User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fletch03
The problem is most people don't have enough tackling/strength. It is widely known that LBs don't need anymore than capped strength/tackling. But at the same time we are seeing LBs with the same speed/agility as cover CB's that are the same level. If anything LB's should be slower and have higher tackling and strength. LB's shouldn't have 80 speed/ 70 agility and 50/50 tackling/strength. But that is how this game is played.

I don't see anything wrong with power backs at all.


+2
 
Maddoc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by Maddoc

Originally posted by Iceman16


Originally posted by THE PWNER



Originally posted by Iceman16




Originally posted by THE PWNER





Originally posted by Iceman16






Originally posted by Bort







Originally posted by Kira








Carrying has a much larger impact than strength in fumbling. If your personal results are different, it's because of a number of things mainly competition, energy and morale.


The formula for deciding if you hang on to the ball would agree with you.


Stats would argue against it Bort. And I'm sure I've got some supporters that are aware of it as well.


You're not very good at picking your arguments


You're not very good at providing any evidence against my own.


Evidence: BORT SAYS SO


Lol. Do you really think everything Bort has ever said about the sim is factual? You haven't been here that long, have you. Are you putting SP into blocking on your D-linemen too?


Bort has said that Blocking plays a small role in breaking blocks. This is factual. It may not be a smart place to spent SP, and he never said "You need blocking to break blocks".


I'd argue that carrying plays a small role in fumbles. More than blocking does for the D-line, but I think that strength is more important and have provided more evidence than "God created everything because the Bible says so!" to prove it.


Bad analogies should be a bannable offense imo

This isn't a "God created everything because the Bible says so" situation, this is a "We are talking to the actual, factual person who created the sim so he probably knows a few things about it that you don't."

There is no middle-man here, vis-à-vis the bible your pants-on-head retarded comparison, because the person who created the sim is saying it himself, not some translated and retranslated book written by some guy who might have known someone related to him maybe

The only "proof" you've submitted is a logical fallacy. Just because you see players with high strength and low carrying fumble less does not mean that strength prevents fumbles more than carrying. Correlation does not imply causation.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
The point is that LBs have a LOT of things to worry about, while as Deathblade said a lot of HBs can get by on speed, agility and carrying. The balance is fucked.
 
fletch03
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by fletch03

Originally posted by Iceman16


Originally posted by fletch03



Originally posted by Iceman16









Do you have power backs or elusive backs on the team you GM?


I have both an elusive and 2 power backs on one team, two elusives on the other 2 teams


Which one has the power backs?


sumatra sting.


So what I'm asking is if you think that your lead tailback should be averaging 9.3 YPC.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=345432



In that game yes. He and the FB clearly outlevel everyone on the opposing team. But when we start playing the top 5 teams in conference do I expect him to have 9.3 avg? no. Also if you look at the game, all he did was break 2 long runs, so his average is distorted. The other power back with the same strength and higher carry avg. 2.2 yards per carry.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fletch03


I honestly don't see anything wrong with the way it is right now.


I am going to have to agree...if folks are getting run over, they should alter their builds.

This is how the all-speed teams lose, and folks finally stop following that herd.

Let the whining fall upon deaf ears.

Stand strong, Bort.
 
THE PWNER
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by THE PWNER

Originally posted by Iceman16


Originally posted by THE PWNER



Originally posted by Iceman16






http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=28120

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=631975

The two backs we had on my team last year. Both elusive backs. First guy had about 35 strength. Second had about 20 strength. Both had 40+ carrying. And we lead the league in fumbles. In a league with primarily power backs. That's my evidence.


by led the league in fumbles, do you mean most or least?


Most.


And you don't know what the carrying of the power backs was? And were your backs set to elusive or combo?


I don't know what my opponents' carrying was, but I would assume it was 40ish. And our guys were both set to combo.


Why/how would you assume that? even soft capping at 48 would be a 20% increase in what your backs had and would make sense to a lot of people as a good stopping point, especially if they're intelligent builders who know the effect of carrying.

Also, assuming they were set to power they would be less likely to fumble than your backs on combo.
 
Bears Rule
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by bhall43

Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi


Originally posted by Iceman16



Originally posted by fletch03




I honestly don't see anything wrong with the way it is right now.


Well considering that Bort AND the rest of the community do, you're missing something.


Just for the record - I haven't seen Bort actually say that he thinks there is something wrong.. and infact I don't know that I think there is anything wrong... I have seen a lot of people talk about the missed tackles and this thread seems to be Bort trying to gauge what the community thinks good builds should be for Players.

If the community says that 60/60 Strength and tackling should be enough to stop 100/70 Strength/Rushing -- then Bort gets an idea as to where there is a difference between perception and reality.


so Bort made this thread in an attempt to fool us all into fighting each other for the kicks of it? ok...


Don't be stupid - Bort simply asked what people thought would be a good build.

Assume for a moment that the community came to a conclusion about what was a good build to tackle the Player described in the OP... Bort would be able to say "See? Power rushing is clearly not the problem because you fools don't even have these stats"... That's what it really comes down to - if the community wants it to require 60str / 60tackling to stop a 100 strength HB.. and if very few LBs have the strength because they all went with speed/agility -- then the problem is with the builds.


so hes just coming up with these gang tackling ideas and such for shits and giggles because there is nothing wrong with the sim?
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by fletch03



I honestly don't see anything wrong with the way it is right now.


I am going to have to agree...if folks are getting run over, they should alter their builds.

This is how the all-speed teams lose, and folks finally stop following that herd.

Let the whining fall upon deaf ears.

Stand strong, Bort.


+100000
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Maddoc
Bad analogies should be a bannable offense imo

This isn't a "God created everything because the Bible says so" situation, this is a "We are talking to the actual, factual person who created the sim so he probably knows a few things about it that you don't."

There is no middle-man here, vis-à-vis the bible your pants-on-head retarded comparison, because the person who created the sim is saying it himself, not some translated and retranslated book written by some guy who might have known someone related to him maybe

The only "proof" you've submitted is a logical fallacy. Just because you see players with high strength and low carrying fumble less does not mean that strength prevents fumbles more than carrying. Correlation does not imply causation.


EVIDENCE actually implies my causation. It proves it, in fact.

And honestly, are you telling me that Bort doesn't make changes to the sim every pre-season? And that there aren't issues with them every time? Please, just because he tries to code something a certain way does not by any means make it happen that way.
 
raiderdav
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by fletch03



I honestly don't see anything wrong with the way it is right now.


I am going to have to agree...if folks are getting run over, they should alter their builds.

This is how the all-speed teams lose, and folks finally stop following that herd.

Let the whining fall upon deaf ears.

Stand strong, Bort.


Herd mentality exists in the NFL and College just as much. See running backs by committee, west coast offense, Texas Tech spread, etc. Stick with the way it is and adjust.
 
El_Windex
Baby Executive
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by fletch03



I honestly don't see anything wrong with the way it is right now.


I am going to have to agree...if folks are getting run over, they should alter their builds.

This is how the all-speed teams lose, and folks finally stop following that herd.

Let the whining fall upon deaf ears.

Stand strong, Bort.


*salute*
 
fletch03
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
The point is that LBs have a LOT of things to worry about, while as Deathblade said a lot of HBs can get by on speed, agility and carrying. The balance is fucked.


Your right they do. But do they also need the same speed and agility as CBs? no. But most people think "hell i don't mind if I miss a few tackles as long as I get to the play quicker" which I agree with.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by THE PWNER
Originally posted by Iceman16

Originally posted by THE PWNER


Originally posted by Iceman16



Originally posted by THE PWNER




Originally posted by Iceman16







http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=28120

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=631975

The two backs we had on my team last year. Both elusive backs. First guy had about 35 strength. Second had about 20 strength. Both had 40+ carrying. And we lead the league in fumbles. In a league with primarily power backs. That's my evidence.


by led the league in fumbles, do you mean most or least?


Most.


And you don't know what the carrying of the power backs was? And were your backs set to elusive or combo?


I don't know what my opponents' carrying was, but I would assume it was 40ish. And our guys were both set to combo.


Why/how would you assume that? even soft capping at 48 would be a 20% increase in what your backs had and would make sense to a lot of people as a good stopping point, especially if they're intelligent builders who know the effect of carrying.

Also, assuming they were set to power they would be less likely to fumble than your backs on combo.


Considering I've probably seen a good 200 HB builds in the mid-30s in levels, I'd say that my guessing based on what people generally do in the situation is what happened.

And why/how do you assume that changing a 40 to a 48 is a 20% change in fumbling chances?
 
Maddoc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by Maddoc

Bad analogies should be a bannable offense imo

This isn't a "God created everything because the Bible says so" situation, this is a "We are talking to the actual, factual person who created the sim so he probably knows a few things about it that you don't."

There is no middle-man here, vis-à-vis the bible your pants-on-head retarded comparison, because the person who created the sim is saying it himself, not some translated and retranslated book written by some guy who might have known someone related to him maybe

The only "proof" you've submitted is a logical fallacy. Just because you see players with high strength and low carrying fumble less does not mean that strength prevents fumbles more than carrying. Correlation does not imply causation.


EVIDENCE actually implies my causation. It proves it, in fact.

And honestly, are you telling me that Bort doesn't make changes to the sim every pre-season? And that there aren't issues with them every time? Please, just because he tries to code something a certain way does not by any means make it happen that way.


You have no evidence, you don't even have numbers, you have stats for one player and estimated stats for a second player.

Two player sample? Shit, I'm sold!
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Seriously, Power RBs should be left alone...if people want to stop them...raise your tackling and strength. Easy as that, it's not impossible to stop a power RB. It's not like they are going to outrun you. lol
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.