User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Endorsements - What I am thinking
Page:
 
MV Thunder
Rubber Duck
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by butler312
I do kind of have a problem with some people's stance on this. They didn't like the original method because it was unrealistic that average players or backup players would get endorsements. Now that Bort has this MVP method planned, I'm hearing the exact same people complaining that it will be weighted too heavily towards the glamour positions. Well, isn't that what you wanted, realism? Since 1975 there have only been 2 MVPs that weren't QBs or RBs, and that was Lawrence Taylor (LB) in 1986 and Mark Moseley (K) in 1982. So which do you guys want, realism or fairness?


I favored the first plan but no one really cared if I did or didnt.I thought it was more well rounded and fair in giving them out.Now with this new system I see it will be more ramped towards certain players and teams. Teams playing gutted or slow build teams will rack up unreal high stats.This will give those players such an unfair advantage over ones that dont.
I saw more fairness in the way they were handed out before but now its all a new game.I think I will just start making glamor players.tbo
Last edited Mar 2, 2009 13:02:18
 
Snakebite99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cigtyme
you do not think this will cause TO style me players arguing and begging for snaps or setting their tactics opposite the coordinator to get better numbers


This was something that bothered me with the whole "fame" thing initially, but the more i think about it, the more i kind of like it. It'll force teams a bit more cognizant of the types of guys theyre bringing to their team. And eventually, guys like that will get the bad name around the league, and no one will wanna sign them. Players with great builds but shitty agents arent worth it in this game imo.
 
Drago
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Malachorn
I pretty much hate endorsements and everything about them, tbh.
I know it's not gonna be a popular idea... but I just wouldn't do them at all, tbh.


this.
 
fullxtension
offline
Link
 
It seems like the performance of the team is weighted too highly in determining endorsements. The other factors are overwhelmed. Guys with no stats to speak of and fame fully 200 points below other players get the endorsement because their team had a better record. While I agree winning sells, its a little bit over the top IMO.
 
butler312
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fullxtension
It seems like the performance of the team is weighted too highly in determining endorsements. The other factors are overwhelmed. Guys with no stats to speak of and fame fully 200 points below other players get the endorsement because their team had a better record. While I agree winning sells, its a little bit over the top IMO.


I still agree. I think that was the only thing that needed fixing from the original method.
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Kk,

I've been hashing out some ideas, and I wanted to note them down for feedback:

1. We come up with a MVP calculation. Base it on the current "top threats" calculations, combined with the fame value. Since you don't gain much, if any, fame from playing gutted teams, it will help to balance out the formula. With a bit of fiddling, I think it could work pretty well, and add a fun element of "MVP race" to each league. This will make glamor players more glamorous as well. We'll run a full season on the test server and tweak our formula until it looks pretty good based on the full season's stats. We do a separate MVP list for Offense, Defense, and ST players, per conference.

2. We give 3 top "corporate" endorsements per conference at the end of the season, which will be taken from the current endorsements that are given for that league level. This is given to the top O/D/ST MVP's in the MVP race. They can take this item with them if they are promoted.

3. We give 1 "national" endorsement per team that is equal to the current endorsements from 2 tiers down, ranked by the same MVP system. Alternatively, we could do a lottery per team based on the MVP calculation = more tickets. We do this at week 8, and base it on the current league results.

4. We give 2 "local" endorsement per team that is equal to the current bottom tier endorsements. So Pro teams get the ones from BBB, which are +2's, and AAA gets +1's from the current pool of pee-wee items. We hand these out at weeks 4/8/12 based on the current season's rankings, with a general lottery system based on current fame values. These items last 4 weeks. I see this as a fun way to keep the items circulating and keep interest up throughout the season.

- Teams cannot get more than 3 endorsements. If they already have 3, they lose out on national or local deals depending on if they got all the MVP awards or not.

- A player cannot get more than 1 endorsement.

- Only 3 endorsements can be active in a game. This heads off MVP players who become FA's at the end of a season joining other teams to stack them.

- If you are traded or cut, you lose your item. (debatable since 3 endorsements active heads off a lot of problems)

- We scrap the "one per position" idea and just give out items that are made for the selected player's position.

- Leagues below AA are not eligible for the national or corporate endorsements, and instead each team gets 3 local endorsements.

- We remove the current items, let people keep their cash, and maybe give some BT's or something for their trouble. We then do our first set of per-team local items in 6 days. This should give some time to adapt the script I have and test it on the test server, though it'd be pretty straight forward.

- If we can come up with an MVP formula everyone likes by week 8, we can do the national ones then. If not, we just wait on that until next season.

Some feedback on the idea would be great; The folks I have pitched it to so far think it's pretty good and helps keep everyone feeling involved.

Note: Please try to keep things civil in this thread and help be constructive with ideas. The mods and I will not hesitate to suspend people for flaming and trolling.


Who is Kk?
 
Dub J
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
Who is Kk?


One of the most irritating things to see, tbh.

 
We_Rule
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Hogfan
Originally posted by awesome

Who is Kk?


One of the most irritating things to see, tbh.



Everybody knows its Kevin kleinsaucer......moron.

 
chilidave
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by kretchfoop

I think it would be a good time to introduce a MNF game for each league and link the game in each league forum...fame would be doubled for performance in that game...every team would get at least one MNF game a season and they would be based on even-leveled matchups. This would further reward teams that are playing in the right league as they would see more MNF games. As well, it would be a great opportunity to build the game and level of interest for players.

I made the thread a while ago about how to work it, but it is ultimately not my call. I am just suggesting that the game add this for more of a business feel to owning a team/players on top of the extra benefits of getting people more involved.


Like a "starred" game for the season?


I like this idea, and possibly the even matched foe could be "evenly matched/most faced" to create solid rivalries.
 
oddibemcd
offline
Link
 
I am thinking that other problems, such as the test server fiasco, should receive more time and attention than endorsements.
 
Notak
offline
Link
 
Honestly, endorsements suck now, kind of a waste imo. I own a team and I am glad we have soem endorsemtns, but adding one to an attribute. I mean yeah it is better than nothing but all this hoopla for not too much. Plus the best players didnt even come close to getting an endorsment, at least not ones that are threats. We got two endorsments and they were for back-up players. I am glad for those players but it is nothing like I thought it was going to be and I have 2 guys with endorsemnts and it is good to have plus 1, but the guys I have them for are nto top threats for their teams either. still confused what is going on I guess, this is a huge let down for me
 
Link
 
Originally posted by oddibemcd
I am thinking that other problems, such as the test server fiasco, should receive more time and attention than endorsements.



It wouldn't be a fiasco if people quit making it out to be a bigger deal than it really is.
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
Originally posted by oddibemcd

I am thinking that other problems, such as the test server fiasco, should receive more time and attention than endorsements.



It wouldn't be a fiasco if people quit making it out to be a bigger deal than it really is.


...isn't that the truth.
 
eholling
offline
Link
 
Posted in another suggestion thread
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2226376

This would take a complete re-write but it would be a more fair and fun way to handle endorsements.

Rather than distribute them randomly per team, have them offered periodically to all players beyond a certain fame level, as if your agent were trying to set up endorsement deals for you. The interface could/would function very much the same way that equipment shopping does now. The difference is that each endorsement comes with additional daily salary and a piece of equipment that must be worn to collect that salary. Remove the equipment and equipment is lost and you stop receiving the extra cash.

The endorsement you're offered is based on your league, your level and your fame. Additionally, the equipment that goes with the endorsement may actually be detrimental to your performance. For example, a Pro level linebacker is offered 100k a season to endorse a product that gives a -2 Vision. Balance would need to be looked at of course but you get the idea. If you want that 2500k a day, you have to wear item. Stop wearing it and it goes away and you have to wait for the next endorsement deal.

Additional Option:
Rather than have an endorsement equipment slot, you could make it take up an actual equipment slot. So, you get an offer for 150k to wear a particular brand of gloves that gives you +2 to speed and a +1 Superior Vision. Unfortunately, you already have a +7 speed set of gloves. You can't upgrade the endorsement equipment. If you want the cash, you have to deal with the equipment.

This could help pay for standard equipment upgrades which will become increasingly difficult to afford for all teams as we approach the level 56 mark in the higher leagues next season. This also helps player build diversity as you may use endorsement equipment to help pay for upgrades to superior equipment in another slot.

This is just a thought but it really could add another level to the game at the player/agent level if it's done right.
 
Blisser
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yukon Don
Originally posted by driftinggrifter

Originally posted by oddibemcd


I am thinking that other problems, such as the test server fiasco, should receive more time and attention than endorsements.



It wouldn't be a fiasco if people quit making it out to be a bigger deal than it really is.


...isn't that the truth.


still a fiasco because Bort caved into the people making a big deal out of it...
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.