User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Demotion Ideas for the WPL
Page:
 
Link
 
Im going to update the OP w/ idea's bort has liked or thought were interesting...if anyone can bump those up w/ Borts quote that would be helpful.
 
ICRockets
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by viking maniac 1
People are gonna start trying to get into the so-called easy pro leagues so that they can get to the WPL anyway. It wouldn't surprise me to see OC's,DC's and elite players moving from the "power" leagues to these "easy" leagues to get in the WPL. The plans are probably already in place for some


I'm sure that's true. Doesn't that then make USAPL worse and make the other leagues better?

Wouldn't that help foster "parity"? I don't see the issue here.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Gart888
Is that the goal here? To make OPL = USAPL?


Thats something Bort needs to ask himself.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla
Originally posted by ROYAL23

This is gonna be a mess!!!
Is it just me, or has this thread proven that ideas cannot be discussed in forums at all? I swear I've seen the same 4 ideas as "original posts" about 20 times each


I'm actually fairly surprised about how well it's gone. Not a whole lot of flaming and good constructive criticism.
 
Link
 
at the end of the season we have a large poker tournament where the represent your team, if you finish in the bottom 16 your team is eliminated. Then we hold poker tournaments to determine who moves up. So if 3 USAPL teams are eliminated in the top 3 in the USAPL poker tournament get promoted. Perfect plan.
Edited by Timetoshine-Beta on Jul 27, 2009 22:14:32
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnit643
Originally posted by lukin83

Originally posted by turnit643

Originally posted by lukin83



I am not 100% for divisions. I am 100% for all 8 regions being represented equally. If that is possible without divisions, I am all for it. Show me the way and I will follow.


Done.

4 teams from each get a shot in the first season.

2 more each season after that.

Make the playoffs or go home.

Always at least two from a region.

Always opportunity for more.

All 8 regions repped equally.


: middlefinger :

How does this ultimately make OPL = USAPL?


The same way any of these suggestions do ... players look at the ladder, they see wow OPL is easy, let's join a team there, win, and get to the WL quick.


I can see from where this thread is going that USAPL will always remain the elite pro league in the game. I don't like it, but that ultimately does not matter in the grad scheme of things. The inferior regions will never close the gap on USAPL because the perception of USAPL is not going to change. USA will own the WL and up-and-coming teams will want to be a part of that and not the underdog OPL, SEAPL, etc. I honestly did not know why I thought it could be any different.
 
Knightman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Im going to update the OP w/ idea's bort has liked or thought were interesting...if anyone can bump those up w/ Borts quote that would be helpful.


Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by ImTheScientist

It would also be cool if when a team is in the WPL they get a symbol or something that designates where they are from.


Simple but fantastic idea. +1


Here's one that's been pretty non-controversial....


EDIT: OK, I'm an idiot.....it was YOUR idea in the first place!
Edited by Knightman on Jul 27, 2009 22:15:55
 
BBVD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Timetoshine-Beta
Originally posted by Gart888

Originally posted by viking maniac 1


So if 4 teams from the same pro league make the playoffs in the WPL then none of them get demoted and no teams from that league get promoted


nope, 2 teams from that pro league still get promoted.


what if the 2 worst records were to make it to the championship game and the top team was say 16-0....lulz


THANK YOU

too much in this game can be based on one fluke sim

16 sims removes the opportunity for flukes to affect the season too much
 
JeffSteele
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Im going to update the OP w/ idea's bort has liked or thought were interesting...if anyone can bump those up w/ Borts quote that would be helpful.
I mean you p much just have "8 or 16 demotions", "divsions or not" and "where do demoted teams go" ... every suggestion (besides the money one) is some combination of answers to those questions.
 
Knightman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Im going to update the OP w/ idea's bort has liked or thought were interesting...if anyone can bump those up w/ Borts quote that would be helpful.


Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Knightman

OK, it's been a while since I posted my suggestion, and since Bort has said he doesn't like the divisions idea....

What about the idea of assigning a pot of money to WPL teams based on their original regions?

This would promote parity as if OPL has only 2 teams splitting a pot and USAPL has 6, each OPL team will get 3 times as much money as the USAPL teams. Since EQ upgrades at the levels we're talking about cost much more than a level boost, and players will only level 5 times a season, giving a team that extra cash may be enough to compensate for lower level players it may have. Even if it gets demoted, it has a wad of cash to dole out to recruits who want EQ upgrades for their players, thus giving them a recruiting advantage. Higher level players migrate to the teams that have the cash, and Voila!----parity!!!

This system can continue even after parity exists, since presumably each league will have the same number of teams in the WPL and get the same amount of money.

Now that the issue of parity gets addressed, there's no problem with allowing teams to go back to their original regions and resume their rivalries/friendships with familiar foes. After all, remember when GLB was touted as much as a social networking game as it was football? Why destroy the social networking aspect of it by randomizing demotion?


Interesting and out of the box at the very least. Kinda like taking the idea of media revenue and splitting it by representation in the league.
 
Anarcho
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ryiotgear
Originally posted by Gart888

Originally posted by BBVD


Originally posted by ChicagoTRS



IMO keep it simple:

4 go up this year from each pro conference = 32 teams

next season demote all non-playoff teams - put them in their past conf - demote more teams from the pro league to make space..

2 conf champs get promoted...

rinse repeat...

The benefits of this is that it is simple to implement and only the best of the best play the WPL. It is ridiculous to suggest any system that has a top team being demoted just because there is another top team from the same conf. The goal should be to get the best 32 teams in the WPL.


yes!

where you at bort?


yeah, this is by far the most logical method.


How isn't this thread over yet? This option makes way too much sense compared to any other alternative.

Edit - and ITS' idea of adding flags for your home region for World League Teams is a pretty cool idea


I think this is the best idea and will please the most. The only people who would get upset would be the Pro team that gets moved back to AAA because there are 3 teams from one region returning or something. I don't think that is a big deal though. With the extra AAA teams being promoted, it is a wash.

The only addition I would make is allowing teams to select if they want to go back to their region or a random region (don't let teams select regions). This way, teams that want to go back to their region can, but those that don't care can be placed in a random Pro League that has an opening. It will help a little bit in balancing the leagues, at least it should over several seasons.
 
ICRockets
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lukin83
Originally posted by turnit643

Originally posted by lukin83


Originally posted by turnit643


Originally posted by lukin83




I am not 100% for divisions. I am 100% for all 8 regions being represented equally. If that is possible without divisions, I am all for it. Show me the way and I will follow.


Done.

4 teams from each get a shot in the first season.

2 more each season after that.

Make the playoffs or go home.

Always at least two from a region.

Always opportunity for more.

All 8 regions repped equally.


: middlefinger :

How does this ultimately make OPL = USAPL?


The same way any of these suggestions do ... players look at the ladder, they see wow OPL is easy, let's join a team there, win, and get to the WL quick.


I can see from where this thread is going that USAPL will always remain the elite pro league in the game. I don't like it, but that ultimately does not matter in the grad scheme of things. The inferior regions will never close the gap on USAPL because the perception of USAPL is not going to change. USA will own the WL and up-and-coming teams will want to be a part of that and not the underdog OPL, SEAPL, etc. I honestly did not know why I thought it could be any different.


Seriously, do you hear yourself? This makes NO sense. You're trying to say "Well, if a USAPL team wins the WPL the 1st 3 seasons, then everybody's going to think "Oh, I want to be on a USAPL team because IF by some chance we make it to the WPL we're ABSOLUTELY GUARANTEED to be the best!"

It's illogical for the same reason that you can't guarantee a coin will be heads because it was heads the last 47 times you flipped it. Past outcomes do not guarantee future results. And if people want to believe they do, and they go to USAPL for that reason....FINE!!! LET THEM!! Like I said before, the people that do that for the reasons you're citing are thinking like idiots. They're not the ones whose opinion on "parity" I give a crap about.
 
boomer82
offline
Link
 
16 demotions/promotions every year is clearly the way to go. Keeps lots of fresh blood moving into the WL and lets the "lesser" teams go back to a regional Pro tier where they have a greater chance for success.

As far as keeping the teams in their original regions, the only time that becomes an issue is if more than 2 teams are slotted for demotion. If that happens, I say the 2 teams with the best record get to go back to their original Pro region, if they so choose, and the other 2 are randomly assigned.
 
JeffSteele
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Anarcho
I think this is the best idea and will please the most. The only people who would get upset would be the Pro team that gets moved back to AAA because there are 3 teams from one region returning or something. I don't think that is a big deal though. With the extra AAA teams being promoted, it is a wash.
With respect to this point, those extra demotions to AAA shouldn't complain because they really didn't deserve to be in Pro and are just there because there happened to be two teams who gave up.

 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lukin83
Originally posted by turnit643
Originally posted by lukin83
Originally posted by turnit643
Originally posted by lukin83


I am not 100% for divisions. I am 100% for all 8 regions being represented equally. If that is possible without divisions, I am all for it. Show me the way and I will follow.


Done.

4 teams from each get a shot in the first season.

2 more each season after that.

Make the playoffs or go home.

Always at least two from a region.

Always opportunity for more.

All 8 regions repped equally.


: middlefinger :

How does this ultimately make OPL = USAPL?


The same way any of these suggestions do ... players look at the ladder, they see wow OPL is easy, let's join a team there, win, and get to the WL quick.


I can see from where this thread is going that USAPL will always remain the elite pro league in the game. I don't like it, but that ultimately does not matter in the grad scheme of things. The inferior regions will never close the gap on USAPL because the perception of USAPL is not going to change. USA will own the WL and up-and-coming teams will want to be a part of that and not the underdog OPL, SEAPL, etc. I honestly did not know why I thought it could be any different.


Luke, do you think I'm pushing a USAPL-first bias? I'm not, no reason to and really don't get why the system I support would lead you to think that. You want four teams from each region each season, period. I want the best to stay regardless of home region with two from each getting a chance to join each season. Yeah, it may for a while be USAPL heavy, but it may also be OPL heavy at some point in the future, or EEPL, or whatever. I just don't want to sacrifice competition - potentially the best this game has seen - just to make each region feel loved.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.