User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Jason Elliott
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
Jason, the point here is that soft-capped vision for a DE still doesn't get him off the line without waiting a fairly long time. Vision should be no better than the 5th most important attribute for a DE (behind strength, speed, agility, tackling, and probably also behind stamina). Is there any other position that can't do it's fundamental job without having it's 5th most important attribute well over the soft cap (besides, possibly, CBs, but that's another, somewhat significant problem with this game that deserves its own thread).


Vision should be top three for every position I won't bend on that. And if soft capped vision still isn't getting DE's off the line then thats a problem. But there are people in here saying that they will never put points into it and thats there problem.
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
Warlock,

Once again, we're in agreement about what the problem was. I just think that the way to have fixed this was to punish low strength realistically (with morale/stamina hits), and not make vision an oddly unrealistic attribute (low vision should have an evasive DE run into the OT, not stand still. . . unfortunately, low vision now seems to describe vision at 50).


Which is exactly how many OTs felt when they realized that they needed speed to the soft cap or higher to not get run around by speed/agility DEs. OTs also have the same issue, 50 agility is considered low by many (granted it's a little more of a priority to OTs than vision should be for a DE). Combine both speed and agility issues with an OT and I think it's on par with the DE needing high vision TBPH.

Bottom line, this is why tweaking isn't going to ever fix the core problem... the system currently being used is borked and needs to be addressed.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Jason,

That's fine, but currently, vision is not one of the top three attributes for HBs, WRs, OTs, OGs, Cs, FBs, TEs or DTs. It is, arguably, top three only for QBs, DBs and, now DEs.
 
Broker Hart
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by mutleyddmc

Originally posted by Jason Elliott


Originally posted by mutleyddmc



Originally posted by Jason Elliott




I'll post this again and this should be the way it should be.

Vision should ne needed for all positions, it is not just the ability to see the field which everyone in here keeps saying. if you got 8 vision he should be getting a ton of penalties, and getting juked by play action fakes, taking bad lanes to the QB, missing tackles etc.


i dont think you realise that we arent saying low vision means that we have good lanes to QB, getting juked missing tackles. but what we are saying is that low vision doesnt mean counting to 10 before rushing the passer.



I agree with that totally, but at the same time you should still upgrade your vision for the above reasons i stated.


My De's have sufficent vision anyway so im not worried about that. i mworried that 30-40 vision will be effected


One of my DEs who played today has 40 vision, 10 first step and a ton of speed and agility and he got NO jumps off the line. In fact, he sat there and waited for a second or 2 before even rushing, how stupid is that?




Looks to me like the entire defense is slowed up a little bit. The offense is moving way before the defense is.

 
rj414
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Broker Hart
Originally posted by jrry32

Originally posted by mutleyddmc


Originally posted by Jason Elliott



Originally posted by mutleyddmc




Originally posted by Jason Elliott





I'll post this again and this should be the way it should be.

Vision should ne needed for all positions, it is not just the ability to see the field which everyone in here keeps saying. if you got 8 vision he should be getting a ton of penalties, and getting juked by play action fakes, taking bad lanes to the QB, missing tackles etc.


i dont think you realise that we arent saying low vision means that we have good lanes to QB, getting juked missing tackles. but what we are saying is that low vision doesnt mean counting to 10 before rushing the passer.



I agree with that totally, but at the same time you should still upgrade your vision for the above reasons i stated.


My De's have sufficent vision anyway so im not worried about that. i mworried that 30-40 vision will be effected


One of my DEs who played today has 40 vision, 10 first step and a ton of speed and agility and he got NO jumps off the line. In fact, he sat there and waited for a second or 2 before even rushing, how stupid is that?




Looks to me like the entire defense is slowed up a little bit. The offense is moving way before the defense is.



Agreed, the entire defense just looks terrible off the snap.
 
navytexas1
offline
Link
 
I love how you say the GAME IS BROKEN, without saying GAME IS BROKEN, Good Job
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock
Originally posted by Gyuri1

Warlock,

Once again, we're in agreement about what the problem was. I just think that the way to have fixed this was to punish low strength realistically (with morale/stamina hits), and not make vision an oddly unrealistic attribute (low vision should have an evasive DE run into the OT, not stand still. . . unfortunately, low vision now seems to describe vision at 50).


Which is exactly how many OTs felt when they realized that they needed speed to the soft cap or higher to not get run around by speed/agility DEs. OTs also have the same issue, 50 agility is considered low by many (granted it's a little more of a priority to OTs than vision should be for a DE). Combine both speed and agility issues with an OT and I think it's on par with the DE needing high vision TBPH.

Bottom line, this is why tweaking isn't going to ever fix the core problem... the system currently being used is borted and needs to be addressed.


Edited for truth
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by Warlock

Originally posted by Gyuri1


Warlock,

Once again, we're in agreement about what the problem was. I just think that the way to have fixed this was to punish low strength realistically (with morale/stamina hits), and not make vision an oddly unrealistic attribute (low vision should have an evasive DE run into the OT, not stand still. . . unfortunately, low vision now seems to describe vision at 50).


Which is exactly how many OTs felt when they realized that they needed speed to the soft cap or higher to not get run around by speed/agility DEs. OTs also have the same issue, 50 agility is considered low by many (granted it's a little more of a priority to OTs than vision should be for a DE). Combine both speed and agility issues with an OT and I think it's on par with the DE needing high vision TBPH.

Bottom line, this is why tweaking isn't going to ever fix the core problem... the system currently being used is borted and needs to be addressed.


Edited for truth


Scace, you'll be interested in what I found about offensive levels in other areas.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1464175
 
Kayoh
offline
Link
 
I'm not even going to bother ready any other posts, just the OP.

If your Agility isn't >61, Speed isn't >49, OR Vision isn't >49, then that's your problem right there. Fix it.
 
Pensfan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kayoh
I'm not even going to bother ready any other posts, just the OP.

If your Agility isn't >61, Speed isn't >49, OR Vision isn't >49, then that's your problem right there. Fix it.


agreed 100%... I would even suggest that the Agility > 80, Speed > 60, Vision >50
 
Kayoh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Pensfan
Originally posted by Kayoh

I'm not even going to bother ready any other posts, just the OP.

If your Agility isn't >61, Speed isn't >49, OR Vision isn't >49, then that's your problem right there. Fix it.


agreed 100%... I would even suggest that the Agility > 80, Speed > 60, Vision >50
That seems a bit extreme. He doesn't even have Lv 32 upgrades yet.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kayoh
I'm not even going to bother ready any other posts, just the OP.

If your Agility isn't >61, Speed isn't >49, OR Vision isn't >49, then that's your problem right there. Fix it.


If you think that, you're the one with the problem.
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Pensfan
Originally posted by Kayoh

I'm not even going to bother ready any other posts, just the OP.

If your Agility isn't >61, Speed isn't >49, OR Vision isn't >49, then that's your problem right there. Fix it.


agreed 100%... I would even suggest that the Agility > 80, Speed > 60, Vision >50


We're building an OT, not a CB.
 
Pensfan
offline
Link
 
damnit.. I missed you weren't still talking about DEs.

My bad.


 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kayoh
I'm not even going to bother ready any other posts, just the OP.

If your Agility isn't >61, Speed isn't >49, OR Vision isn't >49, then that's your problem right there. Fix it.


Seriously, I've seen two of your posts in the FB forum and now this one. Everything I've read in those posts has struck me as bad advice or uninformed. Please, do us all a favor and stop posting... not trying to be a jerk-off or anything, but you're dis-information will probably end up hurting anyone not knowledgeable enough, to know your advice from good advice.

P.S. 49 speed, 61 agility and 49 vision won't solve the issue completely. I have better stats than that on my OT and he still gets beat by the better built speed/agility DEs... maybe not after the most recent changes to protector, although I haven't gotten the chance to test them yet.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.