Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by Maddoc
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by Maddoc
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by Maddoc
Bad analogies should be a bannable offense imo
This isn't a "God created everything because the Bible says so" situation, this is a "We are talking to the actual, factual person who created the sim so he probably knows a few things about it that you don't."
There is no middle-man here, vis-à-vis the bible your pants-on-head retarded comparison, because the person who created the sim is saying it himself, not some translated and retranslated book written by some guy who might have known someone related to him maybe
The only "proof" you've submitted is a logical fallacy. Just because you see players with high strength and low carrying fumble less does not mean that strength prevents fumbles more than carrying. Correlation does not imply causation.
EVIDENCE actually implies my causation. It proves it, in fact.
And honestly, are you telling me that Bort doesn't make changes to the sim every pre-season? And that there aren't issues with them every time? Please, just because he tries to code something a certain way does not by any means make it happen that way.
You have no evidence, you don't even have numbers, you have stats for one player and estimated stats for a second player.
Two player sample? Shit, I'm sold!
You got players to disprove it? Til then, shut the fuck up. My numbers apply to what I deal with. Don't agree? Don't put points into strength.
How about I just listen to the guy that made the game when he tells me in no uncertain terms that Fumbling helps more than Strength for holding onto the ball? See, he's the one who actually has the numbers.
Wait, no, I better distrust the one who wrote the code and come up with my half-cocked theories based on how one or two players performs, that seems like a much more sound plan.
I'm sure flames54 knows a lot more about how builds work than Bort does.
I'd say he knows a lot about what is effective in the metagame, but you'd have to be pretty stupid to think that he somehow knows more about the algorithms that actually decide why things work as they do in the game than Bort.
Originally posted by Maddoc
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by Maddoc
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by Maddoc
Bad analogies should be a bannable offense imo
This isn't a "God created everything because the Bible says so" situation, this is a "We are talking to the actual, factual person who created the sim so he probably knows a few things about it that you don't."
There is no middle-man here, vis-à-vis the bible your pants-on-head retarded comparison, because the person who created the sim is saying it himself, not some translated and retranslated book written by some guy who might have known someone related to him maybe
The only "proof" you've submitted is a logical fallacy. Just because you see players with high strength and low carrying fumble less does not mean that strength prevents fumbles more than carrying. Correlation does not imply causation.
EVIDENCE actually implies my causation. It proves it, in fact.
And honestly, are you telling me that Bort doesn't make changes to the sim every pre-season? And that there aren't issues with them every time? Please, just because he tries to code something a certain way does not by any means make it happen that way.
You have no evidence, you don't even have numbers, you have stats for one player and estimated stats for a second player.
Two player sample? Shit, I'm sold!
You got players to disprove it? Til then, shut the fuck up. My numbers apply to what I deal with. Don't agree? Don't put points into strength.
How about I just listen to the guy that made the game when he tells me in no uncertain terms that Fumbling helps more than Strength for holding onto the ball? See, he's the one who actually has the numbers.
Wait, no, I better distrust the one who wrote the code and come up with my half-cocked theories based on how one or two players performs, that seems like a much more sound plan.
I'm sure flames54 knows a lot more about how builds work than Bort does.
I'd say he knows a lot about what is effective in the metagame, but you'd have to be pretty stupid to think that he somehow knows more about the algorithms that actually decide why things work as they do in the game than Bort.






























