User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Players Looking for Teams > about to be lvl 34 WR looking for season 7
Page:
 
bruiser 1234
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jackriley
Originally posted by bruiser 1234

Originally posted by jackriley


Originally posted by rip_city




combine is way overrated IMO


ABSOLUTELY 100% Right!

The combine is worth about as much as Mel Kiper's opinion on draftee's



FYP


haha, Yes, that's sooooooo true too!


McShay is much better, but not great.
 
rip_city
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hornetsxcp3
Originally posted by rip_city

Originally posted by hornetsxcp3


Originally posted by bruiser 1234



Originally posted by hornetsxcp3




Originally posted by rip_city





Originally posted by jackriley






Originally posted by rip_city







Sam Bradford drops back has a man its Calvin Johnson for his 3rd TD of the game.


doesnt that just sound right


but let me ask you this.. if they DO go Oher #1, whats the chances of getting Stafford OR Bradford?


hmm if they go Oher #1 chance of getting a franchise QB is not good with Dallas's pick but again depends on how Dallas does. Good QB's can fall a little depending on the demand. Personally I like Bradford the most out of the QB's that could come out. I see Stafford as a game managing QB. Nothing wrong with that but I see Bradford as a QB who can make the big plays and can be a star.


I would definitely take Stafford over Bradford I know everyone likes how Bradford plays in college but Stafford is more familiar with a Pro Style O


I disagree. Bradford's offense is not really the spread offense, and he has to read the defense. He does not run, so I see his offense pretty close to a pro style. Staffords is a bit more, but he does not make as good of reads and not as much accuracy IMO


I some what agree but I think they run the spread sometimes but I could be wrong I think it really depends on what the two do at the combine


combine is way overrated IMO


I think that is the most vital thing to find good talent because you have a whole different game in college


this is why a lot of busts happen. Workout warriors and nothing more. ME i like to look at film more and see what they do as a FOOTBALL PLAYER not what they do without pads. You cant measure a guys heart, desire to win, blocking down field, and stuff like that at the combine.
 
bruiser 1234
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rip_city


this is why a lot of busts happen. Workout warriors and nothing more. ME i like to look at film more and see what they do as a FOOTBALL PLAYER not what they do without pads. You cant measure a guys heart, desire to win, blocking down field, and stuff like that at the combine.


Like Vernon Gholston, look what he did this season so far.
 
rip_city
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bruiser 1234
Originally posted by jackriley

Originally posted by bruiser 1234


Originally posted by jackriley



Originally posted by rip_city





combine is way overrated IMO


ABSOLUTELY 100% Right!

The combine is worth about as much as Mel Kiper's opinion on draftee's



FYP


haha, Yes, that's sooooooo true too!


McShay is much better, but not great.


I agree with ya on that. McShay has been right on quite a bit and was dead on with his man love for Matt Ryan.
 
Hornet F Baby
offline
Link
 
Ok so how can you tell if Graham Herrell will be able to convert from Spread to Pro style?
 
rip_city
offline
Link
 
i didnt say the combine didnt have some good to it but my point is they put way to much into it
 
Link
 
Again, agreed rip. And it just doesn't go to what a guy does when HE is the target, as a WR or whether it be what he does on Hail Mary passes (QB's) or how he hits a hole (RB's), it's what they do when the focus ISN'T entirely on them too. When they're asked to do things that aren't necessarily 'in their job description' as positional players. These are the types of things you get no glimpse of in the combine.
 
bruiser 1234
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hornetsxcp3
Ok so how can you tell if Graham Herrell will be able to convert from Spread to Pro style?


His mechanics. His footwork. His arm motion. His accuracy on the 12-15 yard outs, the 20 yard seam throw, and the deep ball. His ability to read the D, and look off safeties. His ability to not focus on one WR, which is hard with Crabtree there.
 
Hornet F Baby
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rip_city
i didnt say the combine didnt have some good to it but my point is they put way to much into it


I agree they take a little too much out of it but I think it is a great way of finding good talent for the draft
 
Link
 
Originally posted by hornetsxcp3
Ok so how can you tell if Graham Herrell will be able to convert from Spread to Pro style?


I think the combine has some 'essential features' but you're not going to get the most important aspects of scouting out of it imo.
 
bruiser 1234
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rip_city
i didnt say the combine didnt have some good to it but my point is they put way to much into it


Fans, and Kiper put too much into it. Most NFL teams do not put as much into it
 
Hornet F Baby
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bruiser 1234
Originally posted by hornetsxcp3

Ok so how can you tell if Graham Herrell will be able to convert from Spread to Pro style?


His mechanics. His footwork. His arm motion. His accuracy on the 12-15 yard outs, the 20 yard seam throw, and the deep ball. His ability to read the D, and look off safeties. His ability to not focus on one WR, which is hard with Crabtree there.


you can't tell all of that because of the difference of offenses
 
rip_city
offline
Link
 
I have a question too. Why dont they make them run the 40 in pads? They are not running in a game without pads so even the 40 is flawed to me.
 
bruiser 1234
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bruiser 1234
Originally posted by hornetsxcp3

Ok so how can you tell if Graham Herrell will be able to convert from Spread to Pro style?


His mechanics. His footwork. His arm motion. His accuracy on the 12-15 yard outs, the 20 yard seam throw, and the deep ball. His ability to read the D, and look off safeties. His ability to not focus on one WR, which is hard with Crabtree there.


You have to watch game film. If you watched the film work McShay did with Ryan. Ryan was always set when he threw, he always has his shoulders square, he was able to look off a S, was able to throw deep. Manipulate the pocket and hit his check downs when needed.
 
Hornet F Baby
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jackriley
Originally posted by hornetsxcp3

Ok so how can you tell if Graham Herrell will be able to convert from Spread to Pro style?


I think the combine has some 'essential features' but you're not going to get the most important aspects of scouting out of it imo.


I wasn't saying that I'm saying it is a good way of telling who has potential
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.