Hugo - 10 picks is what happens when you have a level 25 QB build like a level 16 QB, going up against mid-20's CB's, DL's, LB's, etc. in a game that got out of hand early, and the SIM forcing the passing game, as per usual.
Does the SIM need tweaks to offense because defense is overpowered at the higher levels right now? Yes.
Did this play a part in the result? Of course it did.
But the offense issues with the SIM affect EVERYONE -- no team is singled out, but bad builds sure are, so you can't blame it on the SIM alone.
The QB's build is bad. That much has been discussed. The other team boosted a ton of their players before the game. Also been discussed, that will throw things off (whether teams should be able to boost right before playoffs, with players magically becoming 3 levels mightier, is another topic for discussion - it isn't realistic, and I'm sure it will be talked about again). The defense, from first glance, look like at the very least good builds, if not excellent builds.
The reason this happened, for the most part, is confidence. The QB threw two picks and was sacked 3-4 times very early in the game. His low confidence led to his morale being shot.
The main issue here is that there is no sub setting to pull a QB when his morale is shot, thus avoiding the confidence/morale spiral which led to a 9 INT game. If there is any beef, that's it right there, and Larry and Co. should push for that option for season 4, along with the other updates. Another HUGE issue is not being able to throw the ball away - should be in QB advanced tactics, letting the QB decide how risky he wants to be. And a smaller one is the idea of eating a sack at times if you're in the pocket (once penalties are adding for intentional grounding, and I say this is smaller because a sack = less morale, so it isn't an optimal choice).
So, in conclusion and for the simpletons who feel like arguing with logic...
Recipe for Disaster
-------------------
Take 1 poorly build QB with low confidence, low throwing and low strength for his level
Add a very good defense with many players that just got three levels better and have good builds
Add a very good and aggressive gameplan against the offense
Add a number of early mistakes and/or situations of bad luck leading the QB being sacked multiple times and throwing multiple interceptions
Take away the QB's morale for the game
Add some playing from behind, forcing this QB to keep chucking the ball
Take away the ability to throw the ball away or eat a sack in a bad situation
Take away the ability to sub this QB out for a backup without current morale issues
And you get...one hell of a rough game for this team with no way in the current SIM to stop the bleeding.
-----
As always, this game has brought some issues to light, both with a player build (if anyone doesn't think confidence is REQUIRED for certain positions now, its your own fault when this happens to you) and with the need for more ADVANCED OPTIONS from the player and the team to avoid this becoming a repeat occurrence.
What is not needed is a tweak to the SIM to make confidence and/or morale less of a factor - noone should be rewarded for neglecting to contribute points to a MAJOR ATTRIBUTE.
Hopefully this clears things up.