User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > GLB Notes > CPL > Interesting topic of the Week: Evolutionism versus Creationism
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Azure Dreams
Not at all.

And you apparently fail to grasp the fact that I'm intentionally preventing you from pinning me down.

For the intents and purposes of this topic, we can go with this:

I feel that gay marriage should be legal because laws are in place to protect with as few restrictions as possible and that banning gay marriage oppresses without offering anything legally acceptable.


I think you are trying to use legalese here. How about English?

I'm especially talking about the bolded part
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 03:36:36
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Actually, I should rephrase. You're SUPPOSED TO BE wrong.
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Azure Dreams

Not at all.

And you apparently fail to grasp the fact that I'm intentionally preventing you from pinning me down.

For the intents and purposes of this topic, we can go with this:

I feel that gay marriage should be legal because laws are in place to protect with as few restrictions as possible and that banning gay marriage oppresses without offering anything legally acceptable.


I think you are trying to use legalese here. How about English?


If you have trouble with it, look the words up. It's not a complicated summation.
 
Link
 
I edited my post and bolded the part that makes no sense or needs better defined
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Though to clarify "legally acceptable" i mean protection of your livelihood a opposed to-say- upholding your religious beliefs (note: upholding, not protecting. The latter is good, the former is not the job of the government).

I abbreviated because long posts seem to scare you.
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
I edited my post and bolded the part that makes no sense or needs better defined


Ah. Well that works out well because I already identified that as the unclear part on my own.
 
Serenity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
I feel a family structure of 1 man and 1 woman is ideal to raise children as it gives children of both sexes a role model as to how their gender should behave. I feel a boy should learn to act like a man and a girl should learn to act like a woman.

You feel gender isn't important.

I think that sums it up. Sorry, that is more than 2 sentences, but still concise.


I'd think it would be much healthier for someone to grow up with 2 dads or 2 moms than in a home where the dad beats/abuses the mom...
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
No. Maybe possibly having a different definition of gender rolls than SI does is far worse than growing up in a home where you are hit and don't get a good education.
 
Link
 
I can see where you are coming from in a legal way.

It really just comes down to if you think that increasing the % of gay people in the population would be harmful or not.

You don't think it would hurt.

I think it would. Not that being gay would cause more death or murder or anything like that. I just think if you don't "push" people to being male or female in gender then you will have alot of people who will go both ways. Then tell me who they are supposed to get married to if they want a little bit of both?

It would lead to the eventual destruction of marriage all together. And then it would lead to children not properly being raised. And then *that* would lead to bad things like higher dropout rates, higher drug addiction, teen pregnancies, etc. You know, the stuff you see in many single mother homes where the father isn't around.
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 03:49:38
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Serenity
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

I feel a family structure of 1 man and 1 woman is ideal to raise children as it gives children of both sexes a role model as to how their gender should behave. I feel a boy should learn to act like a man and a girl should learn to act like a woman.

You feel gender isn't important.

I think that sums it up. Sorry, that is more than 2 sentences, but still concise.


I'd think it would be much healthier for someone to grow up with 2 dads or 2 moms than in a home where the dad beats/abuses the mom...


no one has ever argued that point. But society has to have an ideal to shoot for.

If you say something else is just as good as 1 mother and 1 father, then you are breaking down that structure.

All things being equal, nothing is as good as 1 mother and 1 father. Most of us were raised in that environment, but we seem to be telling the next generation that 1 mother and no father is ok, 1 father and 0 mother is ok, 2 fathers and 0 mothers is ok. They really aren't. Maybe on an individual case basis, but we aren't talking about case by case here. We are talking about opening this thing up to EVERYONE.

 
Serenity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Serenity

Originally posted by SteelersInsider


I feel a family structure of 1 man and 1 woman is ideal to raise children as it gives children of both sexes a role model as to how their gender should behave. I feel a boy should learn to act like a man and a girl should learn to act like a woman.

You feel gender isn't important.

I think that sums it up. Sorry, that is more than 2 sentences, but still concise.


I'd think it would be much healthier for someone to grow up with 2 dads or 2 moms than in a home where the dad beats/abuses the mom...


no one has ever argued that point. But society has to have an ideal to shoot for.

If you say something else is just as good as 1 mother and 1 father, then you are breaking down that structure.

All things being equal, nothing is as good as 1 mother and 1 father. Most of us were raised in that environment, but we seem to be telling the next generation that 1 mother and no father is ok, 1 father and 0 mother is ok, 2 fathers and 0 mothers is ok. They really aren't. Maybe on an individual case basis, but we aren't talking about case by case here. We are talking about opening this thing up to EVERYONE.



And why is it not ok?
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
I take no exception to you thinking that it's bad to increase the amount of gay people. Your beliefs are your beliefs whether they're retarded or epiphanic.

But the point is that it's not about whether your belief is okay. It's about the fact that, no back and forth, 100% no question laws are not meant to be used the way you are trying to use them.

Your level of extrapolation is absolutely ridiculous from an argument's standpoint and founded in nothing remotely provable. And the burden is not mine to disprove the need for the law, it is yours to prove it's need.

If you can't prove that a law is needed to protect people, it should not be in place. That's the founding principal of our legal system. The fact that you think it will lead to other things which might be bad or the fact that your religious group says what the law would be preventing is bad is not acceptable grounds upon which to make a restriction for others.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Azure Dreams
No. Maybe possibly having a different definition of gender rolls than SI does is far worse than growing up in a home where you are hit and don't get a good education.



comparing to the worst case doesn't make it right. Are you saying it isn't possible to get hit by 2 fathers?


you have used that argument (comparing to the worst case) a couple times now. I let the other ones go. It isn't a very good way to make an argument for something:


"I think I should let my kids eat Doritos and Coke all day. It could be worse. After all, there are kids who are starving to death in India. At least they aren't starving to death, right?"
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Serenity

Originally posted by SteelersInsider


I feel a family structure of 1 man and 1 woman is ideal to raise children as it gives children of both sexes a role model as to how their gender should behave. I feel a boy should learn to act like a man and a girl should learn to act like a woman.

You feel gender isn't important.

I think that sums it up. Sorry, that is more than 2 sentences, but still concise.


I'd think it would be much healthier for someone to grow up with 2 dads or 2 moms than in a home where the dad beats/abuses the mom...


no one has ever argued that point. But society has to have an ideal to shoot for.

If you say something else is just as good as 1 mother and 1 father, then you are breaking down that structure.

All things being equal, nothing is as good as 1 mother and 1 father. Most of us were raised in that environment, but we seem to be telling the next generation that 1 mother and no father is ok, 1 father and 0 mother is ok, 2 fathers and 0 mothers is ok. They really aren't. Maybe on an individual case basis, but we aren't talking about case by case here. We are talking about opening this thing up to EVERYONE.



Ignoring the fact that you aren't stating fact, you're stating opinion:

So what? No one is preventing alcoholics from copulating or marrying. There are more children than there are ideal homes by your definition. Someone needs to raise the children. You choose the horribly unfit over the non-ideal.
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Azure Dreams

No. Maybe possibly having a different definition of gender rolls than SI does is far worse than growing up in a home where you are hit and don't get a good education.



comparing to the worst case doesn't make it right. Are you saying it isn't possible to get hit by 2 fathers?


you have used that argument (comparing to the worst case) a couple times now. I let the other ones go. It isn't a very good way to make an argument for something:


"I think I should let my kids eat Doritos and Coke all day. It could be worse. After all, there are kids who are starving to death in India. At least they aren't starving to death, right?"


If 2 men could give birth, you'd have a point. When applying for adoption and things like that, the couple is researched.

I'm using the worst case becasue you are accepting it as a necessary evil when it is not one.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.