User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
.spider.
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
How do you stop a player from only staying with a team for 1 season?

Besides, look at all the controls that have been put into place already to try to stop people like this and look at how much it still happens. People are going to keep finding ways to game the system, the system has to be changed in some way so people won't want to game it anymore.


Identify what the big problems are.....Dont allow trading from one team to another. Allow reporting of "potential gaming trades" and have support look into it and penalize said teams. I KNOW other owners know about it and upset about it but they dont report it because they KNOW nothing will be done....well come up w/ a rule and start enforcing it. First offense both trading teams lose 10 Million, second offense both teams go CPU.

Bet that would stop it right there.....

Then, how to take care of teams that are loading players with cash. Only allow 1 reneg per season....I mean think about it, how many NFL teams do you know that send a player a contract every 3 days to give them more cash?

Only problem I can see w/ that is people "messing up" and sending the wrong contract the first time.....I dont know how high that # would be, however there could be a system set in place to re-allow one based on their explanation of what they did wrong. Let the mods handle it.

That takes care of IMO the 2 biggest problems to the system.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
1) Don't allow trading from one team to another?
2) Support needs more work just to hold onto this system?
3) Equipment fund means renegotiations aren't necessary at all anymore
 
.spider.
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
I didnt say dont allow trading I said let the mischievous activity be user monitored, make it known that it will be taken very seriously and if 2 teams are caught trying to pad the bank of eachother or whatever there will be serious fines and possible team removal from BOTH owners.....

The reneg thing is self explanatory. you have to be pretty dumb to screw up a renegotiation. Allow 1 maybe 2 per season and they cant just continue to load up a player with cash with signing bonuses.

And to #3, yes I understand, but the problem is they are using the Equip fund to fund equip and then the season before sending them to the "big team" they are reneging 10-15 times to send them off with 4+ Million.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jbleich
Dont allow trading from one team to another.


Originally posted by Jed
1) Don't allow trading from one team to another? o_O




Originally posted by jbleich
The reneg thing is self explanatory. you have to be pretty dumb to screw up a renegotiation. Allow 1 maybe 2 per season and they cant just continue to load up a player with cash with signing bonuses.


I didn't say people would screw it up, I said limiting it would be useless because of the equipment fund. It would do nothing.

Originally posted by jbleich
And to #3, yes I understand, but the problem is they are using the Equip fund to fund equip and then the season before sending them to the "big team" they are reneging 10-15 times to send them off with 4+ Million.


So then people would go with full equipment and 2+ million instead. So what? The problem isn't solved, it's just lessened.


And that's the point: you can put all these things in that you want, but they're just going to lessen the issue, they're not going to actually stop the issue.
 
.spider.
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
But not allowing teams to trade back and forth for the sole purpose of growing one teams bank AND not allowing teams to reneg 20 times to give a player 5 Million takes care of the 2 biggest issues...whats left? A fully equipped level 48 guy with 1-2 Million (from 6-7 seasons of unspent salary) from a farm team.....that isnt a problem imo....that's what farm teams are for and I'm all for farm teams....it's when a team has 6 farm teams and 4 of them are solely used as cash cows...
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
I'll try it one more time:

Yes, those are the issues.

No, your solutions won't stop them, they'll barely even slow them down.
 
.spider.
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
I'll try it one more time:

Yes, those are the issues.

No, your solutions won't stop them, they'll barely even slow them down.


I disagree.....it wont stop them completely, but it will put a major dent in it for sure.

It's no different then having your dots come up with various teams and requesting the equip fund always to be team cash first and saving your money for when you someday get to the "big team"
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
won't put a dent in them at all. Teams rarely use trades as the main method. They use expiring contracts and resigning. Bort's EQ solution is easily the one that will address it on a wide scale basis.
 
.spider.
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catch22
They use expiring contracts and resigning. .


Please Explain
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
When a team is going to move a player to another team, they load them up through the EQ fund, give them a max contract with a max signing bonus that ends on day 40. At the end of the season, the player with all his shiny money and EQ signs a contract with the "main" team which does not have to worry about the EQ costs for that player and can sign them to a minimum contract. Happens all the time... I know, because I've been a part of some of the teams that have done it and seen many others do it. Doesn't mean I was a fan of it, but it's become the method of survival/success that the best organizations are utilizing.

Edit to add - the one thing I've suggested to Bort to discourage the above is to really make chemistry have a HUGE effect and to make it harder to regain. Right now teams can dump complete rosters and the low chemistry won't affect them and they rebuild it much too quickly. A completely new team should take several seasons to learn to mesh together, not half a season. (Case in point is Ministry of Defense, I was a coordinator for them last season and their team was never negatively affected by extremely low chemistry)
Edited by Catch22 on Jan 27, 2010 10:48:04
 
.spider.
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catch22
When a team is going to move a player to another team, they load them up through the EQ fund, give them a max contract with a max signing bonus that ends on day 40. At the end of the season, the player with all his shiny money and EQ signs a contract with the "main" team which does not have to worry about the EQ costs for that player and can sign them to a minimum contract. Happens all the time... I know, because I've been a part of some of the teams that have done it and seen many others do it. Doesn't mean I was a fan of it, but it's become the method of survival/success that the best organizations are utilizing.


Max contract is what a 400k signing bonus...only allow them to do it once. If they want to pay 2/1 through the equip fund so be it.

I never said it was a fix, I simply said it is a big dent to the problem.

I just thing overhauling the whole equipment system to where making money meaningless would really lessen the "fun" it is to be an owner and manage money....

If you give all of the money back to the team of equipment you have just made money meaningless
If you give half of the money back to the team you still havent fixed the problem as teams will continue to do what they are doing.
 
.spider.
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catch22
Edit to add - the one thing I've suggested to Bort to discourage the above is to really make chemistry have a HUGE effect and to make it harder to regain. Right now teams can dump complete rosters and the low chemistry won't affect them and they rebuild it much too quickly. A completely new team should take several seasons to learn to mesh together, not half a season. (Case in point is Ministry of Defense, I was a coordinator for them last season and their team was never negatively affected by extremely low chemistry)


But then you have the argument of almost every pro team has to turn over half a roster every season starting at 50ish chemistry...not fair if AAA teams are coming up w/ younger players and come in with 100 chem across the board and Pro teams have to fight decline and start the season sub 70 just because they are forced to replace declining players.
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
Eh, money is already meaningless for the best teams/organizations. I seriously never even looked twice at budgets or anything of that sort because it was never a worry... money was easy to get.. and if anything the EQ fund and setting ticket prices was more of an annoyance than something that was "fun" because money is so meaningless, it'd be more fun if it had value and saving your pennies actually would mean something. We can figure out other ways to use money, EQ doesn't have to be the only thing it can be used on, but EQ is such a huge issue that teams are exploiting/gaming that something needs to be done.

The problems this will solve will make the game more fun for a hell of a lot more of people. We're just going to have to agree to disagree on this one.
Edited by Catch22 on Jan 27, 2010 10:54:49
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jbleich
But then you have the argument of almost every pro team has to turn over half a roster every season starting at 50ish chemistry...not fair if AAA teams are coming up w/ younger players and come in with 100 chem across the board and Pro teams have to fight decline and start the season sub 70 just because they are forced to replace declining players.


The other part of my suggestion is that there is no chemistry penalty if a player that is >440 days old leaves the team. This would offset that.
 
.spider.
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catch22
Eh, money is already meaningless for the best teams/organizations. I seriously never even looked twice at budgets or anything of that sort because it was never a worry... money was easy to get.. and if anything the EQ fund and setting ticket prices was more of an annoyance than something that was "fun" because money is so meaningless, it'd be more fun if it had value and saving your pennies actually would mean something. We can figure out other ways to use money, EQ doesn't have to be the only thing it can be used on, but EQ is such a huge issue that teams are exploiting/gaming that something needs to be done.

The problems this will solve will make the game more fun for a hell of a lot more of people. We're just going to have to agree to disagree on this one.


The reason you have this opinion though is the teams that you are on have apparently practiced what we talking about here and therefore yes it is meaningless....Look at all sides of the token bud....For teams like Sofia whom have NEVER used farm teams...yet....for this advantage it still is a money management process....the only reason I have a 30 Mill bank now is season 12 WL We knew we where not going to make it to the playoffs so We stopped with all L64 gear....had I been in pro that season Sofia would be at or arnound 10 mil right now.

If you read your paragraph again you'll find out that the latter is what caused the former...so we should do something about the cause, not the effect.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.