Originally posted by CoachZ
I applaud this change. We were discussing this very subject in our forums just the other day. There is absolutely NO liquidity in the FA market for the players that SHOULD be available for the team level equivalent of that team.
First season teams who were here from day one, should have a pool of players level 16-24 range, second season teams should have a pool about 8 below that, and the newbie teams should be starting the exact same way the first season teams did...lower level first year players just beginning or coming out of the D leagues.
But that liquidity does not exist. Why? Because ALL teams have the ability to recruit players at any level. Naturally, the more expansion there is in this game, the larger the demand for the highest possible FA is naturally going to occur.
Two things arise out of this. First, teams in the first or second season can't really improve that much, possibly move up from the bottom or middle tier of their league and challenge competitively, because there just aren't enough FA's FOR THEIR LEVEL available...they're spread to thin within ALL the teams . Secondly, newbie and second season teams suffer tremendous ass kickings because one or two teams in their league are loaded with player levels that really have no reason to be competing at such a lower level. for whatever reason...friends, bankrupting payrolls, collusion, etc.
The results of this, is a game that IS NOT FUN for a large majority in here. Now I'm one of the lucky ones. A#1 league is VERY even, very competitive, and so much fun, non of us owners in their can hardly wait for the next game...but this doesn't exist for most.
By penalizing the huge disparity in levels, Bort is trying to make ALL the leagues play like ours. In my book, that's not a good thing...that's a GREAT thing. If a player is penalized for playing in a league below his level, he won't take those nutsy contracts to do so in the future. This will add liquidity back to the FA market, teams will become more balanced, be able to improve within their league...and the game becomes an even better game.
Now, for those that are gonna bitch that this hits them hard...they've been spending hours to recruit their Level 18 guys for the new Africa League, remember this. One of the reasons we play a beta game, is to find out what's WRONG with the game at this stage, and make changes in it's design and rules. Hundreds of first season teams sucking the FA market dry with third season players is wrong. All of us that began with a team the first season didn't have this advantage, and now...neither will the new teams.
The main goal of game testing, for all of you that have never done this before, is to find BALANCE in the game...so it's FUN for everybody. During this testing period, rules and code changes. This is a good rule and code change.
CZ
Well said.
This can only help when it comes to making all leagues more competitive and more fun for 99% of players/owners/gm's.
Yeah you always gonna have the small minority who get a kick out of taking their level 20 to a new expansion team so they can run up some huge numbers, but really what enjoyment is it as an owner/player/gm winning(or losing) 75-0 week in week out?
This way players have more of a chance of slotting in a league where they play similar skill levels. Keep leagues stronger.