User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > NERF THE FUMBLES NOW!!!
Page:
 
Grim Truth
offline
Link
 
What's funny is that all the time we heard "just wait until LB's build more strength and tackling and less speed and agility and your Speed/Elusive RB's will be dominant", now they start doing it and instead of the Speed/Elusive RB's being successful they just fumble more, even when CB's hit them...

The defenses changed to stop powerbacks and they found a way to stop everybody.
 
raidersrock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by raidersrock

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by raidersrock



Your solution to that was nerf QBs.


Wrong, that is part of what we're working on. The other part is not ready yet.

Once again, I love you too.


QBs take longer to find a quick target when pressure is coming. Pretty much the same.

Can't wait to see this new idea....


The other portion is blockers being stunned by shed blocks so they can't just reengage all the time. Works just a little too well right now. There's a thread by hazy in the test section if you're interested.


I saw,

But it kinda goes back to the whole conistency thing. I dont understand all these changes that you have to adapt your players to the sim and you can't build players how they should be and get success.
Last edited Apr 26, 2009 18:28:27
 
Weather
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks
WHINE WHINE WHINE WHINE WHINE WHINE


 
Zadith
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks
Originally posted by Zadith

Originally posted by Phantom_Opera


Sounds like Defenses are getting nerfed again. We fixed our builds, but we get nerfed.


sadly it looks like it..


Defense isn't getting nerfed. Bort's just going to fix the fumbling problem.


And by doing so we lose one of the few advantages we have. We have spent the last 2 seasons being beaten to death by power backs. Can you just give us at least half a season with a good amount of FFs? lol
 
CapnEnnui
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
Originally posted by Zadith



That happened to the defense when they went all out on agility/speed to keep up with offenses before the changes to tackling and then they were up the creek without a paddle until they pumped strength and tackling and now elusive HBs are feeling the same problems...



Pretty much, this.

Throw in, though, that an awful lot of defenders went from +15% Speed/Agility to +15 Power Tackler.


And that it's easier to put yourself on power tackling since broken tackles don't work as well.

So how is it whining when things suddenly change on well-established builds?
 
Octowned
offline
Link
 
I think possibly there was an indirect thing here with power tackler. It happened to combine with the maturity of a lot of players who two seasons ago started building toward making FFum machines.

I, for one, noticed Bort's posts in the "how much tackling should a defensive player have to stop a 100+ strength powerback" thread, which hinted VERY VERY STRONGLY that if only ppl took tackling/strength from 30 to 60, they'd be stopping powerbacks and even forcing fumbles. *gasp* other people noticed too, and now it is working.

Now, take it one step further. Bort said you can't get away with a TACKLER having no TACKLING. So why can a HB have no carrying?!?

This was all blatantly obvious to become a part of the meta game and reach maturity right around now, and I have multiple agents in my network who confirm these results.

---

Now, with that out of the way, I do think defenses did get too much of an unintended boost this offseason. Powerbacks weren't nerfed, but rather defense's have the options which now stack along with the current maturing builds to make them very powerful.

But before anybody complains, you need to make a few checks on your builds...
60+ carrying?
5+ cover up?

If you don't have these, shame on you. Your main purpose is to carry the ball and hold on to it. If defenses weren't allowed to get away with not having tackling, why can you not have carrying and cover up?

---

If players do have 60 carrying, cover up, etc., and are still fumbling like crazy to mediocre builds, then we have a problem. It sounds like this new "sliding bar" could fix the issues here though. Reward the strong, carrying, cover up, fall for yards guys, and allow the fast, agile, juking, weak guys to duck and hold on to the ball.

I ask you Bort to really make sure there is a problem before tweaking. People are building too one-dimensionally and expecting too many results from their players. Not everybody can be a star.

---

Also, lol @ post who said elusivebacks are worthless. Use them right. You really expect them to do something on a slam or slow developing off tackle play to the right, when the defense has a bunch of beasts waiting at the line for them? Come on, they aren't super heros. Get them to the outside where speed and agility actually matters, and stop running straight into the FFum machines with your 20 strength / 20 carrying backs and calling them worthless
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CapnEnnui


It's not defender's fault any more than it's running back's fault. It's the fault of the sim constantly changing what a good build is and what a good build isn't. But once people do what works, it changes for the worse. And it sucks for everyone. This isn't offense against defense, this is players against sim changes.


A LOT of perceived changes are not sim changes; they are movement in the meta-game.

The game is in flux. Everyone should have known this from the get-go.

I don't want 14 fumbles in a game, either, but I don't think just changing mechanics is necessarily the right answer. A lot of giant stats in this game come about as a direct result of there being no adjustments during a game. A mismatch gets inflated badly, especially ones that involve the same interaction over and over (like a DE vs. OT, or a returner getting tackled by a dedicated cover guy.)

Much of this should be fought with some kind of "reactiveness" in the sim (with player direction).
 
headsigh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by weather
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks

WHINE WHINE WHINE WHINE WHINE WHINE




oh u
 
Zadith
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CapnEnnui
Originally posted by kurieg

Originally posted by Zadith




That happened to the defense when they went all out on agility/speed to keep up with offenses before the changes to tackling and then they were up the creek without a paddle until they pumped strength and tackling and now elusive HBs are feeling the same problems...



Pretty much, this.

Throw in, though, that an awful lot of defenders went from +15% Speed/Agility to +15 Power Tackler.


And that it's easier to put yourself on power tackling since broken tackles don't work as well.

So how is it whining when things suddenly change on well-established builds?


My guys on power tackling miss a few tackles a game from what I have seen. Were you also on the LBs side when the power backs were destroying groups of defenders at the same time? Just trying to make a point, no matter what Bort does he is going to over power one group and screw the other...just the nature of the game...
 
JcWildcat
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Octowned
I think possibly there was an indirect thing here with power tackler. It happened to combine with the maturity of a lot of players who two seasons ago started building toward making FFum machines.

I, for one, noticed Bort's posts in the "how much tackling should a defensive player have to stop a 100+ strength powerback" thread, which hinted VERY VERY STRONGLY that if only ppl took tackling/strength from 30 to 60, they'd be stopping powerbacks and even forcing fumbles. *gasp* other people noticed too, and now it is working.

Now, take it one step further. Bort said you can't get away with a TACKLER having no TACKLING. So why can a HB have no carrying?!?

This was all blatantly obvious to become a part of the meta game and reach maturity right around now, and I have multiple agents in my network who confirm these results.

---

Now, with that out of the way, I do think defenses did get too much of an unintended boost this offseason. Powerbacks weren't nerfed, but rather defense's have the options which now stack along with the current maturing builds to make them very powerful.

But before anybody complains, you need to make a few checks on your builds...
60+ carrying?
5+ cover up?

If you don't have these, shame on you. Your main purpose is to carry the ball and hold on to it. If defenses weren't allowed to get away with not having tackling, why can you not have carrying and cover up?

---

If players do have 60 carrying, cover up, etc., and are still fumbling like crazy to mediocre builds, then we have a problem. It sounds like this new "sliding bar" could fix the issues here though. Reward the strong, carrying, cover up, fall for yards guys, and allow the fast, agile, juking, weak guys to duck and hold on to the ball.

I ask you Bort to really make sure there is a problem before tweaking. People are building too one-dimensionally and expecting too many results from their players. Not everybody can be a star.

---

Also, lol @ post who said elusivebacks are worthless. Use them right. You really expect them to do something on a slam or slow developing off tackle play to the right, when the defense has a bunch of beasts waiting at the line for them? Come on, they aren't super heros. Get them to the outside where speed and agility actually matters, and stop running straight into the FFum machines with your 20 strength / 20 carrying backs and calling them worthless


Great post. Couldn't say it any better myself.
 
bhall43
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Grim Truth
What's funny is that all the time we heard "just wait until LB's build more strength and tackling and less speed and agility and your Speed/Elusive RB's will be dominant", now they start doing it and instead of the Speed/Elusive RB's being successful they just fumble more, even when CB's hit them...

The defenses changed to stop powerbacks and they found a way to stop everybody.


lol...defenses didnt change anything except their VA choice. Nice try tho.
 
CapnEnnui
offline
Link
 
This didn't slowly build to a head, Octowned. It happened right when the season changed, almost immediately, because of broken tackle changes and VA changes. 60 carrying and 5+ cover up would've been excessive last season for an elusive back so saying it's shameful not to have it now is just wrong.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zadith
My guys on power tackling miss a few tackles a game from what I have seen. Were you also on the LBs side when the power backs were destroying groups of defenders at the same time? Just trying to make a point, no matter what Bort does he is going to over power one group and screw the other...just the nature of the game...


Neither of your higher level defensive players missed a tackle and they both forced a fumble. By the way, I was on the LBs side when power backs were destroying groups of defenders at the same time.
 
ssupermans
offline
Link
 
I have a buddy on here that has built 4 or 5 HB only one of which has been a power built mainly cause he didnt like the way he acted in a game none of which over the past few games have had any problems fumbling and are still putting up great stats, like I said all but one are elusive we are talking like 30-50 strength depending on which guy your looking at and 50-55 carrying one of them is strictly a KR/PR and like I said no problems.
 
trentw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by trentw
We haven't even talked about kick offs where you had damn well better have a Powerback or a Fullback return now, because WR's and Cb's have no cover up option, and imo returns is where fumbles are out of control. That said once again you have thousands of ST'ers who have pumped power tackling who will expect a reset if fumbling is nerfed.


I don't mind quoting myself, especially when I feel it needs to be said again.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.