User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > NERF THE FUMBLES NOW!!!
Page:
 
CapnEnnui
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
Originally posted by CapnEnnui



It's not defender's fault any more than it's running back's fault. It's the fault of the sim constantly changing what a good build is and what a good build isn't. But once people do what works, it changes for the worse. And it sucks for everyone. This isn't offense against defense, this is players against sim changes.


A LOT of perceived changes are not sim changes; they are movement in the meta-game.

The game is in flux. Everyone should have known this from the get-go.

I don't want 14 fumbles in a game, either, but I don't think just changing mechanics is necessarily the right answer. A lot of giant stats in this game come about as a direct result of there being no adjustments during a game. A mismatch gets inflated badly, especially ones that involve the same interaction over and over (like a DE vs. OT, or a returner getting tackled by a dedicated cover guy.)

Much of this should be fought with some kind of "reactiveness" in the sim (with player direction).


metagame and game changes is semantics. Nerfing attribute VAs was a GAME change so how is moving over to power tackling from a nerfed VA a metagame change?

Broken tackles being less effective was a GAME change so how is setting d players to force fumbles a metagame change?
Last edited Apr 26, 2009 18:34:19
 
bluemagus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CapnEnnui
Originally posted by Luzod

I think we are getting close to realism. However, Bort must stop falling for whinners.

If you look at this topic, many people are defending the actual sim. Still there are 4~5 whinners (yes, because the arguments you are using are really weak. The guy who's HB fumbled 15 times after his 180 plays still here for example) and they seems to be getting to Bort. Really, listen to reason and stop listening to guys that chose (yes, because in RPG you make choices on how you want your players to be) to have a very fast/agile HB that can't hold the ball.

It was their choice not to invest on carrying, so let them suffer.

The only guy with a point actually is GeneralM, but still, it's only 1 player in 1 game and we don't even know opponents builds, so...


They chose not to invest in a stat that wasn't useful until now. How is that their fault?

And how is this many fumbles "close to realism"? I said it already, Adrian Peterson is "fumble prone" because he fumbled 6 times in 16 games. That's not the rate we're going right now.


Wasn't 3 in one game though? (4 really if I remember right but the refs messed up on the call). Sounds like a confidence issue.

In effect the opposing team, seeing that the Vikings were 1-dimensional went to a run focus and attacked the RB with a focus on the ball.
Last edited Apr 26, 2009 18:36:45
 
CapnEnnui
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by trentw
Originally posted by trentw

We haven't even talked about kick offs where you had damn well better have a Powerback or a Fullback return now, because WR's and Cb's have no cover up option, and imo returns is where fumbles are out of control. That said once again you have thousands of ST'ers who have pumped power tackling who will expect a reset if fumbling is nerfed.


I don't mind quoting myself, especially when I feel it needs to be said again.


Quoted for next page
 
CapnEnnui
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bluemagus
Originally posted by CapnEnnui

Originally posted by Luzod


I think we are getting close to realism. However, Bort must stop falling for whinners.

If you look at this topic, many people are defending the actual sim. Still there are 4~5 whinners (yes, because the arguments you are using are really weak. The guy who's HB fumbled 15 times after his 180 plays still here for example) and they seems to be getting to Bort. Really, listen to reason and stop listening to guys that chose (yes, because in RPG you make choices on how you want your players to be) to have a very fast/agile HB that can't hold the ball.

It was their choice not to invest on carrying, so let them suffer.

The only guy with a point actually is GeneralM, but still, it's only 1 player in 1 game and we don't even know opponents builds, so...


They chose not to invest in a stat that wasn't useful until now. How is that their fault?

And how is this many fumbles "close to realism"? I said it already, Adrian Peterson is "fumble prone" because he fumbled 6 times in 16 games. That's not the rate we're going right now.


Wasn't 3 in one game though? (4 really if I remember right but the refs messed up on the call). Sounds like a confidence issue.


If it was, it would've been a confidence issue last season too. But it wasn't.
 
headsigh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by trentw
Originally posted by trentw

We haven't even talked about kick offs where you had damn well better have a Powerback or a Fullback return now, because WR's and Cb's have no cover up option, and imo returns is where fumbles are out of control. That said once again you have thousands of ST'ers who have pumped power tackling who will expect a reset if fumbling is nerfed.


I don't mind quoting myself, especially when I feel it needs to be said again.


If the CB is a returner, they need to train carrying + get associated VAs.

I don't think anything will, or should be nerfed.

Nothing should be nerfed here.

I think during the offseason, Bort needs to take a good, long look at his simulations- even from the time-tested ones to the newly introduced scripting.

This is the part where you have to wonder how this man, as good as he is, can run this game on his own.
 
Zadith
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
Originally posted by Zadith

My guys on power tackling miss a few tackles a game from what I have seen. Were you also on the LBs side when the power backs were destroying groups of defenders at the same time? Just trying to make a point, no matter what Bort does he is going to over power one group and screw the other...just the nature of the game...


Neither of your higher level defensive players missed a tackle and they both forced a fumble. By the way, I was on the LBs side when power backs were destroying groups of defenders at the same time.


No but they have missed tackles. Just because a few games they have 2-3 tackles with 1 FF doesn't mean they have not also missed tackles in other games.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CapnEnnui

Originally posted by Luzod


I think we are getting close to realism. However, Bort must stop falling for whinners.

If you look at this topic, many people are defending the actual sim. Still there are 4~5 whinners (yes, because the arguments you are using are really weak. The guy who's HB fumbled 15 times after his 180 plays still here for example) and they seems to be getting to Bort. Really, listen to reason and stop listening to guys that chose (yes, because in RPG you make choices on how you want your players to be) to have a very fast/agile HB that can't hold the ball.

It was their choice not to invest on carrying, so let them suffer.

The only guy with a point actually is GeneralM, but still, it's only 1 player in 1 game and we don't even know opponents builds, so...


They chose not to invest in a stat that wasn't useful until now. How is that their fault?

And how is this many fumbles "close to realism"? I said it already, Adrian Peterson is "fumble prone" because he fumbled 6 times in 16 games. That's not the rate we're going right now.


Oh so there should be realism on fumbles but yet a RB should still be able to average 300 yards a game.
 
headsigh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by CapnEnnui


Originally posted by Luzod



I think we are getting close to realism. However, Bort must stop falling for whinners.

If you look at this topic, many people are defending the actual sim. Still there are 4~5 whinners (yes, because the arguments you are using are really weak. The guy who's HB fumbled 15 times after his 180 plays still here for example) and they seems to be getting to Bort. Really, listen to reason and stop listening to guys that chose (yes, because in RPG you make choices on how you want your players to be) to have a very fast/agile HB that can't hold the ball.

It was their choice not to invest on carrying, so let them suffer.

The only guy with a point actually is GeneralM, but still, it's only 1 player in 1 game and we don't even know opponents builds, so...


They chose not to invest in a stat that wasn't useful until now. How is that their fault?

And how is this many fumbles "close to realism"? I said it already, Adrian Peterson is "fumble prone" because he fumbled 6 times in 16 games. That's not the rate we're going right now.


Oh so there should be realism on fumbles but yet a RB should still be able to average 300 yards a game.


Do you put words in people's mouths this frequently or did I catch you on a bad day?
 
CapnEnnui
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by CapnEnnui


Originally posted by Luzod



I think we are getting close to realism. However, Bort must stop falling for whinners.

If you look at this topic, many people are defending the actual sim. Still there are 4~5 whinners (yes, because the arguments you are using are really weak. The guy who's HB fumbled 15 times after his 180 plays still here for example) and they seems to be getting to Bort. Really, listen to reason and stop listening to guys that chose (yes, because in RPG you make choices on how you want your players to be) to have a very fast/agile HB that can't hold the ball.

It was their choice not to invest on carrying, so let them suffer.

The only guy with a point actually is GeneralM, but still, it's only 1 player in 1 game and we don't even know opponents builds, so...


They chose not to invest in a stat that wasn't useful until now. How is that their fault?

And how is this many fumbles "close to realism"? I said it already, Adrian Peterson is "fumble prone" because he fumbled 6 times in 16 games. That's not the rate we're going right now.


Oh so there should be realism on fumbles but yet a RB should still be able to average 300 yards a game.


SHUT UP you're just evading one problem by pointing at another!

RBs in pro leagues DON'T tend to average 300 yards a game. RBs who play gutted teams better damn well get tons of yards. This is about how the PRO LEAGUES are working, and I'm not even in them, I'm just sick of having almost no control over how good or bad my builds are!

Now that people know how good picking Sure Tackler/Power Tackler is, it's going to be the new I Slam unless something is done, so quit whining about RB yards and think about how stupid THIS problem is.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lolMurp
Originally posted by jrry32

Originally posted by CapnEnnui



Originally posted by Luzod




I think we are getting close to realism. However, Bort must stop falling for whinners.

If you look at this topic, many people are defending the actual sim. Still there are 4~5 whinners (yes, because the arguments you are using are really weak. The guy who's HB fumbled 15 times after his 180 plays still here for example) and they seems to be getting to Bort. Really, listen to reason and stop listening to guys that chose (yes, because in RPG you make choices on how you want your players to be) to have a very fast/agile HB that can't hold the ball.

It was their choice not to invest on carrying, so let them suffer.

The only guy with a point actually is GeneralM, but still, it's only 1 player in 1 game and we don't even know opponents builds, so...


They chose not to invest in a stat that wasn't useful until now. How is that their fault?

And how is this many fumbles "close to realism"? I said it already, Adrian Peterson is "fumble prone" because he fumbled 6 times in 16 games. That's not the rate we're going right now.


Oh so there should be realism on fumbles but yet a RB should still be able to average 300 yards a game.


Do you put words in people's mouths this frequently or did I catch you on a bad day?


Todays been a solid day for me, I haven't cut myself once and have laid off the self loathing, I guess I just put word's in people's mouth this frequently. But it twas a good point, people always demand that defenses should be realistic but are cool when offenses are running rampant. Not saying that he does, but most of GLB does.

 
bluemagus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CapnEnnui

If it was, it would've been a confidence issue last season too. But it wasn't.


I wasn't commenting on the sim directly, but rather the example.

Early on LBs needed little STR/TKL so they didn't up it because it provided little advantage and the points were more beneficial used elsewhere. Slowly the sim started requiring more and more STR/TKL, on the pace of 5-10 points a season. The last two seasons saw a even steeper ramp-up of needed STR/TKL due to powerbacks and some changes Bort decided to hold off on. Those owners adapted. Now they've got LBs with potentially more STR/TKL than needed so they're using settings to try to regain some benefit of those SP.

This is the reason for the increased SP. I fully understand people's frustration with it, but when Bort stepped in on the DE/OT thing, things went to hell a few seasons later. Bort didn't step in on the LB/PB thing, and now we have people saying 'well it wasn't that important last season, so why should I have to suffer this season.' I agree it's not the best way to run things, but it is better than a knee jerk reaction that we're going to be on the other side of the Nerf 'teeter-totter' next season with.

Good ideas:

- Carrying Slider
- Dedicated KR/PR position
- Force carrying check on Fum recovery player for how fast they can take off with the ball to prevent the Ffum = DefTD
 
CapnEnnui
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by lolMurp

Originally posted by jrry32


Originally posted by CapnEnnui




Originally posted by Luzod





I think we are getting close to realism. However, Bort must stop falling for whinners.

If you look at this topic, many people are defending the actual sim. Still there are 4~5 whinners (yes, because the arguments you are using are really weak. The guy who's HB fumbled 15 times after his 180 plays still here for example) and they seems to be getting to Bort. Really, listen to reason and stop listening to guys that chose (yes, because in RPG you make choices on how you want your players to be) to have a very fast/agile HB that can't hold the ball.

It was their choice not to invest on carrying, so let them suffer.

The only guy with a point actually is GeneralM, but still, it's only 1 player in 1 game and we don't even know opponents builds, so...


They chose not to invest in a stat that wasn't useful until now. How is that their fault?

And how is this many fumbles "close to realism"? I said it already, Adrian Peterson is "fumble prone" because he fumbled 6 times in 16 games. That's not the rate we're going right now.


Oh so there should be realism on fumbles but yet a RB should still be able to average 300 yards a game.


Do you put words in people's mouths this frequently or did I catch you on a bad day?


Todays been a solid day for me, I haven't cut myself once and have laid off the self loathing, I guess I just put word's in people's mouth this frequently. But it twas a good point, people always demand that defenses should be realistic but are cool when offenses are running rampant. Not saying that he does, but most of GLB does.



Pointing at average yards per game is meaningless in a game where awesome teams play horrible and gutted teams.

Offenses aren't that overpowered right now. I have 10 defensive players and one offensive player (another in peewee) so I'm certainly not asking for a boost to offense.

One TERRIBLE way to try to make defense better is to have tons and tons of fumbles all the time. That's not a fix.
 
headsigh
offline
Link
 
Soylent Green is people, guys.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CapnEnnui
Originally posted by jrry32

Originally posted by CapnEnnui



Originally posted by Luzod




I think we are getting close to realism. However, Bort must stop falling for whinners.

If you look at this topic, many people are defending the actual sim. Still there are 4~5 whinners (yes, because the arguments you are using are really weak. The guy who's HB fumbled 15 times after his 180 plays still here for example) and they seems to be getting to Bort. Really, listen to reason and stop listening to guys that chose (yes, because in RPG you make choices on how you want your players to be) to have a very fast/agile HB that can't hold the ball.

It was their choice not to invest on carrying, so let them suffer.

The only guy with a point actually is GeneralM, but still, it's only 1 player in 1 game and we don't even know opponents builds, so...


They chose not to invest in a stat that wasn't useful until now. How is that their fault?

And how is this many fumbles "close to realism"? I said it already, Adrian Peterson is "fumble prone" because he fumbled 6 times in 16 games. That's not the rate we're going right now.


Oh so there should be realism on fumbles but yet a RB should still be able to average 300 yards a game.


SHUT UP you're just evading one problem by pointing at another!

RBs in pro leagues DON'T tend to average 300 yards a game. RBs who play gutted teams better damn well get tons of yards. This is about how the PRO LEAGUES are working, and I'm not even in them, I'm just sick of having almost no control over how good or bad my builds are!

Now that people know how good picking Sure Tackler/Power Tackler is, it's going to be the new I Slam unless something is done, so quit whining about RB yards and think about how stupid THIS problem is.


Well no, actually I was pointing out that it's bad logic that something that is detrimental to the offense should have to be made to have realistic stats while something in favor of offense shouldn't have realistic numbers.

 
ShakeNBake
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Grim Truth
Originally posted by ShakeNBake

lmao


u guys should have ur own comedy show


1) You don't have a RB
2) Your teams RB fumbled twice
3) Very likely your team only won because the other teams RB fumbled 3 times (though I think that was on special teams).

You have no reason to be here but trolling...

EDIT: Just bit the bullet, bought new pieces of EQ to boost my RB's carry 9 points... So, we'll see if he's still fast enough to get outside on pitches while not fumbling every 3-5 carries thanks to 30 strength CB's......


My HB fumbled twice and i'm not bitching, huh?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.