Gotta jump in here -
#1 - each player in football (from Pee Wee to Pros) modify their tackling style to be effective more times than not. Very few players try to take on a power back head on. They are taught to go low, not high. So strength + tackle isn't all that important.
For me it should be:
Strength+Carry+Speed vs Speed+Agility+Tackle+jump (add jump only if a diving tackle), if these are equal you can have a "tie breaker" of RB agility (ability to squirm) vs tackler's strength (ability to hold on). This is for wrap up/ sure tackle.
So a 100 strength, 70 carry, 50 speed back should get brought down by a 80 speed, 50 tackle, 50 agility MLB on 1st attempt about 80% of the time, breaking the initial tackle 20% of the time.
For those looking for real life examples here's a great one for those who remember:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ThX1qkIgbEg&feature=related
Okoye vs Atwater
Here's a whole highlight reel:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ncWETBUel2s&feature=PlayList&p=11B2A27C987DCB0B&playnext=1&index=12
In real life it isn't always the strongest guy who wins...
#1 - each player in football (from Pee Wee to Pros) modify their tackling style to be effective more times than not. Very few players try to take on a power back head on. They are taught to go low, not high. So strength + tackle isn't all that important.
For me it should be:
Strength+Carry+Speed vs Speed+Agility+Tackle+jump (add jump only if a diving tackle), if these are equal you can have a "tie breaker" of RB agility (ability to squirm) vs tackler's strength (ability to hold on). This is for wrap up/ sure tackle.
So a 100 strength, 70 carry, 50 speed back should get brought down by a 80 speed, 50 tackle, 50 agility MLB on 1st attempt about 80% of the time, breaking the initial tackle 20% of the time.
For those looking for real life examples here's a great one for those who remember:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ThX1qkIgbEg&feature=related
Okoye vs Atwater
Here's a whole highlight reel:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ncWETBUel2s&feature=PlayList&p=11B2A27C987DCB0B&playnext=1&index=12
In real life it isn't always the strongest guy who wins...






























