User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > A WPL WITHOUT MM-OFGand WW IS BS
Page:
 
taurran
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Buxx
Better for Bort to give a lil personal attention to just 1 league ... his biggest league ... than to let artificial intelligence fuck it all up.
The committee sets it up ... then Bort reviews their work.
The only thing id automate is allowing the superbowl winner from each pro league to go.


Pretty sure USA Pro is no bigger than any other Pro league.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by taurran
Originally posted by coachviking

Originally posted by randomguymike


Originally posted by coachviking




USA PRO 5
SA PRO 5
CPL 4
EEPL 2
OPL 3
WEPL 2
SEPL 1
No Pro Affiliation 3

Not really a USA PRO heavy vote. If you saw any of the "discusion" threads in the forum about the vote their is a heavy anit-USA PRO bias at times.
CPL 3



So..... move the three non-pro to EEPL, WEPL, and SEPL and you have pretty much the original format suggested. One USPL and SAPL team gets 'hosed' . If all this is over two teams, why the hell can't all the whiners just shut up?


NO this isn't the teams that made the list this is the affiliation of the the Voters. Sorry for not being clear. Here is the break down by league for Top 32 teams

USA 11 of the 32
APL 5 of the 32
CPL 4 of the 32
SAPL 4 of the 32
WEPL 3 of 32
SEA 3 of 32
EEPL 2 of 32
OPL 0 of 32


I fail to see how this is not bias?


It would be biased if there were no tournaments and the votes are purely based on speculation, but check out PWT and Hazy's tourney, USAPL teams have a much better winning % than any other Pro League. Doesn't mean there are no good teams in other Pro Leagues, USAPL simply has more. Facts are facts.

Take SDL in USAPL for example, the team finished 4-12 in the West conference, but is 3-1 against 4 PLAYOFF teams from other Pro Leagues.
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by taurran
So what you're telling me is you want more reps and more competition for a WPL trophy while screwing other leagues out of a chance at a championship? You want to rely on players in an online game rather than a set system?


What a lot of the USAPL folks are saying is that they want the World League to be a best of the best league, not just a some of the best league.

Why is that hard to understand?

Take the 16 league final participants and take the next top 16 teams as determined by Hazy's elite 8, the PWT elite 8 and the Colley/LARS computer rankings.

That's not arbitrary./ That's not random and it certainly isn't biased to any one region.

Or heck, how about delay the World League for a season and run a play in tournament for using all 128 pro teams that made the playoffs. The top 32 make it to the World League.

If folks want the World League to be the best of the best, why "wait for it to work out", why not just make it that way to start with and set up the promotion/demotion system to allow every league to be represented.
 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
Well, every league in virtually every sport that has a league disparity has arbitrary "top leagues".

Soccer? La Liga, English Premiership and Serie A dominate the Champions League format
Football? SEC, Big 12, etc dominate the BCS landscape

The only solution to the problem is to have a tournament during the season where EVERY Pro level team plays in it and the 32 left standing at the end of it go to the WL. If that happens to be 10 teams from the same league so be it.

Can't have it both ways though, can't say "we want the best to go to the WL" and at the same time say "this will hurt the credibility of the Pro league that lost all these teams" - there will be plenty of teams ready to assume those positions.

Seed them accordingly and let them battle their way to the WL in a 1-off tournament - force these teams to take these games seriously if they want to move to the WL. If the #4 seed loses to the #253rd seed - tough titty.

Week 10 - 256 teams reduced to 128 teams
Week 12 - 128 teams reduced to 64 teams
Week 14 - 64 teams reduced to 32 teams - and there is your WL for the following season - and done in time so that it doesn't get in the way of the playoffs either.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by taurran
Furthermore,

This whole debate is really retarded. I mean, if there were more USA teams allowed in the world league or tourney, it just means that each is less likely to win a championship trophy for that season. If the USA Pro league is the best, as it seems to believe, they should be consoled in the fact that the teams that DO get promoted to WPL have the highest chance to win the championship as any. The ones that just miss out on being promoted then are first in line for a USA Pro league trophy. I don't see where the downside is. You've got a better chance at winning a trophy both ways.

This argument just comes down to people wanting preferential treatment. If things are they way they say, they'll be better off even with 4 teams in WPL.


That's why we talk about winning %s, not just number of wins.
 
coachviking
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by taurran
Originally posted by Buxx

Better for Bort to give a lil personal attention to just 1 league ... his biggest league ... than to let artificial intelligence fuck it all up.
The committee sets it up ... then Bort reviews their work.
The only thing id automate is allowing the superbowl winner from each pro league to go.


Pretty sure USA Pro is no bigger than any other Pro league.


Bigger NO Better YES
 
taurran
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Originally posted by taurran

So what you're telling me is you want more reps and more competition for a WPL trophy while screwing other leagues out of a chance at a championship? You want to rely on players in an online game rather than a set system?


What a lot of the USAPL folks are saying is that they want the World League to be a best of the best league, not just a some of the best league.

Why is that hard to understand?

Take the 16 league final participants and take the next top 16 teams as determined by Hazy's elite 8, the PWT elite 8 and the Colley/LARS computer rankings.

That's not arbitrary./ That's not random and it certainly isn't biased to any one region.

Or heck, how about delay the World League for a season and run a play in tournament for using all 128 pro teams that made the playoffs. The top 32 make it to the World League.

If folks want the World League to be the best of the best, why "wait for it to work out", why not just make it that way to start with and set up the promotion/demotion system to allow every league to be represented.


What's so hard to understand that "best" is often subjective?
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97

Or heck, how about delay the World League for a season and run a play in tournament for using all 128 pro teams that made the playoffs. The top 32 make it to the World League.


If we do that, at least 8 teams from USAPL will make it, possibly 12.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Originally posted by taurran

So what you're telling me is you want more reps and more competition for a WPL trophy while screwing other leagues out of a chance at a championship? You want to rely on players in an online game rather than a set system?


What a lot of the USAPL folks are saying is that they want the World League to be a best of the best league, not just a some of the best league.

Why is that hard to understand?

Take the 16 league final participants and take the next top 16 teams as determined by Hazy's elite 8, the PWT elite 8 and the Colley/LARS computer rankings.

That's not arbitrary./ That's not random and it certainly isn't biased to any one region.

Or heck, how about delay the World League for a season and run a play in tournament for using all 128 pro teams that made the playoffs. The top 32 make it to the World League.

If folks want the World League to be the best of the best, why "wait for it to work out", why not just make it that way to start with and set up the promotion/demotion system to allow every league to be represented.



because all non-USA teams know that USA has enjoyed a huge recruiting advantage since the beginning

go check out the FA ads from the last 10 seasons and see how many said USA ONLY

not only would the balanced system make the other leagues even with USA Pro in recruiting, this would even turn the table and even make people favor non-USA leagues because it would be easier to make the WPL. in EE or SEA for instance

Edited by Tony Dungy on Jul 28, 2009 07:20:18
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by taurran
What's so hard to understand that "best" is often subjective?


It's not, but I do know that the system I propose will do a heck of a lot better job getting the best teams into a World League than taking the 4 conference finalists from each league.

No one can suggest the top 4 from each league of the best 32 teams in GLB.

So I ask again, is the purpose of the World League to have the best 4 teams from each league, or is the purpose to have the best 32 teams in GLB?

If you want a World League the only rewards the best from each region, then you will have a neutered World League that doesn't mean jack for a few seasons.
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tony Dungy

because all non-USA teams know that USA has enjoyed a huge recruiting advantage since the beginning

go check out the FA ads from the last 10 seasons and see how many said USA ONLY

not only would the balanced system make the other leagues even with USA Pro in recruiting, this would even turn the table and even make people favor non-USA leagues because it would be easier to make the WPL. in EE or SEA for instance


Actually, folks have wanted a World League for a long time. Since it was on the NGTH list, folks made USAPL the defacto World League and the best talent flocked there.

Now you are telling the best talent and the best teams that the effort they put into the game doesn't matter because we are going to reward weaker leagues and ignore the fact the community tried to build a World League on it's own.

Is that what this is about? The destruction of USAPL because folks looked to it as the World League for quite some time? If so, come out and say. Put your agenda on the table.
 
taurran
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Originally posted by taurran

What's so hard to understand that "best" is often subjective?


It's not, but I do know that the system I propose will do a heck of a lot better job getting the best teams into a World League than taking the 4 conference finalists from each league.

No one can suggest the top 4 from each league of the best 32 teams in GLB.

So I ask again, is the purpose of the World League to have the best 4 teams from each league, or is the purpose to have the best 32 teams in GLB?

If you want a World League the only rewards the best from each region, then you will have a neutered World League that doesn't mean jack for a few seasons.


It will have the best of the best from each region, barring those making excuses for losing early in the playoffs. It will mean jack, because the top 4 teams from each region is a large enough sample size to get the "best" in the game involved.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by greengoose
Well, every league in virtually every sport that has a league disparity has arbitrary "top leagues".

Soccer? La Liga, English Premiership and Serie A dominate the Champions League format
Football? SEC, Big 12, etc dominate the BCS landscape

The only solution to the problem is to have a tournament during the season where EVERY Pro level team plays in it and the 32 left standing at the end of it go to the WL. If that happens to be 10 teams from the same league so be it.

Can't have it both ways though, can't say "we want the best to go to the WL" and at the same time say "this will hurt the credibility of the Pro league that lost all these teams" - there will be plenty of teams ready to assume those positions.

Seed them accordingly and let them battle their way to the WL in a 1-off tournament - force these teams to take these games seriously if they want to move to the WL. If the #4 seed loses to the #253rd seed - tough titty.

Week 10 - 256 teams reduced to 128 teams
Week 12 - 128 teams reduced to 64 teams
Week 14 - 64 teams reduced to 32 teams - and there is your WL for the following season - and done in time so that it doesn't get in the way of the playoffs either.



I think some are saying that balancing the leagues is just as important as having the top teams together

taking all USAPL teams means that no one currently in APL, EE, or SEA will EVER be able to recruit the best players and be the #1 team in the game.

It will take 4-5 seasons of relegations for there to be even 2-3 top teams relegated there and odds are that the recruiting of those teams would go way down and they might have to gut unless it is a Evil Monkeys or Benitos that somehow gets relegated there. Even then, we all saw how recruiting for a elite team like WSI withered in 1 season.

 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by taurran
It will have the best of the best from each region, barring those making excuses for losing early in the playoffs. It will mean jack, because the top 4 teams from each region is a large enough sample size to get the "best" in the game involved.


And yet everyone is saying that it's time to break USAPL's stranglehold on the best teams and best talent. If that's the case, taking 4 teams from USAPL and 4 teams from APL and 4 teams from OPL...pretty much means you aren't taking the best teams. Or are you telling me the 5th team in USAPL isn't better than the 4th teams from OPL or APL or SEAPL or pretty much any other league?

The best teams from each region is not the best teams because we all know the regions aren't equally balanced.
 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
No matter the method used to determine the entrants to a WL - somebody is gonna bitch, moan and whine.

If it's the top of each league, some leagues will whine about those other leagues being inferior.
If it's by a tournament, some teams will whine they got a "bad draw" in the seeding process, or whine that a 1-off tournament isn't fair.

Bort is in a no-win scenario here - the only thing he can do is bulk order a bunch of Kleenex.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.