User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Jason Elliott
I'll post this again and this should be the way it should be.

Vision should ne needed for all positions, it is not just the ability to see the field which everyone in here keeps saying. if you got 8 vision he should be getting a ton of penalties, and getting juked by play action fakes, taking bad lanes to the QB, missing tackles etc.


i dont think you realise that we arent saying low vision means that we have good lanes to QB, getting juked missing tackles. but what we are saying is that low vision doesnt mean counting to 10 before rushing the passer.
 
Jason Elliott
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Voltron
Originally posted by Jason Elliott

Originally posted by vrshah


And bad teams w/o strategy or good builds are getting a free pass.

Why? Because there are so many of them that their voices are louder even though they are "wronger"


Having a DE with low vision = a bad build, but it's cool if they get a free pass?


So it's ok to make them have to have Tackling, strength, agility, speed, vision at soft cap with stamina pushing it as well?


A receiver has to have speed, agility, confidence, stamina, catching, vision, and carrying and for some blocking. Qb's have to have strength, vision, throwing, stamina, confidence. again, why are DE's so special.
 
Jason Elliott
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mutleyddmc
Originally posted by Jason Elliott

I'll post this again and this should be the way it should be.

Vision should ne needed for all positions, it is not just the ability to see the field which everyone in here keeps saying. if you got 8 vision he should be getting a ton of penalties, and getting juked by play action fakes, taking bad lanes to the QB, missing tackles etc.


i dont think you realise that we arent saying low vision means that we have good lanes to QB, getting juked missing tackles. but what we are saying is that low vision doesnt mean counting to 10 before rushing the passer.


I agree with that totally, but at the same time you should still upgrade your vision for the above reasons i stated.
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
I don't understand the strawman you are attacking, Jason. The issue, is that DEs aren't fine with 30 vision. In fact, I have one DE with over 50 vision. Prior to today's game, he was getting a few sacks a game, and a decent amount of hurries. Today he got 0 sacks and 1 hurry, b/c it took him several ticks to move off of the line. I'm guessing he'd need over 70 vision to be able to move at the snap, and that's ridiculous.


Amen. But we all knew this was coming.

 
Voltron
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jason Elliott
Originally posted by Voltron

Originally posted by Jason Elliott


Originally posted by vrshah



And bad teams w/o strategy or good builds are getting a free pass.

Why? Because there are so many of them that their voices are louder even though they are "wronger"


Having a DE with low vision = a bad build, but it's cool if they get a free pass?


So it's ok to make them have to have Tackling, strength, agility, speed, vision at soft cap with stamina pushing it as well?


A receiver has to have speed, agility, confidence, stamina, catching, vision, and carrying and for some blocking. Qb's have to have strength, vision, throwing, stamina, confidence. again, why are DE's so special.


Show me a WR with soft capped confidence, stamina, vision and carrying.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Jason Elliott
Originally posted by mutleyddmc

Originally posted by Jason Elliott


I'll post this again and this should be the way it should be.

Vision should ne needed for all positions, it is not just the ability to see the field which everyone in here keeps saying. if you got 8 vision he should be getting a ton of penalties, and getting juked by play action fakes, taking bad lanes to the QB, missing tackles etc.


i dont think you realise that we arent saying low vision means that we have good lanes to QB, getting juked missing tackles. but what we are saying is that low vision doesnt mean counting to 10 before rushing the passer.



I agree with that totally, but at the same time you should still upgrade your vision for the above reasons i stated.


My De's have sufficent vision anyway so im not worried about that. i mworried that 30-40 vision will be effected
 
xylo
offline
Link
 
"Amen. But we all knew this was coming"
I thought he'd move the emphasis onto Strength not Vision !
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Nevermind. Mis-read Jason's post.
Last edited Nov 18, 2008 12:51:48
 
Jason Elliott
offline
Link
 
I am working on getting my receiver's stats up to soft cap to be well rounded, but I never said they have to be soft capped, they have to have all of those attributes though.
 
Jason Elliott
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
Jason,

WRs do not need to have each of speed, vision, carrying, agility, stamina, catching and confidence soft capped in order to catch the ball. It looks like DEs will need all of what Voltron said in order to do their jobs. Frankly, there's a similar problem with CBs, as they need speed, agility, vision all to the 3rd cap, and a good amount of jumping, tackling, stamina and confidence (not to mention SAs) and they will still get beat 60% of the time when in close coverage.


For a balanced DE yes, not just for a pure pass rushing DE no.
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
DEs with soft capped tackling, strength and vision... aren't the DEs that are the problem TBPH. It's the DE's that don't bother with tackling, strength and vision that are the problem. Those speed/agility DEs are blowing right past OTs who have 50+ agility, 30+ speed, soft capped vision and 2nd capped blocking/strength. This is the problem that people are complaining about, pretty much. A balanced build OT gets embarrassed by a guy who has ignored everything but speed, agility and some SAs.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Jason, the point here is that soft-capped vision for a DE still doesn't get him off the line without waiting a fairly long time. Vision should be no better than the 5th most important attribute for a DE (behind strength, speed, agility, tackling, and probably also behind stamina). Is there any other position that can't do it's fundamental job without having it's 5th most important attribute well over the soft cap (besides, possibly, CBs, but that's another, somewhat significant problem with this game that deserves its own thread).
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
Jason, the point here is that soft-capped vision for a DE still doesn't get him off the line without waiting a fairly long time. Vision should be no better than the 5th most important attribute for a DE (behind strength, speed, agility, tackling, and probably also behind stamina). Is there any other position that can't do it's fundamental job without having it's 5th most important attribute well over the soft cap (besides, possibly, CBs, but that's another, somewhat significant problem with this game that deserves its own thread).


OTs and speed
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Warlock,

Once again, we're in agreement about what the problem was. I just think that the way to have fixed this was to punish low strength realistically (with morale/stamina hits), and not make vision an oddly unrealistic attribute (low vision should have an evasive DE run into the OT, not stand still. . . unfortunately, low vision now seems to describe vision at 50).
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mutleyddmc
Originally posted by Jason Elliott

Originally posted by mutleyddmc


Originally posted by Jason Elliott



I'll post this again and this should be the way it should be.

Vision should ne needed for all positions, it is not just the ability to see the field which everyone in here keeps saying. if you got 8 vision he should be getting a ton of penalties, and getting juked by play action fakes, taking bad lanes to the QB, missing tackles etc.


i dont think you realise that we arent saying low vision means that we have good lanes to QB, getting juked missing tackles. but what we are saying is that low vision doesnt mean counting to 10 before rushing the passer.



I agree with that totally, but at the same time you should still upgrade your vision for the above reasons i stated.


My De's have sufficent vision anyway so im not worried about that. i mworried that 30-40 vision will be effected


One of my DEs who played today has 40 vision, 10 first step and a ton of speed and agility and he got NO jumps off the line. In fact, he sat there and waited for a second or 2 before even rushing, how stupid is that?
Last edited Nov 18, 2008 13:00:45
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.