User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
RIP Al Davis
offline
Link
 
lol
 
beenlurken
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HALL OF FAMER Al Davis
terrible. X-Factor should never exist in any way, shape or form.


I agree... but if it must, then is this a fair compromise?
 
sunshineduck
offline
Link
 
I miss when this thread had unicorns and ponies in it
 
SAINT615
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RandomBeast
do you have any way to discover what your players natural ability is before committing to a build direction? if not, it is functionally no different than random x-factor.


I think the difference here is the thought that 1 in 12,000 players may have an "x-factor" and may or may not be able to build to exploit that edge.

Beenlurken is suggesting that every player have an "x-factor" and, with any luck, they will figure out what direction they are supposed to build in. The returns of exceptional players in his scenario would be much, much greater than whatever is currently going on.

Another option - which would give players something else to do and give another training option - would be to have weekly performance tied even more closely to some targeted weight range and give training options that allowed you to skip training strength or agility in favor of getting closer to your weight (through some sort of weight loss/weight gain program).

 
Link
 
Originally posted by beenlurken
I hate to bump this again... but does anyone have an opinion?


We want the very idea of "hidden" attributes to die--I'm not interested in any suggestion to make it more "fair".
 
PsychoMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
btw, BP, Bort liked your take on the X-factor from like 15 pages back.


whats that supposed to mean?
 
Bigmoneydave
offline
Link
 
That's just as bad or worse tbh. Why do you think it would be any less random than AEQ? I don't know about you guys but I don't want to spend 3 seasons trying to create a player with a relevant x-factor.
 
beenlurken
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RandomBeast
do you have any way to discover what your players natural ability is before committing to a build direction? if not, it is functionally no different than random x-factor.


Not early on... but by mid career you should have some idea and by end of career it should pretty clear which direction you should have gone. At the very least it give players a chance to "fix" their build mid/end career and salvage the player to have some kind of impact using their X-Factor (they wont be as good as they could have been but they should still be worth keeping around).

Also, It adds a new dynamic to slow building... sell out and guess for the first half of the players career and potentially waste potential X-Factor or cautiously build (saving some SP's instead of strategically applying to get max benefit from natural level ups) to try to get the most out of the X-Factor.

 
taz20075
offline
Link
 
Dear bort,

I'd gladly test the x-factor on my players. Please PM me when you've added the code.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by PsychoMan
whats that supposed to mean?


It was a joke post--a detailed one, but a joke nonetheless.
 
Dragon82
offline
Link
 


First off I am not saying there is an X-factor just giving an argument for all the people that say it does not make any sense to have one, that there is a reason that makes sense for it to be there.

Money.

I do not know if there is an x factor or not, but it does make sense from a financial stand point. For a business (most businesses not all) to succeed it needs to have loyal repeat customers. So what do you need to have repeat customers? You give them a reason to continue to come back and spend money.

You have a consumable product (i.e. something that when purchased will not last forever). Multiple similar products with cosmetic or functional differences (like barbie dolls, g.i. joes, video games). Something that has added benefit if you own more than one or you need more than one (like light bulbs, batteries). You have add-ons for your product(s). You make small change or limited addition to your product, an upgraded model. Changes to your product that make older versions obsolete or not as good. You create a habit or need (or use an existing one) in your customer to get your product or service the previous points can all help achieve this. There are more, but that should be significant for this example.



So lets take a look at those compared to GLB.

1.) consumable product: Players decline, retire, and do not get full flex back.
Check
2.) Similar products with cosmetic or functional differences: Many different positions and build possibilities. Causal and pee-wee leagues.
Check
3.) Added benefit to having more than one: more players or farm teams the more likely you to have an elite dot and/or keep your team successful and your team on top.
Check
4.) add ons: custom equipment, casual leagues, pee-wee even va's and AEQ sense you can build your player drastically different with these additions leading to players wanting to retire and start over to take advantage of the new additions. Check
5.) Changes upgrades over time: Let's see each season we get a new feature, ai addition, new plays, new training, aeq... Check
6.) Changes that make previous models obsolete: Buffs nerfs to certain attributes, abilities and positions
Check
7) Habit for your product. GLB has a built in habit sense American football is immensely popular, so GlB already has a existing habit to get people to check out the game and be willing to give it some time.


The question is how do you turn that initial response to the game into an all out addiction?

Behavior modification.

First step give the people rewards for sticking around and doing good. You make a token system. Teachers give students stickers and stars for dong well in class. In GLB you get small trophy icons for your player and your team doing well. The above examples also have an effect on behavior modification once the desire to be successful is created in the customer.

So far GLB has a lot points that favor behavior modification to create a habit. So what could push that habit forming even more and get people to buy even more flex? What is the best weapon in modifying behavior and creating a habit?


Variable reinforcement.


And how can GLB create variable reinforcement for creating players?


Superstar dots


People want to make that superstar dot. They want to own that dominate player, they want to be apart of that top team. Now the reason a very uncommon x factor like plus 5-10% to all rolls makes sense, is that people will see the dominate dots. They see they can be made and they want to make them. They start making players and build the player the way they think that top dot is built. If their dot does not turn out that way, they retire and build a different way. They continue to do this and maybe they get an amazing dot or maybe they are about to give up, then they see another elite dot, and another. Guess what that does? The player then figures if more people are doing it there must be something that I missed and didn't try. They go and try again to make an elite dot.


The same idea behind gambling. You have a payoff at a variable ratio. (By the way variable ratio is scientifically the best way to create a habit). You have payoffs occur the lights go off the siren sounds and everyone around notices, and starts betting more because they are now reinforced with the possibility that it could be them next. In GLB the elite Dots are noticed by those around them (league opponents, team mates, and in some cases most of the GLB community). The object is to make the payoff seem 100% random, and to occur enough to keep people trying, but not occur enough where to many people are winning and you are losing money. In GLB we already covered why their is a need for elite dots and if everybody could build an elite dot it would weaken the strength of the addiction and people would not need to spend so much flex "testing" builds.


Using a variable ratio has been proven to be the best method for modifying behavior whether in adults, raising children, or training an animal and creating an addiction. Researchers can condition animals to repeatedly press a button for hours if they think eventually the button press will lead to a positive response.


If there is an x-factor it would really strengthen the habit of continuing to press the same create a player and buy flex buttons over and over in hopes of an elite player being born.


Again not saying there is an x-factor as I have not personally done research on it or acquired data. Just that rare occurrences whether it be, specific ratios of attributes, sa's, va's, height, weight, or a random bonus to rolls (an x-factor), it can really add to the addiction level players have for the game, and as a result add a noticeable benefit to the bottom line of the business that is GLB.
 
NSchmidt10
offline
Link
 
Dear Bort,

Please get rid of the x-factor. We have known it exists since season 4.

Thank you.
 
Link
 
Dragon82: folks would leave in droves were they to learn that their dots ability to perform was limited NOT by the choices they made with the dot over the course of a career, but instead by some artificial bullshit factor beyond their control.
 
PsychoMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
It was a joke post--a detailed one, but a joke nonetheless.


Yeah, but ...

Did Bort like it because it was a funny joke?
Did Bort like it because it was similar to how the x-factor actually works?
Did Bort like it because it was a good idea of how to implement the x-factor when he decides to add it?
 
tsherr
offline
Link
 
I'm not sure if I feel better knowing that my placeholder players (and that is pretty much all of them) are placeholders because they were fucked at birth, or pissed off that I wasted all this time and money trying to change them from placeholders into superstars.

It is very telling the Bort hasn't bothered to weigh in in this thread but instead is active in a no-customer zone.

T
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.