User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > GLB Notes > CPL > Interesting topic of the Week: Evolutionism versus Creationism
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Azure Dreams
Believe it or not, you can be in banking without being jewish.

That said, he was not a banker. He was in retail.

And yes, my avatar is jewy right now. Know what else? If everyone else's was, mine would have a santa hat. Asheme's avatar has the hasidic jewcurls too, does that mean he's jewish?

Lastly, for fuck's sake, be a little educated about cultures other than your own, at least. Jewish beanie? Yarmulke or kippah (or at least yamaka, even though that's just the first word misspelled)

You have never seen me say I'm Jewish.

Know who I can be extra sure of this? I'm not Jewish.

Know what else is fun here? Every argument we've made can apply almost as much against the Jewish community as the Christian community.

And lastly, just for shits and giggles, I feel the need to point out that all Christians ARE Jews. They're just Jews who believe a few additional things.


I don't think your religion has anything to do with this. I would argue that you weren't Jewish in religion anyway (maybe by race).

That doesn't have ANYTHING to do with what we were talking about though. I said you weren't Christian or certainly didn't understand Christians. I am correct on this issue whether you are Muslim or Jewish or Wiccan or Atheist.
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
I feel a family structure of 1 man and 1 woman is ideal to raise children as it gives children of both sexes a role model as to how their gender should behave. I feel a boy should learn to act like a man and a girl should learn to act like a woman.

You feel gender isn't important.

I think that sums it up. Sorry, that is more than 2 sentences, but still concise.


Whoa whoa whoa, now you're making things up again.

The only part of your first bit I have any problem with is the "boy should act like a man" part because a man doesn't have a set way of acting. But I know what you mean anyway, so we'll move past that.

The second bit? When did I say gender isn't important?

No, you're welcomed to believe that and I very well may agree with you.

However, I'm able to look objectively at it and realize that laws are not supposed to be made to appease my beliefs and that, even if I believe what you said, if I can't prove that not-restricting things that might go contrary to that belief- like gay marriage- is harmful to me, then I have no legal ground to stand on.

This isn't a difference of belief that's coming to a head, it's a refusal to accept that the laws aren't there to fit your belief structure butting up against relative objectivism.
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Azure Dreams

Believe it or not, you can be in banking without being jewish.

That said, he was not a banker. He was in retail.

And yes, my avatar is jewy right now. Know what else? If everyone else's was, mine would have a santa hat. Asheme's avatar has the hasidic jewcurls too, does that mean he's jewish?

Lastly, for fuck's sake, be a little educated about cultures other than your own, at least. Jewish beanie? Yarmulke or kippah (or at least yamaka, even though that's just the first word misspelled)

You have never seen me say I'm Jewish.

Know who I can be extra sure of this? I'm not Jewish.

Know what else is fun here? Every argument we've made can apply almost as much against the Jewish community as the Christian community.

And lastly, just for shits and giggles, I feel the need to point out that all Christians ARE Jews. They're just Jews who believe a few additional things.


I don't think your religion has anything to do with this. I would argue that you weren't Jewish in religion anyway (maybe by race).

That doesn't have ANYTHING to do with what we were talking about though. I said you weren't Christian or certainly didn't understand Christians. I am correct on this issue whether you are Muslim or Jewish or Wiccan or Atheist.


You have no clue whether I'm Christian. The only reason I won't prove you right or wrong is because it leads to assumptions being made.

And who are you to say whether I understand Christians? From what I see, I understand Chrisitans just as well as you do. Being Christian doesn't = understanding them and vice versa.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Azure Dreams
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

I feel a family structure of 1 man and 1 woman is ideal to raise children as it gives children of both sexes a role model as to how their gender should behave. I feel a boy should learn to act like a man and a girl should learn to act like a woman.

You feel gender isn't important.

I think that sums it up. Sorry, that is more than 2 sentences, but still concise.


Whoa whoa whoa, now you're making things up again.

The only part of your first bit I have any problem with is the "boy should act like a man" part because a man doesn't have a set way of acting. But I know what you mean anyway, so we'll move past that.

The second bit? When did I say gender isn't important?

No, you're welcomed to believe that and I very well may agree with you.

However, I'm able to look objectively at it and realize that laws are not supposed to be made to appease my beliefs and that, even if I believe what you said, if I can't prove that not-restricting things that might go contrary to that belief- like gay marriage- is harmful to me, then I have no legal ground to stand on.

This isn't a difference of belief that's coming to a head, it's a refusal to accept that the laws aren't there to fit your belief structure butting up against relative objectivism.



You said that it doesn't matter if more kids become gay because of confusing them about gender. Should I find the post?
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 03:23:55
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
My point is that Christianity shouldn't have anything to do with the matter at hand and I've never heard an argument against gay marriage being legalized that wasn't rooted in it or another religion (which can refer to any belief structure).
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Azure Dreams

Originally posted by SteelersInsider


I feel a family structure of 1 man and 1 woman is ideal to raise children as it gives children of both sexes a role model as to how their gender should behave. I feel a boy should learn to act like a man and a girl should learn to act like a woman.

You feel gender isn't important.

I think that sums it up. Sorry, that is more than 2 sentences, but still concise.


Whoa whoa whoa, now you're making things up again.

The only part of your first bit I have any problem with is the "boy should act like a man" part because a man doesn't have a set way of acting. But I know what you mean anyway, so we'll move past that.

The second bit? When did I say gender isn't important?

No, you're welcomed to believe that and I very well may agree with you.

However, I'm able to look objectively at it and realize that laws are not supposed to be made to appease my beliefs and that, even if I believe what you said, if I can't prove that not-restricting things that might go contrary to that belief- like gay marriage- is harmful to me, then I have no legal ground to stand on.

This isn't a difference of belief that's coming to a head, it's a refusal to accept that the laws aren't there to fit your belief structure butting up against relative objectivism.



You said that it doesn't matter if more kids become gay because of confusing them about gender. Should I find the post?


I asked why it matters. I asked why that's harmful. Because if you can't prove it is, you have no legal argument.

I never said I don't think it matters. I never even said the claims I'm making represent my beliefs. I've been known to argue on the behalf of other beliefs against my own if I think they need challenging at that particular time.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Azure Dreams
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Originally posted by Azure Dreams


Believe it or not, you can be in banking without being jewish.

That said, he was not a banker. He was in retail.

And yes, my avatar is jewy right now. Know what else? If everyone else's was, mine would have a santa hat. Asheme's avatar has the hasidic jewcurls too, does that mean he's jewish?

Lastly, for fuck's sake, be a little educated about cultures other than your own, at least. Jewish beanie? Yarmulke or kippah (or at least yamaka, even though that's just the first word misspelled)

You have never seen me say I'm Jewish.

Know who I can be extra sure of this? I'm not Jewish.

Know what else is fun here? Every argument we've made can apply almost as much against the Jewish community as the Christian community.

And lastly, just for shits and giggles, I feel the need to point out that all Christians ARE Jews. They're just Jews who believe a few additional things.


I don't think your religion has anything to do with this. I would argue that you weren't Jewish in religion anyway (maybe by race).

That doesn't have ANYTHING to do with what we were talking about though. I said you weren't Christian or certainly didn't understand Christians. I am correct on this issue whether you are Muslim or Jewish or Wiccan or Atheist.


You have no clue whether I'm Christian. The only reason I won't prove you right or wrong is because it leads to assumptions being made.


There are assumptions that are made from you being afraid to reveal your beliefs/religion/lack of religion. Might as well put your cards on the table.....

 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
That is your belief. I decline.

Do you feel that there should be a law forcing me to?
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
also: lol at afraid.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Azure Dreams


I asked why it matters. I asked why that's harmful. Because if you can't prove it is, you have no legal argument.

I never said I don't think it matters. I never even said the claims I'm making represent my beliefs. I've been known to argue on the behalf of other beliefs against my own if I think they need challenging at that particular time.


I'm trying to pin you down to a BRIEF statement of what you believe.

How about this:

You feel that being gay doesn't represent a hardship, so if a few kids get turned gay in the confusion of legalizing marriages, then that is ok because there is no damage to the child from a legal standpoint.

Am I getting closer?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Azure Dreams
That is your belief. I decline.

Do you feel that there should be a law forcing me to?


I'm glad I have the confidence in my beliefs to be able to speak about them openly.

You must not be too sure of yours.
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Not at all.

And you apparently fail to grasp the fact that I'm intentionally preventing you from pinning me down.

For the intents and purposes of this topic, we can go with this:

I feel that gay marriage should be legal because laws are in place to protect with as few restrictions as possible and that banning gay marriage oppresses without offering anything legally acceptable.
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Azure Dreams

That is your belief. I decline.

Do you feel that there should be a law forcing me to?


I'm glad I have the confidence in my beliefs to be able to speak about them openly.

You must not be too sure of yours.


Sure, let's go with that.

Clearly, I'm unconfident. I think that's been exhibited.

I will, however, offer forth that confident in does not go hand-in-hand with blinded by. Just a fwiw.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Azure Dreams


I never even said the claims I'm making represent my beliefs. I've been known to argue on the behalf of other beliefs against my own if I think they need challenging at that particular time.


Wow. I've been arguing with a guy who doesn't even necessarily believe what is coming out of his mouth?

You remind me of Jrry. Are you his brother? His dad is a lawyer I think, so I can sort of understand why he feels the need to argue with everyone though if that is how he communicated with his dad.
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
What I believe is irrelevant. I'm not arguing my beliefs, for the most part. I'm arguing legality. Your arguing your beliefs.

And you think your beliefs trump legality.

You are wrong.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.