Originally posted by CapnEnnui






Originally posted by Luzod







I think we are getting close to realism. However, Bort must stop falling for whinners.

If you look at this topic, many people are defending the actual sim. Still there are 4~5 whinners (yes, because the arguments you are using are really weak. The guy who's HB fumbled 15 times after his 180 plays still here for example) and they seems to be getting to Bort. Really, listen to reason and stop listening to guys that chose (yes, because in RPG you make choices on how you want your players to be) to have a very fast/agile HB that can't hold the ball.

It was their choice not to invest on carrying, so let them suffer.

The only guy with a point actually is GeneralM, but still, it's only 1 player in 1 game and we don't even know opponents builds, so...


They chose not to invest in a stat that wasn't useful until now. How is that their fault?

And how is this many fumbles "close to realism"? I said it already, Adrian Peterson is "fumble prone" because he fumbled 6 times in 16 games. That's not the rate we're going right now.


Oh so there should be realism on fumbles but yet a RB should still be able to average 300 yards a game.


SHUT UP you're just evading one problem by pointing at another!

RBs in pro leagues DON'T tend to average 300 yards a game. RBs who play gutted teams better damn well get tons of yards. This is about how the PRO LEAGUES are working, and I'm not even in them, I'm just sick of having almost no control over how good or bad my builds are!

Now that people know how good picking Sure Tackler/Power Tackler is, it's going to be the new I Slam unless something is done, so quit whining about RB yards and think about how stupid THIS problem is.


Well no, actually I was pointing out that it's bad logic that something that is detrimental to the offense should have to be made to have realistic stats while something in favor of offense shouldn't have realistic numbers.



I think no matter what we do, the game is going to be a game.

There's always going to be a 100-0 game, I think.

Striving for realism is fine and all, but sooner or later, we've all got to realize that internet text footballs ran by some guy in his basement =/= a real, honest-to-god american football sim.


I completely agree. That's my point, we should just focus on getting the sim working right instead of aiming for realistic numbers that break the sim even worse. Stop aiming for, well, NFL RBs only get 4-6 fumbles a year so my HB shouldn't fumble more than that. Bort should get fumbles a bit under control(but NOT make them non existant) and Bort should then focus on fixing broken elements in the sim instead of aiming to please whoever comes out screaming next about the lack of realism whether it be OL owners about DEs or LB owner about Power HBs or etc.



This is mostly a good post, but DEs could've said it before they got nerfed, I slam users could've said it before they got nerfed, etc.

I'm not saying fumbling should end. I'm saying there are too many all of the sudden and no way to build a fix for it this season.
 
ShakeNBake
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lolMurp
Originally posted by ShakeNBake

Originally posted by CapnEnnui


People keep building a good build one way, then it gets changed on them, and hordes of people shout YOURE BUILDING IT WRONG when that wasn't the case a week ago.


Again, u no show a decent HB that fumbles


Adrian Peterson, Ahman Green.

GLB?
Why have you not actually tried to look for them yourself? I'm not a search engine.


I wasn't talking about the NFL
 
Grim Truth
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ShakeNBake
Originally posted by Grim Truth

Originally posted by ShakeNBake




i don't believe it for a second


That I have 2 coverup?


That a decently built HB is fumbling a couple times a game, show me


That's a double edged sword if ever there was.

I can link all the RB's I know of who are fumbling, but you'll demand their build... Which means exposing builds given to me in confidence just to win a silly argument, or for you to say "they don't have 60 carry so they suck" when their a Speed/Elusive RB and need to work Speed and Agility to even have a chance at productivity and 60 carry is unrealistic to expect when you're building someone who isn't a one-dimensional Powerback.

On the other hand, I could stay true to my word, not link anyone and expose their builds, and you can say I'm lying...
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Isn't it kind of obvious what happened? Attribute VAs got nerfed. Now the defensive players started putting points into VAs that increased the chances of forcing fumbles.
 
ShakeNBake
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Grim Truth
Originally posted by ShakeNBake

Originally posted by Grim Truth


Originally posted by ShakeNBake





i don't believe it for a second


That I have 2 coverup?


That a decently built HB is fumbling a couple times a game, show me


That's a double edged sword if ever there was.

I can link all the RB's I know of who are fumbling, but you'll demand their build... Which means exposing builds given to me in confidence just to win a silly argument, or for you to say "they don't have 60 carry so they suck" when their a Speed/Elusive RB and need to work Speed and Agility to even have a chance at productivity and 60 carry is unrealistic to expect when you're building someone who isn't a one-dimensional Powerback.

On the other hand, I could stay true to my word, not link anyone and expose their builds, and you can say I'm lying...


U just bitch on, ur builds u can show suck so u choose not to so u can continue ur bitching
 
CapnEnnui
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by CapnEnnui

Originally posted by jrry32




Actually, no I'm more basing it off the people who still think that DEs are working properly because they aren't getting a lot of stats even against bad teams or the same people who scream for fumbles to be fixed when their HB has 40 carrying. Fumbles are out of whack, especially on kickoffs but part of this problem is people not getting their carrying up while Defensive players got strength and tackling up.


This would be true if it happened gradually, but it didn't. At the end of last season fumbling wasn't happening all the time. Did those defensive players really just get all the str/tkl they need to force a fumble plus per game, or did the dynamic of the game change?


You're 100% INCORRECT. Fumbles were just like this at the end of last season, it just so happened that not many people had the balls to play on power tackling with Power HBs and the Strong I Slam. Do you want proof?


You're somewhat right, actually. But it's gotten much easier to play power tackling since power HBs were nerfed, and much more rational to pick the power tackler VA, so things are still way different. And the real victim is every offensive ball holder EXCEPT power HBs
 
headsigh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Isn't it kind of obvious what happened? Attribute VAs got nerfed. Now the defensive players started putting points into VAs that increased the chances of forcing fumbles.


Yeah, and now that Bort will ineveitably succumb to the madness, a lot of linebackers will be looking for a job next year.
 
ShakeNBake
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Isn't it kind of obvious what happened? Attribute VAs got nerfed. Now the defensive players started putting points into VAs that increased the chances of forcing fumbles.


I don't see the problem
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.