User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Provide a Refund to the Nashville Team in USA AA#1
Page:
 
Meryk
offline
Link
 
I'm not about to read pages 1 through 41 just to get caught up on what is being discussed.

The game isn't broken, it's just catching up, proving that speed isn't everything. I've noticed a dramatic increase in INTs this season. When it became an issue for my team, I didn't cry foul. I found the problem. Naturally, tactically speaking, I'm not going to release the solution.

Sure, it's obvious that Bort tweaked a few things for this season without telling anyone, but I think that was brilliant on his part. The last time he told us some things would change in the algorithms, everybody threw a fit when shit went bad for their players/teams.

I will say this, though. If you find the pattern to the INTs, you'll find the solution to your problems. Once the INT problem was addressed with my team, it was night and day.
 
Octane Hugo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Meryk
I'm not about to read pages 1 through 41 just to get caught up on what is being discussed.

The game isn't broken, it's just catching up, proving that speed isn't everything. I've noticed a dramatic increase in INTs this season. When it became an issue for my team, I didn't cry foul. I found the problem. Naturally, tactically speaking, I'm not going to release the solution.

Sure, it's obvious that Bort tweaked a few things for this season without telling anyone, but I think that was brilliant on his part. The last time he told us some things would change in the algorithms, everybody threw a fit when shit went bad for their players/teams.

I will say this, though. If you find the pattern to the INTs, you'll find the solution to your problems. Once the INT problem was addressed with my team, it was night and day.


You do realize the QB threw 15 INTS all season, right? And that this is the result of a MAJORLY screwed up sim, right?

This is why you read the muthafuckin topic before you muthafuckin post

 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Octane Hugo
Originally posted by Meryk

I'm not about to read pages 1 through 41 just to get caught up on what is being discussed.

The game isn't broken, it's just catching up, proving that speed isn't everything. I've noticed a dramatic increase in INTs this season. When it became an issue for my team, I didn't cry foul. I found the problem. Naturally, tactically speaking, I'm not going to release the solution.

Sure, it's obvious that Bort tweaked a few things for this season without telling anyone, but I think that was brilliant on his part. The last time he told us some things would change in the algorithms, everybody threw a fit when shit went bad for their players/teams.

I will say this, though. If you find the pattern to the INTs, you'll find the solution to your problems. Once the INT problem was addressed with my team, it was night and day.


You do realize the QB threw 15 INTS all season, right? And that this is the result of a MAJORLY screwed up sim, right?

This is why you read the muthafuckin topic before you muthafuckin post




You do realize the team RAN THE BALL ALL SEASON, that is why he never got into a game like this before, but I guess this is why you look at the team before you POST.
 
Krunchy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Octane Hugo

You do realize the QB threw 15 INTS all season, right? And that this is the result of a MAJORLY screwed up sim, right?

This is why you read the muthafuckin topic before you muthafuckin post



Who cares how many interceptions he threw all season. Some helpful reading for you: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Statistical_independence

And way to stay classy.
 
Octane Hugo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay

You do realize the team RAN THE BALL ALL SEASON, that is why he never got into a game like this before, but I guess this is why you look at the team before you POST.


I know that, but I don't care what your strategy is; 10 picks in a matchup like this should never happen.


Originally posted by Krunchy

Who cares how many interceptions he threw all season. Some helpful reading for you: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Statistical_independence

And way to stay classy.


I have another word for you: trends. Also, consistency.

Oh wow, sorry I didn't act like a gentlemen on an online forum. :/ I'll be sure to use all my dinner table manners.

 
karma99
offline
Link
 
With the forum search being broken this thread his become very handy for getting a quick reminder of who's good to sign up with as an owner next season, and who's to be avoided. For that reason alone, it's been worthwhile
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Hugo - 10 picks is what happens when you have a level 25 QB build like a level 16 QB, going up against mid-20's CB's, DL's, LB's, etc. in a game that got out of hand early, and the SIM forcing the passing game, as per usual.

Does the SIM need tweaks to offense because defense is overpowered at the higher levels right now? Yes.

Did this play a part in the result? Of course it did.

But the offense issues with the SIM affect EVERYONE -- no team is singled out, but bad builds sure are, so you can't blame it on the SIM alone.

The QB's build is bad. That much has been discussed. The other team boosted a ton of their players before the game. Also been discussed, that will throw things off (whether teams should be able to boost right before playoffs, with players magically becoming 3 levels mightier, is another topic for discussion - it isn't realistic, and I'm sure it will be talked about again). The defense, from first glance, look like at the very least good builds, if not excellent builds.

The reason this happened, for the most part, is confidence. The QB threw two picks and was sacked 3-4 times very early in the game. His low confidence led to his morale being shot.

The main issue here is that there is no sub setting to pull a QB when his morale is shot, thus avoiding the confidence/morale spiral which led to a 9 INT game. If there is any beef, that's it right there, and Larry and Co. should push for that option for season 4, along with the other updates. Another HUGE issue is not being able to throw the ball away - should be in QB advanced tactics, letting the QB decide how risky he wants to be. And a smaller one is the idea of eating a sack at times if you're in the pocket (once penalties are adding for intentional grounding, and I say this is smaller because a sack = less morale, so it isn't an optimal choice).

So, in conclusion and for the simpletons who feel like arguing with logic...

Recipe for Disaster
-------------------

Take 1 poorly build QB with low confidence, low throwing and low strength for his level

Add a very good defense with many players that just got three levels better and have good builds

Add a very good and aggressive gameplan against the offense

Add a number of early mistakes and/or situations of bad luck leading the QB being sacked multiple times and throwing multiple interceptions

Take away the QB's morale for the game

Add some playing from behind, forcing this QB to keep chucking the ball

Take away the ability to throw the ball away or eat a sack in a bad situation

Take away the ability to sub this QB out for a backup without current morale issues

And you get...one hell of a rough game for this team with no way in the current SIM to stop the bleeding.

-----

As always, this game has brought some issues to light, both with a player build (if anyone doesn't think confidence is REQUIRED for certain positions now, its your own fault when this happens to you) and with the need for more ADVANCED OPTIONS from the player and the team to avoid this becoming a repeat occurrence.

What is not needed is a tweak to the SIM to make confidence and/or morale less of a factor - noone should be rewarded for neglecting to contribute points to a MAJOR ATTRIBUTE.

Hopefully this clears things up.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by Octane Hugo

Originally posted by Meryk


I'm not about to read pages 1 through 41 just to get caught up on what is being discussed.

The game isn't broken, it's just catching up, proving that speed isn't everything. I've noticed a dramatic increase in INTs this season. When it became an issue for my team, I didn't cry foul. I found the problem. Naturally, tactically speaking, I'm not going to release the solution.

Sure, it's obvious that Bort tweaked a few things for this season without telling anyone, but I think that was brilliant on his part. The last time he told us some things would change in the algorithms, everybody threw a fit when shit went bad for their players/teams.

I will say this, though. If you find the pattern to the INTs, you'll find the solution to your problems. Once the INT problem was addressed with my team, it was night and day.


You do realize the QB threw 15 INTS all season, right? And that this is the result of a MAJORLY screwed up sim, right?

This is why you read the muthafuckin topic before you muthafuckin post




You do realize the team RAN THE BALL ALL SEASON, that is why he never got into a game like this before, but I guess this is why you look at the team before you POST.



You're still around running your mouth over topics you couldn't bother to RESEARCH? He threw the ball 511 times this season--and only threw 15 picks. He was NOWHERE to be found on the conference leader board in regard to interceptions.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Meryk
I'm not about to read pages 1 through 41 just to get caught up on what is being discussed.

The game isn't broken, it's just catching up, proving that speed isn't everything. I've noticed a dramatic increase in INTs this season. When it became an issue for my team, I didn't cry foul. I found the problem. Naturally, tactically speaking, I'm not going to release the solution.

Sure, it's obvious that Bort tweaked a few things for this season without telling anyone, but I think that was brilliant on his part. The last time he told us some things would change in the algorithms, everybody threw a fit when shit went bad for their players/teams.

I will say this, though. If you find the pattern to the INTs, you'll find the solution to your problems. Once the INT problem was addressed with my team, it was night and day.



No valid "sim" includes coding that allows a PLAYOFF team to throw 10 picks in a game, period.

At this point I'm not really interested in what "pattern to the INTs" existed--coding of that nature has no business in an American style football sim.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by Meryk

I'm not about to read pages 1 through 41 just to get caught up on what is being discussed.

The game isn't broken, it's just catching up, proving that speed isn't everything. I've noticed a dramatic increase in INTs this season. When it became an issue for my team, I didn't cry foul. I found the problem. Naturally, tactically speaking, I'm not going to release the solution.

Sure, it's obvious that Bort tweaked a few things for this season without telling anyone, but I think that was brilliant on his part. The last time he told us some things would change in the algorithms, everybody threw a fit when shit went bad for their players/teams.

I will say this, though. If you find the pattern to the INTs, you'll find the solution to your problems. Once the INT problem was addressed with my team, it was night and day.



No valid "sim" includes coding that allows a PLAYOFF team to throw 10 picks in a game, period.

At this point I'm not really interested in what "pattern to the INTs" existed--coding of that nature has no business in an American style football sim.


Here we go again, the magical use of the word PLAYOFF Sim,

Tell me this, we will go point by point.

A. Do you think your QB has a horrible, bad, average, good, great build.

Pick one.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
The Sim simulates based on player builds. The fact that it's a playoff game has nothign to do with it.

There are things that should be tweaked from that game that have been talked about - pulling the QB if in game morale drops too low, setting a basement for in game morale, etc but the fact that it's a playoff game should have absolutely nothign to do with it.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Cruzi
Rather than go ballistic over a defensive performance that doesn't look all that far fetched...



Put down the blunt--10 picks by one team in a playoff game is "far fetched" no matter how one chooses to look at it.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
I understand your frustration Larry...it is no fun to lose, esp. when a player has a career worst day. But just because he only threw 15 picks in 511 attempts this season doesn't mean its impossible to throw a ton in a game - you just hadn't faced a situation like you did in the playoff game in terms of a confidence/morale spiral, coupled with the poor build.

It was exaggerated by no ability to sub him out when his morale tanked and the fact that a QB can't throw the ball away in this game.

So yes, the 9 INT's are an exaggeration based on the SIM's current set of rules and tactics. Had advanced sub settings been available, 9 INT's from your starter don't happen, maybe he's pulled after 4 or 5 or 6. And if he can choose on his player advanced settings to play safe (throw the ball away when there is great coverage on the receivers) he might not have even thrown that many.

But alas, none of us have those options yet, and the SIM did work as intended based on its current format.

So I understand the frustration, but this one game doesn't mean the SIM is completely broken. Offense needs to be given a boost, agree 100% there, but the overall SIM is doing pretty well for the most part, esp. at its current age.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Man, does my playoff experience bar with positive effects on confidence in the playoffs (thanks to Ken for that add) ever seem like a good idea now

And I think drifter has been through this as well, but I'm not sure there is anything he hasn't thought of - not trying to steal the thunder of the man with tons of good ideas
Last edited Jul 15, 2008 08:19:16
 
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

Originally posted by Meryk


I'm not about to read pages 1 through 41 just to get caught up on what is being discussed.

The game isn't broken, it's just catching up, proving that speed isn't everything. I've noticed a dramatic increase in INTs this season. When it became an issue for my team, I didn't cry foul. I found the problem. Naturally, tactically speaking, I'm not going to release the solution.

Sure, it's obvious that Bort tweaked a few things for this season without telling anyone, but I think that was brilliant on his part. The last time he told us some things would change in the algorithms, everybody threw a fit when shit went bad for their players/teams.

I will say this, though. If you find the pattern to the INTs, you'll find the solution to your problems. Once the INT problem was addressed with my team, it was night and day.



No valid "sim" includes coding that allows a PLAYOFF team to throw 10 picks in a game, period.

At this point I'm not really interested in what "pattern to the INTs" existed--coding of that nature has no business in an American style football sim.


Here we go again, the magical use of the word PLAYOFF Sim,

Tell me this, we will go point by point.

A. Do you think your QB has a horrible, bad, average, good, great build.

Pick one.



The season long sim says his performance was in the average to good range. Feel free to check the conference leader board--9th in yards passing, 6th in TD passes, NOWHERE on the league board in regard to interceptions. But you have an obvious aversion to facts as you've ably demonstrated throughtout this entire thread.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.