User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > GLB Notes > CPL > Interesting topic of the Week: Evolutionism versus Creationism
Page:
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

The problem you have is all the men who became gay in jail, all the guys who were happily married to a woman for many years and then decide to switch over....and the every increasing number of girls who like girls now that it is cool/popular. If sexual identity wasn't determined in part by environment, then these things wouldn't be happening.


1. Why is that a problem.

2. What men become gay in jail? Having gay sex and/or even relationship that might be considered gay doesn't mean you're gay, necessarily. It means you have basic human needs and another man was the only choice you were given.

3. WHAT guys who were happily married to women for many years and decide to switch over? You're talking about this huge demographic as if it-you know- exists.

4. Girls hooking up with other girls because they think guys like it aren't lesbians.

You're arguing that people decide to do something that you consider a gay thing to do later in life, not that they "become" gay.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Azure Dreams
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

I also never said I represented ALL Christians, but as a Christian I feel I speak for Christians alot better than you (who has NO IDEA what Christians believe).

And if you don't think that environment affects a child's gender, then you are never going to agree with me. Simple as that.

The argument really boils down to that.

Show some scientific proof that gender is assigned at birth and you will win over alot more people than by falling back on a BOGUS claim that it is all about religion.

The problem you have is all the men who became gay in jail, all the guys who were happily married to a woman for many years and then decide to switch over....and the every increasing number of girls who like girls now that it is cool/popular. If sexual identity wasn't determined in part by environment, then these things wouldn't be happening.


I have no idea what Christians believe? Now you're making assumptions. For all you know, I am Christian. You have no idea what my religious or political affiliation is. You know only the following:

I'm a male.
I'm straight.
I believe that gay marriage should be legal in the USA.

You're the kind of person I would hate were I christian (and that I do hate if I am) because you feel you speak for me. Many Christian people are pro-gay marriage you know. And there are many people who aren't Christians who know a SHITLOAD more about the religion than you do.

And it doesn't fucking matter what the reason is, as stupid as your argument there is. The fact is you can't prove that it's bad, so its prevalence doesn't matter.


listen numnuts. I don't speak for all Christians.

That is absurd.


I can tell by the HATE in your for Christians that you aren't Christian. You also refer to Christians as THEY and not WE. It is easy to tell that you are not Christian.


Also, I heard you say you were Jewish before.
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Azure Dreams

Just because you didn't mention it doesn't mean it wasn't the reasoning.

Your "reasoning" was that it harms society because it will confuse kids about gender roles or increase the amount of gay people.

However, why is that harm?

...Because you don't approve of gay marriage and you have set gender roles you want fulfilled.

And why is that?

Because it is what your religion teaches.

You can't tell me the reason is "because you believe X" or "because it will cause harm" without explaining why you believe it or why it causes harm and expect that you will have made a legitimate point.



what you are arguing for is completely abolishing gender roles



No, it isn't. And even if it were, you STILL HAVEN'T GIVEN A REASON THAT'S BAD.

Abolishing slavery somewhat abolished race roles. Should that not have happened? It did not completely, nor would this. Straight people- religious or otherwise- who believe in the gender roles you believe in could still live in those roles to their hearts content.

However, every other person wouldn't be forced to because of them.
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Azure Dreams

Originally posted by SteelersInsider


I also never said I represented ALL Christians, but as a Christian I feel I speak for Christians alot better than you (who has NO IDEA what Christians believe).

And if you don't think that environment affects a child's gender, then you are never going to agree with me. Simple as that.

The argument really boils down to that.

Show some scientific proof that gender is assigned at birth and you will win over alot more people than by falling back on a BOGUS claim that it is all about religion.

The problem you have is all the men who became gay in jail, all the guys who were happily married to a woman for many years and then decide to switch over....and the every increasing number of girls who like girls now that it is cool/popular. If sexual identity wasn't determined in part by environment, then these things wouldn't be happening.


I have no idea what Christians believe? Now you're making assumptions. For all you know, I am Christian. You have no idea what my religious or political affiliation is. You know only the following:

I'm a male.
I'm straight.
I believe that gay marriage should be legal in the USA.

You're the kind of person I would hate were I christian (and that I do hate if I am) because you feel you speak for me. Many Christian people are pro-gay marriage you know. And there are many people who aren't Christians who know a SHITLOAD more about the religion than you do.

And it doesn't fucking matter what the reason is, as stupid as your argument there is. The fact is you can't prove that it's bad, so its prevalence doesn't matter.


listen numnuts. I don't speak for all Christians.

That is absurd.


I can tell by the HATE in your for Christians that you aren't Christian. You also refer to Christians as THEY and not WE. It is easy to tell that you are not Christian.


Also, I heard you say you were Jewish before.


Now look whose name-calling.

There is no hate in me for Christians. My mother is a Christian and I love her very much and she is a very intelligent woman whose viewpoints I respect. There is a hate in my for the obstinate, foolish viewpoints that some religious people (Chrisitans, Jews, Muslims, take your pick) try to force on others.

You have never seen me say I'm Jewish.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Azure Dreams
Originally posted by SteelersInsider


The problem you have is all the men who became gay in jail, all the guys who were happily married to a woman for many years and then decide to switch over....and the every increasing number of girls who like girls now that it is cool/popular. If sexual identity wasn't determined in part by environment, then these things wouldn't be happening.


1. Why is that a problem.

2. What men become gay in jail? Having gay sex and/or even relationship that might be considered gay doesn't mean you're gay, necessarily. It means you have basic human needs and another man was the only choice you were given.

3. WHAT guys who were happily married to women for many years and decide to switch over? You're talking about this huge demographic as if it-you know- exists.

4. Girls hooking up with other girls because they think guys like it aren't lesbians.

You're arguing that people decide to do something that you consider a gay thing to do later in life, not that they "become" gay.




The problem is you say that people are only attracted to 1 gender or the other from birth.

If someone can suddenly become attracted to the same sex because their choices are limited, then that means they CHOSE to switch. You can't say it is born with, then say that you can switch if you want to.

You are going to back-track from your "gays were born that way" argument now and say that many/most people are born attracted to both sexes argument now I bet. If you do, then that is only going to lead to marriages between 3 or more people next. DUCY?

 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
And I refer to YOU and the people who share your viewpoint as they. The only times I've referred to Christians as a whole as anything involved a concerted effort to do so. I would call Jews they. I would call atheists they. This isn't indicative of how I identify myself, it's indicative of the fact that I am not pretending to represent an entire group just because they describe themselves with the same word sometimes.
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Azure Dreams

Originally posted by SteelersInsider



The problem you have is all the men who became gay in jail, all the guys who were happily married to a woman for many years and then decide to switch over....and the every increasing number of girls who like girls now that it is cool/popular. If sexual identity wasn't determined in part by environment, then these things wouldn't be happening.


1. Why is that a problem.

2. What men become gay in jail? Having gay sex and/or even relationship that might be considered gay doesn't mean you're gay, necessarily. It means you have basic human needs and another man was the only choice you were given.

3. WHAT guys who were happily married to women for many years and decide to switch over? You're talking about this huge demographic as if it-you know- exists.

4. Girls hooking up with other girls because they think guys like it aren't lesbians.

You're arguing that people decide to do something that you consider a gay thing to do later in life, not that they "become" gay.




The problem is you say that people are only attracted to 1 gender or the other from birth.

If someone can suddenly become attracted to the same sex because their choices are limited, then that means they CHOSE to switch. You can't say it is born with, then say that you can switch if you want to.

You are going to back-track from your "gays were born that way" argument now and say that many/most people are born attracted to both sexes argument now I bet. If you do, then that is only going to lead to marriages between 3 or more people next. DUCY?




I never said people are attracted to only 1 gender from birth. That may be the case the majority of the time, but it isn't always true.

I never said they can choose to switch. I said they can choose to have sex with a man.

Are most people attracted to both sexes? No. What the fuck are you talking about? I can tell your argument is crumbling because in addition to small attacks on me youre starting to build up new arguments to destroy that I never made.
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Also, rather than responding piece by piece like I am, you're ignoring the majority of what I say.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Azure Dreams
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Originally posted by Azure Dreams


Originally posted by SteelersInsider



I also never said I represented ALL Christians, but as a Christian I feel I speak for Christians alot better than you (who has NO IDEA what Christians believe).

And if you don't think that environment affects a child's gender, then you are never going to agree with me. Simple as that.

The argument really boils down to that.

Show some scientific proof that gender is assigned at birth and you will win over alot more people than by falling back on a BOGUS claim that it is all about religion.

The problem you have is all the men who became gay in jail, all the guys who were happily married to a woman for many years and then decide to switch over....and the every increasing number of girls who like girls now that it is cool/popular. If sexual identity wasn't determined in part by environment, then these things wouldn't be happening.


I have no idea what Christians believe? Now you're making assumptions. For all you know, I am Christian. You have no idea what my religious or political affiliation is. You know only the following:

I'm a male.
I'm straight.
I believe that gay marriage should be legal in the USA.

You're the kind of person I would hate were I christian (and that I do hate if I am) because you feel you speak for me. Many Christian people are pro-gay marriage you know. And there are many people who aren't Christians who know a SHITLOAD more about the religion than you do.

And it doesn't fucking matter what the reason is, as stupid as your argument there is. The fact is you can't prove that it's bad, so its prevalence doesn't matter.


listen numnuts. I don't speak for all Christians.

That is absurd.


I can tell by the HATE in your for Christians that you aren't Christian. You also refer to Christians as THEY and not WE. It is easy to tell that you are not Christian.


Also, I heard you say you were Jewish before.


Now look whose name-calling.

There is no hate in me for Christians. My mother is a Christian and I love her very much and she is a very intelligent woman whose viewpoints I respect. There is a hate in my for the obstinate, foolish viewpoints that some religious people (Chrisitans, Jews, Muslims, take your pick) try to force on others.

You have never seen me say I'm Jewish.


I'm pretty sure I have. I could be getting you mixed up with Zithers. I thought his dad was the rock star and your dad was the hot-shot in Banking. Didn't you give a link to a federal reserve bank that he was on the board of?

I just noticed that you had a Jewish beanie thing on also. I'm pretty sure I'm right.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Azure Dreams
Also, rather than responding piece by piece like I am, you're ignoring the majority of what I say.


there is no much rage and bad arguments I'm forced to ignore most of it.

Let's keep it simple and 2 sentence responses at most, ok?
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Believe it or not, you can be in banking without being jewish.

That said, he was not a banker. He was in retail.

And yes, my avatar is jewy right now. Know what else? If everyone else's was, mine would have a santa hat. Asheme's avatar has the hasidic jewcurls too, does that mean he's jewish?

Lastly, for fuck's sake, be a little educated about cultures other than your own, at least. Jewish beanie? Yarmulke or kippah (or at least yamaka, even though that's just the first word misspelled)

You have never seen me say I'm Jewish.

Know who I can be extra sure of this? I'm not Jewish.

Know what else is fun here? Every argument we've made can apply almost as much against the Jewish community as the Christian community.

And lastly, just for shits and giggles, I feel the need to point out that all Christians ARE Jews. They're just Jews who believe a few additional things.
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 03:16:10
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Azure Dreams

Also, rather than responding piece by piece like I am, you're ignoring the majority of what I say.


there is no much rage and bad arguments I'm forced to ignore most of it.

Let's keep it simple and 2 sentence responses at most, ok?


So I should just take this as a concession, then?
 
Link
 
I feel a family structure of 1 man and 1 woman is ideal to raise children as it gives children of both sexes a role model as to how their gender should behave. I feel a boy should learn to act like a man and a girl should learn to act like a woman.

You feel gender isn't important.

I think that sums it up. Sorry, that is more than 2 sentences, but still concise.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Azure Dreams
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Originally posted by Azure Dreams


Also, rather than responding piece by piece like I am, you're ignoring the majority of what I say.


there is no much rage and bad arguments I'm forced to ignore most of it.

Let's keep it simple and 2 sentence responses at most, ok?


So I should just take this as a concession, then?


concession that you lost.
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Azure Dreams

Also, rather than responding piece by piece like I am, you're ignoring the majority of what I say.


there is no much rage and bad arguments I'm forced to ignore most of it.

Let's keep it simple and 2 sentence responses at most, ok?


Also regarding this: Saying "fuck" doesn't imply rage. I love argument. I'm not angry at all. Frustrated is the absolute furthest you are capable of getting me and the only thing about this that has frustrated me is your blind ignorance of things I say and refusal to debate properly.

I argue with everything. Whenever I talk to republicans, they think I'm a democrat. Whenever I talk to democrats, they think I'm a republican.

Same with your attempts to assign me a religion. It's just an attempt to pin me down so you can use that to dismiss my arguments. Well, how I identify myself has nothing to do with anything.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.