User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Endorsements - What I am thinking
Page:
 
Xero00
offline
Link
 
I think a poll is in order, as several other issues were put to a vote.
 
SundaySmoken
offline
Link
 
This will be the reason, and among other things, that I will no longer pump money to Bort and friends! GLB is getting to be to big for it's own britches!!!!!
Last edited Feb 27, 2009 14:58:39
 
geekor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xero00
I think a poll is in order, as several other issues were put to a vote.


+100
 
butler312
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Blisser
Originally posted by butler312


I think a lot of the problem stems from the realism. Everyone thinks that the best players should get the endorsements, and that is not at all how Bort originally intended it. He wanted it to be random and for everyone to have a chance, with the best players only getting a slight advantage. It was never supposed to be realistic, just like items having bonuses in the first place isn't realistic.

The only real problem I saw with it was how it awarded winning a little too much. But it wasn't anything to get in an uproar about. There was nothing wrong with the way Bort intended to give them out in the first place. I do like this system better myself, but I still fail to see the reason everyone got so upset and demanded it to be done over right now. IMO, any new system should be held off until next season until it is thoroughly tested so we don't go through this again.


It may be skewed a little too much in favor of league champions and what not, but it does still give a chance for everyone in the league to potentially get one. I don't like the new idea at all, I see lots more flaws in it to be honest. Put it to a poll, fairest way to get the opinion of the whole GLB community.


For me it honestly depends on how this ends up working:

3. We give 1 "national" endorsement per team that is equal to the current endorsements from 2 tiers down, ranked by the same MVP system. Alternatively, we could do a lottery per team based on the MVP calculation = more tickets. We do this at week 8, and base it on the current league results.

If it is a lottery where everyone has a chance to win, then I like it. If it is weighted too much by the MVP formula, so that only the top 5 players or so get a legitimate shot, then I don't like. All of this also hinges on coming up with a successful MVP formula that gives every player, regardless of position, an opportunity to win. How do you come up with a system that rewards a OT the same as a QB. Or a DT the same as a CB who also returns kicks? It isn't something that will be easy at all to do.

Last edited Feb 27, 2009 15:02:05
 
Blisser
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by butler312

For me it honestly depends on how this ends up working:

3. We give 1 "national" endorsement per team that is equal to the current endorsements from 2 tiers down, ranked by the same MVP system. Alternatively, we could do a lottery per team based on the MVP calculation = more tickets. We do this at week 8, and base it on the current league results.

If it is a lottery where everyone has a chance to win, then I like it. If it is weighted too much by the MVP formula, so that only the top 5 players or so get a legitimate shot, then I don't like. All of this also hinges on coming up with a successful MVP formula that gives every player, regardless of position, an opportunity to win. How do you come up with a system that rewards a OT the same as a QB. Or a DT the same as a CB who also returns kicks? It isn't something that will be easy at all to do.



I think making it so people who get deals can't get cut or traded would solve the problem with the original method, then possibly find a way to bump so lesser fame people can get a better chance, have some minimum baseline of fame that everyone gets per season, that once you exceed it goes away. let's say 100 fame for example, until you earn 100, that's what you have, once you cross that threshold you can earn more.
 
Link
 
Obviously this has been brought up already in this thread, but if the current endorsements are going to be taken away then the player who had them should be reimbursed in some manner. I understand that some players who aren't worthy of an endorsement got one, but my HB has been a star since his first season and damn well deserves his endorsement.
Something like 900 flex points (full boosts for a season) would be alright.

Endorsements are redone each season, right? So Bort should just leave things the way they are and correct it next time around.
 
butler312
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by EggplantWizard
Obviously this has been brought up already in this thread, but if the current endorsements are going to be taken away then the player who had them should be reimbursed in some manner. I understand that some players who aren't worthy of an endorsement got one, but my HB has been a star since his first season and damn well deserves his endorsement.
Something like 900 flex points (full boosts for a season) would be alright.

Endorsements are redone each season, right? So Bort should just leave things the way they are and correct it next time around.


I agree something should be given out, but so many people seem to have a problem with anyone getting anything. Someone suggested 1 VA, and many people really hated it. They don't want any more than cash, basically because that is equivalent to nothing to an individual. I'm not sure if it can be VA because not everyone is level 25, but I don't see why flex points or bonus tokens would be any problem at all.
 
BobbyBlackk
offline
Link
 
Indiv. League distribution should be implemented. If it's a lottery and not 'based on actuality' than ALL leagues should have their own distribution, instead of 'x' amount of endorsements per. League; BBB, A, AA, AAA, Pro. I'd personally say scrap it, and work on a 'fair' formula for next season, strictly based on performance like an MVP Race as was stated. Endorsements aren't given to those who are "lucky", they should go to those who deserve them, performance wise.
 
Blisser
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BobbyBlackk
Indiv. League distribution should be implemented. If it's a lottery and not 'based on actuality' than ALL leagues should have their own distribution, instead of 'x' amount of endorsements per. League; BBB, A, AA, AAA, Pro. I'd personally say scrap it, and work on a 'fair' formula for next season, strictly based on performance like an MVP Race as was stated. Endorsements aren't given to those who are "lucky", they should go to those who deserve them, performance wise.


Just because this is the good example of a real life endorsement scenario. Women's tennis: Martina Hingis vs. Anna Kournikova. Even though Hingis is on a different playing level from Kournikova, Kournikova got endorsement deals, with no major singles, and one of a few doubles wins was partnered with Hingis....

Moral of the story, the most deserving don't always get endorsements, though Hingis did have some herself.
 
Banned
offline
Link
 
how about we worry about the epic sugegstions, bort, which are better and more important, instead of wasting time with endorsements, id much rather have weather,stadium upgrades, rooms where we can watch the game live
 
Mynno
offline
Link
 
And how do you determine performance? If you give them to top 3-5 at their position that will create a problem as well. It seems logical but what about a number 4 or 5 receiver, are they any less valuable to a team winning their conference than the number 1 or 2? Some might argue yes but they would be wrong. The best teams have depth at each position and those who backup are just as valuable as those who start sometimes more so.

Another thing to think about is the way the GM's gameplan a game. If the team is a run oriented team then the receivers and tightend's stats will suffer but that does not mean they are not good or worthy of an endorsement. It will also lead to players demanding more playing time and to start so they have a better shot at getting an endorsement. I can only imagine at this point what recruiting will be like next season because of this.

Once you start giving a few players an advantage that other players can not achieve on their own you are unbalancing a game mechanic and people will always complain about unfair advantages.
 
ChuckTaylor
offline
Link
 
Booo Hooo Your endorsement ,you didn't earn is getting stripped and you want compensation? We get it....everybody else got lucky...buy YOU? your guy was the sh*t and earned his. LMAO

It's one thing to hope to be compensated ,it's another thing to demand to be compensated.

WTF planet do you live on?
 
bills_red
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Boltz
how about we worry about the epic sugegstions, bort, which are better and more important, instead of wasting time with endorsements, id much rather have weather,stadium upgrades, rooms where we can watch the game live


this. 34 and 43 DC also would be nice.
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
Sorry, I have not been following this as it is now past 600 posts. I was thinking as a suggestion. How about letting owenrs pick a player from their team to add to the pot for endorsements? Something simple like a check box next to a player for team captain or endorsement candidate on the team roster page. Then at least one player from each team that has an active owner has a shot.

Its just a thought. I like the endorsements idea. It sounds fun.

Edited spelling
Last edited Feb 27, 2009 17:40:37
 
butler312
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AngryDragon
Sorry, I have not been following this as it is now past 600 posts. I was thinking as a suggestion. How about letting owenrs pick a player from their team to add to the pot for endorsements? Something simple like a check box next to a player for team captain or endorsement candidate on the team roster page. Then at least one player from each team that has an active owner has a shot.

Its just a thought. I like the endorsements idea. It sounds fun.

Edited spelling


It would be too easy to abuse by corrupt owners. I wouldn't mind voting, but if so it should be the whole team or something.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.