User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Announcements > State of the Game Address and the End of Season 3
Page:
 
garrett0532
offline
Link
 
BINGO waltgang. If there is a pass rushing DE smash the ball in his face.
 
browns4life
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Waltang
Originally posted by browns4life

Dear Bort,

Thanks for all the great work you have put into this game. It's been a blast (apart from the sometimes very frustrating part of recruiting).

I would just like to bring up the point that teams' Defenses have a LOOPHOLE in pass rushing. They can put their best pass rusher at LDE to go up against the normal "run blocking" tackle who lacks elite pass blocking skills and thus render useless the stud LOT who has the "Protect" Special Ability and other pass blocking skills.

We have talked about this often among management of our team and believe a way to combat this loophole would be to do the following:
1.) Allow teams to tie a certain player to be assigned to another player. i.e. my stud LOT should follow around DE1 or DE2 regardless if hes at LDE or RDE.
2.) Protect SA should kick in for aforementioned LOT. Perhaps the rule should be that the Protect SA can only be granted to one OT or the other based on a flag that the manager of tactics can set.


Thanks for reading (if you took the time to read this far) I know there are tons of posts here


That is not a loophole, as it is how the NFL works. Offensive linemen have never to my knowledge followed around a DE. Offensive players have to get set first, then defenses adjust to them. A "stud" pass rushing DE is a run stopping liability against otherwise equally matched players while lined over the ROT. This should become especially true with the wrap-up tackling nerf. Just run the ball at him.



Well since I don't have audible control like real NFL teams, I can't change the play to run run run when I see a mean, fast DE coming down the "wrong" side. I just don't think a team's DE should be able to dominate games like they have in our league simply because they threw their DE on that side..because this is a sim and we can't do everything the same way as a real football game, I think this scenario should at least be looked at.
 
Caledric
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by browns4life
Originally posted by Waltang

Originally posted by browns4life


Dear Bort,

Thanks for all the great work you have put into this game. It's been a blast (apart from the sometimes very frustrating part of recruiting).

I would just like to bring up the point that teams' Defenses have a LOOPHOLE in pass rushing. They can put their best pass rusher at LDE to go up against the normal "run blocking" tackle who lacks elite pass blocking skills and thus render useless the stud LOT who has the "Protect" Special Ability and other pass blocking skills.

We have talked about this often among management of our team and believe a way to combat this loophole would be to do the following:
1.) Allow teams to tie a certain player to be assigned to another player. i.e. my stud LOT should follow around DE1 or DE2 regardless if hes at LDE or RDE.
2.) Protect SA should kick in for aforementioned LOT. Perhaps the rule should be that the Protect SA can only be granted to one OT or the other based on a flag that the manager of tactics can set.


Thanks for reading (if you took the time to read this far) I know there are tons of posts here


That is not a loophole, as it is how the NFL works. Offensive linemen have never to my knowledge followed around a DE. Offensive players have to get set first, then defenses adjust to them. A "stud" pass rushing DE is a run stopping liability against otherwise equally matched players while lined over the ROT. This should become especially true with the wrap-up tackling nerf. Just run the ball at him.



Well since I don't have audible control like real NFL teams, I can't change the play to run run run when I see a mean, fast DE coming down the "wrong" side. I just don't think a team's DE should be able to dominate games like they have in our league simply because they threw their DE on that side..because this is a sim and we can't do everything the same way as a real football game, I think this scenario should at least be looked at.


This is called scouting... if they have a tendency to switch their pass rusher to the other DE spot, then set your team to run more towards him.
 
browns4life
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Caledric Scorpion
Originally posted by browns4life

Originally posted by Waltang


Originally posted by browns4life



Dear Bort,

Thanks for all the great work you have put into this game. It's been a blast (apart from the sometimes very frustrating part of recruiting).

I would just like to bring up the point that teams' Defenses have a LOOPHOLE in pass rushing. They can put their best pass rusher at LDE to go up against the normal "run blocking" tackle who lacks elite pass blocking skills and thus render useless the stud LOT who has the "Protect" Special Ability and other pass blocking skills.

We have talked about this often among management of our team and believe a way to combat this loophole would be to do the following:
1.) Allow teams to tie a certain player to be assigned to another player. i.e. my stud LOT should follow around DE1 or DE2 regardless if hes at LDE or RDE.
2.) Protect SA should kick in for aforementioned LOT. Perhaps the rule should be that the Protect SA can only be granted to one OT or the other based on a flag that the manager of tactics can set.


Thanks for reading (if you took the time to read this far) I know there are tons of posts here


That is not a loophole, as it is how the NFL works. Offensive linemen have never to my knowledge followed around a DE. Offensive players have to get set first, then defenses adjust to them. A "stud" pass rushing DE is a run stopping liability against otherwise equally matched players while lined over the ROT. This should become especially true with the wrap-up tackling nerf. Just run the ball at him.



Well since I don't have audible control like real NFL teams, I can't change the play to run run run when I see a mean, fast DE coming down the "wrong" side. I just don't think a team's DE should be able to dominate games like they have in our league simply because they threw their DE on that side..because this is a sim and we can't do everything the same way as a real football game, I think this scenario should at least be looked at.


This is called scouting... if they have a tendency to switch their pass rusher to the other DE spot, then set your team to run more towards him.



Dude..of course we scout..we aren't stupid..we did after all.. just get promoted to the PROS!

When you move your pass rusher to that side, you NULLIFY the Protect SA for your LOT..and if thats not a loophole I dunno what is
 
Waltang
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by browns4life
Originally posted by Caledric Scorpion

Originally posted by browns4life

Originally posted by Waltang

Originally posted by browns4life

Dear Bort,

Thanks for all the great work you have put into this game. It's been a blast (apart from the sometimes very frustrating part of recruiting).

I would just like to bring up the point that teams' Defenses have a LOOPHOLE in pass rushing. They can put their best pass rusher at LDE to go up against the normal "run blocking" tackle who lacks elite pass blocking skills and thus render useless the stud LOT who has the "Protect" Special Ability and other pass blocking skills.

We have talked about this often among management of our team and believe a way to combat this loophole would be to do the following:
1.) Allow teams to tie a certain player to be assigned to another player. i.e. my stud LOT should follow around DE1 or DE2 regardless if hes at LDE or RDE.
2.) Protect SA should kick in for aforementioned LOT. Perhaps the rule should be that the Protect SA can only be granted to one OT or the other based on a flag that the manager of tactics can set.


Thanks for reading (if you took the time to read this far) I know there are tons of posts here


That is not a loophole, as it is how the NFL works. Offensive linemen have never to my knowledge followed around a DE. Offensive players have to get set first, then defenses adjust to them. A "stud" pass rushing DE is a run stopping liability against otherwise equally matched players while lined over the ROT. This should become especially true with the wrap-up tackling nerf. Just run the ball at him.



Well since I don't have audible control like real NFL teams, I can't change the play to run run run when I see a mean, fast DE coming down the "wrong" side. I just don't think a team's DE should be able to dominate games like they have in our league simply because they threw their DE on that side..because this is a sim and we can't do everything the same way as a real football game, I think this scenario should at least be looked at.


This is called scouting... if they have a tendency to switch their pass rusher to the other DE spot, then set your team to run more towards him.



Dude..of course we scout..we aren't stupid..we did after all.. just get promoted to the PROS!

When you move your pass rusher to that side, you NULLIFY the Protect SA for your LOT..and if thats not a loophole I dunno what is


Was it the first time they had ever done this? They cant move the DE back and forth mid-game. Plan accordingly. Have the ROT set his focus to pass block if its a tendency and you insist on passing, or counter it by swapping your tackles.

You're a promoted GM, no one is saying your dumb, but the idea that one player would be able to magically bestow their pass blocking ability to a player lined up 6 yards away is silly. No matter the case, until the effects of new wrap-up tackling nerf are seen, this argument should be null and void.
 
Jacobby
offline
Link
 
Question with the new WR depth charts.

Here is an example:

WR1 = Best WR, WR2 = 2nd Best, WR3 = 3rd Best, WR4 = 4th Best, WR5 = 5th Best

It is late in the game and my Best WR and 2nd Best WR are tired and sitting on the bench. Offense runs a 3 receiver set. Does my 3rd best WR (the best I have on the field) line up at WR3 and have the too WRs that are worse than him line up at 1 and 2?

Or will the 3rd best receiver get bumped to WR1 and the other two follow suit?

I hope this made sense sorry if it didn't
 
RIP Al Davis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jacobby
Question with the new WR depth charts.

Here is an example:

WR1 = Best WR, WR2 = 2nd Best, WR3 = 3rd Best, WR4 = 4th Best, WR5 = 5th Best

It is late in the game and my Best WR and 2nd Best WR are tired and sitting on the bench. Offense runs a 3 receiver set. Does my 3rd best WR (the best I have on the field) line up at WR3 and have the too WRs that are worse than him line up at 1 and 2?

Or will the 3rd best receiver get bumped to WR1 and the other two follow suit?

I hope this made sense sorry if it didn't


I'm wondering a lot about this too. It doesn't really seem like a really big deal though. I put my backup CBs at CB1 and CB2 as well as CB3, CB4 and CB5 just to make sure they're on the field. Strangely, the depth chart on my teams' profile shows no CBs at all. I'm sure they'll get that fixed though.
 
Donbomba
offline
Link
 
I've asked this earlier but it has been lost in the pile....

I'm interested to know where the money comes from to pay players all they need to score a high fame factor?

My team has been struggling to stay ahead of the curve in terms of wages and stadium construction since I purchased a gutted team. Our fan factor has never been as high as it is now and it is still relatively, low.

39, 5 , 0.

I'm already finding it hard to convince many/all high level free agents to play for my team. I'm worried that with a greater reliance on money, these players will now be even less likely to sign with my team.

Will there be some sort of offset to ensure those higher levels that join with a struggling team are rewarded for their committment?

Will there also be a change in the current fan factor that will see low fan factor teams that get a win against highly regarded teams a bonus to their FF?

Will endorcements pay the players the extra money they are required, or will it go to the team fund? Or is it purely a fluff thing?
 
Waltang
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jacobby
Question with the new WR depth charts.

Here is an example:

WR1 = Best WR, WR2 = 2nd Best, WR3 = 3rd Best, WR4 = 4th Best, WR5 = 5th Best

It is late in the game and my Best WR and 2nd Best WR are tired and sitting on the bench. Offense runs a 3 receiver set. Does my 3rd best WR (the best I have on the field) line up at WR3 and have the too WRs that are worse than him line up at 1 and 2?

Or will the 3rd best receiver get bumped to WR1 and the other two follow suit?

I hope this made sense sorry if it didn't


I am pretty sure I am correct in this, the scrimage games will tell.

Provided you did not set any backups, they would never sub out. (gonna be lots of backup WR's bitching about playing time til the GM's figure that out)

The trick to setting the depth charts will be to place a non-WR at all 5 starting spots initially, then add and set up all 5 spots ordered however you prefer, with the person you want to be starter at each position in the second slot at each position. Once set, then go and remove the non-WR's from the depth chart and you should be set.
 
browns4life
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Waltang
Originally posted by browns4life

Originally posted by Caledric Scorpion


Originally posted by browns4life


Originally posted by Waltang


Originally posted by browns4life


Dear Bort,

Thanks for all the great work you have put into this game. It's been a blast (apart from the sometimes very frustrating part of recruiting).

I would just like to bring up the point that teams' Defenses have a LOOPHOLE in pass rushing. They can put their best pass rusher at LDE to go up against the normal "run blocking" tackle who lacks elite pass blocking skills and thus render useless the stud LOT who has the "Protect" Special Ability and other pass blocking skills.

We have talked about this often among management of our team and believe a way to combat this loophole would be to do the following:
1.) Allow teams to tie a certain player to be assigned to another player. i.e. my stud LOT should follow around DE1 or DE2 regardless if hes at LDE or RDE.
2.) Protect SA should kick in for aforementioned LOT. Perhaps the rule should be that the Protect SA can only be granted to one OT or the other based on a flag that the manager of tactics can set.


Thanks for reading (if you took the time to read this far) I know there are tons of posts here


That is not a loophole, as it is how the NFL works. Offensive linemen have never to my knowledge followed around a DE. Offensive players have to get set first, then defenses adjust to them. A "stud" pass rushing DE is a run stopping liability against otherwise equally matched players while lined over the ROT. This should become especially true with the wrap-up tackling nerf. Just run the ball at him.



Well since I don't have audible control like real NFL teams, I can't change the play to run run run when I see a mean, fast DE coming down the "wrong" side. I just don't think a team's DE should be able to dominate games like they have in our league simply because they threw their DE on that side..because this is a sim and we can't do everything the same way as a real football game, I think this scenario should at least be looked at.


This is called scouting... if they have a tendency to switch their pass rusher to the other DE spot, then set your team to run more towards him.



Dude..of course we scout..we aren't stupid..we did after all.. just get promoted to the PROS!

When you move your pass rusher to that side, you NULLIFY the Protect SA for your LOT..and if thats not a loophole I dunno what is


Was it the first time they had ever done this? They cant move the DE back and forth mid-game. Plan accordingly. Have the ROT set his focus to pass block if its a tendency and you insist on passing, or counter it by swapping your tackles.

You're a promoted GM, no one is saying your dumb, but the idea that one player would be able to magically bestow their pass blocking ability to a player lined up 6 yards away is silly. No matter the case, until the effects of new wrap-up tackling nerf are seen, this argument should be null and void.



Walt, thanks for the responses - it's just a little frustrating to feel brushed off in this thread after watching all season a team do this and brag up how great they are and then narrowly escape with the championship against us.

I'm not going to say we lost the championship game because of this but it definitely didn't help that I felt I had to swap my pass blocking OT specialist to the right side.

The ROT was built for run blocking..and I have pretty much found that using pass focus or run focus gives too much negative to the one side with only a marginal help on the plus side, so I've found "No focus" is usually best.

As far as swapping tackles..that's all fine and dandy but now since my LOT is playing out of position, the protect skill - that I used several points on - no longer kicks in as that's only active if you're in the LOT slot.

We will see how the tackling changes affect things in the new scrimmages I guess but I still suspect this loophole will exist because pass rushing DEs usually have alot of str/agi/spd and thats..pretty much what a run stopping DE needs (well besides the tackling)

We'll see how much it changes..
 
Jacobby
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Waltang
Originally posted by Jacobby

Question with the new WR depth charts.

Here is an example:

WR1 = Best WR, WR2 = 2nd Best, WR3 = 3rd Best, WR4 = 4th Best, WR5 = 5th Best

It is late in the game and my Best WR and 2nd Best WR are tired and sitting on the bench. Offense runs a 3 receiver set. Does my 3rd best WR (the best I have on the field) line up at WR3 and have the too WRs that are worse than him line up at 1 and 2?

Or will the 3rd best receiver get bumped to WR1 and the other two follow suit?

I hope this made sense sorry if it didn't


I am pretty sure I am correct in this, the scrimage games will tell.

Provided you did not set any backups, they would never sub out. (gonna be lots of backup WR's bitching about playing time til the GM's figure that out)

The trick to setting the depth charts will be to place a non-WR at all 5 starting spots initially, then add and set up all 5 spots ordered however you prefer, with the person you want to be starter at each position in the second slot at each position. Once set, then go and remove the non-WR's from the depth chart and you should be set.



That sounds crazy enough to work!
 
Link
 
When will the new teams be released?
 
Waltang
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by browns4life

Walt, thanks for the responses - it's just a little frustrating to feel brushed off in this thread after watching all season a team do this and brag up how great they are and then narrowly escape with the championship against us.

I'm not going to say we lost the championship game because of this but it definitely didn't help that I felt I had to swap my pass blocking OT specialist to the right side.

The ROT was built for run blocking..and I have pretty much found that using pass focus or run focus gives too much negative to the one side with only a marginal help on the plus side, so I've found "No focus" is usually best.

As far as swapping tackles..that's all fine and dandy but now since my LOT is playing out of position, the protect skill - that I used several points on - no longer kicks in as that's only active if you're in the LOT slot.

We will see how the tackling changes affect things in the new scrimmages I guess but I still suspect this loophole will exist because pass rushing DEs usually have alot of str/agi/spd and thats..pretty much what a run stopping DE needs (well besides the tackling)

We'll see how much it changes..


Actually, I want to appologize, as I completely misinterpreted what you were suggesting. I thought you were suggesting the LT's protect should effect the RT, not that it should activate when playing RT. I still think its best to let the effects shake themselves out before adding additional game modifications, but I can agree with your suggestion as spelled out above, or some modification to how protect works to let either tackle have access to it.
 
Caledric
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jonnyhotcakes48
When will the new teams be released?


soon(tm)
 
caneswizard
offline
Link
 
Would Bort or a Mod please explain how the WR, WR1, WR2, WR3, etc and CB, CB1, CB2, CB3, etc really works so we don't waste time guessing. Thanks!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.