User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Endorsements - What I am thinking
Page:
 
slashxtreme
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
The new system has it's weaknesses, for example certain positions are now never going to be able to get the MVP award. The TE and FB for example will NEVER compete for the MVP award or be in t he top 3 of the MVP award. Basically it's goin to make the offensive skill positions God again, no bother.. It happens. No one should make O-Line guys and definitely not TE's and FB's that's just a waste of points

But all in all it's a good system, one that people obviously put a lot of thought into.
Last edited Feb 28, 2009 11:35:43
 
Link
 
Any system implemented will have it's flaws....there is no perfect system nor will there ever be....Skill positions are more recognized and get more of the endorsements in real life so it would be more realistic
 
Blisser
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lucky_eagle_13
Any system implemented will have it's flaws....

That didn't stop the children from whining before, until they got their way, the new system is just as flawed, if not more restrictive in certain situations.
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
This is headache galore, but it is nice to see some reward for being the "best."
 
Maddencoach
offline
Link
 
Why cant you have a little bit of both award. Some endorsement for fame, some for stats and some random
 
cowtesticles2001
udder pressure
offline
Link
 
post 666....endorsements were a good idea before serious thought was put into them and the first round failed....

with them not being as important or special as before....I'm not excited to see them...
 
Blisser
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cowtesticles2001
post 666....endorsements were a good idea before serious thought was put into them and the first round failed....

with them not being as important or special as before....I'm not excited to see them...


Exactly! The nice ones like were given out first time around, are going to be even more exclusive, the rest<anything below MVP> are going to be junk.

Ways to approach it
1.) Stick to your guns and leave it the way it was, with tweaks in the future. This isn't a Beta anymore after all...
2.) Put this even lamer system into effect that appeases all the people who whined about the first one, fixes very little and causes new issues.
3.) Scrap it all together and worry about other things GLB related.

Prior to dumping the first one, before it even went into effect, this should have been put to a Poll. I think the voice of a few unfairly spoke for the community as a whole. Very disappointed in how this transpired.
 
butler312
offline
Link
 
The more I look at it and think about it the more I hate this new system and like the old system better. The only thing that really needed fixing was adding a cap to the number of players per team that can be awarded with the equipment. With this new system the only equipment that is really significant is the MVP endorsement. So you have to put up the best stats at a position the formula favors. I don't like that.
 
Fat Colin
offline
Link
 
for lineman they need another factor for getting their chances higher than just fame and pancakes
 
aceinthehouse
offline
Link
 
modified borts announement for endorsements


I have my suggestion buried in the 5000 pages of Endorsement suggestion page and it pisses me off!

I don't know if it sucks or if it just got missed...? So would you members try to actually read my suggestion and "NEW" implementation compared to Bort's and compare who 's you like the most please?

All I did was use Bort's original "Announcement" idea with respect,and just modify it...so it would be fair to ALL GLB members.

I believe Fame should be the MAJOR focus on endorsements,since that seems to be in real life,who gets the big sponsorships regardless of player position...The new idea has fame as PART of who will recieve endorsements along with stats and who knows what other formula involved,but not a priority IMO.


I have a new idea...

Since Endorsements should co-inside with Fame,this is what I think Bort could do...to keep things fair for everyone.

Keep the same idea that Bort has on "Corporate Endorsement,"National Endorsement" and "Local Endorsement",but these will be the 3 types of an endorsement a player can get depending on his FAME.

#1)Each Team gets 1 of each for 3 players on their team (being a Corporate,National and Local Endorsements)No more and No less

#2)A "Corporate Endorsement" goes into a Lottery for whatever Player on that Particular team that has a Fame of 2000-or more.It is the best set of equipment and skills a person can get and it does not matter what league you are in.If there is only 1 person with 2000-or more than he will continue to have that endorsement until he is cut,traded.If 2 or more players on that team have 2000-or more in fame, than a Lottery will decide who gets the "Corporate Endorsement" for that team after each season.If Zero Players on that team have 2000-or more Fame,than none will recieve a Corporate Endorsement.But only 1 person can get this endorsement per team,if that player meets the 2000 Fame or more requirement.

#3)A "National Endorsement" is the next level of Endorsements.Each team will have 1 player get this endorsement if they have a FAME of 1000-1999 in Fame.Again,if they have more than 1 player with this fame qualifications,than there will be a lottery for those players on that team to decide who gets it.If Zero have the required fame than none will recieve this endorsement.If a player is cut or traded,than he will lose his endorsement.The skills here are very good,but not quite as good as a Corporate endorsement.

#4)Then you have the "Local Endorsement".Only 1 player can get this endorsement per team as well and any player on that team qualifies for this endorsement for as long his fame is 0-999 or below 999 in Fame.All Players meeting this criteria will have a lottery for that team to decide who gets the "Local" endorsement.

#5)Either way....each team will have the chance of having a player with a Corporate,National and Local endorsement(3 players) if that team has a player who qualifies in that certain Criteria.There will be a Lottery after each season as the Player carries his endorsement for 1 full season.A player can also get Lucky and get it the next season(and after) if either he draws the lottery again,or is the only player on the team that fits the required criteria in FAME.

#6)Then we come to the MVP Endorsements which is NEW...If a Player that currently carries any of the 3 possible Endorsements through the season and Wins a Gold,Silver or Bronze personal award for his personal trophy case.There are no limits and there are no Other requirements for this award.However,you Must have 1-3 current endorsements(corporate,national or local) to qualify for this award.This is the absolute very best endorsement,but VERY hard to get.This MVP endorsement offers the best skill sets of any of the other 3 endorsements.

#7)If you have won an MVP endorsement,which is given out at the end of every season...(when personal trophies are distributed) then you enter that next season with the MVP Award and Endorsement.You will not qualify for the other 3 endorsements,since you carry an MVP endorsement....but you can maintain the MVP endorsement(the best),if you can maintain a gold, Silver or Bronze personal award for that next following season and retain it!

#8)...and Yes,A team can have a player with a MVP award and the 3 other endorsement players as well (corporate,national and Local) since the MVP endorsement is a separate entity/endorsement and won after a player had previously had one of the 3 other endorsements.As there are limits to the 3 major endorsements per team(1 player each)...there is no limit to MVP's per team,as they are separate.

simplified
-------------------------------------------------------
Each Team="Corporate endorsement"
1)1 player with 2000 in fame or higher
2)2 or more players have lottery to decide who gets it
3)No 2000 in fame player on team/NO ENDORSEMENT
4)Player with 2000 fame keeps endorsement on team until Cut,traded,or others on team have 2000 in fame for lottery system
5)The best skillset of endorsements and equipment(exception of MVP endorsement)

Each Team=National endorsement
1)1 player with 1000-1999 in Fame
2)2 or more players have Lottery to decide who gets it
3)No player with 1000-1999 in fame/NO ENDORSEMENT
4)Player with 2000 fame keeps endorsement on team until Cut,traded,or others on team have 1000-1999 in fame for lottery system
5)The 2nd best best skillset of endorsements (behind Corporate and of course the Great MVP Endorsement)

Each Team=Local Endorsements
1)1 Player 0-999 in Fame
2)2 or more players have Lottery to decide who gets it
3)Every team gets just 1 Local Endorsement
4)Player with 0-999 fame keeps endorsement on team until Cut or traded and Lottery is used every season to decide who gets the Local endorsement, since everyone would qualify and be within the Fame requirement.
5)The 3rd and last in skillsets and equipment

MVP Award and Endorsement
--------------------------------------------------------
1)Can only recieve this award if carrying the 3 possible endorsements of Corporate,National or Local.
2)To achieve the MVP award and endorsement,player must recieve a Gold,Silver or Bronze Personal award, while holding one of the 3 Endorsements(corporate,National or Local)
3)Player maintains this award,as long as he continues to achieve the Gold,Silver or bronze personal awards each season.(top 3 in those stats)
4)Cannot carry the other 3 Endorsements(Corporate,National and Local),while carrying the MVP endorsement
5)While each team can only carry 1 endorsement each of the Corporate,National and Local....There is no limit to how many MVP's a team can carry,since it is a separate entity and not part of the other 3 endorsements.MVP endorsement is NOT a Lottery system and is earned while carrying 1/3 endorsements and achieving top 3 in stats.


 
butler312
offline
Link
 
I do kind of have a problem with some people's stance on this. They didn't like the original method because it was unrealistic that average players or backup players would get endorsements. Now that Bort has this MVP method planned, I'm hearing the exact same people complaining that it will be weighted too heavily towards the glamour positions. Well, isn't that what you wanted, realism? Since 1975 there have only been 2 MVPs that weren't QBs or RBs, and that was Lawrence Taylor (LB) in 1986 and Mark Moseley (K) in 1982. So which do you guys want, realism or fairness?
 
Blisser
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by butler312
I do kind of have a problem with some people's stance on this. They didn't like the original method because it was unrealistic that average players or backup players would get endorsements. Now that Bort has this MVP method planned, I'm hearing the exact same people complaining that it will be weighted too heavily towards the glamour positions. Well, isn't that what you wanted, realism? Since 1975 there have only been 2 MVPs that weren't QBs or RBs, and that was Lawrence Taylor (LB) in 1986 and Mark Moseley (K) in 1982. So which do you guys want, realism or fairness?


The new system doesn't fix either.
 
drake262
loldrake
offline
Link
 
673
 
NVJumper
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by slashxtreme
The new system has it's weaknesses, for example certain positions are now never going to be able to get the MVP award. The TE and FB for example will NEVER compete for the MVP award or be in t he top 3 of the MVP award. Basically it's goin to make the offensive skill positions God again, no bother.. It happens. No one should make O-Line guys and definitely not TE's and FB's that's just a waste of points

But all in all it's a good system, one that people obviously put a lot of thought into.


When is the last time you saw a FB or TE get an MVP award in real life?

Anyway, people will still make them. I probably will make a TE (one of the few positions I've never made before) soon, and the OL is my favorite position to make, but I am liking my FS right now, too.

Not everyone cares about the glitz and glamour, lol
 
Mowie Rad
offline
Link
 
As much as I question the new system, and how it favors the stat mongers who may be 0-16 but at least their one guy has great stats...I would argue about the statement in regards to TE's or FB's, it really depends on the team and how they use those positions. We personally tend to pass to the TE as much as anyone normally, and if you used a FB for goal line runs, then they could have good numbers. My one thought is that the team should be taken into account over the individual, ie team rushing totals decide the endorsement, then the individual selected from the team members eligible, would keep the playing field even for teams who spread the plays around.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.