User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Archived Changes > The Archetype Discussion Thread
Page:
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by justin.clemons88
How soon will we know which season it is going to be out? Day 30, Day 40?


As soon as I know, you'll know. Assume season 15 though until otherwise told.
 
crawlins
offline
Link
 


Obviously it was not clear...thats why I asked the question. Man...you guys need to be a little more polite to the people who are your customers, or you just might lose them.
Edited by crawlins on Feb 10, 2010 18:54:12
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catch22
I have reasons for not taking suggestions. They are good ones. I don't think I need to explain the rationale either.

Yes, actually you do. Good lord, hazy, what in the hell has happened to you? Just a month ago you were talking about how communication between the staff and the player base was something you wanted to work at improving, and now you're saying that you don't owe any explanations to the users and that you don't even want to hear their input. That's an exorcist-like transformation.

Originally posted by Catch22
from January 10th:
I am really hoping to improve some of the processes around here as well as keeping the users informed about what is going on and improving the communication. I'm excited to be joining the GLB team and look forward to the challenge of making this game even better.


Originally posted by Catch22
from February 10th:
If you have a suggestion or want to add/change something, do not pm me about it as I will delete it without even looking at it.


-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Originally posted by
As I've said - if it's an issue that is potentially game breaking or affects game balance, send it my way, but we're not taking suggestions. Period.

Even if we momentarily ignore the bizarre 180 on your beliefs about communication and interaction with the player base, this is a ridiculously asinine way of approaching the biggest change the game has ever seen. Our input doesn't matter? Those of us who have been around a while realize that most of our suggestions are a waste of time because the staff hasn't cared what we thought, they just do whatever the hell they want and only react after it's clear that they screwed up because of all the rioting on the forums. I guess I should credit you for honesty in saying up front that you don't give a damn what we think, but that's still a mind-boggling way to talk to the people who support this game. We don't matter? We shouldn't even bother with suggestions? Jesus Christ.

Originally posted by
If that's out of line so be it, one of the problems this game has always had is Bort has had problems saying no to the people in the forums

Are you kidding? The biggest problems with the sim have always been from Bort springing changes on us without getting customer input. How disastrous would the new VAs have been if people hadn't rioted over how obviously unbalanced some of them were going to be? Maybe if the staff of GLB listened to the users once in a while, you wouldn't constantly screw up the game, and maybe we wouldn't feel so unwanted. At least pretend to give a crap about our ideas while you're taking our money.
Edited by jdbolick on Feb 10, 2010 18:58:36
 
Maddoc
offline
Link
 
If you allow people to take any SA they want, you probably ought to make it obvious about when certain SAs do and do not work.

Like people asking a few times a season when Blitz SA works, or if Aura of Intimidation works on offense, etc.
 
PatrolzCat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catch22
As soon as I know, you'll know. Assume season 15 though until otherwise told.


Ok helps somewhat. Will there at least be weekly updates on how testing is going? Can you personally please post on the ADMIN Announcement box if something pushes it back to season 16? Will you do that?
 
spoonhurler
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catch22

I'm all about making this game the best game possible for every one, not just for people that post in the forums. I'm also all about making this game the best possible game and I'm not going to do something if I don't have a very good reason for doing so. We (GLB) are going to be taking a much harder stance in terms of game development. While we encourage suggestions and will continue to do so, the bottom line is we have to do what we feel is best for the game. In this case, we have a very good foundation and are going to proceed with what we have.


As a fairly new player I'm glad to hear this. I'm thankful for the users that have played this since S1 and if I had but know about it I would have definitely been part of it but I joined the first time I heard about it. One of the reasons many games fail is because they have trouble trying to keep the balance between attracting new players and placating current ones.

People wanted more plays and formations. They are getting it. They wanted a better balance for positions... I will be glad to make some spectacular LBs next season and we are doing this. We are getting more options. The game is progressing and I personally think it's for the better.
 
Longhornfan1024
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catch22
As long as it's not in one of their two trees, the player will be able to choose it. Hell, a DT can choose Pump Fake if he wants to. It's the players choice.


Cool.

Second question (I promise I'll limit it to three ): have you guys been running a lot of builds through to try and figure out where agents will try and take their builds? I'm kind of worried (and I'm saying this despite the fact that I'm planning on building one) that KR/PRs are going to be overpowered. The new VPB doesn't let us use the new KR/PR archetypes, but just going from what I can do with the current ALGs, I can roughly estimate where one will be with the new system. It looks like it will be possible to build a CB KR/PR with close to 135 speed, 85 agility, 70+ vision, 70+ carrying, 60+ strength, capped confidence/stamina, 40ish jumping, 16 RS, 16 Spin, 8-10FS/CD, and some break tackle AEQ. I'm not sure how that combined with the bonus to RS and CD, the fact that they can now be 5'8" and 170lbs, and the VA bonuses isn't going to be overpowered. I'm sure a CB like that will have some issues holding onto the ball, but he will be ridiculously fast and agile.
 
PatrolzCat
offline
Link
 
You guys are going to change my game. The game I figured out how to manipulate to my liking. This isn't fair. You are making to level of a playing field. That is what a lot of you guys sound like. This is perfect. Keep up the good work guys. Things are finally starting to turn towards the better. I am finally starting to feel like you guys are actually listening, and fixing the problems. Not just compounding them with more problems, because a handful of people are crying about it.

When's the last time other then the new player creation being able to choose your skill points how you want has this game seen a major change? The training system change like 8 or 9 seasons ago? The VA's? How long ago was that? This game has to move on. Some people have to realize there comfort level has to change. You have to learn new things with the new system, and that is why most don't like it, because they lose that advantage they had.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
edit: posted in wrong thread
Edited by TrevJo on Feb 10, 2010 19:02:50
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 

Originally posted by jdbolick

Are you kidding? The biggest problems with the sim have always been from Bort springing changes on us without getting customer input. How disastrous would the new VAs have been if people hadn't rioted over how obviously unbalanced some of them were going to be? Maybe if the staff of GLB listened to the users once in a while, you wouldn't constantly screw up the game, and maybe we wouldn't feel so unwanted. At least pretend to give a crap about our ideas while you're taking our money.

Ding
Originally posted by Longhornfan1024
Cool.

Second question (I promise I'll limit it to three ): have you guys been running a lot of builds through to try and figure out where agents will try and take their builds? I'm kind of worried (and I'm saying this despite the fact that I'm planning on building one) that KR/PRs are going to be overpowered. The new VPB doesn't let us use the new KR/PR archetypes, but just going from what I can do with the current ALGs, I can roughly estimate where one will be with the new system. It looks like it will be possible to build a CB KR/PR with close to 135 speed, 85 agility, 70+ vision, 70+ carrying, 60+ strength, capped confidence/stamina, 40ish jumping, 16 RS, 16 Spin, 8-10FS/CD, and some break tackle AEQ. I'm not sure how that combined with the bonus to RS and CD, the fact that they can now be 5'8" and 170lbs, and the VA bonuses isn't going to be overpowered. I'm sure a CB like that will have some issues holding onto the ball, but he will be ridiculously fast and agile.


sort of, I mean Kr/PR suck dude, Have you watched real games at the WL? Vs top teams kr/pr don't do shit. Imagine a KR touchdown when blaze/valhalla play. 0 chance of that happening. Super bowl KR tds happen occasionally. KR/PR need a buff due to st'er being oped. I don't think its as op'ed as you think, only because KR/pr suck bad vs great teams as is.
Edited by David Stern on Feb 10, 2010 19:04:28
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by justin.clemons88
You guys are going to change my game. The game I figured out how to manipulate to my liking. This isn't fair. You are making to level of a playing field.


lol. I can promise you those who are good at math will find an advantage. I already have every position broken down exactly how I want/what the end build will be. /not factoring aeq/va/sim changes obviously
 
PatrolzCat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by David Stern
lol. I can promise you those who are good at math will find an advantage. I already have every position broken down exactly how I want/what the end build will be. /not factoring aeq/va/sim changes obviously


Hey you make me sound like I was actually crying like that. Fix it Stern!!! FIX IT NOW!!!
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catch22
We will be testing this thoroughly and make sure that things are working before it ever gets rolled out.


lol
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by justin.clemons88
You guys are going to change my game. The game I figured out how to manipulate to my liking. This isn't fair. You are making to level of a playing field. That is what a lot of you guys sound like. This is perfect. Keep up the good work guys.

Don't even bother posting if you can't be bothered to read what other people have to say, because in the end all that accomplishes is just to shine a giant spotlight on your own ignorance. People are pointing out obvious problems with the archetypes as proposed. We're trying to correct issues before they're actually implemented, both because we're intelligent enough to see those things coming, and because we're concerned about what's best for the game.

Originally posted by
When's the last time other then the new player creation being able to choose your skill points how you want has this game seen a major change?

There has never been a change this large, which is precisely why the staff has to listen to the ideas of the consumer base. That doesn't mean going along with what I think, or what the majority thinks, but it does mean giving honest and open consideration of our concerns. Can you imagine a politician who said that he didn't give a flying damn what his constituents thought and that they should just keep their thoughts to themselves since he'll delete any Email and trash any letter that he gets about the health care proposal? What about a pizza place owner who tells customers that he doesn't give a damn what they think about his products? It's insanity.

Originally posted by
You have to learn new things with the new system, and that is why most don't like it, because they lose that advantage they had.

Someone with minimal awareness would realize that this characterization could only apply to people who oppose the change as a whole and just want the status quo. Unfortunately you completely lack any such awareness, and therefore you have no clue what people are saying or what their motivations might be, hence the incomprehensible babbling.
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick

Are you kidding? The biggest problems with the sim have always been from Bort springing changes on us without getting customer input. How disastrous would the new VAs have been if people hadn't rioted over how obviously unbalanced some of them were going to be? Maybe if the staff of GLB listened to the users once in a while, you wouldn't constantly screw up the game, and maybe we wouldn't feel so unwanted. At least pretend to give a crap about our ideas while you're taking our money.


Originally posted by Catch22
from January 10th:
I am really hoping to improve some of the processes around here as well as keeping the users informed about what is going on and improving the communication. I'm excited to be joining the GLB team and look forward to the challenge of making this game even better.




You really think communication hasn't improved and that I'm not keeping users informed? Really? In the past, you wouldn't have even gotten one archetypes discussion thread. Yet, I've done it twice now.

If there's one thing I now in life it's this - you can't please everyone and I'm just going to continue doing my job because I know I'm doing it well. If you don't think so, then that's your right.
Edited by Catch22 on Feb 10, 2010 19:09:02
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.