User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Archived Changes > The Archetype Discussion Thread
Page:
 
Kirghiz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Meatdawg
Originally posted by Rage Kinard

Power backs and combo backs could get lead block for when they are blocking for the offensive FB.



I like that one for power backs. Would help on qb runs as well?


Would be more useful on the speed back imo for the QB runs.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Meatdawg
RR on a scat back would be deadly


I have to decide between RR and FS on my scatback FB. Since he will already have 100+ agility while running routes, I'm thinking RR may be better than FS. But 10 FS on a FB that will have 127 speed and 92 agility sounds pretty sweet as well.
 
Billy Corman
offline
Link
 
I thought we were being sarcastic ...
 
Justiciable
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Staz
"The Strong Base skill gives him a bonus to pushing the blocker out of the way."




To me, I'm curious to see what effect First Step has on kick distance. Snarl, Big Hit, Monster Hit, Diving Tackle, Wrap Up Tackle, Change Direction, & Growl. If Closing Speed works on kick offs, then I'd be curious to see how effective THAT is.


"This player has a powerful lower body..."

Originally posted by Billy Corman
I thought we were being sarcastic ...


 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Field General so he can play QB and handoff the ball.
 
coachingubigr
lounge guy
offline
Link
 
DEMORALIZE!
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Can we get that "hot button issue" forum made any time soon?
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
The thread Player Archetype Seamless Integration? has been merged into this thread
 
saintedix
offline
Link
 
Okay, so why is Bort making it so that when archetypes are integrated, the existing players start from building their archetype from where they are? Why not adjust stats of these players based on the archetype they chose? Obviously it's because ALGs are difficult to predict SP-wise because of the caps, yada yada...

I literally just sat down for 15 minutes and did some number crunching on a few positions (HB, C, QB, LB) and came within 10% values of the average archetype build of the same level by adjusting the stats based on the difference between the "old" (existing) ALGs and the archetype ALGs for the respective position.

Sometimes I wonder who is running the dog-and-pony thought process behind some of these things...
 
Kayoh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by saintedix
within 10%

I'm thinking this is why. 10% is not close enough.
 
Staz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by saintedix
Okay, so why is Bort making it so that when archetypes are integrated, the existing players start from building their archetype from where they are? Why not adjust stats of these players based on the archetype they chose? Obviously it's because ALGs are difficult to predict SP-wise because of the caps, yada yada...

I literally just sat down for 15 minutes and did some number crunching on a few positions (HB, C, QB, LB) and came within 10% values of the average archetype build of the same level by adjusting the stats based on the difference between the "old" (existing) ALGs and the archetype ALGs for the respective position.

Sometimes I wonder who is running the dog-and-pony thought process behind some of these things...


Because I'm sure Bort really doesn't want to go back and create a script/code to account for training, SP allocation, cap building, SSB, SB, etc. for a one time event. I think letting you choose an archetype and have it from that point forward is just fine. Of course, older players will be developmentally "behind" newer players in a few seasons, but will they really play each other? S14 players will be only a tiny bit worse than S15 players, since they'll only miss a season of the new archetypes (sure, 13 levelsish)
 
daddie7120
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by saintedix
Okay, so why is Bort making it so that when archetypes are integrated, the existing players start from building their archetype from where they are? Why not adjust stats of these players based on the archetype they chose? Obviously it's because ALGs are difficult to predict SP-wise because of the caps, yada yada...

I literally just sat down for 15 minutes and did some number crunching on a few positions (HB, C, QB, LB) and came within 10% values of the average archetype build of the same level by adjusting the stats based on the difference between the "old" (existing) ALGs and the archetype ALGs for the respective position.

Sometimes I wonder who is running the dog-and-pony thought process behind some of these things...


You wont have to create new players...

New players = $$$
 
saintedix
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by daddie7120
You wont have to create new players...

New players = $$$


Yeah, well he's giving 90% flex back on most of these players anyway, so he's not really making much of a profit. When is he just going to hire another programmer, heck, even a guy good at math to fix some of these things?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by saintedix
Okay, so why is Bort making it so that when archetypes are integrated, the existing players start from building their archetype from where they are? Why not adjust stats of these players based on the archetype they chose? Obviously it's because ALGs are difficult to predict SP-wise because of the caps, yada yada...

I literally just sat down for 15 minutes and did some number crunching on a few positions (HB, C, QB, LB) and came within 10% values of the average archetype build of the same level by adjusting the stats based on the difference between the "old" (existing) ALGs and the archetype ALGs for the respective position.

Sometimes I wonder who is running the dog-and-pony thought process behind some of these things...


Good Question.
 
joe blitz
offline
Link
 
Season 23 (or wherever) with no dots in the 60s is going to be awesome.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.