User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
vrshah
offline
Link
 
And bad teams w/o strategy or good builds are getting a free pass.

Why? Because there are so many of them that their voices are louder even though they are "wronger"
 
Broker Hart
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gargus
Originally posted by Gyuri1


R-E-S-P-E-C, find out what it means to me, give it to me, give it to me,


dammit, now i have the real song in my head...

jerk



Forgot the "T"
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sarg01

I'm not defending unseen changes, but please note that you did have preseason to adjust. I know many folks didn't wait to boost for pre-season, but remember that's the whole reason it exists, to give you a feel for the changes.


I agree with your logic on that point, but I didn't get the chance to see how I would perform in the preseason against good speed rushers. That meant that I didn't expect to get circle-strafed while standing still in the season opener.

So, if the proper changes won't be made to the sim (balanced changes)... I believe neither side in this problem should get an unfair advantage of a respec... or they both should, not just one side.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Broker Hart
Originally posted by Gargus

Originally posted by Gyuri1



R-E-S-P-E-C, find out what it means to me, give it to me, give it to me,


dammit, now i have the real song in my head...

jerk



Forgot the "T"


no he was asking for a Respec. no respect
 
Gargus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock
Originally posted by Sarg01


I'm not defending unseen changes, but please note that you did have preseason to adjust. I know many folks didn't wait to boost for pre-season, but remember that's the whole reason it exists, to give you a feel for the changes.


I agree with your logic on that point, but I didn't get the chance to see how I would perform in the preseason against good speed rushers. That meant that I didn't expect to get circle-strafed while standing still in the season opener.

So, if the proper changes won't be made to the sim (balanced changes)... I believe neither side in this problem should get an unfair advantage of a respec... or they both should, not just one side.


That's why I said we should ALL get to respec... GODDAMMIT Gyuri1, as I was typing respec, i couldn't stop singing it in my head.

 
Broker Hart
offline
Link
 
I know. I was just finishing the song


I think we naad a little respect along with that respec...
Last edited Nov 18, 2008 12:21:22
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Warlock, I'm with you on that. The thing that pisses me off most about these changes is not the effect on my DEs (though that does kind of suck), but that my OT, who I've spent a long time trying to figure out how to build correctly to stop the speed/agility rushers is now much, much worse than OTs built by people who don't think that OTs need agility. At least 20 of his SPs put into agility and 20 SPs put into speed were completely wasted. That's 8 levels of SPs that could have been spent getting his Protector SA up to 10 and making him a pancake machine.

In other words, people who've followed this game, and worked hard to build good players tailored to the realities of this game are in a worse position than those who've done nothing but focus on one or two main attributes.

If Bort thought there was a problem here, why didn't he say so when he realized it. That would have allowed all of us to hold our boosts or save our SPs until a solution was reached. There's no possible way that he thought there was an actionable problem yesterday, but not a week ago (or three weeks ago, as these issues existed last season).
Last edited Nov 18, 2008 12:29:02
 
Sockamidic
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vrshah
And bad teams w/o strategy or good builds are getting a free pass.

Why? Because there are so many of them that their voices are louder even though they are "wronger"


"GLBNews: For those that you'll never be able to please, what can you do, if anything?

Bort: Just try our best. There are some people, though, who just hate on everything for whatever reason. I don't think you can change their mind, so we mainly focus on responding to the people who are less negative and more constructive. "
 
Broker Hart
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
Warlock, I'm with you on that. The thing that pisses me off most about these changes is not the effect on my DEs (though that does kind of suck), but that my OT, who I've spent a long time trying to figure out how to build correctly to stop the speed/agility rushers is now much, much worse than OTs built by people who don't think that OTs need agility. At least 20 of his SPs put into agility and 20 SPs put into speed were completely wasted. That's 8 levels of SPs that could have been spent getting his Protector SA up to 10 and making him a pancake machine.



I still dont think we have heard the end of the speed DE complaints. I think Bort's changes will help the OT some, but I still think there will be sack totals that people are not going to like. I think at least part of the points you spent on speed and agility for the OT were well spent.
 
Jason Elliott
offline
Link
 
I'll post this again and this should be the way it should be.

Vision should ne needed for all positions, it is not just the ability to see the field which everyone in here keeps saying. if you got 8 vision he should be getting a ton of penalties, and getting juked by play action fakes, taking bad lanes to the QB, missing tackles etc.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Voltron
I refuse to put points into Vision, you're like 4 yards away from the QB. It's not like you're playing FS/SS/LB/CB and need to see most of the field.


vision also = correct vision of the snap count. since very low vision = false start, very high vision also = good jump on the snap. makes sense to me
 
Jason Elliott
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vrshah
And bad teams w/o strategy or good builds are getting a free pass.

Why? Because there are so many of them that their voices are louder even though they are "wronger"


Having a DE with low vision = a bad build, but it's cool if they get a free pass?
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
I don't understand the strawman you are attacking, Jason. The issue, is that DEs aren't fine with 30 vision. In fact, I have one DE with over 50 vision. Prior to today's game, he was getting a few sacks a game, and a decent amount of hurries. Today he got 0 sacks and 1 hurry, b/c it took him several ticks to move off of the line. I'm guessing he'd need over 70 vision to be able to move at the snap, and that's ridiculous.
Last edited Nov 18, 2008 12:39:54
 
Voltron
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jason Elliott
Originally posted by vrshah

And bad teams w/o strategy or good builds are getting a free pass.

Why? Because there are so many of them that their voices are louder even though they are "wronger"


Having a DE with low vision = a bad build, but it's cool if they get a free pass?


So it's ok to make them have to have Tackling, strength, agility, speed, vision at soft cap with stamina pushing it as well? Oh and not to mention having speed, agility and strength at the 3/4 point caps.
Last edited Nov 18, 2008 12:40:48
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
Warlock, I'm with you on that. The thing that pisses me off most about these changes is not the effect on my DEs (though that does kind of suck), but that my OT, who I've spent a long time trying to figure out how to build correctly to stop the speed/agility rushers is now much, much worse than OTs built by people who don't think that OTs need agility. At least 20 of his SPs put into agility and 20 SPs put into speed were completely wasted. That's 8 levels of SPs that could have been spent getting his Protector SA up to 10 and making him a pancake machine.


I agree with most of what you said as well. Which is why I don't want to see tweaks, I want the blocking system changed completely. The method I proposed would make it important to balance attributes, but still focusing on a couple (depending on what you want to be your forte). It'd also increase the importance of SAs, relative to who you're going against... not how high you can get the SA itself. As well as making strength more important and speed less important (for lineman anyways).

In that type of system, there would still be mismatches, that can be taken advantage of... which there should be TBPH. I really think the heart of the problem is that the mismatches are too glaring. There needs to be a little more balance with how a good build performs and the game-planning side of it can only compensate for so much of it.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.