Originally posted by kurieg
Originally posted by CapnEnnui
It's not defender's fault any more than it's running back's fault. It's the fault of the sim constantly changing what a good build is and what a good build isn't. But once people do what works, it changes for the worse. And it sucks for everyone. This isn't offense against defense, this is players against sim changes.
A LOT of perceived changes are not sim changes; they are movement in the meta-game.
The game is in flux. Everyone should have known this from the get-go.
I don't want 14 fumbles in a game, either, but I don't think just changing mechanics is necessarily the right answer. A lot of giant stats in this game come about as a direct result of there being no adjustments during a game. A mismatch gets inflated badly, especially ones that involve the same interaction over and over (like a DE vs. OT, or a returner getting tackled by a dedicated cover guy.)
Much of this should be fought with some kind of "reactiveness" in the sim (with player direction).
metagame and game changes is semantics. Nerfing attribute VAs was a GAME change so how is moving over to power tackling from a nerfed VA a metagame change?
Broken tackles being less effective was a GAME change so how is setting d players to force fumbles a metagame change?
Originally posted by CapnEnnui
It's not defender's fault any more than it's running back's fault. It's the fault of the sim constantly changing what a good build is and what a good build isn't. But once people do what works, it changes for the worse. And it sucks for everyone. This isn't offense against defense, this is players against sim changes.
A LOT of perceived changes are not sim changes; they are movement in the meta-game.
The game is in flux. Everyone should have known this from the get-go.
I don't want 14 fumbles in a game, either, but I don't think just changing mechanics is necessarily the right answer. A lot of giant stats in this game come about as a direct result of there being no adjustments during a game. A mismatch gets inflated badly, especially ones that involve the same interaction over and over (like a DE vs. OT, or a returner getting tackled by a dedicated cover guy.)
Much of this should be fought with some kind of "reactiveness" in the sim (with player direction).
metagame and game changes is semantics. Nerfing attribute VAs was a GAME change so how is moving over to power tackling from a nerfed VA a metagame change?
Broken tackles being less effective was a GAME change so how is setting d players to force fumbles a metagame change?
Last edited Apr 26, 2009 18:34:19






























