User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
Link
 
Gotta jump in here -

#1 - each player in football (from Pee Wee to Pros) modify their tackling style to be effective more times than not. Very few players try to take on a power back head on. They are taught to go low, not high. So strength + tackle isn't all that important.

For me it should be:

Strength+Carry+Speed vs Speed+Agility+Tackle+jump (add jump only if a diving tackle), if these are equal you can have a "tie breaker" of RB agility (ability to squirm) vs tackler's strength (ability to hold on). This is for wrap up/ sure tackle.

So a 100 strength, 70 carry, 50 speed back should get brought down by a 80 speed, 50 tackle, 50 agility MLB on 1st attempt about 80% of the time, breaking the initial tackle 20% of the time.

For those looking for real life examples here's a great one for those who remember:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ThX1qkIgbEg&feature=related

Okoye vs Atwater

Here's a whole highlight reel:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ncWETBUel2s&feature=PlayList&p=11B2A27C987DCB0B&playnext=1&index=12

In real life it isn't always the strongest guy who wins...
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fletch03
Originally posted by Iceman16

The point is that LBs have a LOT of things to worry about, while as Deathblade said a lot of HBs can get by on speed, agility and carrying. The balance is fucked.


Your right they do. But do they also need the same speed and agility as CBs? no. But most people think "hell i don't mind if I miss a few tackles as long as I get to the play quicker" which I agree with.


Tbh I'm sure there are a couple of LBs at various levels that are at least faster than some safeties on their team.
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
60/60 is a good, balanced LB build, and should be okay against a super-strong power back, but shouldn't own him, either. Anything below it, and the LB should be pwned.


Well tell that to people who say that Powerbacks are too powerful - I bet a LOT of LBs have less than 120 for their combined Strength+Tackling.
 
fletch03
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Seriously, Power RBs should be left alone...if people want to stop them...raise your tackling and strength. Easy as that, it's not impossible to stop a power RB. It's not like they are going to outrun you. lol


agreed.
 
bhall43
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by tautology

Originally posted by fletch03




I honestly don't see anything wrong with the way it is right now.


I am going to have to agree...if folks are getting run over, they should alter their builds.

This is how the all-speed teams lose, and folks finally stop following that herd.

Let the whining fall upon deaf ears.

Stand strong, Bort.


+100000


i know of several teams that would disagree with that equation...
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Maddoc
Originally posted by Iceman16

Originally posted by Maddoc


Bad analogies should be a bannable offense imo

This isn't a "God created everything because the Bible says so" situation, this is a "We are talking to the actual, factual person who created the sim so he probably knows a few things about it that you don't."

There is no middle-man here, vis-à-vis the bible your pants-on-head retarded comparison, because the person who created the sim is saying it himself, not some translated and retranslated book written by some guy who might have known someone related to him maybe

The only "proof" you've submitted is a logical fallacy. Just because you see players with high strength and low carrying fumble less does not mean that strength prevents fumbles more than carrying. Correlation does not imply causation.


EVIDENCE actually implies my causation. It proves it, in fact.

And honestly, are you telling me that Bort doesn't make changes to the sim every pre-season? And that there aren't issues with them every time? Please, just because he tries to code something a certain way does not by any means make it happen that way.


You have no evidence, you don't even have numbers, you have stats for one player and estimated stats for a second player.

Two player sample? Shit, I'm sold!


You got players to disprove it? Til then, shut the fuck up. My numbers apply to what I deal with. Don't agree? Don't put points into strength.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
60/70 should be a smart way to build a LB, because a LB needs more skills than just to make tackles of power backs. But power backs should still win some of the battles against them, or they're useless.

Right now, most LB's don't have near the 60/70. At whatever level, if Speed is higher than Strength or Tackling, the LB should be humiliated by a good power back.

But if you want someone who'd tackle the hypothetical guy consistently, then you should have to do with Tackling what CB's and WR's do with Speed. That likely isn't worth it to prevent missing, say, 15-20% of tackles on one type of back at 60/70, though.


Again the problem that everyone has voiced is that a CB cannot have enough tackling without keeping up with WRs- the way to fix this is force WRs to put some points into strength- No more 20 strength WRs... unless people want their players to be fumbling machines or finish games with 20 energy.

I know someone is going to say "well in the nfl Wrs don't fumble alot..."- well GLB isn't the NFL. Think of GLB like your backyard football game. There is always that little skinny guy who can run flat out but whenever he is tackled he gets creamed- then he gets up and complains that we are playing tackle football or says he is hurt- thats what the WRs are in GLB right now and they need to reflect that.

EDIT: I don't know why I quoted you...
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 22:16:55
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fletch03
Originally posted by jrry32

Seriously, Power RBs should be left alone...if people want to stop them...raise your tackling and strength. Easy as that, it's not impossible to stop a power RB. It's not like they are going to outrun you. lol


agreed.


+1, I don't see the problem at this time.
 
Maddoc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by Maddoc

Originally posted by Iceman16


Originally posted by Maddoc



Bad analogies should be a bannable offense imo

This isn't a "God created everything because the Bible says so" situation, this is a "We are talking to the actual, factual person who created the sim so he probably knows a few things about it that you don't."

There is no middle-man here, vis-à-vis the bible your pants-on-head retarded comparison, because the person who created the sim is saying it himself, not some translated and retranslated book written by some guy who might have known someone related to him maybe

The only "proof" you've submitted is a logical fallacy. Just because you see players with high strength and low carrying fumble less does not mean that strength prevents fumbles more than carrying. Correlation does not imply causation.


EVIDENCE actually implies my causation. It proves it, in fact.

And honestly, are you telling me that Bort doesn't make changes to the sim every pre-season? And that there aren't issues with them every time? Please, just because he tries to code something a certain way does not by any means make it happen that way.


You have no evidence, you don't even have numbers, you have stats for one player and estimated stats for a second player.

Two player sample? Shit, I'm sold!


You got players to disprove it? Til then, shut the fuck up. My numbers apply to what I deal with. Don't agree? Don't put points into strength.


How about I just listen to the guy that made the game when he tells me in no uncertain terms that Fumbling helps more than Strength for holding onto the ball? See, he's the one who actually has the numbers.

Wait, no, I better distrust the one who wrote the code and come up with my half-cocked theories based on how one or two players performs, that seems like a much more sound plan.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheFranticMoron
Again the problem that everyone has voiced is that a CB cannot have enough tackling without keeping up with WRs- the way to fix this is force WRs to put some points into strength- No more 20 strength WRs... unless people want their players to be fumbling machines or finish games with 20 energy.

I know someone is going to say "well in the nfl Wrs don't fumble alot..."- well GLB isn't the NFL. Think of GLB like your backyard football game. There is always that little skinny guy who can run flat out but whenever he is tackled he gets creamed- then he gets up and complains that we are playing tackle football or says he is hurt- thats what the WRs are in GLB right now and they need to reflect that.


+1

Originally posted by Iceman16
The point is that LBs have a LOT of things to worry about, while as Deathblade said a lot of HBs can get by on speed, agility and carrying. The balance is fucked.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Maddoc
Originally posted by Iceman16

Originally posted by Maddoc


Originally posted by Iceman16



Originally posted by Maddoc




Bad analogies should be a bannable offense imo

This isn't a "God created everything because the Bible says so" situation, this is a "We are talking to the actual, factual person who created the sim so he probably knows a few things about it that you don't."

There is no middle-man here, vis-à-vis the bible your pants-on-head retarded comparison, because the person who created the sim is saying it himself, not some translated and retranslated book written by some guy who might have known someone related to him maybe

The only "proof" you've submitted is a logical fallacy. Just because you see players with high strength and low carrying fumble less does not mean that strength prevents fumbles more than carrying. Correlation does not imply causation.


EVIDENCE actually implies my causation. It proves it, in fact.

And honestly, are you telling me that Bort doesn't make changes to the sim every pre-season? And that there aren't issues with them every time? Please, just because he tries to code something a certain way does not by any means make it happen that way.


You have no evidence, you don't even have numbers, you have stats for one player and estimated stats for a second player.

Two player sample? Shit, I'm sold!


You got players to disprove it? Til then, shut the fuck up. My numbers apply to what I deal with. Don't agree? Don't put points into strength.


How about I just listen to the guy that made the game when he tells me in no uncertain terms that Fumbling helps more than Strength for holding onto the ball? See, he's the one who actually has the numbers.

Wait, no, I better distrust the one who wrote the code and come up with my half-cocked theories based on how one or two players performs, that seems like a much more sound plan.


I'm sure flames54 knows a lot more about how builds work than Bort does.
 
TehKyou
offline
Link
 
I think we need to combine aspects of what Flames54 and DeathBlade have said.

Elusive Running Style effects:
Reduces the agility requirements to successfully excecute a "juking" manuever
Increases the strength requirements to successfully smash through a tackler
Use slightly more energy while running, but not as much energy lossed when tackled (going down quickly.)
Less likely to activate a "Drag" check

Power Running Style effects:
Increases the agility requirements to successfully execute a "juking" manuever
Reduces the strength requirement to successfully smash through a tackler
Use slightly less energy while running (pretty much going straight ahead) but lose slightly more energy when being tackled (fighting for yards)
More likely to activate "Drag" check


Wrap Up Tackling effects:
Increases the Strength requirements to knock over a player using Power Running Focus or "Stun them"
Reduces vision requirements to not be fooled by various "jukes" on a player using a more Elusive Running Focus
less energy used in tackles (unless dragged)
less energy and morale loss caused on player tackled
In General, more likely to wrap up the ball carrier and bring him down, but less likely to bring him straight down (Dragging)

Power Tackling effects:
Reduces Strength requirements to knock over a player using Power Running Focus or "Stun" them
Increases vision requirements to not be fooled by various "jukes" on a player using a more Elusive Running Focus
Higher Energy expended in tackle attempts
Slight in game Morale increase on successful tackles
Higher Energy and Morale loss caused on player tackled
In General, less likely to wrap up the ball carrier and bring him down if he isn't initially knocked down (No Dragging)
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
So, before I step away from the computer for a while (I'll probably be back some later), I'll answer the question that strarted the thread with my view of it:

60/60 should be the minimum to avoid being pwned by power backs.

60/70 (the 70 in Tackling, which should be slightly more important than Strength in tackling) should be enough to play well against them (still missing tackles at times), but the most at level 40ish that's consistent with the LB being able to do something other than just tackle power backs.

...and something like 75/90 if you really wanted to almost never miss a tackle (but not very advisable, as you couldn't do much else).

75/90 might even be needed at a player's peak of level 60something.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
So, before I step away from the computer for a while (I'll probably be back some later), I'll answer the question that strarted the thread with my view of it:

60/60 should be the minimum to avoid being pwned by power backs.

60/70 (the 70 in Tackling, which should be slightly more important than Strength in tackling) should be enough to play well against them (still missing tackles at times), but the most at level 40ish that's consistent with the LB being able to do something other than just tackle power backs.

...and something like 75/90 if you really wanted to almost never miss a tackle (but not very advisable, as you couldn't do much else).

75/90 might even be needed at a player's peak of level 60something.


In complete agreement.
 
raiderdav
offline
Link
 
As one of those giddy power back owners, I love the idea of dragging dots.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.