User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > GLB Notes > CPL > Interesting topic of the Week: Evolutionism versus Creationism
Page:
 
Serenity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Azure Dreams

No. Maybe possibly having a different definition of gender rolls than SI does is far worse than growing up in a home where you are hit and don't get a good education.

comparing to the worst case doesn't make it right. Are you saying it isn't possible to get hit by 2 fathers?


So because it's possible for that to happen no gay couples should be allowed to raise kids?
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
And even if the adoption thing wasn't the case... so what if 2 men can hit people? You're just showing equality. If there was a much higher chance of a gay couple beating their child, then there would be grounds for it. But there isn't. So why should the gay couple who would provde exquisitely and love their child and keep him or her safe be prevented from doing so when the straight couple who puts their daughter on the street at 14 years old to make money isn't?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Serenity
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Originally posted by Serenity


Originally posted by SteelersInsider



I feel a family structure of 1 man and 1 woman is ideal to raise children as it gives children of both sexes a role model as to how their gender should behave. I feel a boy should learn to act like a man and a girl should learn to act like a woman.

You feel gender isn't important.

I think that sums it up. Sorry, that is more than 2 sentences, but still concise.


I'd think it would be much healthier for someone to grow up with 2 dads or 2 moms than in a home where the dad beats/abuses the mom...


no one has ever argued that point. But society has to have an ideal to shoot for.

If you say something else is just as good as 1 mother and 1 father, then you are breaking down that structure.

All things being equal, nothing is as good as 1 mother and 1 father. Most of us were raised in that environment, but we seem to be telling the next generation that 1 mother and no father is ok, 1 father and 0 mother is ok, 2 fathers and 0 mothers is ok. They really aren't. Maybe on an individual case basis, but we aren't talking about case by case here. We are talking about opening this thing up to EVERYONE.



And why is it not ok?


because it is hurting the hundreds of kids who now are not going to be raised by 2 parents.


(I'm not talking about adoption here on an individual basis. I'm talking about legalizing gay marriage and what it would do to the 1 man-1 woman marriage after 15-20 years - in my opinion at least).

 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Anyway, we're off the original topic (which I won by the way) and the second topic (which I won by the way... but given that it was about me, that isn't surprising), so I'm going to go.
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Serenity

Originally posted by SteelersInsider


Originally posted by Serenity



Originally posted by SteelersInsider




I feel a family structure of 1 man and 1 woman is ideal to raise children as it gives children of both sexes a role model as to how their gender should behave. I feel a boy should learn to act like a man and a girl should learn to act like a woman.

You feel gender isn't important.

I think that sums it up. Sorry, that is more than 2 sentences, but still concise.


I'd think it would be much healthier for someone to grow up with 2 dads or 2 moms than in a home where the dad beats/abuses the mom...


no one has ever argued that point. But society has to have an ideal to shoot for.

If you say something else is just as good as 1 mother and 1 father, then you are breaking down that structure.

All things being equal, nothing is as good as 1 mother and 1 father. Most of us were raised in that environment, but we seem to be telling the next generation that 1 mother and no father is ok, 1 father and 0 mother is ok, 2 fathers and 0 mothers is ok. They really aren't. Maybe on an individual case basis, but we aren't talking about case by case here. We are talking about opening this thing up to EVERYONE.



And why is it not ok?


because it is hurting the hundreds of kids who now are not going to be raised by 2 parents.


(I'm not talking about adoption here on an individual basis. I'm talking about legalizing gay marriage and what it would do to the 1 man-1 woman marriage after 15-20 years - in my opinion at least).



And there's the reason that this is all invalid horseshit when it comes to legality.


Also, the reason that you probably shouldn't get married. If you have so little confidence in your marriage that you think 2 guys getting married somewhere 100 miles away is going to ruin it, you suck at being maried.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Serenity
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Originally posted by Azure Dreams


No. Maybe possibly having a different definition of gender rolls than SI does is far worse than growing up in a home where you are hit and don't get a good education.

comparing to the worst case doesn't make it right. Are you saying it isn't possible to get hit by 2 fathers?


So because it's possible for that to happen no gay couples should be allowed to raise kids?


I'm not even talking about adoption.

On a case by case basis, I think being raised by a single person or a brother and a sister or 2 gay men might be a preferable solution to being beat if there are no other solutions. Those are private events that do not shake the fabric of a society. I'm sure it is going on now and no one really cares (gay adoption). Gay adoptions certainly aren't influencing the next generation of kids in their sexual identity. The only people who are going to be affected by gay adoptions are those kids being adopted. And there are relatively a very small number of kids who have been adopted by gay couples from what I understand.
 
Serenity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Serenity

Originally posted by SteelersInsider


Originally posted by Serenity



Originally posted by SteelersInsider




I feel a family structure of 1 man and 1 woman is ideal to raise children as it gives children of both sexes a role model as to how their gender should behave. I feel a boy should learn to act like a man and a girl should learn to act like a woman.

You feel gender isn't important.

I think that sums it up. Sorry, that is more than 2 sentences, but still concise.


I'd think it would be much healthier for someone to grow up with 2 dads or 2 moms than in a home where the dad beats/abuses the mom...


no one has ever argued that point. But society has to have an ideal to shoot for.

If you say something else is just as good as 1 mother and 1 father, then you are breaking down that structure.

All things being equal, nothing is as good as 1 mother and 1 father. Most of us were raised in that environment, but we seem to be telling the next generation that 1 mother and no father is ok, 1 father and 0 mother is ok, 2 fathers and 0 mothers is ok. They really aren't. Maybe on an individual case basis, but we aren't talking about case by case here. We are talking about opening this thing up to EVERYONE.



And why is it not ok?


because it is hurting the hundreds of kids who now are not going to be raised by 2 parents.


(I'm not talking about adoption here on an individual basis. I'm talking about legalizing gay marriage and what it would do to the 1 man-1 woman marriage after 15-20 years - in my opinion at least).



and how is it hurting them?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Azure Dreams

Also, the reason that you probably shouldn't get married. If you have so little confidence in your marriage that you think 2 guys getting married somewhere 100 miles away is going to ruin it, you suck at being maried.


lol. I talk to you, but you don't listen.

I said I'm over 21. It isn't going to affect me. It will affect my KIDS when I have them. It will affect marriages for the next 100 years. Allowing gay marriages is a huge event. I don't think you realize how revolutionary of an idea that is. You certainly haven't thought through all the possible ramifications from it.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Serenity


and how is it hurting them?


you don't think that it is helpful for a girl to have a female role model around and for a boy to have a male role model around?
 
Serenity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Serenity



and how is it hurting them?


you don't think that it is helpful for a girl to have a female role model around and for a boy to have a male role model around?


you know the parents don't have to be the only role models a child has
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Azure Dreams
And even if the adoption thing wasn't the case... so what if 2 men can hit people? You're just showing equality. If there was a much higher chance of a gay couple beating their child, then there would be grounds for it. But there isn't. So why should the gay couple who would provde exquisitely and love their child and keep him or her safe be prevented from doing so when the straight couple who puts their daughter on the street at 14 years old to make money isn't?


adoption is pretty rare and not worth discussing in depth. why did you shift the focus to adoption?

we were talking about gay marriage.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Serenity
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Originally posted by Serenity




and how is it hurting them?


you don't think that it is helpful for a girl to have a female role model around and for a boy to have a male role model around?


you know the parents don't have to be the only role models a child has


true, but it helps if the role models are there on a daily basis.

we are talking about ideal situations here too.

just because you can't hit the target every time doesn't mean that you shouldn't aim for a bulls-eye every time.
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 04:17:44
 
Serenity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Serenity

Originally posted by SteelersInsider


Originally posted by Serenity





and how is it hurting them?


you don't think that it is helpful for a girl to have a female role model around and for a boy to have a male role model around?


you know the parents don't have to be the only role models a child has


true, but it helps if the role models are there on a daily basis.

we are talking about ideal situations here too.

just because you can't hit the target every time doesn't mean that you shouldn't aim for a bulls-eye every time.


we are?
Because nothing in this world will ever be ideal so why are you trying to argue with that standard.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Serenity


Because nothing in this world will ever be ideal so why are you trying to argue with that standard.


I think marriage just the way it is has worked for many years in many cultures. Changing it can cause serious unforeseen problems.

I think you only have to look to single parent households to see that children who grow up in that environment have it much rougher in life. Part of that very well could be that they lack a male (or female) role model as a parent. Having 2 moms is never going to teach you how to be a man in the same way.
 
X
offline
Link
 
Again...this topic takes off when I am not around.

Ok, first, it seems that people in this argument are getting attacked more on the basis of their belief system than their actual points so to clarify before I get called a "Christian-hater" or something else...

Personally, I am a "non-theist", if that wasn't already obvious. I am not a non-theist because I hate religion or because it was shoved down my throat. I came to non-theism due to a gradual critical analysis of religious doctrine and realized that, at least for me, a belief in a supreme being just didn't make any sense.

I come from a Christian background. My family is Baptist even to the point of having a Baptist minister for a close relative. My wife is Catholic. She comes from a devout Italian-American Catholic family.

I don't hate religion in general. Unlike some other non-theists I don't believe that religion is the root of much of the world's evil. I think religion is a human-construct and like other human-constructs it is flawed and it reflects our flaws. Yes, many terrible things have been done in the name of "religion" but that is because humans are apt to do terrible things. I believe that if there was no religion people would find other reasons to do terrible things because, in general, we just suck.

Generally, I have no problem with religion save for one point and that is when it starts to encroach on places it shouldn't belong, specifically in the way our government operates.

I call myself a "non-theist" and more specifically an "atheist" because it best reflects my philosophical beliefs, but really I am just a Secularist. I don't think that religion has any place in government. This is generally why I feel so strongly about the gay marriage issue because the only reason that there isn't nation-wide legalized gay marriage in the US is on the basis of religious rhetoric and not on any legal or rational ground.

So there. I was going actually respond to some of the posts on the last few pages after clarifying my stance but after typing out that drivel I am now too sleepy. Maybe after lunch.
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 08:26:58
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.