User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
If vision is going to matter for a DE, then low vision should mean bad pathing, poor ability to read running plays. It shouldn't mean standing still for awhile (this goes for vision for LBs as well, another position that has been rendered completely unrealistic as a band-aid covering a different problem). You know, the things that poor vision used to mean for a DE, before it also included having to count to 10 Mississippi before being able to rush. I'm looking forward to the further backyard-type changes to the game, like when power backs only have to be touched with two hands rather than be tackled, as it's too hard for some agents to build guys capable of tackling.
Last edited Nov 18, 2008 11:41:39
 
Modok
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stryves
Originally posted by Voltron

Never thought I'd have to soft cap vision on my DE.


Never thought I'd have to soft cap Agility and Speed on an OT.


The best OT's in the NFL are not agile?
 
Broker Hart
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Voltron
Originally posted by Modok

I am still trying to figure out why a DE needs as much vision as my corner.




The obvious answer to this is...

"Bort has spoken"

Instead of a speedy DE, now you need one with x-ray wision to get to the QB. Not saying vision should not be inportant, but to say we are gonna give the offense another advantage, and make your defense wait a second before they can move is like playing backyard football, and having a 10 Mississippi rush rule.

Last edited Nov 18, 2008 11:44:16
 
Jason Elliott
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gargus
Originally posted by Jason Elliott

Originally posted by mutleyddmc


surely a De can rush the passer no matter how much vision its his job dammit


Vision is also football smarts, less vision equals more penalties, less reaction time etc. Why should DE's get a break on this and pretty much every other position need it?


A retarded monkey can move at the snap of a ball. That's why DE's have a SA called first step. Wanna guess what "First Step" is supposed to do? Lemme read it to you:

"This player has a very fast reaction time."

Well QB"s are supposed to be able to check down and OT's are supposed to be able to atleast get a hand on a DE and first an SA is only as good as it's physical attribute, meaning if your vision is low, that SA wont be as affective.
Last edited Nov 18, 2008 11:46:12
 
Gargus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stryves
Originally posted by Voltron

Never thought I'd have to soft cap vision on my DE.


Never thought I'd have to soft cap Agility and Speed on an OT.


Not that this is the gospel, but lets take a look at Joe Thomas' Madden 09 rating, shall we?

SPD: 68
Acceleration: 82 (note this would be a hybrid of agility since there isn't an ACC attribute)
AGI: 74

Granted this is for a fully built guy... but if the DE's are beating you, wouldn't you wanna account for your failures?
 
Gargus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jason Elliott

Well QB"s are supposed to be able to check down and OT's are supposed to be able to atleast get a hand on a DE and a first SA is only as good as it's physical attribute, meaning if your vision is low, that SA wont be as affective.


Agreed, except that First Step is based on Agility. Not Vision.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Was based on agility, Gargus, was. Not any more, apparently.
 
stryves
offline
Link
 
My OT isn't getting beat yet, he plays RT and rarely has someone go around, but this is in the AA league.
 
Jason Elliott
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gargus
Originally posted by Jason Elliott


Well QB"s are supposed to be able to check down and OT's are supposed to be able to atleast get a hand on a DE and a first SA is only as good as it's physical attribute, meaning if your vision is low, that SA wont be as affective.


Agreed, except that First Step is based on Agility. Not Vision.

Your right about that but vision could also be a determining factor in wiether or not they take a good path to the QB.
Last edited Nov 18, 2008 11:47:51
 
Gargus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
Was based on agility, Gargus, was. Not any more, apparently.


Well, then let us go and change our build. If we're going to change the rules, give us our points back.
 
Gargus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jason Elliott

Agreed, except that First Step is based on Agility. Not Vision.

Your right about that but visison could also be a determining factor in wiether or not they take a good path to the QB.


Fine, change that. But don't have us wait 45 seconds before we start to rush.
 
Gargus
offline
Link
 
Actually you know what... that would be a good suggestion, and a good way for Bort to make money. Charge FP to people who want to get their points back, and build it to the new rules.

How about that? Would you all agree that that could be a fix to everyone's problems?
 
Voltron
offline
Link
 
I refuse to put points into Vision, you're like 4 yards away from the QB. It's not like you're playing FS/SS/LB/CB and need to see most of the field.
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gargus
Originally posted by Gyuri1

Was based on agility, Gargus, was. Not any more, apparently.


Well, then let us go and change our build. If we're going to change the rules, give us our points back.


That could be said by OTs when this season started... things were changed so that we started getting run around, while last season that wasn't the case.
 
Jason Elliott
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock
Originally posted by Gargus

Originally posted by Gyuri1


Was based on agility, Gargus, was. Not any more, apparently.


Well, then let us go and change our build. If we're going to change the rules, give us our points back.


That could be said by OTs when this season started... things were changed so that we started getting run around, while last season that wasn't the case.


Spot on.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.