User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
uscbucsfan
offline
Link
 
I think it is only fair if we have to lower sacks to be realistic to lower pancakes....20-40+ a game is absurd
 
Mr_Victor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock
Originally posted by Kayoh

I'm not even going to bother ready any other posts, just the OP.

If your Agility isn't >61, Speed isn't >49, OR Vision isn't >49, then that's your problem right there. Fix it.


Seriously, I've seen two of your posts in the FB forum and now this one. Everything I've read in those posts has struck me as bad advice or uninformed. Please, do us all a favor and stop posting... not trying to be a jerk-off or anything, but you're dis-information will probably end up hurting anyone not knowledgeable enough, to know your advice from good advice.

P.S. 49 speed, 61 agility and 49 vision won't solve the issue completely. I have better stats than that on my OT and he still gets beat by the better built speed/agility DEs... maybe not after the most recent changes to protector, although I haven't gotten the chance to test them yet.


Yeah and protector doesn't work at ROT vs LDEs where people are lining up speed rushers.

The only cure I have found to speed rushers is to run at them early and pancake the hell out of them. If they want to build an olympic sprinter, run him over early in the game and often, that slows them down later when you want to pass ;-)
 
PDO
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by uscbucsfan
I think it is only fair if we have to lower sacks to be realistic to lower pancakes....20-40+ a game is absurd


Not to mention have hurries that actually, you know, DO SOMETHING and to have DE's able to deflect passes at the LOS.

As it is right now, a sack is the only useful kind of pressure on the QB.... and Bort just made it impossible to get one because most of GLB couldn't understand how to make an OT. There were successful OT's out there that could stop DE's.

Now bad OT's can hold good DE's to a hurry or two... and in an even matchup, the DE is done before he even starts.

So bloody stupid.
 
Black Peter
offline
Link
 
I've seen DEs deflect it at the LOS.
 
uscbucsfan
offline
Link
 
nevermind
Last edited Nov 19, 2008 17:29:36
 
PDO
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Toriq
I've seen DEs deflect it at the LOS.


Only on dumps to the HB.
 
imking27
offline
Link
 
problem is need to set skill both have to initiate a kind of engagement who ever wins the check (which usually has more points) will block in the one they put points in either speed engagement where agility and speed help or strength engagement focus on strength and blocking. this way you could control most of time how you block but line could counter by not putting points in these set skills. Instead they could beat you at blocking and strength or speed and agility. would give bonus if you are engaging strength and blocking and I have more points. same with the agility and speed. the bonus would maybe be applied to the checks on if i get around your block.
 
ron2288
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PDO
Originally posted by uscbucsfan

I think it is only fair if we have to lower sacks to be realistic to lower pancakes....20-40+ a game is absurd


Not to mention have hurries that actually, you know, DO SOMETHING and to have DE's able to deflect passes at the LOS.

As it is right now, a sack is the only useful kind of pressure on the QB.... and Bort just made it impossible to get one because most of GLB couldn't understand how to make an OT. There were successful OT's out there that could stop DE's.

Now bad OT's can hold good DE's to a hurry or two... and in an even matchup, the DE is done before he even starts.

So bloody stupid.


not to mention LOT can now block a DE and LB at once..this is so dam stupid...people need to learn to keep a TE in to block shorten their passing ..and try not to pass for 80 yards in one throw..now we have super LOTS..with builds that suck...unreal
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ron2288
not to mention LOT can now block a DE and LB at once..this is so dam stupid...people need to learn to keep a TE in to block shorten their passing ..and try not to pass for 80 yards in one throw..now we have super LOTS..with builds that suck...unreal


Not quite. I was barely giving my QB enough time... this was with 65 strength, 64 blocking, 50 speed, 67 agility and 49 vision (plus 2-2-2-2-1 pass tree and 2 first step). Set to pass block focus and going against one of the top speed rushing DEs in my league. I shut him down for the most part, but there was a couple plays where my QB just barely got the pass off before the DE was about to get him.

That isn't a sucky build, although I didn't have a jacked up protector SA either. Not to mention I set up the OAI to have the TE on the left side pass blocking most of the time (sometimes with a back helping). At worst, I had only one back to help protect (these were the majority of the plays where I was almost beat btw).

So I can't speak of the protector thing much, but it looked a lot more accurate to me. The DE was getting past my OT (with a back helping), in a little over 2 secs. Meaning that if the QB didn't get rid of the ball fast, he'd have been sacked.

It's looks pretty fair to me...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=219759&pbp_id=3861357

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=219759&pbp_id=3861557

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=219759&pbp_id=3861479

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=219759&pbp_id=3861742

Here's some against my back-up who has 5 protector, ~40 speed and ~60 agility...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=219759&pbp_id=3862085

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=219759&pbp_id=3862124

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=219759&pbp_id=3862115

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=219759&pbp_id=3862602
 
ron2288
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock
Originally posted by ron2288

not to mention LOT can now block a DE and LB at once..this is so dam stupid...people need to learn to keep a TE in to block shorten their passing ..and try not to pass for 80 yards in one throw..now we have super LOTS..with builds that suck...unreal


Not quite. I was barely giving my QB enough time... this was with 65 strength, 64 blocking, 50 speed, 67 agility and 49 vision (plus 2-2-2-2-1 pass tree and 2 first step). Set to pass block focus and going against one of the top speed rushing DEs in my league. I shut him down for the most part, but there was a couple plays where my QB just barely got the pass off before the DE was about to get him.

That isn't a sucky build, although I didn't have a jacked up protector SA either. Not to mention I set up the OAI to have the TE on the left side pass blocking most of the time (sometimes with a back helping). At worst, I had only one back to help protect (these were the majority of the plays where I was almost beat btw).

So I can't speak of the protector thing much, but it looked a lot more accurate to me. The DE was getting past my OT (with a back helping), in a little over 2 secs. Meaning that if the QB didn't get rid of the ball fast, he'd have been sacked.

It's looks pretty fair to me...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=219759&pbp_id=3861357

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=219759&pbp_id=3861557

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=219759&pbp_id=3861479

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=219759&pbp_id=3861742

Here's some against my back-up who has 5 protector, ~40 speed and ~60 agility...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=219759&pbp_id=3862085

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=219759&pbp_id=3862124

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=219759&pbp_id=3862115

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=219759&pbp_id=3862602


that is all nice and whatever..but I am talking about 1 OT blocking a LB and DE..I am for bring balance..and I will say there was something wrong before the change..but it could be fixed...there was teams..a lot of teams blocking the DE that are in question.....But now you got OT that are blocking a blitzing LB and a rushing DE...so basically the offense could beat something that was wrong and they get a ton of help now.....after most high level DE have boosted..again I will say something needed to be done..but why not wait until the off season and if you want links I will show them

..also I say nothing about OT having a sucky build...
Last edited Nov 19, 2008 21:59:35
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ron2288
that is all nice and whatever..but I am talking about 1 OT blocking a LB and DE..I am for bring balance..and I will say there was something wrong before the change..but it could be fixed...there was teams..a lot of teams blocking the DE that are in question.....But now you got OT that are blocking a blitzing LB and a rushing DE...so basically the offense could beat something that was wrong and they get a ton of help now.....after most high level DE have boosted..again I will say something needed to be done..but why not wait until the off season and if you want links I will show them.


I've seen some of the plays where it appears that the OT is blocking two players... it happens IRL, just not how most people envision it. Although, I've personally blocked two players on a number of occasions IRL, even occasionally in that Hercules type of way (a hand on each, without giving up any ground).

Football is a game of angles. If the overload player takes a poor angle, he's going to block himself out of the play. Simply by running into the OT/DE battle.

It doesn't happen all the time in GLB either, I do see it occasionally though. I also see the overload blitz work as well... it doesn't always work IRL though, so I don't see a huge issue with it. I think it could use a little tweaking, don't get me wrong, but overall it's not game-breaking (like the 12+ sack performances were).

P.S. You didn't direct the "LOT's with builds that suck" comment at me per say... but I took it as an implication that LOTs with sucky builds have it EZ mode, when it's not true. My OT has a good build and it still takes good game-planning to contain a good speed rush DE.
Last edited Nov 19, 2008 22:05:43
 
ron2288
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock
Originally posted by ron2288

that is all nice and whatever..but I am talking about 1 OT blocking a LB and DE..I am for bring balance..and I will say there was something wrong before the change..but it could be fixed...there was teams..a lot of teams blocking the DE that are in question.....But now you got OT that are blocking a blitzing LB and a rushing DE...so basically the offense could beat something that was wrong and they get a ton of help now.....after most high level DE have boosted..again I will say something needed to be done..but why not wait until the off season and if you want links I will show them.


I've seen some of the plays where it appears that the OT is blocking two players... it happens IRL, just not how most people envision it. Although, I've personally blocked two players on a number of occasions IRL, even occasionally in that Hercules type of way (a hand on each, without giving up any ground).

Football is a game of angles. If the overload player takes a poor angle, he's going to block himself out of the play. Simply by running into the OT/DE battle.

It doesn't happen all the time in GLB either, I do see it occasionally though. I also see the overload blitz work as well... it doesn't always work IRL though, so I don't see a huge issue with it. I think it could use a little tweaking, don't get me wrong, but overall it's not game-breaking (like the 12+ sack performances were).

P.S. You didn't direct the "LOT's with builds that suck" comment at me per say... but I took it as an implication that LOTs with sucky builds have it EZ mode, when it's not true. My OT has a good build and it still takes good game-planning to contain a good speed rush DE.


taken what I said as an implication that LOTs have sucky builds have easy was wrong to do..because I was not implying that...

Now I seen your post that you play football and and all that,...good for you..so do I..and yes I know football is about angles and this or that..but the way you go about your self through this thread you make it sound like they are making your bust at Canton...I am sure you got the rare block in on 2 guys at once...and your wrong it is not as common as you say for a OT to block a DE and lb..does it happen..yes..but not as common as you say
I am saying a level 32 OT blocking well built level 35 LB and level 37 DE on a regular bases in a game is going a little over board...I am not really in the mood to sit here and nit pick with you..there again I am sure you have vast knowledge of the game..that I respect and I am sure you played..I will not question that..I sure you do some wonderful things when you played...
but do try to take me as fool and tell this changes was for the better..or even try to hint that..or dont try to defend that now when OT's do some amazing crap for a whole game it is normal...as you told other on and off through out this thread when they argued about DE you would say it was not normal or this or that....so please do turn in to a hypocrite now that Bort has made a change and the change sucks....We had no problem with the DE before...yes we gave up our share of sacks..but yes we found ways to block the DE on my team and others that GM for.now the QB has all dam day to pass the ball..heck for the QB on my own team he had way to much time to throw in his game tonight...the defense is at a big disadvantage...which if this is what people want fine...because we have an offense full of 85+speed WR and a QB that can wing it... I would like to something that helps both side..now what that is I do not know since I know nothing about programming a simm as this
..
Last edited Nov 19, 2008 22:33:49
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ron2288
taken what I said as an implication that LOTs have sucky builds have easy was wrong to do..because I was not implying that...

Now I seen your post that you play football and and all that,...good for you..so do I..and yes I know football is about angles and this or that..but the way you go about your self through this thread you make it sound like they are making your bust at Canton...I am sure you got the rare block in on 2 guys at once...and your wrong it is not as common as you say for a OT to block a DE and lb..does it happen..yes..but not as common as you say
I am saying a level 32 OT blocking well built level 35 LB and level 37 DE on a regular bases in a game is going a little over board...I am not really in the mood to sit here and nit pick with you..there again I am sure you have vast knowledge of the game..that I respect and I am sure you played..I will not question that..I sure you do some wonderful things when you played...
but do try to take me as fool and tell this changes was for the better..or even try to hint that..or dont try to defend that now when OT's do some amazing crap for a whole game it is normal...as you told other on and off through out this thread when they argued about DE you would say it was not normal or this or that....so please do turn in to a hypocrite now that Bort has made a change and the change sucks....We had no problem with the DE before...yes we gave up our share of sacks..but yes we found ways to block the DE on my team and others that GM for.now the QB has all dam day to pass the ball..heck for the QB on my own team he had way to much time to throw in his game tonight...the defense is at a big disadvantage...which if this is what people want find...because we have an offense full of 85+speed WR and a QB that can wing it... I would like to something that helps both side..now what that is I do not know since I know nothing about programming a simm as this
..


It wasn't wrong to take what you said a certain way, it's part of the communication process. Maybe you need to explain your comments in a way that leaves no room for interpretation, if you do not want to clarify vague comments. I cannot read your mind, only the words that you type.

As for the whole "Canton bust" comment... bad form, friend. I have a high level of personal experience at both of these positions in question, higher than high school football (which TBPH, is the limit of most people's experience). I'm sorry if my experience makes you feel inadequate, but it is what it is.

Now onto the meat of the debate... like I said, most people are envisioning what's actually going on in the replay wrong. When a LB takes a poor path (i.e. angle) on his blitz, he will tie himself up in the block of the OT. That doesn't necessarily mean that the OT is blocking both players (in the sense of a sound technical block anyways). It just means that the LB is being cut off, by the 600 lbs or so, of linemen in his path.

I am also, in no way, being hypocritical. I showed a good sample of plays where a well built DE was still beating a well built OT, he was no longer getting there in 1 second though. Instead it was taking about 2 seconds to beat the OT (who in many of the plays even had a HB/FB helping block). If you watch the replays, the QB was barely getting rid of the ball in time, on some of those plays. I'm positive that if I didn't call plays with extra protection, that well-built DE would have had a couple sacks. So, I'm not sure what you're talking about, when you say that a QB has all day to throw (mine got sacked twice on blitzes in that same game).

Lastly, as I said previously, the OT picking up two blockers doesn't happen enough (from my experiences in GLB) to warrant a national emergency. Nor does it happen every single time, that play still nets sacks... IRL when you blitz unsuccessfully, it generally means that a good QB is going to burn you. Especially if your DBs are out-classed by the WRs. It could use a little tweaking sure, but it's not completely game-changing... like DEs racking up 12 sacks against OTs that had very little trouble with them last season. Our OTs gave up 10 sacks last season (16 games), they given up 19 sacks this season (in 5 games). I've made all the adjustments that I could possibly make and still giving up sacks (even with these new adjustments Bort made). Oh and all the adjustments that I've made has cost us about a full YPC in the running game. Although, it's a fair trade off IMHO... much better than not being able to pass the ball, pretty much, at all.

P.S. I have a DE as well, so I'm taking an objective side in this argument. I'm not really wanting to see either side become completely unstoppable. Overall, I still think it needs further adjusting, but it's a lot more realistic now.
 
ron2288
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock
Originally posted by ron2288

taken what I said as an implication that LOTs have sucky builds have easy was wrong to do..because I was not implying that...

Now I seen your post that you play football and and all that,...good for you..so do I..and yes I know football is about angles and this or that..but the way you go about your self through this thread you make it sound like they are making your bust at Canton...I am sure you got the rare block in on 2 guys at once...and your wrong it is not as common as you say for a OT to block a DE and lb..does it happen..yes..but not as common as you say
I am saying a level 32 OT blocking well built level 35 LB and level 37 DE on a regular bases in a game is going a little over board...I am not really in the mood to sit here and nit pick with you..there again I am sure you have vast knowledge of the game..that I respect and I am sure you played..I will not question that..I sure you do some wonderful things when you played...
but do try to take me as fool and tell this changes was for the better..or even try to hint that..or dont try to defend that now when OT's do some amazing crap for a whole game it is normal...as you told other on and off through out this thread when they argued about DE you would say it was not normal or this or that....so please do turn in to a hypocrite now that Bort has made a change and the change sucks....We had no problem with the DE before...yes we gave up our share of sacks..but yes we found ways to block the DE on my team and others that GM for.now the QB has all dam day to pass the ball..heck for the QB on my own team he had way to much time to throw in his game tonight...the defense is at a big disadvantage...which if this is what people want find...because we have an offense full of 85+speed WR and a QB that can wing it... I would like to something that helps both side..now what that is I do not know since I know nothing about programming a simm as this
..


It wasn't wrong to take what you said a certain way, it's part of the communication process. Maybe you need to explain your comments in a way that leaves no room for interpretation, if you do not want to clarify vague comments. I cannot read your mind, only the words that you type.

As for the whole "Canton bust" comment... bad form, friend. I have a high level of personal experience at both of these positions in question, higher than high school football (which TBPH, is the limit of most people's experience). I'm sorry if my experience makes you feel inadequate, but it is what it is.

Now onto the meat of the debate... like I said, most people are envisioning what's actually going on in the replay wrong. When a LB takes a poor path (i.e. angle) on his blitz, he will tie himself up in the block of the OT. That doesn't necessarily mean that the OT is blocking both players (in the sense of a sound technical block anyways). It just means that the LB is being cut off, by the 600 lbs or so, of linemen in his path.

I am also, in no way, being hypocritical. I showed a good sample of plays where a well built DE was still beating a well built OT, he was no longer getting there in 1 second though. Instead it was taking about 2 seconds to beat the OT (who in many of the plays even had a HB/FB helping block). If you watch the replays, the QB was barely getting rid of the ball in time, on some of those plays. I'm positive that if I didn't call plays with extra protection, that well-built DE would have had a couple sacks. So, I'm not sure what you're talking about, when you say that a QB has all day to throw (mine got sacked twice on blitzes in that same game).

Lastly, as I said previously, the OT picking up two blockers doesn't happen enough (from my experiences in GLB) to warrant a national emergency. Nor does it happen every single time, that play still nets sacks... IRL when you blitz unsuccessfully, it generally means that a good QB is going to burn you. Especially if your DBs are out-classed by the WRs. It could use a little tweaking sure, but it's not completely game-changing... like DEs racking up 12 sacks against OTs that had very little trouble with them last season. Our OTs gave up 10 sacks last season (16 games), they given up 19 sacks this season (in 5 games). I've made all the adjustments that I could possibly make and still giving up sacks (even with these new adjustments Bort made). Oh and all the adjustments that I've made has cost us about a full YPC in the running game. Although, it's a fair trade off IMHO... much better than not being able to pass the ball, pretty much, at all.

P.S. I have a DE as well, so I'm taking an objective side in this argument. I'm not really wanting to see either side become completely unstoppable. Overall, I still think it needs further adjusting, but it's a lot more realistic now.


again not here to nit pick but whatever....
I wasn't calling for an national emergency..everyone else expressing their unhappiness ..so was I

as for your experience making me feel inadequate,please get over your self.
Again I am sure you have a vast experience at the game of football...maybe higher the high school if so good for you
I am sorry if my words offend you this was not my intent.T hat is just how at that time you came across but as I said earlier..I am not in a good mood and the first thing that comes to mind I am typing.



As far as your team's adjustments..again i do not know what to tell expect it sounds like you ran into some bad luck..With thier being so many teams and so many builds..a lot alike with a difference here and there and gutted teams there will be vast difference. Giving up 19 sacks in 5 games would suck..I guess..my team never experienced that from day one since I own it..which I am sure there are a lot of teams that have never given up that many sacks in 5 games.
But againg as for thi being close to realistic...no

heck even in high school with your vast experience would have to agree with the defense blitzing with a free man it is more uncommon to see a QB have 10-20 seconds and still no threat of a sack or even any pressure. I have seen this with other teams since the change..now Is a DE getting to QB in 1 second close to real..no.. to their own right one is as extreme as the other...Heck between our 2 QB's in our
game out of 40 pass attempts we allowed one 1 hurry..never was our QB's in danger of being sack. One QB ending with 76% completion rate the other with 82% completion rate...combing for over 600 yards..we did out level their dline but not by much and combine for 9 TDs.
SO is this not as extreme as a DE getting 5+ sacks..is this close to realistic??
so a DE getting an ungodly amount of sacks is not worse the 2 QB's with no fear of a pass rush throwing for ungodly amount of TD..at least a team dont score 6 points with a sack..unless it is a safety then it is only 2 points..and yes I am complaining that my team was able to put these kinds of numbers..there is not challenge..heck the NFL Qb has 4-5 seconds to get rid of the ball..then more times or not he his sack..heck it is more on the uncommon side to see a QB with all day to throw... so is the changes made this more realistic..no just made it as extreme as the other..again this is what I was getting at..did I word it wrong maybe did I not explain enough maybe..but all one has to do is click on just about any league and see this happening..if it is not happening with your team..then I do not know what to tell you..but dont call this realistic more then it was..it just more extreme going the other way...at least you were able to block DE's ..maybe not in your teams case how it sounds..teams passing for 600+ yards and games turning into 50+something to 60+ something shoot outs is not realistic ..well maybe in collage..then it is not every weekend
Last edited Nov 20, 2008 01:54:13
 
TJ Spikes
offline
Link
 
btw... if speed is so important to an OT's build, why isn't it a Major or even a Minor Attribute for auto progression? Instead they get tackling?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.