User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Demotion Ideas for the WPL
Page:
 
ChicagoTRS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Gart888

Originally posted by BBVD


Originally posted by ChicagoTRS



IMO keep it simple:

4 go up this year from each pro conference = 32 teams

next season demote all non-playoff teams - put them in their past conf - demote more teams from the pro league to make space..

2 conf champs get promoted...

rinse repeat...

The benefits of this is that it is simple to implement and only the best of the best play the WPL. It is ridiculous to suggest any system that has a top team being demoted just because there is another top team from the same conf. The goal should be to get the best 32 teams in the WPL.


yes!

where you at bort?


yeah, this is by far the most logical method.


I remember somebody whose name starts with a G posting something similar a while back. I wonder who it could be?


lol...I really did not read any other posts...

brilliant minds think alike I guess...
 
Ubasstards
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla
i have a question: would the promotion/demotion system of the world league be used in all the other leagues too? or would i tbe used to a smaller extent (so bottom 4 in each conference in the regions gets demoted, etc.)?


no reason to change current system for other leagues. Only difference is world league will determine how many spots in pro are available
 
DiMo28
offline
Link
 
Why so many teams? Just take the top 2 teams from each region. Teams don't get promoted unless there is an opening from a team from their region getting demoted, gutted, or going CPU. Think of it more of a privilege to get to play in the league rather than something that is entitled.

Make it the elite of the elite. 4 per region is too many IMO.
Edited by DiMo28 on Jul 27, 2009 21:53:17
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dirtmcgirt66
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Gart888


Originally posted by BBVD



Originally posted by ChicagoTRS




IMO keep it simple:

4 go up this year from each pro conference = 32 teams

next season demote all non-playoff teams - put them in their past conf - demote more teams from the pro league to make space..

2 conf champs get promoted...

rinse repeat...

The benefits of this is that it is simple to implement and only the best of the best play the WPL. It is ridiculous to suggest any system that has a top team being demoted just because there is another top team from the same conf. The goal should be to get the best 32 teams in the WPL.


yes!

where you at bort?


yeah, this is by far the most logical method.


I remember somebody whose name starts with a G posting something similar a while back. I wonder who it could be?


Demoting 16 teams every season is a bit much dont you think?


Not at all. If you weren't good enough to make playoffs, give someone else a shot.
 
ICRockets
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dirtmcgirt66
Originally posted by ICRockets

Originally posted by Dirtmcgirt66


Originally posted by Dirtmcgirt66



Originally posted by Bort




I think the main problem I can see with the 4 per region "division" idea is that it makes it possible for playoff teams to get demoted over non-playoff teams. We'd have to demote the worst of each division, and it's possible for one region to send 4 teams who will be in the playoffs via wildcard spots, while another region has no wildcards.


Or you could make it a cap of 3 teams getting to the playoffs from each division so that there is always a 4th to demote. Kind of like the current BCS limit with the number of teams a conference can have in a BCS bowl game.


Keep in mind that this also helps with the parity situation. People wont want to get stuck being that 4th USA team in that division that has a good record but still keeps getting demoted. This would force players to spread out to different areas.


Or...it would force them to call the entire WPL a farce where inferior teams get to stay in by virtue of what they did in OTHER leagues instead of what they did in their current league.

That's like saying that Team X from EEPL isn't allowed to play in the playoffs because there were already 7 teams from EEAAA2 and we needed to get one from EEAAA1 so it was fair, even though Team X is 9-7 and Team Y (who was in EEAAA1 last year) was 6-10.



No. If want it to be "fair" then enjoy having 10+ USA Pro teams in the WPL at all times. I have no problem with that but im simply throwing something out there for people who dont want the "fair" way to do it. I have no idea what your stance is because there is to much shit to read lol.


The problem is that you're overlooking other things at play here. To begin with, you'd have 4 USAPL teams in the WPL. If all of them make the playoffs, the next season you have 6 USAPL teams in the WPL. The next season, if all of them make the playoffs, you have 8. The next, if all of them make the playoffs, you have 10. To get 10 USAPL teams in WPL, you would need 4 full seasons. During that team, a TON of recruiting would happen. Some players would start going to the "weaker" Pro regions in anticipation of an easier road to WPL, and some players would go directly to WPL teams looking to be able to match up to the Juggernauts of the WPL. If 6, 8, 10 USAPL teams can weather that storm and keep winning and keep making it to the playoffs, then they deserve to be in that league by virtue of their play on the lolfield.
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lukin83
Originally posted by Dirtmcgirt66

Originally posted by Gart888


Originally posted by ImTheScientist



Originally posted by Bort




Originally posted by lukin83





Originally posted by Bort






Originally posted by ImTheScientist







Originally posted by Bort








I think the main problem I can see with the 4 per region "division" idea is that it makes it possible for playoff teams to get demoted over non-playoff teams. We'd have to demote the worst of each division, and it's possible for one region to send 4 teams who will be in the playoffs via wildcard spots, while another region has no wildcards.


To that I would say .... tough. And I doubt one region would have no wildcards. If it did....it would work itself out over time. If you create set numbers from each league (which most agree you should) then parity will ensue. If you decide to just show love to USAPL, SAPL, or CPL and ignore people like EEP, OPL, SEA I fear for the future of the game and the riots that will ensue over that one.


I don't think there has to be a forced and arbitrary set number in the league from each region at all times. I think that teams should have to fight to stay and winning should be the factor in determining who stays and who goes. All regions would get 2 teams promoted to the world league every season. How is that not equal opportunity?


Can you keep your regional affiliation with that method?


If we don't mind the possibility of an additional team or two getting demoted (assuming there aren't enough CPUs & guts to cover demotions), then yes we can. The question is if that is an acceptable possibility or not. Between the two possibilities, I think I like it more than the possibility of playoff teams getting demoted. Heck, you could go 15-1 and get demoted because the other divisions are terrible or quit.


As long as you can figure out these two keep regional affiliation I would be happy tbh. It would also be cool if when a team is in the WPL they get a symbol or something that designates where they are from.


That's a good call, flags or whatever next to our team names on all the league pages.


Actually bort you cant go 15-1 and get demoted in the division system. I think you are misunderstanding it a bit.


Yeah. I am not doing the math to figure out the highest possible record where you could still get demoted, but it is not 15-1.


I believe it is 14-2...


That would assume going 1-1 with both the #1 and #2 teams in a division and winning every other game.
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ChicagoTRS
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Gart888


Originally posted by BBVD



Originally posted by ChicagoTRS




IMO keep it simple:

4 go up this year from each pro conference = 32 teams

next season demote all non-playoff teams - put them in their past conf - demote more teams from the pro league to make space..

2 conf champs get promoted...

rinse repeat...

The benefits of this is that it is simple to implement and only the best of the best play the WPL. It is ridiculous to suggest any system that has a top team being demoted just because there is another top team from the same conf. The goal should be to get the best 32 teams in the WPL.


yes!

where you at bort?


yeah, this is by far the most logical method.


I remember somebody whose name starts with a G posting something similar a while back. I wonder who it could be?


lol...I really did not read any other posts...

brilliant minds think alike I guess...


he's referring to month(s?) ago.

but yeah, i'm sure a dozen people have come up with that exact same system.
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DiMo28
Why so many teams? Just take the top 2 teams from each region. Teams don't get promoted unless there is an opening from a team from their region getting demoted, gutted, or going CPU. Think of it more of a privilege to get to play in the league rather than something that is entitled.


Might as well use the division idea then.
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
What if you used the division method, but only demoted the 4th team in each division (promoting each pro champion)? That would allow for equal opportunity of 4 teams per region, the ability to keep regional affiliations and essentially ensure that a non-playoff team was demoted.
 
Link
 
It's a "WORLD" league so all pro leagues should be equally represented. After season 11 the 2 teams that finish worst from each league go down one from each conference it's simple. If they finished 2nd and the other team from their home league finished 1st they get demoted.
Edited by viking maniac 1 on Jul 27, 2009 21:57:15
 
JeffSteele
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DiMo28
Why so many teams? Just take the top 2 teams from each region. Teams don't get promoted unless there is an opening from a team from their region getting demoted, gutted, or going CPU. Think of it more of a privilege to get to play in the league rather than something that is entitled.

Make it the elite of the elite. 4 per region is too many IMO.
good question, i think the answer is that WPL in-season struccture is then similar to Pro in-season structure, which adds continuity to the tree.
 
ICRockets
offline
Link
 
OMFG the division idea doesn't work. You just freakin admitted that it's possible for a 14-2 team to get demoted based on your system.
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Also, shuffling up (randomizing) the conference each season would be a good idea wouldn't it? If teams are in the world league for an extended period they'd (probably) get a chance to play all the other big teams.
 
BBVD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by viking maniac 1
It's a "WORLD" league so all pro leagues should be equally represented. After season 11 the 2 teams that finish worst from each league go down one from each conference it's simple. If they finished 2nd and the other team from there home league finished 1st they get demoted.


no
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Gart888
Originally posted by Dirtmcgirt66

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by Gart888



Originally posted by BBVD




Originally posted by ChicagoTRS





IMO keep it simple:

4 go up this year from each pro conference = 32 teams

next season demote all non-playoff teams - put them in their past conf - demote more teams from the pro league to make space..

2 conf champs get promoted...

rinse repeat...

The benefits of this is that it is simple to implement and only the best of the best play the WPL. It is ridiculous to suggest any system that has a top team being demoted just because there is another top team from the same conf. The goal should be to get the best 32 teams in the WPL.


yes!

where you at bort?


yeah, this is by far the most logical method.


I remember somebody whose name starts with a G posting something similar a while back. I wonder who it could be?


Demoting 16 teams every season is a bit much dont you think?


Not at all. If you weren't good enough to make playoffs, give someone else a shot.


But you are leaving out the point that teams could get stuck in a promotion/relegation trap every year. For instance, lets say an OPL team makes it to the WPL by winning their conference title one year. They get bumped up into the WL, dont make the playoffs, and get shuffled back down to OPL where they are still likely one of the best teams there. This will just repeate itself in some areas I can guarantee that and will do nothing for adding parity to the league.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.