Maybe for Ball Carriers you should have an SA for "Break Tackle" not one that implies it breaks tackles. This SA would be activated by the players strength and would improve his roll for braking a tackle attempt.
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
bhall43
offline
offline
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by fletch03
Originally posted by jrry32
Seriously, Power RBs should be left alone...if people want to stop them...raise your tackling and strength. Easy as that, it's not impossible to stop a power RB. It's not like they are going to outrun you. lol
agreed.
+1, I don't see the problem at this time.
I am probably as unbiased as they come as I have all 3 types of RBs(elusive, balanced and Power) and my capped team today got destroyed by 2 Power RBs and I still don't see anything wrong with Power RBs that means they need to be nerfed. Make people fix it for themself Bort instead of fixing it for them.
i dont think they should be nerfed...but i think gang tackling should come into play....
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by fletch03
Originally posted by jrry32
Seriously, Power RBs should be left alone...if people want to stop them...raise your tackling and strength. Easy as that, it's not impossible to stop a power RB. It's not like they are going to outrun you. lol
agreed.
+1, I don't see the problem at this time.
I am probably as unbiased as they come as I have all 3 types of RBs(elusive, balanced and Power) and my capped team today got destroyed by 2 Power RBs and I still don't see anything wrong with Power RBs that means they need to be nerfed. Make people fix it for themself Bort instead of fixing it for them.
i dont think they should be nerfed...but i think gang tackling should come into play....
tautology
offline
offline
Originally posted by bhall43
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by fletch03
Originally posted by jrry32
Seriously, Power RBs should be left alone...if people want to stop them...raise your tackling and strength. Easy as that, it's not impossible to stop a power RB. It's not like they are going to outrun you. lol
agreed.
+1, I don't see the problem at this time.
I am probably as unbiased as they come as I have all 3 types of RBs(elusive, balanced and Power) and my capped team today got destroyed by 2 Power RBs and I still don't see anything wrong with Power RBs that means they need to be nerfed. Make people fix it for themself Bort instead of fixing it for them.
i dont think they should be nerfed...but i think gang tackling should come into play....
I agree they should not be nerfed, but I might argue that gang tackling already comes into play...I'll dig up an example perhaps...
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by fletch03
Originally posted by jrry32
Seriously, Power RBs should be left alone...if people want to stop them...raise your tackling and strength. Easy as that, it's not impossible to stop a power RB. It's not like they are going to outrun you. lol
agreed.
+1, I don't see the problem at this time.
I am probably as unbiased as they come as I have all 3 types of RBs(elusive, balanced and Power) and my capped team today got destroyed by 2 Power RBs and I still don't see anything wrong with Power RBs that means they need to be nerfed. Make people fix it for themself Bort instead of fixing it for them.
i dont think they should be nerfed...but i think gang tackling should come into play....
I agree they should not be nerfed, but I might argue that gang tackling already comes into play...I'll dig up an example perhaps...
schrauben
offline
offline
70 strength
70 tackling
50 speed
50 agility
50 vision
40 confidence
With pertinent SA's as well included should be able to bring down this power back. My issue is when they are breaking tackle after tackle on the same play. Then on the next play they break more tackles than the play before.
There needs to be a formula that takes into account stamina and reduces their chance to break a tackle after each broken tackle on the same play, consecutive plays, etc. The chance/ability of breaking a tackle should lessen the more it happens.
70 tackling
50 speed
50 agility
50 vision
40 confidence
With pertinent SA's as well included should be able to bring down this power back. My issue is when they are breaking tackle after tackle on the same play. Then on the next play they break more tackles than the play before.
There needs to be a formula that takes into account stamina and reduces their chance to break a tackle after each broken tackle on the same play, consecutive plays, etc. The chance/ability of breaking a tackle should lessen the more it happens.
jdros13
offline
offline
Originally posted by bhall43
i dont think they should be nerfed...but i think gang tackling should come into play....
This is absolutely needed and would solve any "problems" people are having.
i dont think they should be nerfed...but i think gang tackling should come into play....
This is absolutely needed and would solve any "problems" people are having.
wombat killer
offline
offline
Originally posted by bhall43
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by fletch03
Originally posted by jrry32
Seriously, Power RBs should be left alone...if people want to stop them...raise your tackling and strength. Easy as that, it's not impossible to stop a power RB. It's not like they are going to outrun you. lol
agreed.
+1, I don't see the problem at this time.
I am probably as unbiased as they come as I have all 3 types of RBs(elusive, balanced and Power) and my capped team today got destroyed by 2 Power RBs and I still don't see anything wrong with Power RBs that means they need to be nerfed. Make people fix it for themself Bort instead of fixing it for them.
i dont think they should be nerfed...but i think gang tackling should come into play....
I agree with this. Gang tackling should have greater success.
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by fletch03
Originally posted by jrry32
Seriously, Power RBs should be left alone...if people want to stop them...raise your tackling and strength. Easy as that, it's not impossible to stop a power RB. It's not like they are going to outrun you. lol
agreed.
+1, I don't see the problem at this time.
I am probably as unbiased as they come as I have all 3 types of RBs(elusive, balanced and Power) and my capped team today got destroyed by 2 Power RBs and I still don't see anything wrong with Power RBs that means they need to be nerfed. Make people fix it for themself Bort instead of fixing it for them.
i dont think they should be nerfed...but i think gang tackling should come into play....
I agree with this. Gang tackling should have greater success.
23yrwej
offline
offline
Originally posted by jdros13
Originally posted by bhall43
i dont think they should be nerfed...but i think gang tackling should come into play....
This is absolutely needed and would solve any "problems" people are having.
TOTALLY AGREED!
Originally posted by bhall43
i dont think they should be nerfed...but i think gang tackling should come into play....
This is absolutely needed and would solve any "problems" people are having.
TOTALLY AGREED!
jdros13
offline
offline
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by bhall43
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by fletch03
Originally posted by jrry32
Seriously, Power RBs should be left alone...if people want to stop them...raise your tackling and strength. Easy as that, it's not impossible to stop a power RB. It's not like they are going to outrun you. lol
agreed.
+1, I don't see the problem at this time.
I am probably as unbiased as they come as I have all 3 types of RBs(elusive, balanced and Power) and my capped team today got destroyed by 2 Power RBs and I still don't see anything wrong with Power RBs that means they need to be nerfed. Make people fix it for themself Bort instead of fixing it for them.
i dont think they should be nerfed...but i think gang tackling should come into play....
I agree they should not be nerfed, but I might argue that gang tackling already comes into play...I'll dig up an example perhaps...
Bort has already said in this thread that there is no gang tackling currently.
Originally posted by bhall43
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by fletch03
Originally posted by jrry32
Seriously, Power RBs should be left alone...if people want to stop them...raise your tackling and strength. Easy as that, it's not impossible to stop a power RB. It's not like they are going to outrun you. lol
agreed.
+1, I don't see the problem at this time.
I am probably as unbiased as they come as I have all 3 types of RBs(elusive, balanced and Power) and my capped team today got destroyed by 2 Power RBs and I still don't see anything wrong with Power RBs that means they need to be nerfed. Make people fix it for themself Bort instead of fixing it for them.
i dont think they should be nerfed...but i think gang tackling should come into play....
I agree they should not be nerfed, but I might argue that gang tackling already comes into play...I'll dig up an example perhaps...
Bort has already said in this thread that there is no gang tackling currently.
Crawly
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
The question I pose to the community (and this is often a topic of much debate) is: what sort of tackling/strength/SA's do you think you should need to consistently stop this guy?
For varying definitions of "Stop"...
To regularly stop a guy like this short in their tracks, I would expect something in the neighborhood of 70-70 strength/tackling.
To regularly tackle a guy like this, I would expect something in the neighborhood of soft-capped strength/tackling. However, the RB would consistently draw out significant extra yardage.
With about 35/35 strength/tackling, I would expect defenders to have a hard time tackling this guy as often as not, and most of the tackles to be extra-yard tackles (shoestring, go low, or drag him down). Defenders in this situation would be more likely to slow the RB down (he'd just drag them along) while someone else comes in for the tackle than they would be to tackle him.
Of course, weight should factor into this significantly - a 350 pound NT with great agility can just stand there and let the RB plow into him, and probably get the tackle. A 180 pound CB would be used as carry-on and placed on the overhead luggage compartment.
-C
The question I pose to the community (and this is often a topic of much debate) is: what sort of tackling/strength/SA's do you think you should need to consistently stop this guy?
For varying definitions of "Stop"...
To regularly stop a guy like this short in their tracks, I would expect something in the neighborhood of 70-70 strength/tackling.
To regularly tackle a guy like this, I would expect something in the neighborhood of soft-capped strength/tackling. However, the RB would consistently draw out significant extra yardage.
With about 35/35 strength/tackling, I would expect defenders to have a hard time tackling this guy as often as not, and most of the tackles to be extra-yard tackles (shoestring, go low, or drag him down). Defenders in this situation would be more likely to slow the RB down (he'd just drag them along) while someone else comes in for the tackle than they would be to tackle him.
Of course, weight should factor into this significantly - a 350 pound NT with great agility can just stand there and let the RB plow into him, and probably get the tackle. A 180 pound CB would be used as carry-on and placed on the overhead luggage compartment.

-C
bhall43
offline
offline
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by bhall43
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by fletch03
Originally posted by jrry32
Seriously, Power RBs should be left alone...if people want to stop them...raise your tackling and strength. Easy as that, it's not impossible to stop a power RB. It's not like they are going to outrun you. lol
agreed.
+1, I don't see the problem at this time.
I am probably as unbiased as they come as I have all 3 types of RBs(elusive, balanced and Power) and my capped team today got destroyed by 2 Power RBs and I still don't see anything wrong with Power RBs that means they need to be nerfed. Make people fix it for themself Bort instead of fixing it for them.
i dont think they should be nerfed...but i think gang tackling should come into play....
I agree they should not be nerfed, but I might argue that gang tackling already comes into play...I'll dig up an example perhaps...
sorry...i know it comes into play...but more realistically...like stated much earlier in this thread...where the power back carries defenders and is slowed down until multiple defenders come...rather than just shedding defenders left and right...
Originally posted by bhall43
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by fletch03
Originally posted by jrry32
Seriously, Power RBs should be left alone...if people want to stop them...raise your tackling and strength. Easy as that, it's not impossible to stop a power RB. It's not like they are going to outrun you. lol
agreed.
+1, I don't see the problem at this time.
I am probably as unbiased as they come as I have all 3 types of RBs(elusive, balanced and Power) and my capped team today got destroyed by 2 Power RBs and I still don't see anything wrong with Power RBs that means they need to be nerfed. Make people fix it for themself Bort instead of fixing it for them.
i dont think they should be nerfed...but i think gang tackling should come into play....
I agree they should not be nerfed, but I might argue that gang tackling already comes into play...I'll dig up an example perhaps...
sorry...i know it comes into play...but more realistically...like stated much earlier in this thread...where the power back carries defenders and is slowed down until multiple defenders come...rather than just shedding defenders left and right...
tautology
offline
offline
Originally posted by jdros13
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by bhall43
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by fletch03
Originally posted by jrry32
Seriously, Power RBs should be left alone...if people want to stop them...raise your tackling and strength. Easy as that, it's not impossible to stop a power RB. It's not like they are going to outrun you. lol
agreed.
+1, I don't see the problem at this time.
I am probably as unbiased as they come as I have all 3 types of RBs(elusive, balanced and Power) and my capped team today got destroyed by 2 Power RBs and I still don't see anything wrong with Power RBs that means they need to be nerfed. Make people fix it for themself Bort instead of fixing it for them.
i dont think they should be nerfed...but i think gang tackling should come into play....
I agree they should not be nerfed, but I might argue that gang tackling already comes into play...I'll dig up an example perhaps...
Bort has already said in this thread that there is no gang tackling currently.
Meaning he has not programmed it specifically, but I think the effect is still there. I will find an example from todays scrimmage on my team.
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by bhall43
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by fletch03
Originally posted by jrry32
Seriously, Power RBs should be left alone...if people want to stop them...raise your tackling and strength. Easy as that, it's not impossible to stop a power RB. It's not like they are going to outrun you. lol
agreed.
+1, I don't see the problem at this time.
I am probably as unbiased as they come as I have all 3 types of RBs(elusive, balanced and Power) and my capped team today got destroyed by 2 Power RBs and I still don't see anything wrong with Power RBs that means they need to be nerfed. Make people fix it for themself Bort instead of fixing it for them.
i dont think they should be nerfed...but i think gang tackling should come into play....
I agree they should not be nerfed, but I might argue that gang tackling already comes into play...I'll dig up an example perhaps...
Bort has already said in this thread that there is no gang tackling currently.
Meaning he has not programmed it specifically, but I think the effect is still there. I will find an example from todays scrimmage on my team.
23yrwej
offline
offline
Originally posted by jdros13
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by bhall43
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by fletch03
Originally posted by jrry32
Seriously, Power RBs should be left alone...if people want to stop them...raise your tackling and strength. Easy as that, it's not impossible to stop a power RB. It's not like they are going to outrun you. lol
agreed.
+1, I don't see the problem at this time.
I am probably as unbiased as they come as I have all 3 types of RBs(elusive, balanced and Power) and my capped team today got destroyed by 2 Power RBs and I still don't see anything wrong with Power RBs that means they need to be nerfed. Make people fix it for themself Bort instead of fixing it for them.
i dont think they should be nerfed...but i think gang tackling should come into play....
I agree they should not be nerfed, but I might argue that gang tackling already comes into play...I'll dig up an example perhaps...
Bort has already said in this thread that there is no gang tackling currently.
Best example:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=350950&pbp_id=117457
Power RB is stuck in a pile of players, gets out...if there was gang tackling he wouldn't get out.
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by bhall43
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by fletch03
Originally posted by jrry32
Seriously, Power RBs should be left alone...if people want to stop them...raise your tackling and strength. Easy as that, it's not impossible to stop a power RB. It's not like they are going to outrun you. lol
agreed.
+1, I don't see the problem at this time.
I am probably as unbiased as they come as I have all 3 types of RBs(elusive, balanced and Power) and my capped team today got destroyed by 2 Power RBs and I still don't see anything wrong with Power RBs that means they need to be nerfed. Make people fix it for themself Bort instead of fixing it for them.
i dont think they should be nerfed...but i think gang tackling should come into play....
I agree they should not be nerfed, but I might argue that gang tackling already comes into play...I'll dig up an example perhaps...
Bort has already said in this thread that there is no gang tackling currently.
Best example:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=350950&pbp_id=117457
Power RB is stuck in a pile of players, gets out...if there was gang tackling he wouldn't get out.
buckets99
offline
offline
When it's one man trying to tackle a guy, it's understandable a bruiser could run through him, but the pinball action in the game is sort of ridiculous. Gang tackling should play a role.
I guess a couple big time tackle breakers NFL wise were like Earl Campbell or maybe a Walter Payton...so, possibly when those type of runners reach level 40ish you can have them become crippled and retire, or maybe have them die of some incurable liver disease.
I guess a couple big time tackle breakers NFL wise were like Earl Campbell or maybe a Walter Payton...so, possibly when those type of runners reach level 40ish you can have them become crippled and retire, or maybe have them die of some incurable liver disease.
n:iceman:16
offline
offline
Originally posted by bhall43
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by wombat killer
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by bhall43
Originally posted by Iceman16
I'm sure flames54 knows a lot more about how builds work than Bort does.
only a fool would really actually think that...
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=26286
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=124758
Yds/game? TDs/game?
Bump for bhall
Your argument actually gets worse and worse the more you post.
Where exactly are you adding anything relevant to this thread?
his one comment was more relevant than your entire argument here...seriously...read what you are posting....look at the examples....and think about what you are saying....pretty soon you will learn how foolish you are being....
Well continue thinking that what he says goes. As much as I'd love to be able to agree with you, it's not the case.
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by wombat killer
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by bhall43
Originally posted by Iceman16
I'm sure flames54 knows a lot more about how builds work than Bort does.
only a fool would really actually think that...
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=26286
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=124758
Yds/game? TDs/game?
Bump for bhall
Your argument actually gets worse and worse the more you post.
Where exactly are you adding anything relevant to this thread?
his one comment was more relevant than your entire argument here...seriously...read what you are posting....look at the examples....and think about what you are saying....pretty soon you will learn how foolish you are being....
Well continue thinking that what he says goes. As much as I'd love to be able to agree with you, it's not the case.
n:iceman:16
offline
offline
Originally posted by cmj33
Wrap Up tackling is not weak tackling. When you are taught to tackle you are taught to get lower than the ball carrier and wrap him up and drive through him. Not stand in one spot wait for him to make contact and let him truck over you.
Power Tackling is used more by SS as they use their shoulder and their body weight and momentum to attempt to take your head off. An more fumbles are caused by Coaches teaching players how to strip the ball as they are tackling than pplayers using power tackling so to imply power tackling should cause more fumbles has always been BS imo. I just don't see how Wrap Up tackling is being even considered a weak form of tackling.
+1
Wrap Up tackling is not weak tackling. When you are taught to tackle you are taught to get lower than the ball carrier and wrap him up and drive through him. Not stand in one spot wait for him to make contact and let him truck over you.
Power Tackling is used more by SS as they use their shoulder and their body weight and momentum to attempt to take your head off. An more fumbles are caused by Coaches teaching players how to strip the ball as they are tackling than pplayers using power tackling so to imply power tackling should cause more fumbles has always been BS imo. I just don't see how Wrap Up tackling is being even considered a weak form of tackling.
+1
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























