User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > NERF THE FUMBLES NOW!!!
Page:
 
CapnEnnui
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by raidersrock

Your solution to that was nerf QBs.


Wrong, that is part of what we're working on. The other part is not ready yet.

Once again, I love you too.


Why do you quote the part of the post that's wrong but leave out the parts that are right?
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
What would be better is a slider that only kicks in once a problem has shown up.

Like an auto-adjust you can turn on. Fumbled once in a game? Take -x% something to gain a boost to not fumbling. Fumble again? Increase some more.

Slider decides how fast you ramp up your "Oh shit".

Let's face it - what really happens is a guy fumbles and gets a couple helmet slaps (unless he was doing something egregiously stupid, like not fair catching when someone is bearing down on him). Fumbles again? Here comes the shitstorm from the coach.


I'm not sure why a ball carrier shouldn't be able to make this decision permanent (rather than waiting to fumble), so long as it would require him making sacrifices to his success in actually carrying the ball (whether it knocks down the break tackle or dive for yards chance, or just causes him to slow down when about to be tackled).

Last edited Apr 26, 2009 18:19:43
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by jrry32

Bort, I am not going to read this whole thread again but did you comment on maybe having elusive RBs fumble less since IRL elusive RBs take less direct hits or put a bar where you could make your guy go down or fight for yards when hit?


The suggestion I like the best was the idea of a new slider. I'm going to be setting up some tests on it tonight.


Thanks and can you check your PMs, I sent you something that will hopefully help you or tell you that you are doing the right thing on DEs.
 
raidersrock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by raidersrock

Your solution to that was nerf QBs.


Wrong, that is part of what we're working on. The other part is not ready yet.

Once again, I love you too.


QBs take longer to find a quick target when pressure is coming. Pretty much the same.

Can't wait to see this new idea....
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by jrry32


Bort, I am not going to read this whole thread again but did you comment on maybe having elusive RBs fumble less since IRL elusive RBs take less direct hits or put a bar where you could make your guy go down or fight for yards when hit?


The suggestion I like the best was the idea of a new slider. I'm going to be setting up some tests on it tonight.


What would be better is a slider that only kicks in once a problem has shown up.

Like an auto-adjust you can turn on. Fumbled once in a game? Take -x% something to gain a boost to not fumbling. Fumble again? Increase some more.

Slider decides how fast you ramp up your "Oh shit".

Let's face it - what really happens is a guy fumbles and gets a couple helmet slaps (unless he was doing something egregiously stupid, like not fair catching when someone is bearing down on him). Fumbles again? Here comes the shitstorm from the coach.


That was included in the idea actually.
 
Zadith
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by jrry32

Bort, I am not going to read this whole thread again but did you comment on maybe having elusive RBs fumble less since IRL elusive RBs take less direct hits or put a bar where you could make your guy go down or fight for yards when hit?


The suggestion I like the best was the idea of a new slider. I'm going to be setting up some tests on it tonight.


Something else that really isn't part of this but I guess it can be tied in...What about giving the Defense VAs that focus on different play types? Like a VA for a LB who has always been good at stopping the run and over the years has gotten better. Maybe give them a boost to something on run plays after a successful vision check or something like that and vice versa for pass plays. Just something to give another option rather than just power tackler since that seems to be the compliant...
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
Originally posted by kurieg

What would be better is a slider that only kicks in once a problem has shown up.

Like an auto-adjust you can turn on. Fumbled once in a game? Take -x% something to gain a boost to not fumbling. Fumble again? Increase some more.

Slider decides how fast you ramp up your "Oh shit".

Let's face it - what really happens is a guy fumbles and gets a couple helmet slaps (unless he was doing something egregiously stupid, like not fair catching when someone is bearing down on him). Fumbles again? Here comes the shitstorm from the coach.


I'm not sure why a ball carrier shouldn't be able to make this decision permanent (rather than waiting to fumble), so long as it would require him making sacrifices to his success in actually carrying the ball (whether it knocks down the break tackle or dive for yards chance, or just causes him to slow down when about to be tackled).



He can make it permanent. He can buy more Carrying and Strength in lieu of other stuff.
 
drake262
loldrake
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by trentw
Originally posted by drake262

Originally posted by trentw


Originally posted by raidersrock



I wonder how long its gonna take Bort to realize he can't run a sim worth shit, and he's long ruined the game. Every season its something new....


Pretty sure he runs a hell of a lot better sim than you do!, I hate it when everyone wants to attack Bort, if you hate him and his game that bad there is a simple solution.


+1 post would read again


Thanks Drake


 
raidersrock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CapnEnnui
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by raidersrock


Your solution to that was nerf QBs.


Wrong, that is part of what we're working on. The other part is not ready yet.

Once again, I love you too.


Why do you quote the part of the post that's wrong but leave out the parts that are right?


Don't expect much more then Canned Responses from any Admin or Mod. Ive learned that since i joind cept for a few cool Mods.
 
CapnEnnui
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Luzod
I think we are getting close to realism. However, Bort must stop falling for whinners.

If you look at this topic, many people are defending the actual sim. Still there are 4~5 whinners (yes, because the arguments you are using are really weak. The guy who's HB fumbled 15 times after his 180 plays still here for example) and they seems to be getting to Bort. Really, listen to reason and stop listening to guys that chose (yes, because in RPG you make choices on how you want your players to be) to have a very fast/agile HB that can't hold the ball.

It was their choice not to invest on carrying, so let them suffer.

The only guy with a point actually is GeneralM, but still, it's only 1 player in 1 game and we don't even know opponents builds, so...


They chose not to invest in a stat that wasn't useful until now. How is that their fault?

And how is this many fumbles "close to realism"? I said it already, Adrian Peterson is "fumble prone" because he fumbled 6 times in 16 games. That's not the rate we're going right now.
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by kurieg

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by jrry32



Bort, I am not going to read this whole thread again but did you comment on maybe having elusive RBs fumble less since IRL elusive RBs take less direct hits or put a bar where you could make your guy go down or fight for yards when hit?


The suggestion I like the best was the idea of a new slider. I'm going to be setting up some tests on it tonight.


What would be better is a slider that only kicks in once a problem has shown up.

Like an auto-adjust you can turn on. Fumbled once in a game? Take -x% something to gain a boost to not fumbling. Fumble again? Increase some more.

Slider decides how fast you ramp up your "Oh shit".

Let's face it - what really happens is a guy fumbles and gets a couple helmet slaps (unless he was doing something egregiously stupid, like not fair catching when someone is bearing down on him). Fumbles again? Here comes the shitstorm from the coach.


That was included in the idea actually.


Great minds and all that!
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by raidersrock
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by raidersrock


Your solution to that was nerf QBs.


Wrong, that is part of what we're working on. The other part is not ready yet.

Once again, I love you too.


QBs take longer to find a quick target when pressure is coming. Pretty much the same.

Can't wait to see this new idea....


The other portion is blockers being stunned by shed blocks so they can't just reengage all the time. Works just a little too well right now. There's a thread by hazy in the test section if you're interested.
 
raidersrock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Luzod
I think we are getting close to realism.


Well last season you were able to run 80 times with 1 player, and now we got 10+ funble games with equal competition. We aren't that close to realism.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
He can make it permanent. He can buy more Carrying and Strength in lieu of other stuff.


My concern is trying to preserve some form of elusive/speed back build, who aren't exactly overpowered at the moment. Powerbacks, which have been overpowered, actually make their player better rushers with strength and carrying, pure speed/elusive backs don't gain much from strength and seem to have lesser gains from carrying.
Last edited Apr 26, 2009 18:23:17
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CapnEnnui
Originally posted by Luzod

I think we are getting close to realism. However, Bort must stop falling for whinners.

If you look at this topic, many people are defending the actual sim. Still there are 4~5 whinners (yes, because the arguments you are using are really weak. The guy who's HB fumbled 15 times after his 180 plays still here for example) and they seems to be getting to Bort. Really, listen to reason and stop listening to guys that chose (yes, because in RPG you make choices on how you want your players to be) to have a very fast/agile HB that can't hold the ball.

It was their choice not to invest on carrying, so let them suffer.

The only guy with a point actually is GeneralM, but still, it's only 1 player in 1 game and we don't even know opponents builds, so...


They chose not to invest in a stat that wasn't useful until now. How is that their fault?

And how is this many fumbles "close to realism"? I said it already, Adrian Peterson is "fumble prone" because he fumbled 6 times in 16 games. That's not the rate we're going right now.


How is it defenders fault to capitalize on other's choices?

Meta-game changes are part of these types of games. Get caught leaning the wrong way and, well, tough shit!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.