Originally posted by tansien
Originally posted by PinTBC
Originally posted by Bort
What's considered a "good" running game? Lots of people are used to 5, 6, 7 YPC being average on here, which is WAY too high - auto first down every 2 plays. Most runs against a good D should go for 2-5, not 4-7. Big runs in the NFL come from missed tackles or blown defensive play calls. If the box is stacked, we shouldn't be forcing teams to get 4 YPC just because it's a number to shoot for - that should shut down the run and make for some wide open receivers. The goal should be to force the defense to play more honest, through variety of plays and the passing game working well.
As much as I wonder about your code sometimes, I firmly believe you are a good architect. Now stop adding periphery stuff to the game, and get your SIM the way you just described, and most of the people playing will cut you some slack.
PinTBC
Ah but on the flip side, the lemming community most also conform to the wisdom that they are stupid and should not follow cookie cutter unbalanced builds...
Tans.
You and I will have to agree to disagree. I like the idea of unbalanced builds (mine mostly aren't though), as it gives those people who wish to be creative a chance to create a strange player that just might turn into a star, or at least a very good player.
The balancing of the builds is an area that I still believe needs an awful lot of work. Right now, the cookie cutter speed build has been replaced with the cookie cutter joe average balanced builds. Games like this tend to get very boring if you can't find ways to make your players different.
While I applaud Bort's general efforts at trying to give people outlets to do that, his method of tacking extra stuff around the SIM is and has been very frustrating, and has actually been causing significant problems. Right now the VAs are claimed to be causing problems and Bort is talking about adjusting the attribute boosters, but without a good SIM, there truly isn't any way he could possibly know enough about their effects to make a detailed judgment on their effects. The endorsements, and awards all fit into the same category.
My son has ADD, and it was a challenge some days working through his homework with him. We would be sitting in the kitchen working on math when suddenly he would jump up looking out the window and shout, "Look a Squirrel!"
I picture Bort working on the code for the SIM, slaving away at his laptop, deep into the guts of the newest SIM, when suddenly, "Wow! I could do VAs this way!" and off he goes...
PinTBC