User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Endorsements - What I am thinking
Page:
 
gopinathtest
offline
Link
 
erer
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Anarcho
I understand the sentiment that some elite players didn't get endorsements.

However, you have to look at it from a gaming standpoint.

What purpose does it serve to award additional gear to players that are already at the peak of their performance? If these players already have 1000 fame, it's because they are already doing pretty well. Giving them the items would just increase the discrepancy between them and the next player.

By doing it "randomly" everyone gets a shot at it, but most likely the players that are in a position of need end up getting it. They may not be the best candidate for the item, but it certainly makes sense from a gaming standpoint why they would get it over the guy who ran for 7,000 yards in 5 games.

There's less reason to whine about this than there would be with the previous system where the rich got richer. Random is fine, even if it means 3rd stringers getting the rewards.


And it's like people can't read. He handed out local endorsements. Everyone has a chance at one. That is the point of the lower level endorsements, to give every Tom, Dick and harry a chance.

It has nothing to do with stats.

Now the national and MVP endorsements will be more stat related and bums will not stand a chance to receive them unless Bort tries to continue to make it fame based which I'm sure he is working on.

Plus, it is pretty obvious that some of the more vocal people who got a piece of endorsement gear from the first batch that was taken away and replaced by a local are whining to scrap it because they are butt hurt.
 
darncat
offline
Link
 
i think the most realistic way to base endorsements is from fame.

however, i think the basic premise of fame is flawed.

for one, a player should reciece fame for having good stats and attributes
as related to others in thier position.
for example, many rookies can get some fame through the combine,
and FBs who score TDs will get fame even if thier rushing totals don't compare to HBs.

By basing it only on close games, it is missing a lot of the point.
sure, a huge performance in an important game should give the most fame,
however, constantly racking up huge numbers in blowout wins
should provide a lot of fame also, it worked for kurt warner his first season...

overall, i think very good job on the game.

the only problem i see with the endorsements is that fame is poorly calculated.
if that was fixed, endorsements could be based mostly on it and it would work fine.
 
JeffSteele
offline
Link
 
I suggest that fame calculations be heavily weighted towards stats against playoff teams, and that thusly someone can "lose" fame for having better stats against a team currently in the playoffs that later during the season finds themselves out of the playoff picture.

Basically, we should implement "Quality Stats", which are stats against only teams currently in the top 8 in their conference. Then, just use those for fame calculations.
 
Link
 
worst thing is getting one and having it taken away IMO
 
Packers27
offline
Link
 
Adding an MVP race would be very cool. I've never been bias. I've always been open-minded but on alert. Seriously, is there any negatives about an MVP race? I don't think so. It would bring another great piece of greatness to this game. Basing it on "fame" and stats combined from the league leaders. There should be an offensive MVP and defensive MVP of every single league. That way everyone can enjoy and have something to play even though their player is a lower skill level. Therefor, make it available for D-Leagues to. If one MVP is giving out per league then a defensive player doesn't stand a chance against glamour players. Thats just my opinion.


Landry, I'm not as familar to GLB as other players but maybe if we had a trophy case that we could stash our awards in, then it would never be taken away. In your case, it would suck to win one or lose one. Once you win it, then its yours for that year and it would be there forever to show off.
Last edited Mar 11, 2009 18:23:12
 
staxringold
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Packers27
Adding an MVP race would be very cool. I've never been bias. I've always been open-minded but on alert. Seriously, is there any negatives about an MVP race? I don't think so. It would bring another great piece of greatness to this game. Basing it on "fame" and stats combined from the league leaders. There should be an offensive MVP and defensive MVP of every single league. That way everyone can enjoy and have something to play even though their player is a lower skill level. Therefor, make it available for D-Leagues to. If one MVP is giving out per league then a defensive player doesn't stand a chance against glamour players. Thats just my opinion.


Landry, I'm not as familar to GLB as other players but maybe if we had a trophy case that we could stash our awards in, then it would never be taken away. In your case, it would suck to win one or lose one. Once you win it, then its yours for that year and it would be there forever to show off.


I definitely think an MVP race would be fun. Either a league leader page or just a top 10/15/20/25 of MVP candidates as the weeks roll along.
 
slydersneak
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by staxringold
Originally posted by Packers27

Adding an MVP race would be very cool. I've never been bias. I've always been open-minded but on alert. Seriously, is there any negatives about an MVP race? I don't think so. It would bring another great piece of greatness to this game. Basing it on "fame" and stats combined from the league leaders. There should be an offensive MVP and defensive MVP of every single league. That way everyone can enjoy and have something to play even though their player is a lower skill level. Therefor, make it available for D-Leagues to. If one MVP is giving out per league then a defensive player doesn't stand a chance against glamour players. Thats just my opinion.


Landry, I'm not as familar to GLB as other players but maybe if we had a trophy case that we could stash our awards in, then it would never be taken away. In your case, it would suck to win one or lose one. Once you win it, then its yours for that year and it would be there forever to show off.


I definitely think an MVP race would be fun. Either a league leader page or just a top 10/15/20/25 of MVP candidates as the weeks roll along.

I wondering how cruise control would affect this!

 
Link
 
Originally posted by Anarcho
I understand the sentiment that some elite players didn't get endorsements.

However, you have to look at it from a gaming standpoint.

What purpose does it serve to award additional gear to players that are already at the peak of their performance? If these players already have 1000 fame, it's because they are already doing pretty well. Giving them the items would just increase the discrepancy between them and the next player.

By doing it "randomly" everyone gets a shot at it, but most likely the players that are in a position of need end up getting it. They may not be the best candidate for the item, but it certainly makes sense from a gaming standpoint why they would get it over the guy who ran for 7,000 yards in 5 games.

There's less reason to whine about this than there would be with the previous system where the rich got richer. Random is fine, even if it means 3rd stringers getting the rewards.


I'm trying to be "positive" about this, but one thing I like about the game is that it tries to somewhat mimic "real" football at the professional level. IN the NFL, endorsements don't go to unknown players very often, who don't play at a high level. They go to higher profile players who are well known. I understand the sentiment that some don't want the "rich to get richer" type of thing. But if the goal is to randomly give stuff to weaker players, then perhaps it would be better to call it something other than an "endorsement" -- because it certainly doesn't work like an endorsement. It's a gift. Not something earned.

Maybe we could come up with another name. Something like a lottery win or something like that......or "Bort Boost"...

Just a thought.

Last edited Mar 12, 2009 09:57:38
 
lan the man
offline
Link
 
hey that sounds good but what i was thinking you could get the coaches from each conference and they vote on 2 or players for every team based on stats and stuff make it more involved.
 
xcrunner12
offline
Link
 
i like this idea
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Problem with endorsement is how screwed up fame is. When 4-4 teams are getting more fame than a 8-0 team in nearly every case I have looked at I can't see how fame can be used to determine endorsements.

Just looking at Pee Wee teams most 8-0 teams will normally have 20 less fame than an 4-4 team and this works all the way to the pro leagues. I have seen 2-6 teams that have more fame than an undefeated team.

The key problem with fame right now is the blowout penalty. When a team wins by more than 70 they get no game fame and no performance bonuses from the game. Also, the team that gets beat by 70 receives no fame.

I just don't see the logic in this when a team is well within the suggested level of the league.



Last edited Mar 13, 2009 17:51:31
 
chrisway
offline
Link
 
Pretty much in agreement, My HB leads the league in both rushing and recieving ....no Love in Canada A 6
 
slydersneak
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
Problem with endorsement is how screwed up fame is. When 4-4 teams are getting more fame than a 8-0 team in nearly every case I have looked at I can't see how fame can be used to determine endorsements.

Just looking at Pee Wee teams most 8-0 teams will normally have 20 less fame than an 4-4 team and this works all the way to the pro leagues. I have seen 2-6 teams that have more fame than an undefeated team.

The key problem with fame right now is the blowout penalty. When a team wins by more than 70 they get no game fame and no performance bonuses from the game. Also, the team that gets beat by 70 receives no fame.

I just don't see the logic in this when a team is well within the suggested level of the league.




Is this a cruise control problem , do you guys play many gutted , slow build teams?
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by slydersneak
Originally posted by Mightyhalo

Problem with endorsement is how screwed up fame is. When 4-4 teams are getting more fame than a 8-0 team in nearly every case I have looked at I can't see how fame can be used to determine endorsements.

Just looking at Pee Wee teams most 8-0 teams will normally have 20 less fame than an 4-4 team and this works all the way to the pro leagues. I have seen 2-6 teams that have more fame than an undefeated team.

The key problem with fame right now is the blowout penalty. When a team wins by more than 70 they get no game fame and no performance bonuses from the game. Also, the team that gets beat by 70 receives no fame.

I just don't see the logic in this when a team is well within the suggested level of the league.




Is this a cruise control problem , do you guys play many gutted , slow build teams?


That's another problem. You can't control how many slow build teams, gut jobs your league may have, but when you play them you will get no game fame. I can see the gut job/slow build team not getting fame since they are hurting the competitive balance of the league, but not a well run team well within the suggested level of the league shouldn't be penalized even in a blowout.



 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.