User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > GLB Notes > CPL > Interesting topic of the Week: Evolutionism versus Creationism
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by X
This is generally why I feel so strongly about the gay marriage issue because the only reason that there isn't nation-wide legalized gay marriage in the US is on the basis of religious rhetoric and not on any legal or rational ground.


So you think the acceptance of gay marriage won't lead more impressionable children to choose having sex with the same sex? Or you just don't think that is a problem?

(Azure doesn't think that more homosexual activity would be a problem).


And I guess you haven't read the last 10 pages because religion wasn't a factor in any reason I gave. I can't wait til after lunch and you get to respond. I'm sure you will consider my argument with an open mind.
 
X
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by X

This is generally why I feel so strongly about the gay marriage issue because the only reason that there isn't nation-wide legalized gay marriage in the US is on the basis of religious rhetoric and not on any legal or rational ground.


So you think the acceptance of gay marriage won't lead more impressionable children to choose having sex with the same sex? Or you just don't think that is a problem?

(Azure doesn't think that more homosexual activity would be a problem).


Do I think that the legalization of gay marriage will lead to a larger instance of gay relationships between our youth? Sure, but not for the reasons I think you mean. I think if homosexual relationships were more accepted by our society you would see more homosexual relationships because homosexuals wouldn't feel as large a need to be closeted. There is a reason that the phrase "in the closet" exists.

I do not believe that it would lead to a much higher instance of homosexual relationships in those people who wouldn't have ended up being gay anyway any more than I think that the abundance of heterosexual relationships in our society leads someone who would typically be homosexual to a heterosexual lifestyle. I think most people are what they are. Some mitigating factors might lead them to experimentation and there are some very extreme cases but in general the I don't think the inclusion of homosexual relationships is any more apt to convert heterosexuals to homosexuals than vice versa.

The fact is that children are exposed to homosexuality already. It isn't something that most are sheltered from and while I know that the inevitable argument will be something to the effect of "the acceptance of homosexual activity in our culture has led to more homosexual behavior" I think that the fact is that the level of homosexuality/heterosexuality in society stays relatively constant. It just seems that there is more instances of homosexuality because it has become more accepted in our culture and homosexuals are just more comfortable being out.

Originally posted by SI
And I guess you haven't read the last 10 pages because religion wasn't a factor in any reason I gave. I can't wait til after lunch and you get to respond. I'm sure you will consider my argument with an open mind.


Ah, this is a situation where a clarification of the target of the statement is needed. My statement about "religious rhetoric" was general. While your opposition of gay marriage might not be based on religion, the motivating force behind the vast majority of the anti-gay marriage is. If you feel that this is not the case then we are in major disagreement there. It is no coincidence at all that there is a major overlap of the anti-gay marriage movement and conservative right-wing Christians. The anti-gay marriage debate is largely one of Christian values vs. liberal progressiveness.
 
Cuivienen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by X
This is generally why I feel so strongly about the gay marriage issue because the only reason that there isn't nation-wide legalized gay marriage in the US is on the basis of religious rhetoric and not on any legal or rational ground.


Religion may be why most people are opposed to it, but there are very solid logical foundations to a ban on homosexual marriage and, more specifically, a homosexual couple's right to adopt kids.

I can't tell you how many studies have been done that highlight the inadequacies of single parents specifically because the child lacks guidance from both sexes.

Sure, a homosexual couple may make better parents than heterosexual couples on a case by case basis, or they may be a better option than foster care regardless. I'm just saying it's not completely a religious issue.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by X

This is generally why I feel so strongly about the gay marriage issue because the only reason that there isn't nation-wide legalized gay marriage in the US is on the basis of religious rhetoric and not on any legal or rational ground.


So you think the acceptance of gay marriage won't lead more impressionable children to choose having sex with the same sex? Or you just don't think that is a problem?

(Azure doesn't think that more homosexual activity would be a problem).


And I guess you haven't read the last 10 pages because religion wasn't a factor in any reason I gave. I can't wait til after lunch and you get to respond. I'm sure you will consider my argument with an open mind.


To say nothing else about anything in this thread, I'd just like to be on record as saying that more people who are of sound mind and body deciding to have sex with others of sound mind and body, being of the same sex or not, is absolutely fine with me.

What goes on behind Adam and Steve's bedroom doors is none of my business, just like what goes on behind mine is none of theirs.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by X


Originally posted by SI

And I guess you haven't read the last 10 pages because religion wasn't a factor in any reason I gave. I can't wait til after lunch and you get to respond. I'm sure you will consider my argument with an open mind.


Ah, this is a situation where a clarification of the target of the statement is needed. My statement about "religious rhetoric" was general. While your opposition of gay marriage might not be based on religion, the motivating force behind the vast majority of the anti-gay marriage is. If you feel that this is not the case then we are in major disagreement there. It is no coincidence at all that there is a major overlap of the anti-gay marriage movement and conservative right-wing Christians. The anti-gay marriage debate is largely one of Christian values vs. liberal progressiveness.


Actually, I think there are just alot of people who don't have the time or intelligence to fully articulate the LOOOOOOONG answer I gave. If you are in a 30 second conversation with someone, there is no way you can explain all of what I said. It would take forever. There is no quick/simple link between gay marriage and hurting society. It is a several step process and it would take 20 years or more to feel the full effect from it. So if I was at a party and the topic came up, I know what my REAL view is (what I wrote here), but I would instead make my point with a funny 1 liner of something like: "I'm sorry, but I believe that the butt wasn't made for that purpose. Asses should have a "exit only" sign on them!"

If the other person kept pushing, I would throw out that I think the Bible provides good advice on a solid way to live life and it prohibits it. Someone would have to push me 3 or 4 times before I gave them my REAL answer.

So maybe Azure isn't digging hard enough with the people he is talking to. Granted, there are some really dumb people who just do what the Bible or their pastor tells them, but most of my friends are smart and can think for themselves. If they disagree with the church, they aren't afraid to say something. I disagreed with many things in the Catholic Church, so I left. If I was a brain dead follower, I would have just listened to whatever they told me, right?

I've certainly looked at both sides of the issue. It isn't black and white like people on BOTH sides pretend that it is. There are rights on both sides being compromised. Much, much, much more research needs to be done into the causes of homosexuality. No one wants to do it though because they will be attacked from both sides regardless of what their research shows.
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 16:11:11
 
DT35
offline
Link
 
Lol
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Originally posted by X


This is generally why I feel so strongly about the gay marriage issue because the only reason that there isn't nation-wide legalized gay marriage in the US is on the basis of religious rhetoric and not on any legal or rational ground.


So you think the acceptance of gay marriage won't lead more impressionable children to choose having sex with the same sex? Or you just don't think that is a problem?

(Azure doesn't think that more homosexual activity would be a problem).


And I guess you haven't read the last 10 pages because religion wasn't a factor in any reason I gave. I can't wait til after lunch and you get to respond. I'm sure you will consider my argument with an open mind.


To say nothing else about anything in this thread, I'd just like to be on record as saying that more people who are of sound mind and body deciding to have sex with others of sound mind and body, being of the same sex or not, is absolutely fine with me.

What goes on behind Adam and Steve's bedroom doors is none of my business, just like what goes on behind mine is none of theirs.


I agree.

You do whatever you want in your bedroom and teach your kids whatever values you want. Just don't teach MY kids that what you do in your bedroom is ok because that isn't up for you to decide.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by SteelersInsider


Originally posted by X



This is generally why I feel so strongly about the gay marriage issue because the only reason that there isn't nation-wide legalized gay marriage in the US is on the basis of religious rhetoric and not on any legal or rational ground.


So you think the acceptance of gay marriage won't lead more impressionable children to choose having sex with the same sex? Or you just don't think that is a problem?

(Azure doesn't think that more homosexual activity would be a problem).


And I guess you haven't read the last 10 pages because religion wasn't a factor in any reason I gave. I can't wait til after lunch and you get to respond. I'm sure you will consider my argument with an open mind.


To say nothing else about anything in this thread, I'd just like to be on record as saying that more people who are of sound mind and body deciding to have sex with others of sound mind and body, being of the same sex or not, is absolutely fine with me.

What goes on behind Adam and Steve's bedroom doors is none of my business, just like what goes on behind mine is none of theirs.


I agree.

You do whatever you want in your bedroom and teach your kids whatever values you want. Just don't teach MY kids that what you do in your bedroom is ok because that isn't up for you to decide.


I have no interest in teaching your children anything (I'm heterosexual but even were I not, I still wouldn't care about your kids).

You can teach them that anything is "ok" if you like, but the choice will still be their's to make.
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 16:39:26
 
X
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
You do whatever you want in your bedroom and teach your kids whatever values you want. Just don't teach MY kids that what you do in your bedroom is ok because that isn't up for you to decide.


Ok, and just checking here, but you do differentiate between homosexual marriage and homosexual intercourse, right?
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by X



Originally posted by Azure again


Originally posted by X again



This is generally why I feel so strongly about the gay marriage issue because the only reason that there isn't nation-wide legalized gay marriage in the US is on the basis of religious rhetoric and not on any legal or rational ground.
.


Been saying that over and over but SI continually reverts back to claiming that he doesn't like it because it will mess people up in a non-religious way (which he thinks because of what he was taught by his religion)


Heterosexuals have done plenty to "mess people up" and to besmirch the institution of marriage without the help for homosexuals. I always get a kick when I hear people say that homosexual marriage would threaten the sanctity of marriage or would corrupt our family values system. Have they been paying attention to how well we've been fucking doing so far?



1.) On the bolded part: I wrote 3 books of explanation without once resorting to using anything Bible or religion related at all and you still have the balls to say that? lol.

2.) Do you think the secular and liberal values coming from Hollywood are having any affect on marriages? Cheating now has no negative connotation. Nor does having children when not married. Nor does men abandoning their children. Brad Pitt cheated on his wife and no ones care. Madonna and everyone else gets married and divorced every few years. Don't you think these images have as much to do with the divorce rate as anything? Liberal values have been shitting on marriage for a long time in my opinion. Allowing gay marriages would just be the final step to killing the institution. It has been under assault for the last 30 years....


1) As I already said, I could write 6 pages based on something without expressly mentioning the thing. You repeatedly express your belief or state your belief as fact without acknowledging where it comes from. And it comes from the Church.

2) What the fuck? Where do you live? There are no negative connotations to cheating? Says who? Men abandoning their children? What people do you hang around that dont' think those things are bad? lmfao okay, we'll just pretend that liberal views promote cheating on your spouse and abandoning your children. This is just a diatribe of ignorant extrapolation.

By the way, conservative people cheat on their spouses just as often as liberal people.
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by X
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

You do whatever you want in your bedroom and teach your kids whatever values you want. Just don't teach MY kids that what you do in your bedroom is ok because that isn't up for you to decide.


Ok, and just checking here, but you do differentiate between homosexual marriage and homosexual intercourse, right?


You're right. And you don't teach the law what is okay because that isn't for you to decide. If I want to teach my kids that killing jews is okay, that's my prerogative. People wouldn't like it but I can.

However, that doesn't mean that the law should accept killing Jews.
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by X
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Originally posted by X


This is generally why I feel so strongly about the gay marriage issue because the only reason that there isn't nation-wide legalized gay marriage in the US is on the basis of religious rhetoric and not on any legal or rational ground.


So you think the acceptance of gay marriage won't lead more impressionable children to choose having sex with the same sex? Or you just don't think that is a problem?

(Azure doesn't think that more homosexual activity would be a problem).


Do I think that the legalization of gay marriage will lead to a larger instance of gay relationships between our youth? Sure, but not for the reasons I think you mean. I think if homosexual relationships were more accepted by our society you would see more homosexual relationships because homosexuals wouldn't feel as large a need to be closeted. There is a reason that the phrase "in the closet" exists.

I do not believe that it would lead to a much higher instance of homosexual relationships in those people who wouldn't have ended up being gay anyway any more than I think that the abundance of heterosexual relationships in our society leads someone who would typically be homosexual to a heterosexual lifestyle. I think most people are what they are. Some mitigating factors might lead them to experimentation and there are some very extreme cases but in general the I don't think the inclusion of homosexual relationships is any more apt to convert heterosexuals to homosexuals than vice versa.

The fact is that children are exposed to homosexuality already. It isn't something that most are sheltered from and while I know that the inevitable argument will be something to the effect of "the acceptance of homosexual activity in our culture has led to more homosexual behavior" I think that the fact is that the level of homosexuality/heterosexuality in society stays relatively constant. It just seems that there is more instances of homosexuality because it has become more accepted in our culture and homosexuals are just more comfortable being out.

Originally posted by SI

And I guess you haven't read the last 10 pages because religion wasn't a factor in any reason I gave. I can't wait til after lunch and you get to respond. I'm sure you will consider my argument with an open mind.


Ah, this is a situation where a clarification of the target of the statement is needed. My statement about "religious rhetoric" was general. While your opposition of gay marriage might not be based on religion, the motivating force behind the vast majority of the anti-gay marriage is. If you feel that this is not the case then we are in major disagreement there. It is no coincidence at all that there is a major overlap of the anti-gay marriage movement and conservative right-wing Christians. The anti-gay marriage debate is largely one of Christian values vs. liberal progressiveness.


Your'e just repeating my arguments. He ignores them.
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by X



Originally posted by SI


And I guess you haven't read the last 10 pages because religion wasn't a factor in any reason I gave. I can't wait til after lunch and you get to respond. I'm sure you will consider my argument with an open mind.


Ah, this is a situation where a clarification of the target of the statement is needed. My statement about "religious rhetoric" was general. While your opposition of gay marriage might not be based on religion, the motivating force behind the vast majority of the anti-gay marriage is. If you feel that this is not the case then we are in major disagreement there. It is no coincidence at all that there is a major overlap of the anti-gay marriage movement and conservative right-wing Christians. The anti-gay marriage debate is largely one of Christian values vs. liberal progressiveness.


Actually, I think there are just alot of people who don't have the time or intelligence to fully articulate the LOOOOOOONG answer I gave. If you are in a 30 second conversation with someone, there is no way you can explain all of what I said. It would take forever. There is no quick/simple link between gay marriage and hurting society. It is a several step process and it would take 20 years or more to feel the full effect from it. So if I was at a party and the topic came up, I know what my REAL view is (what I wrote here), but I would instead make my point with a funny 1 liner of something like: "I'm sorry, but I believe that the butt wasn't made for that purpose. Asses should have a "exit only" sign on them!"

If the other person kept pushing, I would throw out that I think the Bible provides good advice on a solid way to live life and it prohibits it. Someone would have to push me 3 or 4 times before I gave them my REAL answer.

So maybe Azure isn't digging hard enough with the people he is talking to. Granted, there are some really dumb people who just do what the Bible or their pastor tells them, but most of my friends are smart and can think for themselves. If they disagree with the church, they aren't afraid to say something. I disagreed with many things in the Catholic Church, so I left. If I was a brain dead follower, I would have just listened to whatever they told me, right?

I've certainly looked at both sides of the issue. It isn't black and white like people on BOTH sides pretend that it is. There are rights on both sides being compromised. Much, much, much more research needs to be done into the causes of homosexuality. No one wants to do it though because they will be attacked from both sides regardless of what their research shows.


You repeatedly say this, yet you STILL HAVE NOT given me a reason that it should be illegal for same sex couples to be married that was not based in your personal beliefs instilled in you by the church.
 
Link
 
Because legalizing homosexual marriage would make it easier for people to get married purely for the insurance benefits. That's the reason the government doesn't want to support gay marriage.
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
It really wouldn't. There are just as many people of the opposite sex who like insurance benefits as of the same sex.

It *would*, however, increase the amount of people getting tax and insurance benefits.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.