User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Announcements > Team Loans, Chemistry
Page:
 
HootyHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PFDS
not sure if this has been discussed but bringing in a starter and bring in a backup should different. Also by position a new QB particularly a starter should have more effect on chemistry than say a new kicker. this might make it too complex but I'm just throwing it out there. Sorry, if this has been discussed but I don't think I can read all 40 pages of this thread


Good point.

 
TheCondor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by krwynn
Originally posted by Lax32

I think that how many players on the team are owned by the same person should negatively affect the chemistry.

It kind of ruins the game when one person owns every person on his team and has an advantage over everyone else who plays the game how it was supposed to be played.



I strongly disagree. Someone who actually has money invested will be more active than someone who doesn't. They are also the ones helping to finance this game. They shouldnt be punished for it. Do a search for free agents and see how many 1 or 2 player owners are inactive which proves that point perfectly.


Excellent answer, I completely agree. No reason to punish those who pay more to play the game. Besides, anyone who pays to level up or add more players to any team will have an advantage, not just those who have player's of their own on their own team too.
 
panther17
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by krwynn
Originally posted by Lax32

I think that how many players on the team are owned by the same person should negatively affect the chemistry.

It kind of ruins the game when one person owns every person on his team and has an advantage over everyone else who plays the game how it was supposed to be played.



I strongly disagree. Someone who actually has money invested will be more active than someone who doesn't. They are also the ones helping to finance this game. They shouldnt be punished for it. Do a search for free agents and see how many 1 or 2 player owners are inactive which proves that point perfectly.


Not saying I agree with you or disagre but I wouldn't expect any different of an answer from you being that you are one of the guys he is talking about.
 
HootyHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by panther17
Originally posted by krwynn

Originally posted by Lax32


I think that how many players on the team are owned by the same person should negatively affect the chemistry.

It kind of ruins the game when one person owns every person on his team and has an advantage over everyone else who plays the game how it was supposed to be played.



I strongly disagree. Someone who actually has money invested will be more active than someone who doesn't. They are also the ones helping to finance this game. They shouldnt be punished for it. Do a search for free agents and see how many 1 or 2 player owners are inactive which proves that point perfectly.


Not saying I agree with you or disagre but I wouldn't expect any different of an answer from you being that you are one of the guys he is talking about.


Then you should be thanking people like me for helping to finance this game. Not condemning us. You should be slamming the people that join and create players and then leave after a week forcing us to create more players if we want to be competitive.

 
Ballbright
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by krwynn
Originally posted by Lax32

I think that how many players on the team are owned by the same person should negatively affect the chemistry.

It kind of ruins the game when one person owns every person on his team and has an advantage over everyone else who plays the game how it was supposed to be played.



I strongly disagree. Someone who actually has money invested will be more active than someone who doesn't. They are also the ones helping to finance this game. They shouldnt be punished for it. Do a search for free agents and see how many 1 or 2 player owners are inactive which proves that point perfectly.


Actually that proves nothing. There are vastly more 1-2 player owners than everything else combined. You would need a proportion of active owners to number of players they owned in order to get a technically "provable" statistic.

Do I think that owners should be punished for building an entire team out of their own players? NO! I think if they want to spend that kind of money then let them (I think perhaps they should look into making a division specifically for that, but that is a discussion for another time). However, those owners don't need to denigrate those of us who own 1-2 players and spend less (or no) money on the game. WE keep this MULITPLAYER game going by providing a community for it to take place in...

...otherwise it'd just be some lame dude at his house simming against himself...

 
Gott
offline
Link
 
But the guys that fill their own teams with a bunch of players shouldn't act magnanimous because of it. You can still support the game and have your players on other teams.
 
Jaxx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ballbright
Originally posted by krwynn

Originally posted by Lax32


I think that how many players on the team are owned by the same person should negatively affect the chemistry.

It kind of ruins the game when one person owns every person on his team and has an advantage over everyone else who plays the game how it was supposed to be played.



I strongly disagree. Someone who actually has money invested will be more active than someone who doesn't. They are also the ones helping to finance this game. They shouldnt be punished for it. Do a search for free agents and see how many 1 or 2 player owners are inactive which proves that point perfectly.


Actually that proves nothing. There are vastly more 1-2 player owners than everything else combined. You would need a proportion of active owners to number of players they owned in order to get a technically "provable" statistic.

Do I think that owners should be punished for building an entire team out of their own players? NO! I think if they want to spend that kind of money then let them (I think perhaps they should look into making a division specifically for that, but that is a discussion for another time). However, those owners don't need to denigrate those of us who own 1-2 players and spend less (or no) money on the game. WE keep this MULITPLAYER game going by providing a community for it to take place in...

...otherwise it'd just be some lame dude at his house simming against himself...



I am one of those who created all of their own team. If you do not enjoy playing that way than I am all for how you choose to play. I myself am looking to dump my current team and try the interaction with multiple human owners invested in the team and the discussions which will ensue.

To condemn or ask for penalties against those who do play this way is, well ignorant. What specific advantage do you see gained? Salary? Big deal, you can recruit people for the same amount I am told just as easily (although I had little luck I still see tons of teams with lower salaries than I run). Players set to perform how you wish? You are the coach, shouldn't all these players you took the time to recruit be on the same page as you? Where is the line drawn, as some of you put it which is needed to follow the true spirit of how this game was intended to be played? 5 of your players self made? 1 self made? 20 self made? If what you all say is an absolute truth, than there should be no owners of teams with any self owned players (thus with new rules it would take 40 different human players now to make a team, bit on the ridiculous side don't you think??) or everyone should only be allowed to make 1 character active at a time like any other MMO in which you can only be active on 1 at a time.

Who cares in the end, especially if this game starts to introduce more in-depth tactics, won't that be the determining factor among coaches? If you are an owner of only players why in the heck do you give a rat's ass, since it in no way affects you. Sure there are tons of lvl 1 or 2 players looking for a team, but watch in 6 months or less as with most browser games, 60% of those people will be gone due to boredom or work or school or some new MMO or game that was just released. So now you are relegating this game to those who have friends who want to play this game or God forbid someone who is using multiple accounts to play (if you think this does not happen you are wrong).

I see disadvantages, here are just a few. No help when scouting other teams? No interaction or differing opinions offered to think upon or discuss. Hard to find the time to set each player to just the right tactics. Only see one view on how to create players. I would think a collective group working well together would be able to come up with much better strats and far out shine single owners.
Last edited Apr 21, 2008 00:04:12
 
Tomhusker
offline
Link
 
It ain't rocket surgery folks.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
If someone wants to spend the money to purchase a team and players, and is willing to spend the time to manage the team and players, all the power to him.

There is nothing wrong with someone willing to spend the money and time to gain an "edge". Should we ban all private school kids from going to universities because their parents spent more on their education or that these kids might be spending more time studying than other kids? That would be ridiculous, right? Well, so would banning a team owner from owning a team full of his own players.

If anyone thinks that by doing so they have an "edge", he can mimic those people and do the same thing. If you are not willing to put up the money or the time and effort to manage, you don't have the privilege to criticize those who do. If you don't have the money to purchase the team and players, well, son, life is not fair. I want to own the Yankees too.

Bottom line, be a player, don't be a hater.
Last edited Apr 20, 2008 22:45:10
 
cober
offline
Link
 
-Single owner / player teams are already at great disadvantage. They only have one person to game plan. One person to advise on builds. One person to update tatics.

If owner is called away on emergency business there is noone to change the game plan. You will find all the builds on owner team are only things he thought off.

Never will he introduce a new player who has done something out left field which could benefit the rest of the team.
 
catspaw27
offline
Link
 
NOT at a disadvantage. NOT AT ALL.

I got me a couple of GMs/Coordinators to help me game plan, and invite my own players to tell me what they see and how to play. Ask ANY of my players if they like and respect their coach, and you may find my largest fan club: my players.

I give them respect and communicate, they return it exponentially.

And what do we get?

Oceania AAA Champions! That's us.

It's a team game, and we will win further with teamwork.
 
SethMW
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
- If you cut a player who has been inactive for a week or more, you do not lose chemistry for him.

- Players < lv 5 do not affect chemistry when adding/dropping.


I just cut a handful of <5 inactives, and my chemistry dropped like a rock. :/
 
Fezmid
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SethMW
Originally posted by Bort

- If you cut a player who has been inactive for a week or more, you do not lose chemistry for him.

- Players < lv 5 do not affect chemistry when adding/dropping.


I just cut a handful of <5 inactives, and my chemistry dropped like a rock. :/


I also thought Bort said there would be a few days where you could manage the roster and not get dinged at all. I cut a handful of CPU players that I would have cut before the playoffs had I known this was going to be an issue...

The game's fun, but I really don't like how rules change midstream without any warning. Once a game's in Beta, it's supposed to be nearly finished.
 
MrFreeze
offline
Link
 
They`re going to reset the TC before season 2 kicks off. No worries.
 
Fires1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Fezmid


I also thought Bort said there would be a few days where you could manage the roster and not get dinged at all. I cut a handful of CPU players that I would have cut before the playoffs had I known this was going to be an issue...

The game's fun, but I really don't like how rules change midstream without any warning. Once a game's in Beta, it's supposed to be nearly finished.


Fez I think I saw where the whole team chemistry meter is going to be reset before the 1st game, and we can make moves before that.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.